I told you this in the IRC channel, but honestly, I think it's pretty sleek. The beats are attractive and I like the way the spinner looks. It seems less iPod to me and more metallic, though, not that I'm complaining. The 'score iPods' are also kind of nice, despite being a bit out there-- thought it took a few games to get used to them.
I'll use this skin for a while.
Oh, also, on the subject of criticism, if you really want to make it more iPody, I recommend less metal and more ceramic, in terms of color and the way it all looks.