forum

KOTOKO - I can't get over your best smile

posted
Total Posts
44
show more
TKiller
why would you ask me to mod something that's already good o.o

01:21:534 01:21:849 - add beats here?

01:23:533 (4) - move this 1/4 earlier and make 1/4 longer?

01:51:942 (3,4,5) - I'd place this where (7) was (spacing) (and a bit respace next beats)

02:00:780 (3) - this'd look better symmetrical

02:01:727 (5) - make this a single beat and add more beats synched to drums (02:01:938)?

02:02:674 (6) - this beat needs a hitsound, at least a finish

02:09:934 (5) - remove this and make (4) a slider ending on (6)? At least remove whistle from (6), I dunno, it stands out too much.

02:26:349 (6) - moving this to (4) at timeline and adding a repeat suits music better

02:27:296 (1,2,3,4) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/48716 or something like this, well, space this please

02:49:076 (2,3,4) - okay, I'll just say that I didn't like that you add a beat synched to nothing when singer is singing only two syllables, so I won't have to repeat this over the whole map. Move (4) to (3) and make longer >:|

02:51:128 (8) - add a beat?

also, 02:48:760 - 02:58:230 this part lack softwhistle usage, they could accent the vocals and make the map more lively

03:32:005 (1,2,3,4,5) - ????? suddenly not following vocals, better something like http://puu.sh/IDf

03:45:263 (4,5) - while I actually like this and support rhythm patterns like this, but it's hard to tell that it's going to be 1/4 with AR 7

03:47:788 (4) - some hitsound on the end (again the same)

04:08:306 (3,4) - can you synch this to vocals?

04:09:568 (1) - make it end on 04:10:515 and add beats synched to vocals? (Map follows a lot of vocal so it feels a bit out of place when it suddenly does not. And Kotoko songs are accented on vocal, music at most is just a background here, after all, so..)

04:52:182 (6,1,2) - suddenly very loud

05:16:803 (4,1) - I'd like it more as 1/2 repeat slider, but I might be complaining too much..

05:36:058 - 1/2 sliders, especially repeat ones, feel too much slowed with 0,5. Try 0,7 sections for them?

05:42:687 - and now I noticed that you had the names storyboarded :D Silly editor blocking my sight.

05:45:528 (1) - yeah, this is surely sudden after 0,5 section. Really, try 0,7 and you might like it.

06:04:467 (5,6,7,8,9,10) - vocals vocals vocals vocals vocals vocals vocals vocals vocals vocals vocals vocals

07:04:285 (1) - start it 1/4 later and add a beat to where it's starting now. It's also fine if the beat remains silenced.

07:04:285 (1) - also, even if volume is moved to zero at timesection, you can still hear spinning, bonus and a softhitnormal sounds at the end. I'd add blank hitsounds just to silence this slider completely.


Whew, this was tiring to mod since it's already good and it's 7 minutes long. Ok, maybe some of my opinions would make you change something, I'm done here.
Topic Starter
Sure

TKiller wrote:

02:00:780 (3) - this'd look better symmetrical
02:02:674 (6) - this beat needs a hitsound, at least a finish
05:36:058 - 1/2 sliders, especially repeat ones, feel too much slowed with 0,5. Try 0,7 sections for them?
05:45:528 (1) - yeah, this is surely sudden after 0,5 section. Really, try 0,7 and you might like it.
// Fixed list in my parts.

TKiller wrote:

07:04:285 (1) - also, even if volume is moved to zero at timesection, you can still hear spinning, bonus and a softhitnormal sounds at the end. I'd add blank hitsounds just to silence this slider completely.
// I know, but I don't use silenced hitsound for only this spinner. Those hitsounds are fine at other spinners. Blame the audio volume system. >_<
Thanks for mod. :)
SweetBloodyLove
nice map ^^
bmin11
[MoonCarrot]

(캐럿)00:42:498 (x) - 여기서부터 01:02:700 까지 대략적인 소개/인트로 형식으로 문프님과 캐럿님을 소개하는 SB를 넣으면 어떨까요? 기왕 마라톤/합작맵인데 좀 꾸미자던가 부족한 브레이크를 더 넣어보자는 의미로...

(무시하세요) 03:26:639 (1) - 저거 방금 개새끼라고 한건가요

(캐럿)05:24:379 (6) - 노래에 비해 각진 슬라이더는 좀 이질적인 느낌이 드네요... 05:17:750 (2,3,4) 의 경우에는 그래도 패턴이 눈의 결정을 나타내는것 같아서 나쁘지 않다고 생각합니다


...이게 전부내요. 정말 맘에 드네요 <3 수월히 어프까지 가시길 빕니다!
Topic Starter
Sure

bmin11 wrote:

[MoonCarrot]

(캐럿)00:42:498 (x) - 여기서부터 01:02:700 까지 대략적인 소개/인트로 형식으로 문프님과 캐럿님을 소개하는 SB를 넣으면 어떨까요? 기왕 마라톤/합작맵인데 좀 꾸미자던가 부족한 브레이크를 더 넣어보자는 의미로... // 만들어볼게요~

(무시하세요) 03:26:639 (1) - 저거 방금 개새끼라고 한건가요 // 네, 코토코 나쁜X ㅋㅋㅋ

(캐럿)05:24:379 (6) - 노래에 비해 각진 슬라이더는 좀 이질적인 느낌이 드네요... 05:17:750 (2,3,4) 의 경우에는 그래도 패턴이 눈의 결정을 나타내는것 같아서 나쁘지 않다고 생각합니다 // Fixed


...이게 전부내요. 정말 맘에 드네요 <3 수월히 어프까지 가시길 빕니다!
Thanks for mod! :)
Dotsu
My suggestions:


[MoonCarrot]


  • 00:20:717 : Add a circle
    00:21:191 : Add a circle and add clap
    01:05:225 (1): Move to 01:06:330
    01:05:383 (2): Move 1/4 Forward
    01:25:427 (1): Move to 01:26:532
    01:25:585 (2): Move 1/4 Forward
    01:57:624 (2): Repeat +1
    02:00:149 (2): ^
    03:29:164 (1): Add Finish at the beginning
    04:13:356-04:14:619 : Lower the volume
    05:08:280 (3): Add Whistle at the end
    05:10:700 (3): Add Clap at the end
    06:04:783 (7): Whistle
    06:19:619-06:20:724 : Lower the volume

Perfect map~

☆ STAR ☆
MoonFragrance
Topic Starter
Sure
updated
Thanks, i-xu and BL :)

EDIT : SB roll back.
Ra-s
MoonCarrot :)
loli_milk
star~ :)
Kotone
:)
Lissette
an nyung~~!!

Capitalize the tittle ><

MoonCarrot
04:55:023 - useless timing section :p

no kudosu for these little things >.<

Map is Beautiful, you two make a great team :D gratz <3

Star~!
Topic Starter
Sure

Lissette wrote:

an nyung~~!!

Capitalize the tittle >< // No. Check this please.

MoonCarrot
04:55:023 - useless timing section :p // deleted

no kudosu for these little things >.<

Map is Beautiful, you two make a great team :D gratz <3

Star~!
Thank you Liss. ^^
And thanks for stars, Ra-s, loli milk and karenying. :D
Sandpig
hi :D

(>'(oo)')> my mod <('(oo)'<)


MoonCarrot

it's hard for me to find any issue from this map x.x

01:51:311 (2) - short slider with 4 notes and ends on red tick is a little awkward (to me x.x). consider changing it into a 3-note-slider and a circle or just removing the last note.
05:23:432 (3) - ^

but it seems not serious

can't mod anything else but star it :P
Topic Starter
Sure

Sandpig wrote:

01:51:311 (2) - short slider with 4 notes and ends on red tick is a little awkward (to me x.x). consider changing it into a 3-note-slider and a circle or just removing the last note. // Your suggestion also fine, but I wanna keep it as it is.
05:23:432 (3) - ^
Anyway thanks for mod. :D
MoonFragrance
Andrea
Did some IRC Modding.

- Fixed 2 misplaced kiai time.
- Fixed 2 misplaced new combo.

Bubble #1~


EDIT: Moved to Pending Beatmaps.
yaya
fine for me . bubble #2
Lizbeth
Great work oppa, is perfect >//<
Topic Starter
Sure
Hey yaya, long time no see.
Thanks for 2nd bubble. :)
And gracias Liz <3
abalee
♪~
Topic Starter
Sure
yay~ Thank you! abalee :)
deadbeat
<3 yay..gratz yk :3
kodomonoyume
:) congrats~
AngelHoney
:) :)
Topic Starter
Sure
Thanks everyone :)
bmin11

Lizbeth wrote:

Great work oppa, is perfect >//<
tonopah
wonderfull map, and nice anime. i love
Please sign in to reply.

New reply