forum

P!nk - Who Knew

posted
Total Posts
145
show more
Lizbeth
Hi there~~

Re-checking~ :3

Collab
this should be farther from prev object:
00:37:342 (5) -
00:52:342 (1) -
02:12:699 (1) -
02:32:413 (2) -
I know you mainly follow the vocals, but I suggest to add notes on the next white ticks:
00:13:985 -
00:27:699 -
00:55:128 -
01:12:270 -
01:25:985 -
02:41:413 -

Relaxing;
01:24:485 (4) - mmm doesn't fit that much, what about this: http://puu.sh/3Ip4
01:54:699 (1) - start spinner on next white tick, and add circle here.

Maybe use tick rate 2 for all diffs, as ShaggoN diff?
I like the new BG and colors btw ^^<3
Bittersweet
Chequei e ta ok por mim kiwii. Mas bateu preguiça de upar diff e tal por causa de 3 notas, então~ pode add pra mim? x3

And thanks, Liz :3
Kurai
Sorry, I'm late ;~;

General
  1. The background is 800x601. It would be much better if you resize it to 800x601 even if it's just for 1px >.<
Relaxing
  1. HP drain 5 is not a good idea for the easiest difficulty, please reduce it.
  2. 00:20:413 (3) - Add a whistle to this circle to keep the same rhythm as you made with hitsounds before (like 00:18:485 (2,3,4,5))
  3. 00:34:556 (2,4) - As the pattern follows the vocal, these sliders have to follow the vocal too else, they feel late. So reduce them by 1/2 ? Moreover 00:36:270 (4,5,6) are hard too read for new players because of (4) and (5) which are 1/2 spaced, and as (4) feels late, it's confusing.
  4. 00:51:699 (5) - Add a finish to this circle to keep consistency ?
  5. 01:24:485 (4) - This slider sounds weird. It is too early. It would be better if you do something like that instead :
    With a whistle on (4).
  6. 01:39:270 (4) - It's not a good idea to stack it with the end of the slider. This difficulty is the easiest so it is made for beginners, yhis kind of stack are hard to read for them. Consider changing it.
  7. 01:46:556 (1,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3) - The new combo marks in this part don't fit the song. Something like that would be better :
    1. 01:47:199 (1) - Remove new combo
    2. 01:49:985 (6) - Add new combo
    3. 01:50:627 (1) - Remove new combo
    4. 01:53:413 (7) - Add new combo
    5. 01:53:842 (1) - Remove new combo
  8. 01:54:699 (1) - It would make more sense to start this spinner at 01:55:128 because of the cymbal.
  9. 02:09:913 - You should add a note here. else it looks weird because the pattern ends before the vocal.
  10. 02:21:270 (4) - It would make more sense if you end this slider on a main beat such as 02:22:128.
  11. 02:58:556 (5) - I can hear cymbals here, Add a finish ?
Collab - Wiinter's Parts
  1. 00:46:342 (4,6) - These claps don't fit the music, they will fit if you set them on 00:46:127 (3) and 00:46:985 (5).
  2. 00:58:556 - Start this break here like in Relaxing
  3. 02:13:556 - As this part is not based on the vocal. You should add a circle here because of the beat.
Collab - Bittersweet's Parts
  1. 01:14:413 (4,5) - Stack (4) with (1), (5) with (3) and (6) with (1) . It will look nicer. (You can disable the distance snap in this case)
  2. 01:30:270 - This break is short, and as the letterbox is enable, it looks ugly to have the letterbox which appears and disappears in less than 2 seconds. Consider mapping this break ?
  3. 01:38:627 (4,5) - These circles are hidden by the track of the slider, it's hard to read and it's kinda ugly. It would be much better if you change them.
  4. 01:49:770 - It feels empty here, so I suggest you to add a circle here or to make a slider which starts from here and ends at 01:49:985.
  5. 01:54:699 - You need to add a circle here, else the stack feels weird. (And add it a clap)
Shaggon Knew
  1. Nice ;)
Overall, it's a nice map *.* Good job.
Topic Starter
nimi
Liz's Mod

Lizbeth wrote:

Hi there~~

Re-checking~ :3

Collab
this should be farther from prev object:
00:37:342 (5) - oops, fixed
00:52:342 (1) - this one was on purpose >.< but ok, fixed
02:12:699 (1) - fixed
02:32:413 (2) - ^
I know you mainly follow the vocals, but I suggest to add notes on the next white ticks:
00:13:985 - done
00:27:699 - ^
00:55:128 - ^
01:12:270 - ^
01:25:985 - ^
02:41:413 - ^

(chu, seguinte. nas tuas partes ia ter que mudar muito o spacing >_< aí na primeira eu mudei um pouco pra ajeitar, mas nas outras não, então tipo.. da proxima vez que for arrumar mod, arruma isso onegai i.i)

Relaxing;
01:24:485 (4) - mmm doesn't fit that much, what about this: http://puu.sh/3Ip4 sounds much better, fixed
01:54:699 (1) - start spinner on next white tick, and add circle here. done

Maybe use tick rate 2 for all diffs, as ShaggoN diff? done x3
I like the new BG and colors btw ^^<3 Thank yoou <3

Thanks a lot for the re-check Liz <3

Kurai's Mod

KuraiPettan wrote:

Sorry, I'm late ;~; nahh, dw XD

General
  1. The background is 800x601. It would be much better if you resize it to 800x601 even if it's just for 1px >.< oh god.. okay
Relaxing
  1. HP drain 5 is not a good idea for the easiest difficulty, please reduce it. reduced 1 tick
  2. 00:20:413 (3) - Add a whistle to this circle to keep the same rhythm as you made with hitsounds before (like 00:18:485 (2,3,4,5)) nyuu, how did i miss this ;.; fixed
  3. 00:34:556 (2,4) - As the pattern follows the vocal, these sliders have to follow the vocal too else, they feel late. So reduce them by 1/2 ? Moreover 00:36:270 (4,5,6) are hard too read for new players because of (4) and (5) which are 1/2 spaced, and as (4) feels late, it's confusing. hmm. wait what D: fixed the sliders, but i don't get why they're confusing >_<
  4. 00:51:699 (5) - Add a finish to this circle to keep consistency ? done
  5. 01:24:485 (4) - This slider sounds weird. It is too early. It would be better if you do something like that instead :

    With a whistle on (4). wut o3o but there isn't any slider there.. and it's already how it shows in the picture D:
  6. 01:39:270 (4) - It's not a good idea to stack it with the end of the slider. This difficulty is the easiest so it is made for beginners, yhis kind of stack are hard to read for them. Consider changing it. ook, fixed
  7. 01:46:556 (1,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3) - The new combo marks in this part don't fit the song. Something like that would be better :
    1. 01:47:199 (1) - Remove new combo okay
    2. 01:49:985 (6) - Add new combo ^
    3. 01:50:627 (1) - Remove new combo ^
    4. 01:53:413 (7) - Add new combo ^
    5. 01:53:842 (1) - Remove new combo ^
  8. 01:54:699 (1) - It would make more sense to start this spinner at 01:55:128 because of the cymbal. but there's a note there, not a spinner owo the spinner starts at 01:55:128
  9. 02:09:913 - You should add a note here. else it looks weird because the pattern ends before the vocal. indeed XD added
  10. 02:21:270 (4) - It would make more sense if you end this slider on a main beat such as 02:22:128. uhnn.. ok
  11. 02:58:556 (5) - I can hear cymbals here, Add a finish ? oki ~ added
Collab - Wiinter's Parts
  1. 00:46:342 (4,6) - These claps don't fit the music, they will fit if you set them on 00:46:127 (3) and 00:46:985 (5).sounds much better xD thanks
  2. 00:58:556 - Start this break here like in Relaxing fixed
  3. 02:13:556 - As this part is not based on the vocal. You should add a circle here because of the beat.ok, added

Overall, it's a nice map *.* Good job.

Thanks a lot for your mod and star, Kurai x3

Waiting for Bittersweet~
Aleks719
Relaxing
AR -1 will be better, imo.
00:07:127 - add note + finish here, like in Shaggon's diff?
00:37:342 (5) - add finish to the end
00:37:985 (6) - imo, remove note, plays not perfect for me.
01:19:770 (2) - add whistle to the start, to the end
01:21:913 (5) - add whistle to the end
01:23:627 (3) - ^
01:24:913 (5) - start, reverse - whistles, end - finish
01:28:770 (3) - imo, looks a bit better~
SPOILER

124,228,88770,2,0,B|184:184|176:96|112:76|76:132|76:132|24:104|-40:132|4:244|100:260,1,450
01:35:627 (5) - whistle instead of clap
01:36:056 (6) - finish instead of clap
01:41:413 (3) - whistle in the end of slider instead of clap
01:42:485 (4) - add whistle
01:42:913 (5) - add finish
01:43:127 (6) - remove note
01:47:199 (2,3) - add 2 whistles
01:48:913 (5) - add whistle to the end
01:51:056 (3,4,6,7) - add 4 whistles
01:54:056 (3) - whistle instead of clap
01:54:485 (4) - add whistle
01:54:699 (5) - add clap
01:55:128 (1) - add whistle
02:05:199 (4) - add whistles to the 1st reverse and to the end
02:08:199 (3) - add whistle to the start and to the end
02:09:485 (4,5) - add 2 whistles
02:10:556 (6) - add note + finish
02:23:842 (1) - whistle instead of clap
02:27:056 (5) - ^
02:27:485 (6) - finish instead of clap
02:28:985 (2) - 1 grid up
02:32:842 (3) - finishes to the start, to the end, remove clap from the end
02:34:985 (4) - add clap
02:36:056 (3) - add clap to the reverse, to the end
02:37:556 (x) - add note + clap
02:38:628 (3) - whistle instead of clap
02:39:056 (4) - add whistle
02:39:270 (x) - add note + clap
02:39:699 (x) - add note + finish
02:40:128 (5) - add nc (slider)
02:40:985 (x) - add note + clap
02:41:413 (x) - add note + finish
02:42:056 (2) - whistle instead of clap
02:42:485 (3) - add whistles to the all reverses
02:45:485 (2) - whistle instead of clap
02:45:913 (3) - this slider must be 1/2 longer. End of slider here : 02:46:556. add whistle to the start, add finish to the end.
02:47:199 (5) - add whistles to the start, to the end
02:48:270 (x) - add note + finish
02:48:913 (2) - add whistle
02:49:342 (3) - add whistles to the 1st, 3rd reverses, to the end
02:52:342 (2) - add whistle
02:52:770 (3) - his slider must be 1/2 longer. End of slider here : 02:53:413. add whistle to the start, add finish to the end.
02:53:842 (4) - add claps to the start, to the end
02:55:128 (5) - add note + finish
02:55:770 (2) - add whistle
02:56:628 (4) - add whistles to the 1st, 3rd reverses, to the end
02:59:199 (2) - whistle instead of clap
02:59:628 (3) - add whistle
03:00:270 (x) - add note + finish
03:00:913 (5) - make end of this diff same other diffs. So, end of slider must be here : 03:01:985. add whistle to the start, finish to the end.

Collab
Hp drain and OD higher than in hardest difficulty (7 > 6), Imo, it's not correct... Reduce hp and od in your diff? or increase in Shaggon's diff~
00:53:627 (3) - add whistles to the reverse, to the end
...and look on to suggestions for Relaxing, most of suggestions work here too
Bittersweet
01:08:627 (7) - add whistle
01:22:342 (6) - ^
01:32:413 (1) - whistle instead of clap
01:35:199 (3,5) - add whistles
01:36:270 (6) - add finish
01:39:699 (1) - ^
01:43:127 (8) - ^
01:44:842 (3) - replace to 01:44:628 (1/2 earlier)
01:53:413 (6) - finish instead of whistle
01:54:699 - add note + clap

ShaggoN Knew
00:56:949 (1) - whistle instead of finish
02:20:842 (6) - add whistle

Phuuuuuu... star'd
ShaggoN

Aleks719 wrote:

ShaggoN Knew
00:56:949 (1) - whistle instead of finish Yup, sounds better. :3
02:20:842 (6) - add whistle Doesnt change much, but yeah why not. Ok too ^.^
P.S.
Wiinchan why you're using Hchan to ask me to check mod? o_O I'm here at next pc xD
Bittersweet

ShaggoN wrote:

P.S.
Wiinchan why you're using Hchan to ask me to check mod? o_O I'm here at next pc xD

Because i'm more sexy and she likes to send pornografic messeges to me 8D
Topic Starter
nimi
ermm.. she mentioned about the mods and it was easier to talk to her Dx


Aleks719 wrote:

Relaxing
AR -1 will be better, imo. bleh, i prefer it like this ._. i'll wait for someone else's opinion here
00:07:127 - add note + finish here, like in Shaggon's diff? k
00:37:342 (5) - add finish to the end ^
00:37:985 (6) - imo, remove note, plays not perfect for me. ^
01:19:770 (2) - add whistle to the start, to the end ok
01:21:913 (5) - add whistle to the end k
01:23:627 (3) - ^ k
01:24:913 (5) - start, reverse - whistles, end - finish added whistles but not finish
01:28:770 (3) - imo, looks a bit better~ man.. i'd rather not touch this slider >_<" but thanks anyway
SPOILER

124,228,88770,2,0,B|184:184|176:96|112:76|76:132|76:132|24:104|-40:132|4:244|100:260,1,450
01:35:627 (5) - whistle instead of clap ok
01:36:056 (6) - finish instead of clap ^
01:41:413 (3) - whistle in the end of slider instead of clap ^
01:42:485 (4) - add whistle ^
01:42:913 (5) - add finish nope >_<
01:43:127 (6) - remove note ^
01:47:199 (2,3) - add 2 whistles k
01:48:913 (5) - add whistle to the end ^
01:51:056 (3,4,6,7) - add 4 whistles ^
01:54:056 (3) - whistle instead of clap ^
01:54:485 (4) - add whistle ^
01:54:699 (5) - add clap ^
01:55:128 (1) - add whistle ^
02:05:199 (4) - add whistles to the 1st reverse and to the end ^
02:08:199 (3) - add whistle to the start and to the end ^
02:09:485 (4,5) - add 2 whistles ^
02:10:556 (6) - add note + finish nah.. i prefer it like this
02:23:842 (1) - whistle instead of clap k
02:27:056 (5) - ^^
02:27:485 (6) - finish instead of clap changed to whistle
02:28:985 (2) - 1 grid up ^
02:32:842 (3) - finishes to the start, to the end, remove clap from the end added, only in the end though
02:34:985 (4) - add clap done
02:36:056 (3) - add clap to the reverse, to the end added but only in the reverse
02:37:556 (x) - add note + clap added
02:38:628 (3) - whistle instead of clap changed
02:39:056 (4) - add whistle done
02:39:270 (x) - add note + clap ^
02:39:699 (x) - add note + finish ^
02:40:128 (5) - add nc (slider) i'll keep it like this ><
02:40:985 (x) - add note + clap added
02:41:413 (x) - add note + finish ^
02:42:056 (2) - whistle instead of clap ^
02:42:485 (3) - add whistles to the all reverses ^
02:45:485 (2) - whistle instead of clap added the whistle.. but there's no clap in there ._.
02:45:913 (3) - this slider must be 1/2 longer. End of slider here : 02:46:556. add whistle to the start, add finish to the end. done. sounds much better now, thanks
02:47:199 (5) - add whistles to the start, to the end done
02:48:270 (x) - add note + finish ^
02:48:913 (2) - add whistle ^
02:49:342 (3) - add whistles to the 1st, 3rd reverses, to the end ^
02:52:342 (2) - add whistle ^
02:52:770 (3) - his slider must be 1/2 longer. End of slider here : 02:53:413. add whistle to the start, add finish to the end. ^
02:53:842 (4) - add claps to the start, to the end ^
02:55:128 (5) - add note + finish ^
02:55:770 (2) - add whistle ^
02:56:628 (4) - add whistles to the 1st, 3rd reverses, to the end done, but there's no 3rd reverse :v
02:59:199 (2) - whistle instead of clap done
02:59:628 (3) - add whistle ^
03:00:270 (x) - add note + finish ^
03:00:913 (5) - make end of this diff same other diffs. So, end of slider must be here : 03:01:985. add whistle to the start, finish to the end. extended the slider a bit and added a note at 03:01:985 instead.

Collab
Hp drain and OD higher than in hardest difficulty (7 > 6), Imo, it's not correct... Reduce hp and od in your diff? or increase in Shaggon's diff~ oops. reduced 1 tick
00:53:627 (3) - add whistles to the reverse, to the end done
...and look on to suggestions for Relaxing, most of suggestions work here too ohwell. i don't think it's needed to change/add soo many soft whistles.. specially because they don't even make much difference. will take a look again on the hitsounds though
Bittersweet
01:08:627 (7) - add whistle done
01:22:342 (6) - ^ ^
01:32:413 (1) - whistle instead of clap ^
01:35:199 (3,5) - add whistles ^
01:36:270 (6) - add finish ^
01:39:699 (1) - ^ nah D:
01:43:127 (8) - ^ kay
01:44:842 (3) - replace to 01:44:628 (1/2 earlier) nope >< sounds weird imo
01:53:413 (6) - finish instead of whistle kay
01:54:699 - add note + clap done

Phuuuuuu... star'd
Thanks for your mod and star :)
Lizbeth
Re-checking~~ o.o/

Collab
00:57:913 - finish kiai here for the sake of taikoing~
01:46:985 (1) - should be farther

Relaxing
00:57:913 - same as collab~
00:35:842 (3) - should be farther, look at timeline, is not the same distance between 2 and 3, than between 3 and 4, should be reflected on chart.

Rawr~~
GLF09
Gay song...But i love it!
Star for your proyect

Patrick: Eu amo voce :oops: [?]
Topic Starter
nimi

Lizbeth wrote:

Re-checking~~ o.o/

Collab
00:57:913 - finish kiai here for the sake of taikoing~ done~
01:46:985 (1) - should be farther huh? o.o there's no note here D:

Relaxing
00:57:913 - same as collab~ done~
00:35:842 (3) - should be farther, look at timeline, is not the same distance between 2 and 3, than between 3 and 4, should be reflected on chart. ops >.< done

Rawr~~
rawrr thanks so much liz <3

GLF09 wrote:

Gay song...But i love it!
Star for your proyect

Patrick: Eu amo voce :oops: [?]
wut xDD thanks for the star anyways
phonic
Good ;)



Rnked GoGo!

Stra~ 
Lizbeth

Lizbeth wrote:

01:46:985 (1) - should be farther huh? o.o there's no note here D:
I'm pretty sure there's a slider @_@ http://puu.sh/4KIt

Lizbeth wrote:

00:35:842 (3) - should be farther, look at timeline, is not the same distance between 2 and 3, than between 3 and 4, should be reflected on chart. ops >.< done
Still not fixed, this is an example of what is correct: http://puu.sh/4KJE As you see in this image, (2,3) should be more separated then (3,4).
Oh and another thing in Relaxing: 00:39:485 (3) - this slider sounds weird, what about this: http://puu.sh/4KL4

miau~
Topic Starter
nimi

Lizbeth wrote:

Lizbeth wrote:

01:46:985 (1) - should be farther huh? o.o there's no note here D:
I'm pretty sure there's a slider @_@ http://puu.sh/4KIt
weird.. o-o' when i said there wasn't any note there i reopened the editor like 3 times to make sure.. waiting for bitter to fix that since she'll have to move some other stuff on her part

Lizbeth wrote:

00:35:842 (3) - should be farther, look at timeline, is not the same distance between 2 and 3, than between 3 and 4, should be reflected on chart. ops >.< done
Still not fixed, this is an example of what is correct: http://puu.sh/4KJE As you see in this image, (2,3) should be more separated then (3,4).
Oh and another thing in Relaxing: 00:39:485 (3) - this slider sounds weird, what about this: http://puu.sh/4KL4
>_< fixed.. but kept 00:39:056 (1) - in a "wrong" spacing.. there's no problem with that, right? D:
aand fixed the other thing. thanks again liz <3 *bites*
miau~
DeadAlready
ehhh I can't mod so just star for a nice map >w</

oh btw first kiai line in relax and collab diff is not align the timeline, fix it maybe more better? xD
Topic Starter
nimi

quintitem wrote:

ehhh I can't mod so just star for a nice map >w</

oh btw first kiai line in relax and collab diff is not align the timeline, fix it maybe more better? xD
uuughh seems like this lines like moving alone ;~;
thanks a lot for noticing that and for the star, btw :)

EDIT: uploaded with some more changes~
Bittersweet
Desculpa a demora, kiwii ;-;

/me brinca de travar com giratória 20 vezes enquanto upa isso, mas tudo bem.

Download: P!nk - Who Knew (Wiinter) [Collab].osu
Topic Starter
nimi
updated <3
My message is too short.
It's still too short
Lizbeth
This is ready, good luck with the ranking~~~~~
Good job all~
Topic Starter
nimi
thanks a looooot Liz <3
Your message is too short.Your message is too short.Your message is too short.Your message is too short.
[Au]-[Revoir]

Bittersweet wrote:

Somos gays <3 *-*

Whoaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa *-*
jericho2442
oook lowered HP by 1 on relaxing and upped OD by one on shaggon's diff, also a tiiiiny pattern fix in collab, i see no reason to leave this pending now all looks rankable.

enjoy your Heart wiinter \o/
Topic Starter
nimi
thaaaaanks jeri <3
Roddie
Wow.

Congrats for getting your map ranked, Wiinter! :D
GiNa
Gratz Wiinter :D
MoodyRPG
Nice Wiinter ^^
Topic Starter
nimi
thanks everyone :)
dkun
CONGRATS WIINTEREEEERRERERERR

<3
Zelos
YUS MORE P!NK
Bittersweet
Boa kiwii <3 *agarra e aperrrrta até fazer poc*
Hiryuu_old
Congratulation Winter :)
Topic Starter
nimi
*explode*
thanks dkunununununununnnnnn <33 and ShinseinaTenshi :­DD
hoLysoup
^^ ranked map!
Cookiexi_old
lol
Katsuri
Bom.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply