forum

The Eleventh Hour - Game Over

posted
Total Posts
860
show more
Nyxa
Shiirn has been playing good this game and the way mafia are being found out is very un-Mafia like. This game should be about town busting their heads over who is actually mafia and scum busting their heads over how to gain towncred and get mislynches done swiftly.

Barely any of that has happened this game, it's just been a clusterfuck (take the thing with the Giraffe's TWICE, and the whole deal with Haneii and Xiz, and also Mbomb's kinda useless D1 post restriction). On top of that, there's a cop-ish role, a doctor, and a vig, in a game with 9 town to 2 mafia. When there's 9 town all you really need is a doc. It shouldn't take 9 people a cop, a doc, and a vig to figure out who's scum. It's just imbalanced and unfair towards scum.
Shiirn
There's more than just a cop, a doc, and a vig. There are also bulletproofs and role detectives, and whatever the shit Xiz is.


Editting because fuck it: There shouldn't even fucking BE a vig or vengeful in a 9v2 setup. What the shit?
Zexion
Right so, before reading those last posts I was thinking we're betting too much relying on Xiz's info on the Giraffes. HOWEVER, there's also no reason not to believe him. The Xiz v/s Haneii thing yesterday was so damn null that makes a lot of sense if Xiz is town.

So that would make it a matter of {Shiirn, Tess} and {AutoMedic, beeboy} to make it short. No comments on the doctor issue, clearly one of them is lying.

I guess the first one is settled. No matter what perspective you see it, Shiirn post looks scummy as hell because he's practically giving up. Also these are the reasons why I don't really like to play or run closed setups, I guess. I don't really understand beeboy's push on Tess, he's so desperate to get a lynch on Tess that I guess he has to be Shiirn's partner, that way it would make perfect sense... but it's really very desperate, yet I'm still inclined to say it's beeboy.

I guess this is solved. Jess has to make sure he shots beeboy overnight and we shouldn't even need an extra day to end this game.

Vote: Shiirn
Haneii
So shiirn lynch?

Not sure where the votes are now, so I'll check again after the vote count.

Hopefully Jess understands what she needs to do after the lynch.
Nyxa
I doubt Shiirn cares about being lynched. I know I don't.
Topic Starter
Frostings
Vote Count 3.1

(2) Shiirn: Tess, Zexion
(1) Tess: Shiirn
(1) AutoMedic: beeboy123

Not Voting: -[Jess]-, Haneii, AutoMedic, Xiz
AutoMedic
im okay with the shiirn lynch

if beeboy flips town then you guys can lynch me d4 i guess. at this point, i dont really care anymore
AutoMedic
BUT im not going to place my votes yet, i'll see if there's anything that you guys want
Nyxa
Automedic doesn't really seem scummy to me. If he's scum then the only reason he seems more town than beeboy right now is because beeboy makes stupid pushes towards lynches that don't make sense based on gut tells.
Xiz
What if my dreams/checks are fake and I don't know it (like insane cop)

Because as everyone agrees, this is too town sided
Xiz
I'm just trying to wrap my head around how this game could possibly be balanced. Is there perhaps a serial killer in hiding or some 3rd party?

I feel really bad for the mafia team because I can tell your trying hard but, this setup kinda fucked you.
Xiz
I

Xiz wrote:

What if my dreams/checks are fake and I don't know it (like insane cop)
I just realized this is impossible since the mafia team kinda outted themselves lol.


Can we just call it a game? lol.
beeboy123
Why am I dying before automedic again?
Like logically someone explain to me why I would counter claim his doctor claim if I wasn't actually a doctor...
I feel like some bs is going to happen and you will assume there is 2 doctors.
Xiz
@beeboy it doesn't really matter at this point
there are not two doctors
we can misslynch everyone and still win
Nyxa

beeboy123 wrote:

Why am I dying before automedic again?
Like logically someone explain to me why I would counter claim his doctor claim if I wasn't actually a doctor...
I feel like some bs is going to happen and you will assume there is 2 doctors.
I already logically explained to you but it's beyond you I suppose.
beeboy123
Just because you explained it doesn't make it the right decision.
Nyxa
Just because you don't get it doesn't make it the wrong decision.
beeboy123
I am town aligned though so it can't possibly be the right decision silly
Zexion

Xiz wrote:

What if my dreams/checks are fake and I don't know it (like insane cop)

Because as everyone agrees, this is too town sided
We're kinda going by your claims, so please don't increase my paranoia even more :?

beeboy123 wrote:

Just because you explained it doesn't make it the right decision.

beeboy123 wrote:

I am town aligned though so it can't possibly be the right decision silly
Sorry beeboy but even from a town perspective your posts are making no sense. If we go by that logic then nothing we say ever in mafia would work, we can't obviously know which role a person has until we lynch him, but we have to assume and explain things that would lead to some clues about that role. The best explanation wins, otherwise there's no way to move the game forward.
beeboy123
I was under the assumption scum don't falsely counter claim people well before mylo/lylo because they will get lynched and set there team incredibly far back but I guess I am wrong and am dirty scum!
Haneii
Vote:Shiirn
beeboy123
Vote: Shiirn
beeboy123
This game is an auto win apparently so who cares who we lynch.
Nyxa

beeboy123 wrote:

I am town aligned though so it can't possibly be the right decision silly
If you are town aligned then you are a bad player as I have stated before.
If you're scum aligned, same thing.
beeboy123
The fact you guys think I would counter-claim a doctor with 9 players alive doesn't really show you guys are high caliber players as well.
Nyxa
I already posted why it was a good move, you just need to learn to read I guess.
Topic Starter
Frostings
Vote Count 3.2

(4) Shiirn: Tess, Zexion, Haneii, beeboy123 [L-1]
(1) Tess: Shiirn

Not Voting: -[Jess]-, AutoMedic, Xiz
Xiz
-sigh-
vote: shiirn
Nyxa
If Shiirn flips town now I'm gonna have to have a word with Frostings.
Topic Starter
Frostings
The guests wondered, "the twins are here?
But which one made the food disappear?"
The question made them toss and turn
But in the end they voted Shiirn

Vote Count 3.3 (Final)

(5) Shiirn: Tess, Zexion, Haneii, beeboy123, Xiz [Lynch!]
(1) Tess: Shiirn

Not Voting: -[Jess]-, AutoMedic

Shiirn, Jimmy the Giraffe, has been kicked from the party (Lynched!).
He was a Partyspoiler (Mafia) [2-shot Roleblocker]
Topic Starter
Frostings
The time is 2 o'clock
It's Night 3. Actions are due in 24 hours
Topic Starter
Frostings
Resolving Night Actions
Topic Starter
Frostings
The party went throughout the Night
But by the Day, a frightful sight!

Tess, Jerry the Giraffe has been kicked from the party (Night Killed!)
She was a Partygoer (Town) [Vanilla Town / Twin]

beeboy123, Sara the Snake has been kicked from the party (Night Killed!)
He was a Partygoer (Town) [2-shot Doctor]
Topic Starter
Frostings
The time is 3 o'clock

It's Day 4. Deadline is 7 days from now

Vote Count 4.0

Not Voting: -[Jess]-, Haneii, AutoMedic, Zexion, Xiz
With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch
Zexion
Alright, so it has to be this.

Vote: AutoMedic
Xiz
vote:automedic

Also whoever is a rhino is town
Haneii
Really? Still getting alignment dreams? Smh. This game >.>
Xiz
guys what if i've been lying the whole time and I just bussed my partner :O :O
Haneii
Cubone's too cute to bus :O :O
Xiz
Keep talking to me like that, and you are gonna need to buy me dinner
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply