forum

toby fox - Ghost Fight

posted
Total Posts
83
show more
Laurakko
A small mod from #modreqs
General
Use ds (distance snap in "Normal" and "Easy" diificulties. The spacing in this map is kinda bad
Easy
[list:1337]

Wiki wrote:

Avoid stacked notes
Avoid overlapping notes
00:44:909 (1) - reshape this slider to fit the music or just make it gradually curved
just make sliders not so oddly shaped
Normal
  • 00:29:731 (4) - make this slider a circle
Topic Starter
-Kyu

Lassikko wrote:

A small mod from #modreqs
General
Use ds (distance snap in "Normal" and "Easy" diificulties. The spacing in this map is kinda bad
Easy
[list:1337]

Wiki wrote:

Avoid stacked notes
Avoid overlapping notes
00:44:909 (1) - reshape this slider to fit the music or just make it gradually curved
just make sliders not so oddly shaped
Normal
  • 00:29:731 (4) - make this slider a circle

Thank you for the mod!
Mazziv
hi! saw your request in #modreqs!

[Timing]
00:00:109 - set the offset to this point!

[Easy]
Hitsounds are waaaaaaaaaaay too loud!
first of all try to avoid overlaps,they just look ugly 99% of the time,try to keep everything clean!
try to form patterns out of the slidertail(the end of the slider) and the slider heads(the clickable part of the slider!)
for example: 00:00:109 (1,2,3) - <---- this! it looks like this right now
if you use the slidertail/head and try to form a pattern,it will look waaaay better,example>
so try to use this to your advantage and make everything look neat!
ALSO please use distance snap for easy/normal diffs. its a must have! it will keep the spacing consistant and make everything look good(most of the time atleast hue)

soo
00:01:709 (3) - this slider should end on the white tick at 00:02:243 -
00:03:843 (6) - such slider shapes are not fitting into low diffs,keep everything simple!
00:10:776 (1) - same ^
00:23:576 (5) - copy this slider with ctrl+c and paste it here 00:24:643 - after you pasted it in here press ctrl+, to twice!
00:34:243 (1,1) - such things shouldnt be in easy diffs,since the spacing should be small!
the map basically is full of overlaps,try to fix that!


[Normal]
try to apply the stuff from above(Distance snap,no overlaps,slider shapes,etc...)
00:00:131 (1,2,3) - this is the rhythm you used for this part,it repeats right after the last slider and u used a differen rhythm? why that? just try to keep a constant rhythm!


i thinks thats enough for now,if you got any questions,hit me up ingame o/
Topic Starter
-Kyu

Mazziv wrote:

hi! saw your request in #modreqs!

[Timing]
00:00:109 - set the offset to this point!

[Easy]
Hitsounds are waaaaaaaaaaay too loud!
first of all try to avoid overlaps,they just look ugly 99% of the time,try to keep everything clean!
try to form patterns out of the slidertail(the end of the slider) and the slider heads(the clickable part of the slider!)
for example: 00:00:109 (1,2,3) - <---- this! it looks like this right now
if you use the slidertail/head and try to form a pattern,it will look waaaay better,example>
so try to use this to your advantage and make everything look neat!
ALSO please use distance snap for easy/normal diffs. its a must have! it will keep the spacing consistant and make everything look good(most of the time atleast hue)

soo
00:01:709 (3) - this slider should end on the white tick at 00:02:243 -
00:03:843 (6) - such slider shapes are not fitting into low diffs,keep everything simple!
00:10:776 (1) - same ^
00:23:576 (5) - copy this slider with ctrl+c and paste it here 00:24:643 - after you pasted it in here press ctrl+, to twice!
00:34:243 (1,1) - such things shouldnt be in easy diffs,since the spacing should be small!
the map basically is full of overlaps,try to fix that!


[Normal]
try to apply the stuff from above(Distance snap,no overlaps,slider shapes,etc...)
00:00:131 (1,2,3) - this is the rhythm you used for this part,it repeats right after the last slider and u used a differen rhythm? why that? just try to keep a constant rhythm!


i thinks thats enough for now,if you got any questions,hit me up ingame o/

Thank You So Much of your Mod!
and Thanks for teaching me how to use Distance Snap
:) :D
BlueberrySansy
Heya!

Just wanted to give you some advice...

Reccomended timing: 225bpm
Offset: 109

According to AIMod, Kiai isn't snapped to the beat. Also, there is a conflict between audio preview time and uninherited timing points.

I hate to say this, but could you follow the song? I understand you are a new mapper here, don't worry. You can ask the nice people in #modhelp ^w^

Good luck with this, anyway!
Topic Starter
-Kyu

BlueberrySansy wrote:

Heya!

Just wanted to give you some advice...

Reccomended timing: 225bpm
Offset: 109

According to AIMod, Kiai isn't snapped to the beat. Also, there is a conflict between audio preview time and uninherited timing points.

I hate to say this, but could you follow the song? I understand you are a new mapper here, don't worry. You can ask the nice people in #modhelp ^w^

Good luck with this, anyway!
Thanks for your advice,but....
Are you sure 225bpm is good? because that's too fast '-'
And,about the conflict between audio preview time and uninherited timing points.....i don't know how to fix it.... nvm i've fixed it
I'm still a noob please forgive me
Peter
pls higher AR in hard and set BPM to 112,51 :3
BlueberrySansy

ExKyu wrote:

Are you sure 225bpm is good? because that's too fast '-' 255bpm actually fits the song, though.
I'm still a noob please forgive me
That's okay, I'm also a wimp at mapping ^w^

Just keep mapping stuff, study the good ranked maps, approach the #modhelp in-game chat and maybe you'll gain some experience.
Topic Starter
-Kyu

PeterEU wrote:

pls higher AR in hard and set BPM to 112,51
51 is much better than 50
Ok, increased the AR in hard
Peter
I Fixed Normal
http://www.mediafire.com/download/wlntd ... mal%5D.osu
i think it's better, Just modify if i made mistakes
2. i know my avatar is kawai
3. Dont call it PeterEU' Normal i just fixed :3
4 if you need help with easy just tell me :P
Peter
Btw I love Undertale <3 :D
ppgamer
Can I made some GDs ?
at least I have bit more mapping skill that you(just kidding)
Topic Starter
-Kyu

ppgamer wrote:

Can I made some GDs ?
at least I have bit more mapping skill that you(just kidding)
I'm sorry but I think 4 Difficulties is enough for me :)
CerealeKiller
Hey, I did an IRC mod.

I'll drop some useful links :
t/86329
https://osu.ppy.sh/news/61334266941
t/37194

And here's the log
SPOILER
00:44 CerealeKiller: hey
00:44 ExKyu: oh hey!
00:44 CerealeKiller: Wanna IRC mod ?
00:45 ExKyu: what's IRC?
00:45 CerealeKiller: Here
00:45 CerealeKiller: this chat is IRC haha
00:45 ExKyu: In Real Chat?
00:45 ExKyu: omg lol wild guess
00:45 ExKyu: hmm ok
00:45 CerealeKiller: Internet Relay Chat actually
00:45 CerealeKiller: Oh it's like
00:45 ExKyu: hold on wait
00:46 ExKyu: my osu! needs to be updated
00:46 ExKyu: brb
00:48 CerealeKiller: back
00:48 CerealeKiller: you can do a normal mod, with a post on the forum, but I propose you to make a mod here, I just tell you what I think and have your reaction in real time. It's up to you, if you don't have time I can do a normal mod
00:49 ExKyu: i have time
00:49 CerealeKiller: Okay so lets go ?
00:49 ExKyu: ok!
00:49 ExKyu: what diff should we start?
00:49 CerealeKiller: OK first thing, your SV on the easy is way to high
00:50 CerealeKiller: it's 1.8 while it's 1.2 on the normal
00:50 CerealeKiller: a begginer would be so lost if he started with your map
00:50 ExKyu: oooh that....
00:51 ExKyu: actually it was supposed to be 1.8....but PeterEU modded(or should i say fix) my map and probably changed it
00:51 CerealeKiller: you mean that the easy is supposed to be 1.8 ?
00:51 CerealeKiller: it is already 1.8, but it's too high for an easy
00:52 ExKyu: no no,the normal should be 1.8
00:52 CerealeKiller: AH
00:52 CerealeKiller: Well even
00:52 CerealeKiller: I guess the normal is fine
00:52 CerealeKiller: but an easy player can't handle that fast sliders
00:52 ExKyu: should i change the SV for easy?
00:53 CerealeKiller: yes, lower it to 1.0/1.1 I guess
00:53 CerealeKiller: you can even do lower
00:54 CerealeKiller: and you'll have to change the sliders lenght because of that, it might take time
00:55 ExKyu: oh and btw,should i increase the DS for easy?
00:56 CerealeKiller: No no, 1 is really fine for an easy
00:56 CerealeKiller: what you wanna do when you map an easy, is making the map the more consistent possible, constant DS/SV, all set at 1.0 preferentially, and really keep that DS, no jumps
00:58 ExKyu: ooh i see,alright,i'll try my best
00:59 CerealeKiller: OK so about everydiff, you know, the timing/rythm is good
00:59 CerealeKiller: what poses problem is the aesthetics, and quite often, a lack of flow
00:59 CerealeKiller: do you get the concept of flow ?
01:00 ExKyu: i get it
01:00 ExKyu: btw,are you gonna post this IRC on the forum?
01:01 CerealeKiller: Yep, i'll make a copy paste, so no dirt talking here, beware
01:01 CerealeKiller: yeah so often, you can really improve it, you have often just random transitions between circles/sliders
01:02 *CerealeKiller is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/973467 toby fox - Ghost Fight [Easy]]
01:03 CerealeKiller: like here, 00:05:975 (3,4,5) - , look you force the player to move the cursor upway, and then bam left and up again, it breaks the flow
01:03 CerealeKiller: and those exemple are numerous
01:04 CerealeKiller: of course it doesn't make the map unplayable, nor unrankable, but and accumulation of those makes the map unpleasant to play.
01:04 ExKyu: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5567108 is this good?
01:05 CerealeKiller: It's a bit better, but don't hesitate to move other circles also so as to improve flow
01:07 CerealeKiller: here I would rather see something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5567122
01:07 CerealeKiller: see, keep that going up line of circles, and then smoothly you take that slider to go down
01:09 ExKyu: woah how do you do that?
01:10 CerealeKiller: Actually don't mind changing the easy too much maybe since you'll have to remap it a bit (since of the SV change)
01:10 CerealeKiller: Do what ?
01:10 CerealeKiller: A smooth curved slider ?
01:10 ExKyu: yes
01:10 ExKyu: i can't do that
01:10 CerealeKiller: it's super duper easy actually
01:10 CerealeKiller: when you know how
01:10 CerealeKiller: sometimes the slider maker is capricious
01:11 CerealeKiller: but you start the slider, click once (one gray square), click a third time, and end the slider
01:11 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pV85l.jpg
01:12 CerealeKiller: Sometimes you just have to ctrl+z because it makes you a bad slider, and then you just come back to the one you want
01:14 CerealeKiller: Ok so now I'll just paste you where I personnaly would improve the flow, so you can think about it
01:14 CerealeKiller: 00:10:775 (4,5,6,1) -
01:14 ExKyu: is this good? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5567159
01:15 CerealeKiller: yeah taht's it, it's good yes !
01:15 CerealeKiller: 00:12:908 (1,2,3) - (here it overlaps with the slider so it's kinda ugly)
01:16 CerealeKiller: 00:19:842 (5,1,2) -
01:16 CerealeKiller: 00:28:908 (6,1,2) -
01:16 CerealeKiller: 00:40:642 (1,1) - here no flow problem but the long slider overlaps with the following one
01:17 CerealeKiller: 00:43:842 (1,1) - Same
01:17 CerealeKiller: overlaps well done can be fine, but like this its kinda ugly, you wanna avoid them if you don't master them
01:18 CerealeKiller: ok now normal (still pointing out flow issues)
01:18 *CerealeKiller is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/974562 toby fox - Ghost Fight [Normal]]
01:18 CerealeKiller: 00:07:042 (6,7) -
01:18 CerealeKiller: 00:17:175 (1,2,3) -
01:19 ExKyu: wait,is that all the mistakes i should fix on easy?
01:19 CerealeKiller: That's flow issues, you rather wanna fix them, but it's up to you how
01:19 CerealeKiller: I don't give you much time to do them now, just check them and you'll fix them later, fine for you ?
01:20 CerealeKiller: just ask me questions if you don't understand why
01:20 ExKyu: got it!
01:21 CerealeKiller: also, here, 00:17:175 (1,2) - There's a small gap between those but a 1/1 break between, it fools the player, make a bigger spacing so it fits better with the break
01:21 CerealeKiller: 00:20:642 (4,1) - flow
01:23 CerealeKiller: ok and now hard (should I do the GD aswell ? Will the mapper see it ?)
01:24 ExKyu: yes.the map needs heavily modded
01:24 CerealeKiller: okay, so you'll tell him to read the notes, the copy paste
01:24 CerealeKiller: but I'll do it at the end so he don't have to read everything
01:25 CerealeKiller: (if you have questions don't hesitate eh !)
01:25 CerealeKiller: ok so
01:25 *CerealeKiller is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1005418 toby fox - Ghost Fight [Hard]]
01:26 CerealeKiller: 00:00:642 (2,3,4) - flow, you go in a straight line and then bam the slider a lower
01:26 CerealeKiller: 00:01:842 (6,1) -
01:26 CerealeKiller: 00:02:775 (2,3,1) - Kinda of the same here, you go straight and then suddently back to make that really uncomfortable slider
01:27 CerealeKiller: 00:12:642 (7,1) - Same
01:27 ExKyu: pls forgive me but i still don't get how the flow works
01:27 CerealeKiller: Oh
01:27 CerealeKiller: sorry then maybe i'm bothering too much with it
01:28 CerealeKiller: It's a concept quite abstract to understand sure, I understand it
01:28 CerealeKiller: I'll just show you wait
01:28 ExKyu: no no,it's okay.plus,i'm still a noob at mapping so need to know more
01:28 CerealeKiller: yeah
01:30 CerealeKiller: look
01:31 CerealeKiller: in your map, you're having this pattern
01:31 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pV96Q.jpg
01:31 CerealeKiller: your cursor is going with the slider
01:31 CerealeKiller: goes straight to the circle 2 and 3
01:31 CerealeKiller: the path is smooth
01:32 CerealeKiller: but then you suddenly have that go back, and take that slider
01:32 ExKyu: hmm i see
01:32 CerealeKiller: where I put the red arrow, it's where the flow breaks
01:32 ExKyu: but,if i put the slider on top of the circle,it won't let me because of the DS
01:33 CerealeKiller: Yeah I know !
01:33 CerealeKiller: taht's whu mapping is hard, you have a small area
01:33 ExKyu: should i lower the number 3 circle?
01:33 CerealeKiller: and you'll have to make curves, and twist the map around to get it good
01:34 CerealeKiller: yeah you could try this
01:35 CerealeKiller: for exemple I thought about something like this, that'es a possibility. It's not perfect yet, but I made the angle of rotation wider which makes the flow better
01:35 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pV9jg.jpg
01:36 CerealeKiller: you get how you do it ?
01:36 ExKyu: yes
01:36 CerealeKiller: good good !
01:37 CerealeKiller: ok so I'll stop with flow now
01:38 CerealeKiller: I really recomand you this thread
01:38 CerealeKiller: t/86329
01:38 CerealeKiller: It explains very well the concept and give some good illustrations
01:38 CerealeKiller: maybe try to read it and then take another look at your map (especially what I pointed out)
01:40 CerealeKiller: Ok last thing that your map really lacks
01:40 CerealeKiller: is aesthetics, design
01:41 CerealeKiller: Some patterns are nice, perfectible but nice, but some seem so random
01:41 ExKyu: what difficulty,should be precise?
01:42 CerealeKiller: it concerns all of them, wait i'll explain
01:42 CerealeKiller: I can't really point out everything you can improve, because it's a general impression you want to get better, so it's all small things you should work out
01:42 CerealeKiller: so I'll give you some exemples of what you wanna improve in general
01:43 CerealeKiller: ok first of all, the sliders
01:43 CerealeKiller: making sliders is hard to master, but it really can be powerful
01:44 CerealeKiller: about curved sliders, generally you
01:45 CerealeKiller: for short curved slider, avoid to make them too curved, it doesn't look very well
01:46 CerealeKiller: because then the head and the tail of the slider touch, overlap, which makes it ugly
01:46 CerealeKiller: you will prefer sliders like the 6 than the 7
01:46 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pV9V4.jpg
01:47 ExKyu: ahh i see
01:47 ExKyu: it will be more smooth then
01:47 CerealeKiller: yep !
01:47 ExKyu: rather that sharp sliders
01:47 CerealeKiller: Yeah
01:47 CerealeKiller: that also makes a part of the flow, it improves the map on both sides
01:48 CerealeKiller: I noticed you made a lot of really straight sliders (in hard for exemple)
01:48 CerealeKiller: straight sliders are nice, and can often be very pleasant to look
01:49 CerealeKiller: but in your hard, they are almost every one vertical or horizontal
01:49 CerealeKiller: which makes the map very, squary
01:49 CerealeKiller: BUT, if you rotate them a bit, just a little bit, like 5 degrees, it looks so different
01:52 CerealeKiller: like look here, http://puu.sh/pVae0.jpg, I can't explain why, but I prefer the pattern on the left than on the right
01:52 CerealeKiller: even if it's almost the same
01:52 CerealeKiller: a small rotation made a big change
01:52 CerealeKiller: Just try not to make too much straight vertical and straight horizontal sliders
01:53 CerealeKiller: And finally, be careful with sharp sliders
01:53 CerealeKiller: I mean those with red squares in them
01:53 CerealeKiller: unless you make a small angle (I recommand 60 degrees or lower)
01:54 CerealeKiller: try to curve them
01:54 CerealeKiller: at least parially
01:54 CerealeKiller: partially
01:54 CerealeKiller: I'll show you
01:56 CerealeKiller: Look
01:56 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVas0.jpg
01:56 CerealeKiller: from left to right, I like slider 1, 2 ,3 ,4, but I don't like sliders 5 and 6
01:57 CerealeKiller: (I hope you're still following)
01:57 ExKyu: oh yes i am still following
01:57 CerealeKiller: Good good
01:58 CerealeKiller: About overlaps !
01:58 ExKyu: wait,which is the sliders 5 and 6 you mentioned?
01:58 CerealeKiller: the two on the right
01:58 CerealeKiller: the most on the right
01:58 ExKyu: oooh
01:58 CerealeKiller: see ?
01:59 CerealeKiller: It's not much to do, but imo the outcome is very different
01:59 ExKyu: hmm it is a bit unconfortable to me
01:59 CerealeKiller: what is ?
01:59 CerealeKiller: tell me
01:59 ExKyu: yeah,you're right
01:59 ExKyu: i meant the sliders you mentioned
01:59 CerealeKiller: you don't know how to do them ?
01:59 ExKyu: sliders that too sharp won't feel nice
02:00 CerealeKiller: AH, you mean it's uncompfortable to see, the sharp ones ?
02:00 ExKyu: yes
02:00 CerealeKiller: AH yeah, it is
02:01 CerealeKiller: Also if you want to improve your sliders, and have some ideas I recommand you to read that thread t/37194
02:01 CerealeKiller: but you don't always have to do fancy stuff, often simple shape work just fine
02:02 CerealeKiller: OK so I wanted to talk about overlaps
02:02 CerealeKiller: (you know what overlaps are right ?à
02:02 CerealeKiller: )
02:02 ExKyu: ehh....maybe?
02:02 CerealeKiller: Haha
02:02 CerealeKiller: I'll show you
02:04 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVaQL.jpg and http://puu.sh/pVaNU.jpg
02:04 CerealeKiller: see the circles are just a bit touching eachother
02:04 CerealeKiller: well in most cases you wanna avoid that, just because it's not super beautiful
02:05 CerealeKiller: AND, I know it's what the DS told you, to put the circles just at that precise distance, but here you can just move them just a bit, so the circles don't touch anymore
02:05 CerealeKiller: it won't change the gameplay at all, but i'll look nicer
02:06 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVaZ3.jpg
02:08 ExKyu: in what specific time the previous picture you showed me? because i can't see them
02:08 CerealeKiller: 00:03:308 (1,2) - and
02:09 CerealeKiller: 00:07:575 (5,6) -
02:09 CerealeKiller: there are others but I didn't pin every one
02:10 CerealeKiller: ok last thing
02:10 CerealeKiller: is about elements interacting with others
02:11 CerealeKiller: there are two things you can remember, which will look nice, and which aren't too hard to do
02:12 CerealeKiller: the first are blakets
02:13 CerealeKiller: For exemple here (it's the GD but it's a good exemple) 00:32:108 (2,3) -
02:13 CerealeKiller: Is a place where you could do a blanket
02:13 CerealeKiller: a blanket is when the slider embraces the circle
02:15 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVbsi.jpg
02:15 ExKyu: i don't get it
02:15 CerealeKiller: Look on the bottom is what your friend did, and up is what I did
02:16 CerealeKiller: it's not much different, but in what I did, the slider goes smoothly around the circle
02:17 ExKyu: ooh,it makes them look more flaws right?
02:17 CerealeKiller: you can do it with two sliders also
02:17 CerealeKiller: it can improve the flow
02:17 CerealeKiller: but it mostly just make it nicer to look
02:18 CerealeKiller: but yeah, you can do nice things like this http://puu.sh/pVbCi.jpg
02:19 ExKyu: ahh now i get it
02:19 CerealeKiller: yeah see
02:19 CerealeKiller: a last thing you want to do
02:19 CerealeKiller: is when you have straight sliders
02:19 CerealeKiller: make them parallel
02:19 ExKyu: parallel?
02:19 CerealeKiller: you pretty much did it
02:23 ExKyu: btw,how do you copy this IRC? i want to copy it too on my notepad
02:23 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVbU9.jpg
02:23 CerealeKiller: */savelog
02:23 CerealeKiller: Look, here
02:23 CerealeKiller: you have 3 pairs of sliders
02:23 CerealeKiller: imo
02:23 CerealeKiller: 1 and 2 look good, smooth
02:23 CerealeKiller: but 3 is meh
02:24 ExKyu: what time?
02:24 CerealeKiller: No time
02:24 CerealeKiller: I build that up
02:24 CerealeKiller: I believe you didn't do anything meh
02:24 CerealeKiller: but i'm just giving the advice
02:24 ExKyu: oh sorry lol
02:24 CerealeKiller: Haha it's fine
02:24 ExKyu: i see
02:25 CerealeKiller: that's what I meant by parallel
02:25 CerealeKiller: And that's it, i said everything I thought
02:25 ExKyu: */savelog
02:25 CerealeKiller: You can't solve your map just as easy
02:25 CerealeKiller: without the star haha
02:25 ExKyu: oh sorry

And have fun mapping !
Topic Starter
-Kyu

CerealeKiller wrote:

Hey, I did an IRC mod.

I'll drop some useful links :
t/86329
https://osu.ppy.sh/news/61334266941
t/37194

And here's the log
SPOILER
00:44 CerealeKiller: hey
00:44 ExKyu: oh hey!
00:44 CerealeKiller: Wanna IRC mod ?
00:45 ExKyu: what's IRC?
00:45 CerealeKiller: Here
00:45 CerealeKiller: this chat is IRC haha
00:45 ExKyu: In Real Chat?
00:45 ExKyu: omg lol wild guess
00:45 ExKyu: hmm ok
00:45 CerealeKiller: Internet Relay Chat actually
00:45 CerealeKiller: Oh it's like
00:45 ExKyu: hold on wait
00:46 ExKyu: my osu! needs to be updated
00:46 ExKyu: brb
00:48 CerealeKiller: back
00:48 CerealeKiller: you can do a normal mod, with a post on the forum, but I propose you to make a mod here, I just tell you what I think and have your reaction in real time. It's up to you, if you don't have time I can do a normal mod
00:49 ExKyu: i have time
00:49 CerealeKiller: Okay so lets go ?
00:49 ExKyu: ok!
00:49 ExKyu: what diff should we start?
00:49 CerealeKiller: OK first thing, your SV on the easy is way to high
00:50 CerealeKiller: it's 1.8 while it's 1.2 on the normal
00:50 CerealeKiller: a begginer would be so lost if he started with your map
00:50 ExKyu: oooh that....
00:51 ExKyu: actually it was supposed to be 1.8....but PeterEU modded(or should i say fix) my map and probably changed it
00:51 CerealeKiller: you mean that the easy is supposed to be 1.8 ?
00:51 CerealeKiller: it is already 1.8, but it's too high for an easy
00:52 ExKyu: no no,the normal should be 1.8
00:52 CerealeKiller: AH
00:52 CerealeKiller: Well even
00:52 CerealeKiller: I guess the normal is fine
00:52 CerealeKiller: but an easy player can't handle that fast sliders
00:52 ExKyu: should i change the SV for easy?
00:53 CerealeKiller: yes, lower it to 1.0/1.1 I guess
00:53 CerealeKiller: you can even do lower
00:54 CerealeKiller: and you'll have to change the sliders lenght because of that, it might take time
00:55 ExKyu: oh and btw,should i increase the DS for easy?
00:56 CerealeKiller: No no, 1 is really fine for an easy
00:56 CerealeKiller: what you wanna do when you map an easy, is making the map the more consistent possible, constant DS/SV, all set at 1.0 preferentially, and really keep that DS, no jumps
00:58 ExKyu: ooh i see,alright,i'll try my best
00:59 CerealeKiller: OK so about everydiff, you know, the timing/rythm is good
00:59 CerealeKiller: what poses problem is the aesthetics, and quite often, a lack of flow
00:59 CerealeKiller: do you get the concept of flow ?
01:00 ExKyu: i get it
01:00 ExKyu: btw,are you gonna post this IRC on the forum?
01:01 CerealeKiller: Yep, i'll make a copy paste, so no dirt talking here, beware
01:01 CerealeKiller: yeah so often, you can really improve it, you have often just random transitions between circles/sliders
01:02 *CerealeKiller is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/973467 toby fox - Ghost Fight [Easy]]
01:03 CerealeKiller: like here, 00:05:975 (3,4,5) - , look you force the player to move the cursor upway, and then bam left and up again, it breaks the flow
01:03 CerealeKiller: and those exemple are numerous
01:04 CerealeKiller: of course it doesn't make the map unplayable, nor unrankable, but and accumulation of those makes the map unpleasant to play.
01:04 ExKyu: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5567108 is this good?
01:05 CerealeKiller: It's a bit better, but don't hesitate to move other circles also so as to improve flow
01:07 CerealeKiller: here I would rather see something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5567122
01:07 CerealeKiller: see, keep that going up line of circles, and then smoothly you take that slider to go down
01:09 ExKyu: woah how do you do that?
01:10 CerealeKiller: Actually don't mind changing the easy too much maybe since you'll have to remap it a bit (since of the SV change)
01:10 CerealeKiller: Do what ?
01:10 CerealeKiller: A smooth curved slider ?
01:10 ExKyu: yes
01:10 ExKyu: i can't do that
01:10 CerealeKiller: it's super duper easy actually
01:10 CerealeKiller: when you know how
01:10 CerealeKiller: sometimes the slider maker is capricious
01:11 CerealeKiller: but you start the slider, click once (one gray square), click a third time, and end the slider
01:11 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pV85l.jpg
01:12 CerealeKiller: Sometimes you just have to ctrl+z because it makes you a bad slider, and then you just come back to the one you want
01:14 CerealeKiller: Ok so now I'll just paste you where I personnaly would improve the flow, so you can think about it
01:14 CerealeKiller: 00:10:775 (4,5,6,1) -
01:14 ExKyu: is this good? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5567159
01:15 CerealeKiller: yeah taht's it, it's good yes !
01:15 CerealeKiller: 00:12:908 (1,2,3) - (here it overlaps with the slider so it's kinda ugly)
01:16 CerealeKiller: 00:19:842 (5,1,2) -
01:16 CerealeKiller: 00:28:908 (6,1,2) -
01:16 CerealeKiller: 00:40:642 (1,1) - here no flow problem but the long slider overlaps with the following one
01:17 CerealeKiller: 00:43:842 (1,1) - Same
01:17 CerealeKiller: overlaps well done can be fine, but like this its kinda ugly, you wanna avoid them if you don't master them
01:18 CerealeKiller: ok now normal (still pointing out flow issues)
01:18 *CerealeKiller is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/974562 toby fox - Ghost Fight [Normal]]
01:18 CerealeKiller: 00:07:042 (6,7) -
01:18 CerealeKiller: 00:17:175 (1,2,3) -
01:19 ExKyu: wait,is that all the mistakes i should fix on easy?
01:19 CerealeKiller: That's flow issues, you rather wanna fix them, but it's up to you how
01:19 CerealeKiller: I don't give you much time to do them now, just check them and you'll fix them later, fine for you ?
01:20 CerealeKiller: just ask me questions if you don't understand why
01:20 ExKyu: got it!
01:21 CerealeKiller: also, here, 00:17:175 (1,2) - There's a small gap between those but a 1/1 break between, it fools the player, make a bigger spacing so it fits better with the break
01:21 CerealeKiller: 00:20:642 (4,1) - flow
01:23 CerealeKiller: ok and now hard (should I do the GD aswell ? Will the mapper see it ?)
01:24 ExKyu: yes.the map needs heavily modded
01:24 CerealeKiller: okay, so you'll tell him to read the notes, the copy paste
01:24 CerealeKiller: but I'll do it at the end so he don't have to read everything
01:25 CerealeKiller: (if you have questions don't hesitate eh !)
01:25 CerealeKiller: ok so
01:25 *CerealeKiller is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1005418 toby fox - Ghost Fight [Hard]]
01:26 CerealeKiller: 00:00:642 (2,3,4) - flow, you go in a straight line and then bam the slider a lower
01:26 CerealeKiller: 00:01:842 (6,1) -
01:26 CerealeKiller: 00:02:775 (2,3,1) - Kinda of the same here, you go straight and then suddently back to make that really uncomfortable slider
01:27 CerealeKiller: 00:12:642 (7,1) - Same
01:27 ExKyu: pls forgive me but i still don't get how the flow works
01:27 CerealeKiller: Oh
01:27 CerealeKiller: sorry then maybe i'm bothering too much with it
01:28 CerealeKiller: It's a concept quite abstract to understand sure, I understand it
01:28 CerealeKiller: I'll just show you wait
01:28 ExKyu: no no,it's okay.plus,i'm still a noob at mapping so need to know more
01:28 CerealeKiller: yeah
01:30 CerealeKiller: look
01:31 CerealeKiller: in your map, you're having this pattern
01:31 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pV96Q.jpg
01:31 CerealeKiller: your cursor is going with the slider
01:31 CerealeKiller: goes straight to the circle 2 and 3
01:31 CerealeKiller: the path is smooth
01:32 CerealeKiller: but then you suddenly have that go back, and take that slider
01:32 ExKyu: hmm i see
01:32 CerealeKiller: where I put the red arrow, it's where the flow breaks
01:32 ExKyu: but,if i put the slider on top of the circle,it won't let me because of the DS
01:33 CerealeKiller: Yeah I know !
01:33 CerealeKiller: taht's whu mapping is hard, you have a small area
01:33 ExKyu: should i lower the number 3 circle?
01:33 CerealeKiller: and you'll have to make curves, and twist the map around to get it good
01:34 CerealeKiller: yeah you could try this
01:35 CerealeKiller: for exemple I thought about something like this, that'es a possibility. It's not perfect yet, but I made the angle of rotation wider which makes the flow better
01:35 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pV9jg.jpg
01:36 CerealeKiller: you get how you do it ?
01:36 ExKyu: yes
01:36 CerealeKiller: good good !
01:37 CerealeKiller: ok so I'll stop with flow now
01:38 CerealeKiller: I really recomand you this thread
01:38 CerealeKiller: t/86329
01:38 CerealeKiller: It explains very well the concept and give some good illustrations
01:38 CerealeKiller: maybe try to read it and then take another look at your map (especially what I pointed out)
01:40 CerealeKiller: Ok last thing that your map really lacks
01:40 CerealeKiller: is aesthetics, design
01:41 CerealeKiller: Some patterns are nice, perfectible but nice, but some seem so random
01:41 ExKyu: what difficulty,should be precise?
01:42 CerealeKiller: it concerns all of them, wait i'll explain
01:42 CerealeKiller: I can't really point out everything you can improve, because it's a general impression you want to get better, so it's all small things you should work out
01:42 CerealeKiller: so I'll give you some exemples of what you wanna improve in general
01:43 CerealeKiller: ok first of all, the sliders
01:43 CerealeKiller: making sliders is hard to master, but it really can be powerful
01:44 CerealeKiller: about curved sliders, generally you
01:45 CerealeKiller: for short curved slider, avoid to make them too curved, it doesn't look very well
01:46 CerealeKiller: because then the head and the tail of the slider touch, overlap, which makes it ugly
01:46 CerealeKiller: you will prefer sliders like the 6 than the 7
01:46 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pV9V4.jpg
01:47 ExKyu: ahh i see
01:47 ExKyu: it will be more smooth then
01:47 CerealeKiller: yep !
01:47 ExKyu: rather that sharp sliders
01:47 CerealeKiller: Yeah
01:47 CerealeKiller: that also makes a part of the flow, it improves the map on both sides
01:48 CerealeKiller: I noticed you made a lot of really straight sliders (in hard for exemple)
01:48 CerealeKiller: straight sliders are nice, and can often be very pleasant to look
01:49 CerealeKiller: but in your hard, they are almost every one vertical or horizontal
01:49 CerealeKiller: which makes the map very, squary
01:49 CerealeKiller: BUT, if you rotate them a bit, just a little bit, like 5 degrees, it looks so different
01:52 CerealeKiller: like look here, http://puu.sh/pVae0.jpg, I can't explain why, but I prefer the pattern on the left than on the right
01:52 CerealeKiller: even if it's almost the same
01:52 CerealeKiller: a small rotation made a big change
01:52 CerealeKiller: Just try not to make too much straight vertical and straight horizontal sliders
01:53 CerealeKiller: And finally, be careful with sharp sliders
01:53 CerealeKiller: I mean those with red squares in them
01:53 CerealeKiller: unless you make a small angle (I recommand 60 degrees or lower)
01:54 CerealeKiller: try to curve them
01:54 CerealeKiller: at least parially
01:54 CerealeKiller: partially
01:54 CerealeKiller: I'll show you
01:56 CerealeKiller: Look
01:56 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVas0.jpg
01:56 CerealeKiller: from left to right, I like slider 1, 2 ,3 ,4, but I don't like sliders 5 and 6
01:57 CerealeKiller: (I hope you're still following)
01:57 ExKyu: oh yes i am still following
01:57 CerealeKiller: Good good
01:58 CerealeKiller: About overlaps !
01:58 ExKyu: wait,which is the sliders 5 and 6 you mentioned?
01:58 CerealeKiller: the two on the right
01:58 CerealeKiller: the most on the right
01:58 ExKyu: oooh
01:58 CerealeKiller: see ?
01:59 CerealeKiller: It's not much to do, but imo the outcome is very different
01:59 ExKyu: hmm it is a bit unconfortable to me
01:59 CerealeKiller: what is ?
01:59 CerealeKiller: tell me
01:59 ExKyu: yeah,you're right
01:59 ExKyu: i meant the sliders you mentioned
01:59 CerealeKiller: you don't know how to do them ?
01:59 ExKyu: sliders that too sharp won't feel nice
02:00 CerealeKiller: AH, you mean it's uncompfortable to see, the sharp ones ?
02:00 ExKyu: yes
02:00 CerealeKiller: AH yeah, it is
02:01 CerealeKiller: Also if you want to improve your sliders, and have some ideas I recommand you to read that thread t/37194
02:01 CerealeKiller: but you don't always have to do fancy stuff, often simple shape work just fine
02:02 CerealeKiller: OK so I wanted to talk about overlaps
02:02 CerealeKiller: (you know what overlaps are right ?à
02:02 CerealeKiller: )
02:02 ExKyu: ehh....maybe?
02:02 CerealeKiller: Haha
02:02 CerealeKiller: I'll show you
02:04 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVaQL.jpg and http://puu.sh/pVaNU.jpg
02:04 CerealeKiller: see the circles are just a bit touching eachother
02:04 CerealeKiller: well in most cases you wanna avoid that, just because it's not super beautiful
02:05 CerealeKiller: AND, I know it's what the DS told you, to put the circles just at that precise distance, but here you can just move them just a bit, so the circles don't touch anymore
02:05 CerealeKiller: it won't change the gameplay at all, but i'll look nicer
02:06 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVaZ3.jpg
02:08 ExKyu: in what specific time the previous picture you showed me? because i can't see them
02:08 CerealeKiller: 00:03:308 (1,2) - and
02:09 CerealeKiller: 00:07:575 (5,6) -
02:09 CerealeKiller: there are others but I didn't pin every one
02:10 CerealeKiller: ok last thing
02:10 CerealeKiller: is about elements interacting with others
02:11 CerealeKiller: there are two things you can remember, which will look nice, and which aren't too hard to do
02:12 CerealeKiller: the first are blakets
02:13 CerealeKiller: For exemple here (it's the GD but it's a good exemple) 00:32:108 (2,3) -
02:13 CerealeKiller: Is a place where you could do a blanket
02:13 CerealeKiller: a blanket is when the slider embraces the circle
02:15 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVbsi.jpg
02:15 ExKyu: i don't get it
02:15 CerealeKiller: Look on the bottom is what your friend did, and up is what I did
02:16 CerealeKiller: it's not much different, but in what I did, the slider goes smoothly around the circle
02:17 ExKyu: ooh,it makes them look more flaws right?
02:17 CerealeKiller: you can do it with two sliders also
02:17 CerealeKiller: it can improve the flow
02:17 CerealeKiller: but it mostly just make it nicer to look
02:18 CerealeKiller: but yeah, you can do nice things like this http://puu.sh/pVbCi.jpg
02:19 ExKyu: ahh now i get it
02:19 CerealeKiller: yeah see
02:19 CerealeKiller: a last thing you want to do
02:19 CerealeKiller: is when you have straight sliders
02:19 CerealeKiller: make them parallel
02:19 ExKyu: parallel?
02:19 CerealeKiller: you pretty much did it
02:23 ExKyu: btw,how do you copy this IRC? i want to copy it too on my notepad
02:23 CerealeKiller: http://puu.sh/pVbU9.jpg
02:23 CerealeKiller: */savelog
02:23 CerealeKiller: Look, here
02:23 CerealeKiller: you have 3 pairs of sliders
02:23 CerealeKiller: imo
02:23 CerealeKiller: 1 and 2 look good, smooth
02:23 CerealeKiller: but 3 is meh
02:24 ExKyu: what time?
02:24 CerealeKiller: No time
02:24 CerealeKiller: I build that up
02:24 CerealeKiller: I believe you didn't do anything meh
02:24 CerealeKiller: but i'm just giving the advice
02:24 ExKyu: oh sorry lol
02:24 CerealeKiller: Haha it's fine
02:24 ExKyu: i see
02:25 CerealeKiller: that's what I meant by parallel
02:25 CerealeKiller: And that's it, i said everything I thought
02:25 ExKyu: */savelog
02:25 CerealeKiller: You can't solve your map just as easy
02:25 CerealeKiller: without the star haha
02:25 ExKyu: oh sorry

And have fun mapping !

Thank You So Much for your Mod! :)
Sklitterbeer
such awesome song! :o (from #modreqs)

Easy
00:05:975 (3) - Nudge this note a little to the bottom left, A LITTLE, so it lies exactly on the sliderend, exactly!!, for better aesthetic effect. :3
00:21:975 (2,3,4) - don't know about these mate, maybe too hard to read for beginners


The diff is ok. Not outstanding or smth lol

Normal
Make 00:02:775 (2) look like that, remember BEGINNERS are playing the ez/normal diffs :D
00:11:575 (3) - what's with the hitsound here mate? XD finish should be used to FINISH other segments ffs lol
00:32:109 (1) - CODE RED! XD After spinners, at least in ez/normal diffs, there should be some time after the spinner to let the beginner relocate their cursor, because they spun it wildly. Maybe take out the slider. It just doesn't fit there lol
00:40:642 (1) - same here (I was thinking long slider maybe? :p)

PeterEU's Hard
There are so many things wrong with this diff. First off, too many sliders!!! You don't need that many in a hard diff! You should work more with circles, make mini streams, triplets, more jumps etc.. also the spinner at the end feels out of place. There isn't even a sound that would go with it lawllll (you might be saying "there aren't too much sliders wtf" the mapper should work more with circles instead of circles is what im implying here.

for exampel

00:14:642 (6) - this could EASILY have been a triplet. but not a repeating 1/4 slider... ah well, it's not like he's gonna get over his pride and change it lol :p)

Hard
00:07:575 (5) - really? :p make them closer together, this hurts so focking much when I play a map looool
00:29:708 (1) - the slider ends at the opposite side of the next circle. Not a code red situation but it would look better if you maybe rotated it 90 degrees
00:29:708 (1,7,2) - the red and orange circle overlap a little. change-a-that sir!


gl with ur map
Topic Starter
-Kyu

SUPER_Samurai_ wrote:

such awesome song! :o (from #modreqs)

Easy
00:05:975 (3) - Nudge this note a little to the bottom left, A LITTLE, so it lies exactly on the sliderend, exactly!!, for better aesthetic effect. :3-Done
00:21:975 (2,3,4) - don't know about these mate, maybe too hard to read for beginners -Done


The diff is ok. Not outstanding or smth lol

Normal
Make 00:02:775 (2) look like that, remember BEGINNERS are playing the ez/normal diffs :D -Done
00:11:575 (3) - what's with the hitsound here mate? XD finish should be used to FINISH other segments ffs lol -Ok,changed it
00:32:109 (1) - CODE RED! XD After spinners, at least in ez/normal diffs, there should be some time after the spinner to let the beginner relocate their cursor, because they spun it wildly. Maybe take out the slider. It just doesn't fit there lol -I don't think it should be changed.My brother has tested it (he's really suck at osu!)and i asked him if it was hard for him,and he said no,it's ok
00:40:642 (1) - same here (I was thinking long slider maybe? :p) -same ^


PeterEU's Hard
There are so many things wrong with this diff. First off, too many sliders!!! You don't need that many in a hard diff! You should work more with circles, make mini streams, triplets, more jumps etc.. also the spinner at the end feels out of place. There isn't even a sound that would go with it lawllll (you might be saying "there aren't too much sliders wtf" the mapper should work more with circles instead of circles is what im implying here. -You might want to see this http://puu.sh/q4FJH/dd3afa5816.png

for exampel

00:14:642 (6) - this could EASILY have been a triplet. but not a repeating 1/4 slider... ah well, it's not like he's gonna get over his pride and change it lol :p)

Hard
00:07:575 (5) - really? :p make them closer together, this hurts so focking much when I play a map looool -Done
00:29:708 (1) - the slider ends at the opposite side of the next circle. Not a code red situation but it would look better if you maybe rotated it 90 degrees -Done
00:29:708 (1,7,2) - the red and orange circle overlap a little. change-a-that sir! -What overlap? i think you miscopied the circles sir!


gl with ur map
Peter

SUPER_Samurai_ wrote:

such awesome song! :o (from #modreqs)

PeterEU's Hard
There are so many things wrong with this diff. First off, too many sliders!!! You don't need that many in a hard diff! You should work more with circles, make mini streams, triplets, more jumps etc.. also the spinner at the end feels out of place. There isn't even a sound that would go with it lawllll (you might be saying "there aren't too much sliders wtf" the mapper should work more with circles instead of circles is what im implying here.

for exampel

00:14:642 (6) - this could EASILY have been a triplet. but not a repeating 1/4 slider... ah well, it's not like he's gonna get over his pride and change it lol :p)

gl with ur map
oh rly ?
Rizevim
2 Hard diff? :o
Normal
00:22:242 - u can add notes here & and a whistle sound here
00:22:775 - ^
00:23:308 - ^
00:24:375 (9) - how about adding whistle sound here ? :D
00:43:042 (2) - ^
00:47:042 (1,2) - ^
Topic Starter
-Kyu

Rizevim wrote:

2 Hard diff? :o
Normal
00:22:242 - u can add notes here & and a whistle sound here
00:22:775 - ^
00:23:308 - ^
00:24:375 (9) - how about adding whistle sound here ? :D
00:43:042 (2) - ^
00:47:042 (1,2) - ^
Thanks For The Mod~
Sklitterbeer

PeterEU wrote:

oh rly ?


Well, that map has a lot of long beats lmao. Because you're mapping a chiptune song, there aren't a lot of "long" beats. Well, even if, there are still mini streams and triplets missing. :P
Jayne
This map plays wrong, it doesn't follow the music at all.

It's almost entirely in triplets, and you've put everything on the beat.

For example, the slider at 00:08:642 (1) should be extended to end on the second third and the slider at 00:38:775 (2) should be broken up into two different sliders each ending on their respective third. You can't pick a song that's using triplets and then map it on the beat.
forgott3n
best luck to this beatmap
Topic Starter
-Kyu

Jayne wrote:

This map plays wrong, it doesn't follow the music at all.

It's almost entirely in triplets, and you've put everything on the beat.

For example, the slider at 00:08:642 (1) should be extended to end on the second third and the slider at 00:38:775 (2) should be broken up into two different sliders each ending on their respective third. You can't pick a song that's using triplets and then map it on the beat.
No triplets eh? Ok,i'll do what you say,i delete some of the triplets and change it to a long slider (and sorry for the late reply,i kinda don't want to update the map for a few days)


Angelin Dash wrote:

best luck to this beatmap
Thanks so much! i will do hard on this map
intiaz
idk if this will be helpful or not

:
Never saw anything wrong with this, except for from 00:00:109 - 00:17:175 seems to have a repetitive pattern. If possible you should try to fix it. Next diff!!

:
Only problem is from 00:21:975 - 00:25:175 needs combo colors.

PeterEU's:
The 1/8 snap SEEMS INSANE
but thats probably how it's mapped so oh well
At the ending, the spinner should end sooner. :D

:
00:34:242 - 00:37:708 Combo colors! Combo colors!!!!!
and nothing else is wrong with this

Alright, there you go! idk if this is useful, enjoy!
Topic Starter
-Kyu

Intiaz Haniff wrote:

idk if this will be helpful or not

:
Never saw anything wrong with this, except for from 00:00:109 - 00:17:175 seems to have a repetitive pattern. If possible you should try to fix it. Next diff!! idk if i should change it or not,it seems okay to me :)

:
Only problem is from 00:21:975 - 00:25:175 needs combo colors.
Fixed
PeterEU's:
The 1/8 snap SEEMS INSANE
but thats probably how it's mapped so oh well
At the ending, the spinner should end sooner. :D Ok,fixed

:
00:34:242 - 00:37:708 Combo colors! Combo colors!!!!!
and nothing else is wrong with this Fixed

Alright, there you go! idk if this is useful, enjoy!

Thanks for the mod! why do i keep forgetting about the combo colors.....
DeletedUser_2179411
Hi M4M from #modreqs ..

General :
Untick the windscreen support in some of the diff .. since there is no SB..

Easy :

00:01:708 (3) - here i recommended for you to put a circle on the beginning of this slider .. and the slider well start here 00:02:242 - and end as it is
00:03:842 (6) - ^ same .. the slider should begin here 00:04:375 -
00:06:508 (10) - remove this circle and replace it with a slider and end this slider here 00:07:042 - and the next white line it should the next slider will begin ..
00:08:642 (1,2) - blanket this slider with the circle ..
00:19:308 (4,5) - Same as 00:06:508 (10) - to follow the beat , i think
00:26:242 (2,3) - it doesnt look nice here .. make the slider curve and blanket with circle no. 2
00:38:508 (1,1) - fix these two circles and blanket with each other ..
00:40:642 (1) - please make it more beautiful .. just remove it and make it more beautiful ..
00:47:042 (1,1) - Same as 00:38:508 (1,1) - please blanket ..

Normal :

00:00:908 (3) - put a circle on the beginning of this slider and let the slider start from the next white line .. like this -> http://i.imgur.com/dqnDXJF.png .. and make the other slider start from the next white line like the picture ..
00:03:042 (3,4) - ^ Same ..
00:07:308 (7) - its hard for the beginners to play on this slider .. make the slider one reverse and put a circle on the next white line ..
00:13:975 (4) - ^ same its hard to read .. so i recommended for you to remove the reverse and add a slider on next white line ..
00:19:308 (1) - make it more beautiful please ..
00:20:642 (4) - put a slider on the red line and let the slider start from the next white line and end it here 00:21:175 - and add a slider on the next white line and end it on the next red line ..
00:21:975 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3) - please remap this part it sound off .. sorry :(
00:25:175 (4,1,2) - remove these circles and add a slider on it with a reverse on the red line .. i think its follow the beat like that ..
00:29:975 (2) - don't make too much reverse on one slider is hard to read so remap it :( ..
00:36:375 (5) - Same ^

Hard :

00:15:042 (1) - its really old looking so change it please ..
00:35:308 (4,1) - put the slider first and the circle next the slider ..
00:36:375 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - why this part like that .. its not following the beat .. so please remap this part .. :( its up to you
00:38:775 (2) - Same as 00:15:042 (1) -

PeterEU's Hard :

there is so much noises please recheck the HS .. sorry :(


00:01:842 (7) - resnap this slider ..
00:14:642 (6) - why reverse here please remove it and and snap it ..
and please recheck on this diff ..there is some parts are not snapped ..

that's all ..

GL on your map ..
Topic Starter
-Kyu

Rose Melody wrote:

Hi M4M from #modreqs ..

General :
Untick the windscreen support in some of the diff .. since there is no SB..

Easy :

00:01:708 (3) - here i recommended for you to put a circle on the beginning of this slider .. and the slider well start here 00:02:242 - and end as it is
00:03:842 (6) - ^ same .. the slider should begin here 00:04:375 -
00:06:508 (10) - remove this circle and replace it with a slider and end this slider here 00:07:042 - and the next white line it should the next slider will begin ..
00:08:642 (1,2) - blanket this slider with the circle ..
00:19:308 (4,5) - Same as 00:06:508 (10) - to follow the beat , i think
00:26:242 (2,3) - it doesnt look nice here .. make the slider curve and blanket with circle no. 2
00:38:508 (1,1) - fix these two circles and blanket with each other ..
00:40:642 (1) - please make it more beautiful .. just remove it and make it more beautiful ..
00:47:042 (1,1) - Same as 00:38:508 (1,1) - please blanket ..

Normal :

00:00:908 (3) - put a circle on the beginning of this slider and let the slider start from the next white line .. like this -> http://i.imgur.com/dqnDXJF.png .. and make the other slider start from the next white line like the picture ..
00:03:042 (3,4) - ^ Same ..
00:07:308 (7) - its hard for the beginners to play on this slider .. make the slider one reverse and put a circle on the next white line ..
00:13:975 (4) - ^ same its hard to read .. so i recommended for you to remove the reverse and add a slider on next white line ..
00:19:308 (1) - make it more beautiful please ..
00:20:642 (4) - put a slider on the red line and let the slider start from the next white line and end it here 00:21:175 - and add a slider on the next white line and end it on the next red line ..
00:21:975 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3) - please remap this part it sound off .. sorry :(
00:25:175 (4,1,2) - remove these circles and add a slider on it with a reverse on the red line .. i think its follow the beat like that ..
00:29:975 (2) - don't make too much reverse on one slider is hard to read so remap it :( ..
00:36:375 (5) - Same ^

Hard :

00:15:042 (1) - its really old looking so change it please ..
00:35:308 (4,1) - put the slider first and the circle next the slider ..
00:36:375 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - why this part like that .. its not following the beat .. so please remap this part .. :( its up to you
00:38:775 (2) - Same as 00:15:042 (1) -

PeterEU's Hard :

there is so much noises please recheck the HS .. sorry :(


00:01:842 (7) - resnap this slider ..
00:14:642 (6) - why reverse here please remove it and and snap it ..
and please recheck on this diff ..there is some parts are not snapped ..

that's all ..

GL on your map ..

Thank You Very Much! This is very useful!
lazygirl
Oy from modding queue ^^ Sorry for late mod

Easy:

00:01:708 (3,5,9) - make these three first a note then a slider 1/2 the length. This doesn't fit and messes up your NC's
00:40:642 (1) - weird shape and it doesn't fit the rhythm
00:48:108 (1) - remove NC

You need to blanket more, and rhythmically this doesn't always hit the point. Use return sliders more as well ^^

Normal:

A lot of overlaps, be careful this is hard to read for players who play those diffs. Also, lacking blanketting, and as well a lot of long sliders where 1/2 the length would be best.

PeterEU's Hard:

00:01:841 (7) - rhythmically completely off, there's no 1/3 here it's all 1/4
00:16:108 (4,5) - 1/4 not 1/3
00:51:309 (1) - stop mapping here

There's a lot of mistakes in this one. Rhythmically it's quite off, sliders are not blanketted and the patterns are very random.

Hard:

00:21:442 (1,1,1,1) - don't NC
00:24:642 (5) - doesn't fit
00:32:108 (1) - ^

Again blanket, careful for rhythms and flow is weird.

I can see you're new to mapping, and it's not too bad. Lots of mistakes, but nothing that can't be fixed by mapping more! So good luck learning to map and have fun as well doing so :D
Topic Starter
-Kyu
Updated!
intiaz
First:
I made a guest difficulty for your map! I hope you'll use it, it's SUPER-EASY, "Nyantiaz's Beginner."
Here it is!
osu file format v14

[General]
AudioFilename: Undertale OST_ 010 - Ghost Fight.mp3
AudioLeadIn: 0
PreviewTime: 17175
Countdown: 1
SampleSet: Soft
StackLeniency: 0.7
Mode: 0
LetterboxInBreaks: 1
WidescreenStoryboard: 1

[Editor]
DistanceSpacing: 1
BeatDivisor: 2
GridSize: 8
TimelineZoom: 1

[Metadata]
Title:Ghost Fight
TitleUnicode:Ghost Fight
Artist:toby fox
ArtistUnicode:toby fox
Creator:ExKyu
Version:Nyantiaz's Beginner
Source:Undertale
Tags:napstablook undertale soundtrack PeterEU
BeatmapID:0
BeatmapSetID:453997

[Difficulty]
HPDrainRate:2
CircleSize:2
OverallDifficulty:1
ApproachRate:1
SliderMultiplier:0.400000005960464
SliderTickRate:1

[Events]
//Background and Video events
0,0,"Napstablook.jpg",0,0
//Break Periods
//Storyboard Layer 0 (Background)
//Storyboard Layer 1 (Fail)
//Storyboard Layer 2 (Pass)
//Storyboard Layer 3 (Foreground)
//Storyboard Sound Samples

[TimingPoints]
109,533.333333333333,4,2,0,35,1,0
17175,-100,4,2,0,35,0,1
33708,-100,4,2,0,35,0,0


[HitObjects]
88,104,109,6,4,B|128:168|128:168|96:248,1,160.000002384186
192,304,3308,1,8,0:0:0:0:
288,256,4375,2,4,B|328:240|328:240|360:264|392:272|424:248|416:216,2,160.000002384186
176,208,9708,2,8,B|136:224|136:224|88:200|88:200|64:264,1,160.000002384186
192,312,12908,2,8,B|240:280|240:280|288:336,2,120.000001788139
88,272,17175,5,2,0:0:0:0:
176,208,18242,2,4,B|208:176|208:176|240:208|240:208|216:280,1,160.000002384186
320,280,21442,1,8,0:0:0:0:
376,200,22508,2,4,B|424:176|424:176|456:216|456:216|520:192,1,160.000002384186
360,104,25708,6,2,L|320:112,2,40.0000005960464
184,112,27842,2,2,B|136:112|136:112|120:160|80:120,1,120.000001788139
280,168,29975,1,8,0:0:0:0:
224,256,31042,2,8,B|264:280|264:280|272:296|272:296|336:288,1,120.000001788139
416,208,33175,6,2,B|400:144|400:144|376:152|376:152|360:80,1,160.000002384186
240,112,36375,2,2,L|152:144,1,80.0000011920928
224,232,38508,2,8,B|248:272|248:272|296:272,2,80.0000011920928
128,288,41708,1,4,0:0:0:0:
56,224,42775,6,2,B|32:200|32:200|32:64,1,160.000002384186
128,128,45975,1,8,0:0:0:0:
232,120,47042,2,0,B|288:168|288:168|264:192|264:192|280:216,1,120.000001788139
256,192,49175,12,0,51308,0:0:0:0:

Second:
I made a banner for your map! :)

Download: boop
Ayyri
undertale map #929476498476016484056729804567248906572506
Topic Starter
-Kyu

Ayyri wrote:

undertale map #929476498476016484056729804567248906572506
ayy
paydayzcool
I saw a like on my map https://osu.ppy.sh/s/486364 and I decided to give some thanks by modding ur map. XD

Alright.

[Easy]
Turn off grid snap, you wont need it as it will make your map look like it only flows up and down, left to right only. It also helps you use the technique described below.

This map needs to utilize a special technique called "blankets". (https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Formation_Techn ... ket_Combos) This will help make the look of your map much cleaner. For examples:
00:00:109 (1,2,3) - These notes can be changed to look like: https://puu.sh/qRqB9/43dc32d549.png (Notice how the approach circle of 2 matches the curves of 1 and 3)
00:03:308 (4,5) - Although I have rotated 5 clockwise by a lot, you can also see that 4's approach circle is following the inside curve of 5. https://puu.sh/qRqNn/57f597b4fd.png
00:06:508 (8,9) - Blanket curves in your map can also be neatened up more. Notice how 8's approach circle is not following the inside curve of 9: https://puu.sh/qRqR2/e833814e10.png
00:12:908 (1,2) - What you've done here is excellent, but if grid snap was off, it could be even better.
00:14:508 (3,4) - This here is well done. No need to change.
00:23:575 (5,6) - The followcircle of a slider can also make good blankets. This can be demonstrated with these notes: https://puu.sh/qRr2P/5ee073201b.png
Ok, I trust that you now know how this technique works, so please apply this to the other parts of the map that most likely need it. XD

00:00:109 (1) - Be careful when using these types of sliders. Because if you wanted to make a long arc or circle with them, it would be harder and less precise. I'll show you a comparison:

Comparison 1
https://puu.sh/qRrjr/218e25d2c0.png
vs
https://puu.sh/qRrzV/fc83a9dc60.png

Comparison 2
https://puu.sh/qRrFB/3d445c0c31.png
vs
https://puu.sh/qRrO7/86f5af8800.png

You can even move the middlepoint around and make it look even uglier: https://puu.sh/qRrUe/17ecf05f0a.png
So yeah, try to avoid them.

00:06:508 (8,9) - Avoid overlapping notes in easy and normal diffs. It makes the map look less readable.

Well done!
[]

[Normal]
Ok, please revise the distance snapping in this diff. The discrepancies with spacing between two notes are too evident. (One example would be these notes 00:11:309 (2,3,4).)
Also use the blanket technique on notes in this diff that most likely need it.
00:08:642 (1,2) - Once again, please don't overlap notes in easy/normal diffs. It looks less readable to beginner players.
00:20:642 (4) - This is a great example of the weird type of slider I explained in the Easy diff. Note how the curve is completely off.
00:20:642 (4,1) - Also, avoid this overlap.

Nice work again!
[]

[PeterEU's Hard]
A bit better with blankets, but there are still some that need to be cleaned up a bit more.
It also reminds me of a 2009-2011 map.
[]

[Hard]
Whoah, the clap hitsound are way too loud and distracting. (00:21:442 (1,2,3,4))
[]

This map imo is quite good, but I'm sure it can be better XDDD.

Also, if you think that I sound too strict and/or unhelpful, you can choose not to give me a kudosu and ignore this post entirely. :D
Topic Starter
-Kyu
:(

paydayzcool wrote:

I saw a like on my map https://osu.ppy.sh/s/486364 and I decided to give some thanks by modding ur map. XD

Alright.

[Easy]
Turn off grid snap, you wont need it as it will make your map look like it only flows up and down, left to right only. It also helps you use the technique described below.

This map needs to utilize a special technique called "blankets". (https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Formation_Techn ... ket_Combos) This will help make the look of your map much cleaner. For examples:
00:00:109 (1,2,3) - These notes can be changed to look like: https://puu.sh/qRqB9/43dc32d549.png (Notice how the approach circle of 2 matches the curves of 1 and 3)
00:03:308 (4,5) - Although I have rotated 5 clockwise by a lot, you can also see that 4's approach circle is following the inside curve of 5. https://puu.sh/qRqNn/57f597b4fd.png
00:06:508 (8,9) - Blanket curves in your map can also be neatened up more. Notice how 8's approach circle is not following the inside curve of 9: https://puu.sh/qRqR2/e833814e10.png
00:12:908 (1,2) - What you've done here is excellent, but if grid snap was off, it could be even better.
00:14:508 (3,4) - This here is well done. No need to change.
00:23:575 (5,6) - The followcircle of a slider can also make good blankets. This can be demonstrated with these notes: https://puu.sh/qRr2P/5ee073201b.png
Ok, I trust that you now know how this technique works, so please apply this to the other parts of the map that most likely need it. XD

00:00:109 (1) - Be careful when using these types of sliders. Because if you wanted to make a long arc or circle with them, it would be harder and less precise. I'll show you a comparison:

Comparison 1
https://puu.sh/qRrjr/218e25d2c0.png
vs
https://puu.sh/qRrzV/fc83a9dc60.png

Comparison 2
https://puu.sh/qRrFB/3d445c0c31.png
vs
https://puu.sh/qRrO7/86f5af8800.png

You can even move the middlepoint around and make it look even uglier: https://puu.sh/qRrUe/17ecf05f0a.png
So yeah, try to avoid them.

00:06:508 (8,9) - Avoid overlapping notes in easy and normal diffs. It makes the map look less readable.

Well done!
[]

[Normal]
Ok, please revise the distance snapping in this diff. The discrepancies with spacing between two notes are too evident. (One example would be these notes 00:11:309 (2,3,4).)
Also use the blanket technique on notes in this diff that most likely need it.
00:08:642 (1,2) - Once again, please don't overlap notes in easy/normal diffs. It looks less readable to beginner players.
00:20:642 (4) - This is a great example of the weird type of slider I explained in the Easy diff. Note how the curve is completely off.
00:20:642 (4,1) - Also, avoid this overlap.

Nice work again!
[]

[PeterEU's Hard]
A bit better with blankets, but there are still some that need to be cleaned up a bit more.
It also reminds me of a 2009-2011 map.
[]

[Hard]
Whoah, the clap hitsound are way too loud and distracting. (00:21:442 (1,2,3,4))
[]

This map imo is quite good, but I'm sure it can be better XDDD.

Also, if you think that I sound too strict and/or unhelpful, you can choose not to give me a kudosu and ignore this post entirely. :D

Thank You for Your Generous Mod!
I'll apply this tomorrow,because i gtg to sleep :)
Edit: it seems like most of your puush is unavailable.Would you mind resend the puush so i can understand more? thanks
Zozimoto
Ill Get A BN
Topic Starter
-Kyu

Zozimoto wrote:

Ill Get A BN

PLZ FIND ONE I NEED THIS TO BE RANKED
Zozimoto
God Damit Bara. Well, I Tried Getting A BN
Topic Starter
-Kyu

Zozimoto wrote:

God Damit Bara. Well, I Tried Getting A BN

Thanks though for your effort~
I do know that this needs a lot of mods
Zozimoto

ExKyu wrote:

Zozimoto wrote:

God Damit Bara. Well, I Tried Getting A BN

Thanks though for your effort~
I do know that this needs a lot of mods
Sadly, I Cant Mod, Cause
  1. I Dont Find Errors
  2. I Cant Think The Way You Are Thinking With This Map, So I Will Only Ruin The Map With A Mod
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply