1. HyperiBomb's Flower Petal Shower (1.45 stars, 465 notes)
2. Julie's Nostalgia - 4Key (0.85 stars, 230 notes)
3. Reverie (1.05 stars, 227 notes)
4. Unmei's Phantasm (1.13 stars, 303 notes)

Timing

Metadata

General

Ultra Legendaryuu Kaiko

TomArrow wrote:

Timing

The first circle isn't on a "strong beat". The offset shoud be 1619 (if you have the same mp3 as CLSW) fixed
2 timing points ? One is enough was a mistake, fixed

Metadata

Title should be 源流懐古 and romanised title should be Genryuu Kaiko fixed
Source shoud be 東方Project fixed

General

BG shouldn't be larger than 1366x768 current background is temporary, waiting on new one currently
No combo colour?

Ultra Legendaryuu Kaiko

(nice diff name) ty
00:12:712 (1,2) - Flow could be improved
00:21:729 (2,3) - ^
02:02:307 (3,1) - ^
02:23:117 (5,6) - ^
02:35:602 (5,1) - ^
04:40:458 (2,3) - ^
04:47:394 (3,1) - ^
01:15:140 (2,1) - The slider should point towards the next circle.
01:19:302 (1,2) - ^
03:50:515 (2,3) - ^
01:19:302 (1) - I'm not a huge fan of this slider. You should emphasize that part (even if this is just a beginner diff)
03:38:030 (1,2,3,4,5) - This pattern is kinda hard to read for a beginner diff All pretty much fixed, as well as a bunch of other cleanliness fixes, etc

#RankHarderMaps :> :^)

dinopwn wrote:

I think you should change the hitsounds from "normal" to "soft" as it matches the song better Good point, done
Add "touhou" to the tags Done
There should be a break between 2:59:190 and 3:21:387, as well as making 02:56:416 (3) 2 beats longer Would cut the drain time under 5 minutes, which would make it unrankable

00:01:618 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - these notes seem unnecessary for an easy diffThere aren't really many alternatives to this, as there needs to be notes in this section for rankability, they're evenly spaced and not difficult to hit. It's also a reference to monstrata :^))))
00:18:266 (1,3) - these two sliders are overlapping Fixed dat shit
02:02:312 (3) - this slider's curve is not even Not really quite sure what you mean here because from what I see this slider is perfectly fine

LigerZero wrote:

added in Tags "Source of Nostalgia Comiket79 cosmic armonica sumijun すみじゅん kumarisu eastnewsound くまりす hotaru ほたる higan retour kikou 彼岸帰航 riverside view komachi onozuka touhou Kaeidzuka Phantasmagoria of Flower View 東方花映塚"

no kudosu

no problem for rank or fun

[ C Y ] wrote:

reduce the volume...
the hit sounds are too loud...
i think 45% - 60% is perfect... set to 45%, really appreciate this one

01:34:566 (4) - change it into slider untill 01:35:260 ... it'll fill the gap at least... done
02:41:849 - add circle w/ clap hitsound done
02:50:867 (3) - reduce make it till 02:51:560 , and copy it to 02:52:254 .. i think this can be an alternative if you don't want to do it like above.. I think that the current multi repeat is a lot easier for beginners/easy players to visually understand rather than two close sliders

that's all i can found in your map... good luck with it..

Ultra Legendaryuu Kaiko

1. 1. if ,this diff not [ Extra ], change name to [ Easy ] and you need other Diff
2. 2change to Hp 3 / CS 3 / AR 3 / OD 4 [ Your setting is even not Beginner ]
3. 00:57:109 (1) - no overplap
4. 02:39:768 (3) - 02:50:867 (3) - 03:38:034 (1) - 03:46:358 (3) - 03:57:456 (3) -This slider cant use Easssy Diiff
5. 02:52:948 03:48:439 03:59:537 add node here?
6. 05:01:271 (1) - End is looks like here 05:03:179

_ Hatsune Miku wrote:

Frome #modreq

Ultra Legendaryuu Kaiko

1. 1. if ,this diff not [ Extra ], change name to [ Easy ] and you need other Diff https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/392479
2. 2change to Hp 3 / CS 3 / AR 3 / OD 4 [ Your setting is even not Beginner ] kept CS2, changed to HP2, AR2, OD2
3. 00:57:109 (1) - no overplap This overlap is relatively fine, the slider end points towards the next hitcircle/slider and it's pretty hard to confuse honestly.
4. 02:39:768 (3) - 02:50:867 (3) - 03:38:034 (1) - 03:46:358 (3) - 03:57:456 (3) -This slider cant use Easssy Diiff Alright, as much as I would like to compare my relatively bad map to the only other example of an easy marathon map, monstrata's, his is very low bpm and doesn't have a lot of drums while mine is relatively high in both (52/80 compared to 173). I've made a compromise here whereas if this map did not have these sliders, these sections would feel extremely empty and not be nearly as interesting gameplay-wise. I understand that reversing sliders may not be the easiest thing for someone who plays around this difficulty level to understand, but the only alternative is either sounding/playing like shit, or being even MORE unplayable for people around this skill level (STACKING SLIDERS).
5. 02:52:948 03:48:439 03:59:537 add node here? The sounds here aren't really substantial enough to warrant adding another note here, it also acts as a small break for the player.
6. 05:01:271 (1) - End is looks like here 05:03:179 Not really. Spinner's end is exactly where the music stops.

Spotty wrote:

It's good to see that this map is a Marathon and it's not a >Hard ! :3

00:57:109 : I would put the slider a bit on the right, because the last slider is overleaping your slider Fixed!
01:17:225 : Maybe you should do something like this >

that

01:24:855 : same here, imo it's better >

that

01:41:156 : I would add a circle here, with the clap hitsound
02:39:768 : i would do that imo >

SPOILER

Regarding these, I have to leave a space every two beats just so nothing is overlapping, so I can't add these.
03:06:127 : your slider should stop here and then add a circle here > 03:06:820 Done.
03:11:676 : same here, i think the slider can fit like that, but it's better to end it here o/ I kind of want to keep this slider as is, sorry.
03:26:936 : this slider is overleaping with the previous onevery much fixed

That's it, I finished the mod, I hope it helped you >w<

Hope it will be ranked ! <3

NucleaRaven wrote:

Ok so hitsounds.

Firstly add some custom hitsounds (its really ez to do if you dont know how).

Once youve done that call me back (just pm in game when im online) and ill help you without placing the hitsounds (and whether or not the custom hitsounds are good or not).

Also..... DANK

Namki wrote:

[General]
Okay, you don't need comiket 89 in the tags. You can keep it but I don't see any reason to put it.
Set custom combocolours.

[Easy]
01:20:693 (2,3,4) - make flow better, like this.
02:23:121 (5) - here, highlight this white big tick cuz music changes.
02:36:994 (1,2) - make it wider.
02:59:190 (1) - make only one point. You don't need two. yes
03:15:838 (1) - same, you can make same slider without 3 points.
04:08:555 (3) - nah.
04:32:138 (5,1) - blanket.

Best of luck~