1. Beginner (1.5 stars, 89 notes)
2. Groove City (4.79 stars, 473 notes)
3. Hard (3 stars, 195 notes)
4. Insane (4.43 stars, 426 notes)
5. Intermediate (1.85 stars, 127 notes)
6. Light Insane (3.59 stars, 307 notes)

Changelog (From 13/03 onwards)

13/03 Added hitsounds to Insane and reduced its difficulty and AR to better fit the spread
13/03 (2) Toggled the match sample sound to audio for insane
14/03 Changed things in hard difficulty according to CeleriLord's mod (Thanks for that btw)
14/03(2) CeleriLord modded the other difficulties and have changed them according to that (This included upping AR of insane form 8 to 8.5)
14/03(3) Added Beginner difficulty with hitsounds
14/03(4) Added light insane difficulty with hitsounds
15/03 Added intermediate difficulty and changed CS for Beginner to 3.5
15/03(2) Changed difficulties based on teko8's mod (includes change of offset and hitsound volumes)and changed expert to Groove city
16/03 Slowed the SV on the chorus sections in beginner from 1.5 to 1.25 and added hitsounds to Intermediate
16/03(2) We did it!!! Changed the status to pending, added hitsounds to Groove City
17/03 Well i apperantly don't know how to check a box in aimod, now that i have learned i am reverting the map back to WIP to fix the DS on Beginner, Intermediate and Hard (Thanks to Inversal for pointing this out)
18/03 Fixed the DS on Easy and made changes based on the modding of Inversal on the Light Insane, Insane and Groove City difficulty
29/03 Fixed the DS on Intermediate difficulty and started to alter the DS on hard to make it more consistent
30/03 Changed the DS on Hard to be more consistent
31/03 Misc changes to Light Insane, Insane and Groove City difficulties
02/04 Changed as accoding to GuiltyGecko's mod and made some misc combo and sound changes
03/04 Added some custom hitsounds
04/04 Changed the map based on Naxess mod and removed ninja spinners
06/04 Made some misc changes to Light Insane, Insane and Greoove City as well as remove more ninja spinners
10/04 Made changes based on CyberX's mod, removed yet another nija spinner and added some hitsounds. Misc changer were also made

Glorious and good looking mods

CeleriLord
teko8
Inversal
GuiltyGecko
Naxess
CyberX
[https://osu.ppy.sh/u/WISPG_G]WISPG_G[/url]

GuiltyGecko wrote:

Got some time to do the M4M.

Beginner

General:

1. I would change the HP drain to 3 or 3.5 instead of 4. This is because your intermediate has the same drain and this would help differentiate between the two. Especially since this is the a beginner difficulty. I don't know what to put Hp as for low difficulties so thanks. Fixed
2. I would also change the AR to 4. Again, because we want to emphasis the beginner qualities of the map. This is doubly so since the intermediate difficulty has the same AR. Gives more time for newer players to see notes. Changed
3. Speaking of seeing notes, I would recommend increasing the distance spacing to .6 instead of .5. That's because the map feels a little cramped with how many notes are always touching. In my Osu brain, notes touching Uuuusually means fast, but here they are complete white ticks apart and still touch. You can keep the notes in the many of the same patterns they are in now, just spaced out a little more with .6. Here is an example of the touching I'm talking about. 00:07:094 Thanks for this. The map looks a lot cleaner now because of this. Changed
4. 00:27:024 The cymbal strike for ending this section ends on this white tick instead of the previous one. Would suggest moving end of spinner to here. Fixed
5. 07:37:094 Adding a clap hit sound to the end of the spinner helps lead into the next clap section. Fixed

Intermediate

1. 00:27:024 Would move end of spinner here. Same reason as beginner.Fixed
2. 01:08:982 ^ Fixed
3. 01:47:167 I would either remove the hit sound at the end of this spinner, or make it quieter. It's really loud for a song that's fading out.Removed Hitsound

Hard

1. I believe the HP Drain is too high. You can miss 2 notes and essentially fail. I would change the HP drain to 5 or 5.5. Fixed
2. 00:53:877 (10) I would add a clap hit sound to the beginning of this slider. Would follow in well to the upcoming clap section.Changed

Insane

1. 00:33:737 (1) Adding a finish hit sound here compliments the previous finish hit sound section. Changed
2. 01:03:317 The edit in my picture has a better sound flow than what was here before since it follows the slider before. I would suggest a change. Before/After. There is a clear two separate two notes in this part so I've kept it the same
   
   

I didn't see anything worth mentioning in the light insane, and groove city is significantly higher than my Osu skill so I didn't find anything there either. Overall good job though! GL!

Naxess wrote:

From Queue

Beginner

SPOILER

1. 00:05:835 (4,1) - Bad flow, forces a 180 degree turn without repeat. Consider using Ctrl + G and then moving it down a bit for spacing.Looks and feels better with this. Changed
   
   01:29:961 (5) - ^Also Changerd
   
2. 00:19:471 (4) - Generally you should refrain from using more than one repeat per slider in easy, especially in short sliders, since it can be very unexpected for newer players. I'd suggest placing some circles like this instead:
   
   00:48:003 (4) - ^Both Changed
   00:20:310 (1) - The only reason the others, such as this one, are fine is because they're longer and also consistent, so they're easier to recognize.
   Thanks for the advice. Makes sense
3. 00:13:597 (2) - Move the red point in all tight elbow sliders to the middle of their paths, since it both looks and feels better. Plus it fits the beat later in the song.
   00:14:436 (3) - ^
   00:15:275 (4) - ^
   00:16:115 (5) - ^
   00:17:793 (2) - ^
   00:18:632 (3) - ^
   ... ^ I couldn't find a way to see if they were perfectly centered so changed them all manually
   
4. 00:50:520 (1) - Refrain from doing sharp turns like this (over 90 degrees) in easy.
   01:29:961 (5) - ^ Changed
   
5. 01:00:171 (3,4) - Also refrain from stacking in easy. You should basically be able to see every note clearly from the moment they appear.
   It's also inconsistent with the previous measure (4 white ticks), so I'd suggest replacing them with a slider (which you could blanket if you want) like this:
   
   01:40:031 (4,1) - ^ Changed. Feels nicer like this
   
6. 01:44:226 (1) - I don't think you need this hit sound. It's sort of out of place since the music has faded at this point.There wasn't a hitsound on the slider. However i chaged the sample set to Normal and turned the volume down on it.

Intermediate

SPOILER

1. 00:01:639 - I'd suggest placing a note here as well, and making a stack of the other one with it. Changed here and in the rest of the places in this section for consistency
   00:13:177 - Here you could have something as well, although it isn't necessary. Did this and removed the spinner
   00:20:101 - ^
   00:21:779 - ^
   01:32:268 - ^
   01:38:982 - ^ Didn't change the rest as to keep the rhythm simple
   These extra notes are only suggestions, it is not meant that you should add all of them unless you really want to.
   
2. 00:12:129 (1) - This spinner is too short. In general they should be at least a whole measure long (4 white ticks), usually longer.
   00:13:597 (1) - Having to click on notes right after a slider like this can be quite difficult.
   I'd just remove this spinner. Fixed. Removed the spinner
   
3. 00:13:597 (1) - These sliders are a bit too fast for a normal difficulty, especially considering the transition from the previous sliders.
   I'm sure something like this could work a lot better though:
   Changed it here and in the other sections for consistency
   
4. 00:15:275 (3,4) - These repeats are quite sudden at such high slider velocity. Plus This is normal, so you could replace it with something else that requires the player to click more. Even something like two sliders would work:
   
   00:18:632 (3) - ^
   00:21:989 (1) - ^ this should be two sliders or similar, since you're missing a sound where the last slider ends in this image:
   
   00:50:520 (1) - ^
   00:47:164 (4) - ^ Have fixed these sections
   
5. 00:22:828 (2) - Remove this note and add a repeat instead of the note after it, like you did at 00:16:324 (4) . Now a repeat
   
6. 00:40:870 (1) - Right after a spinner. 3 repeats. Perhaps a bit sudden, don't you think?
   01:22:828 (1) - ^ Removed Both Sliders.
   
7. 00:53:877 (1) - Unrankable. So called "Ninja Spinners": https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Ninja_Spinners
   I'd suggest just removing it, since notes are placed right after it. Although you could perhaps place a circle at 00:53:877 with a new combo. Removed and put a slider in instead
   
8. 01:30:171 (5) - There's no sound here, so I'd suggest just removing this circle. Plus it's inconsistent with other parts of the song otherwise. Changed to single note at 01:30:380
   
9. 01:40:031 (2) - Move this circle to 01:39:821 , since it doesn't fit to the music where it is at the moment. Removed Circle
   01:39:191 (1,2) - If you want to stay more consistent, you could shorten the first slider and add another slider like I suggested you'd do at 00:15:275 (3,4) . Changed

Hard

SPOILER

1. Generally hard shouldn't consist of so many jumps. Consider reducing the amount and keeping to distance spacing for the most part.
2. It seems you've placed notes where they shouldn't exist, and skipped places where they should exist, so I'll point them out for you.
3. Should exist but doesn't:
   00:15:066 -
   00:18:422 -
   00:21:779 -
   00:48:632 -
   00:54:926 -
   00:55:345 -
   01:32:268 -
   01:36:884 -
   01:38:982 -
   01:42:338 - Added all these notes
4. Should not exist but does:
   00:19:681 (1) -
   00:53:667 (5) -
   00:53:772 (6) -
   01:09:611 (2,3) -
   01:11:289 (2,3) -
   01:12:968 (2,3) -
   01:14:646 (2,3) - All removed until here
   01:16:324 (2,3) - There is notes from here downwards in this section. Unchanged
   01:17:164 (2,3) -
   01:18:003 (2,3) -
   01:18:842 (2,3) -
   01:33:317 (3) - Replace the slider end with a circle, since that one should exist. Changed the rest
   01:43:387 (4) -
   
5. 00:53:877 (7) - This whistle is really random lol
   01:35:835 (1) - ^ Removed the whistles
6. 01:33:737 (4) - Why not three circles instead? You've done circles basically everywhere else, so I don't see why this part should be easier. Changed to three circles
7. 00:11:919 (1) - Ninja Spinner; unrankable.
   01:07:303 (1) - ^ Remopved Both Spinners
8. This map could probably also use some breaks as well, considering all those spinners. I'd recommend placing short breaks after spinners, since it lets the player reposition their cursor after spinning, because hitting notes directly after one can be quite akward.Added Breaks after the spinners

CyberX wrote:

Here we go my mod
note that everythings here is just my opinons

Insane

00:40:975 (1,2,3) - no sound here There is audio here, it is just incredibly quiet. Am looking at boosting the audio but for right now will lower the volume of the hitsounds.
01:01:849 (5) - 1/4 sound here Changed
01:20:730 (1,2,3,4) - 1/4 sound here Kept as is as it follows the drum
01:22:933 (1,2,3) - didnt match with the music Same as the first advice
01:30:380 (2) - 1/4 sound here Changed
try to rework at the pattern,looks weird ???

Groove City

01:30:380 (2) - delete this,coz no sound there Changed to a jump that follows the music
00:03:737 (3) - ^
00:07:408 (3,5) - ^
00:08:247 (2,4) - ^ All above are changed
00:11:080 (5) - NC too make things more attractive Changed
00:15:275 (1,2,3,4) - the jump is to high,and the song doesnt really intense there Reduced the jump
00:19:891 (5) - 1/4 sound here Changed
00:20:835 (3,5) - delete coz no sound It sound alright for now but may change it in the future
00:22:723 (6) - ^ Changed the triplet to a slider
00:34:366 (1) - just make this as 2 hitcircle Like it now as it is consistent with the rest of the section and matches the piano notes
00:40:975 (1,2,3) - no sound Same audio issue mentioned in Insane
00:48:003 (5) - no sound Follows to background rhythm so I'll keep it
01:01:849 (1) - 1/4 sound Changed
01:05:625 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - too high Changed to a lower DS
01:22:933 (1,2,3) - no sound Same audio issue
01:23:667 (4) - 1/4 sound Prefer this is a way of mapping the creschendo
01:30:380 (6) - 1/4 Fixed
this difficult had the same problem with Insane, the placeing looks weird I'll need further explanation on this

Thanks in advance for choosing my ModQ
Come again next time

sahuang wrote:

Rhythm you catch is quite good,now the problem is about the slider shape and how you place the objects. It's all about practicing and studying imo