1. animask's Rainy Don (4.96 stars, 301 notes)
2. Darcsol's Rain (3.97 stars, 115 notes)
3. Drizzle (1.79 stars, 75 notes)
4. Hail (4.84 stars, 196 notes)

animask wrote:

[Darcsol's Rain]

00:59:057 (1) - Remove New Combo It's fine.
01:00:334 (7) - Stack on previous slider Fixed.
01:11:504 (1) - I don't think using Kiai time like that is allowed... Really? How so?
01:22:036 (1) - Maybe silence the spinner at the end... Actually I have overhauled the Hitsound volume.

vytalibus wrote:

Offset +15 ms, please.

I personally don't like Darcsol's difficulty. Those endless streams of sliders and notes feel more like I'm just continuing something instead of playing to the song. That's more of a personal tick than a grave error, though...

• Delete the hitcircleoverlay(1).png, etc

animask wrote:

Though I disagree with the x2 BPM.

narakucrimson wrote:

Hi Zelos! Let's get onto the mod:

[General]

Nice timing! Though, the offset could be at where the first circle is.

I feel like there are too many claps, and few other hitsounds. I mean, you can do it better! Some soft whistles may fit very well at the begging part of the song.
my claps are fine

[Drizzle]

23:008 (4) - I don't like how these 3 whistles (this one and the ones at 25:561 and 28:115) sound, I feel like they are kinda.. isolated. Maybe they would sound better if they were on soft instead of normal, although that would make that section of the song lack some "power".i like how they sound
1:01:944 (T) - Start the kiai here.added
1:22:370 (SP) - Why silencing this? I'd like to hear something at least xD Not necesarilly a hitsound, but at least something.because silent sounds cooler


[Darcsol's Rain]

The kiai is divided into two sections here. Why don't you (guys) use the same kiai for every difficulty? Personally, I like this one better
i like his mapping style, not his kiai style.

[Hail]

animask wrote:

Though I disagree with the x2 BPM.

I must agree with animask. I don't like that x2 section.
DONT BE HATIN ON MY 2X SECTION :3
1:01:625 (T) - Start the kiai here. It's a little wrong, it starts slightly before 1.added


So, here's my star. Keep up the work on this!

ouranhshc wrote:

Folder

• Delete the hitcircleoverlay(1).png, etc

Overall
Snap green timing sections, especially kiai

Rain - your combos seem a little on the long side
01:16:944 (2) - spacing

Drizzle
Lower AR
01:03:221 (2) - maybe make this slider less sharp

ouranhshc wrote:

Rain - your combos seem a little on the long side It does, But it's fine.
01:16:944 (2) - spacing Fixed.

Glass wrote:

[Overall]
The Kiai section should start on 01:01:944 since it's the beginning of the measure.
The metronome sounds wrong with the current offset, use -1,885ms.
Maybe add another inherited section on 00:51:253 to lower the volume since it seems to be a softer part than the rest of the song o.o

[Drizzle]
Is this supposed to be the easiest difficulty? I suggest using a larger circle size and lower Drain/Approach rate.

[Dracsol's Rain]
Seems fine.

[Hail]
00:15:987 (1,2) - Stack these sliders' ends, or separate the sliders in a way where the second slider's end won't be overlapped under the first slider.
00:18:540 (1,2) - ^
01:00:987 - 01:01:466 - You could use a stream here.

I don't play Taiko so I didn't mod animask's diff x:

That's all~ Have a star

Blue Dragon wrote:

Darcsol's Rain
00:55:242 (3) - New combo Fixed.
00:59:072 (1) - Remove new combo if you're doing ^ No I'm not.

Loved this diff

Sushi wrote:

Yo

[Skin]
I recommand make the border of the hitcircle completely white by making it into the overlay. the coloured border looks really really ugly with slider. (look at how it is done in the template skin)
You have some duplicated useless files (check your folder)
I suggest to make the lightning more transparent, too. it's very, very, very eye catchy. maybe a little smaller too.

I suggest using custom combo colours.

using such a negative offset is not necessary. you can put it to 668. notes before an offset are not a problem. negative offset is necessary only in some cases.added

[Drizzle]
Nothing special to say.
Sliders could be prettier though.

[Darcsol's]
Raise that damn volume! I could barely hear the hitsounds! that's very important!
00:51:412 (TS) - WHY IS IT SO LOW the player can't hear if what he's doing is good or not :I
01:22:051 (1) - don't make the whole spinner silent, just the end.

[Hail]
Hurr... I don't like small circles...
Besides, the diff feels like old maps,.. no offence... this can be way better. atm it just feels like a path of small hitcircles very regularly spaced. you don't have a lot of fun with that.
besides, the 2x sections kills it, imo. combined with the small circles, the patterns and the spacing too makes it worse.
not offended. but i dont have much intent to change this. some people may find it fun. others wont. its inevitable.

Btw, your 2x.png looks horrible (white pixels everywhere) and the way it is SB'd is hurr...
so much as it gets the point across.

[Taiko]
01:04:976 (14) - sounds bad imo.
01:10:083 (14) - ^
and all following ones.
Spliting Kiai in taiko is not necessary. make the 2 kiais one please.
also, do not silence the final spinner.

KRZY wrote:

[Darscol's Rain]
Some of the sliders don't really make sense to me. Generally, I think you'd do far better to avoid putting snare drums on sliderticks. Otherwise, fine.

Sushi wrote:

[Darcsol's]
Raise that damn volume! I could barely hear the hitsounds! that's very important!
00:51:412 (TS) - WHY IS IT SO LOW the player can't hear if what he's doing is good or not :I
01:22:051 (1) - don't make the whole spinner silent, just the end. Okay...