green = fixed
red = no change
blue = comment/considering
red = no change
blue = comment/considering
"Lolipop"
Normal
From 00:24:260 - 00:25:927 would be a good place for a spinner since there's a little bit of bass right there.
If you put one in this difficulty, consider putting a spinner in your other ones as well. Good idea, added for all diffs
00:27:593 (1,2) - Curving up and over like this might be better unless you want to go straight up. keep for now
01:06:552 - Vocals start here and it feels kind of empty. You sure you don't want to do anything here? it's fine, players need a break and I'm following instruments/percussion throughout the song
01:12:593 (4,5) - Since these are flowing towards the side, try leaning 01:13:843 (6) to the right a little more. Just a suggestion. fixed
01:15:510 (4) - Consider moving the end of this slider down some and re positioning notes as needed. I think it's fine
01:16:760 (7) - Move the back/reverse of this slider down too if you'd like. The only reason I'm suggesting this, and the previous change are because these sliders seem a little too slated/sharp imo. The beats on the white ticks are stronger here, so I want to reflect that with more rigid flow
01:36:343 (4) - Since this seems slanted, moving back/reverse of 01:34:677 (1) to the left might feel better. Your choice. I think this is ok
02:24:260 (1) - Consider leaning this a little less as well. fixed
No major issues to fix.Hard
01:34:677 (1) - Anyway you can move this slider down a bit. It's pretty close to the hp bar. Close is fine since it isn't touching
Other than that, this map seems fine.Lunatic
03:13:843 (7,8,9,10) - Consider curving this stream to the right side a little bit. I think it would feel really nice intentional, since I use a lot of straight sliders to indicate a change in music at 03:14:260 -
Other than that suggestion, I don't have any problems with this difficulty.
Good luck ranking this map thanks for modding!
"RVMathew"
Returning the favour
Testplays: First Sightread
Hard: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528449 (careless misses)
Lunatic: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528110 (sliderbroke but nothing of major concern)
Note that whatever I say is my own opinion so you do not have to follow everything I say.
General
1) 03:14:260 This part has a lot of energy, so it would be nice to have kiai on it. I am worried that this may not be implemented as around 33% or more of the map is kiai time. Yes, I tried to reflect this with a different mapping style, but I would like to save the kiai for the chorus sections
Hard
1) 00:29:052 Here there is a vocal bit; since I like mapping to vocals, I would make this part clickable by adding a note here. Another effect it has is that for me it continues the flow. I do know that this is a hard difficulty so you may argue that doing so may make the map more difficult. Yeah, the difficulty spread is the reason I didn't map it. This already uses a lot of 1/4 rhythms, so I want to include breaks where possible to try and compensate.
If I wanted to map the vocals fully at this part: I would have added notes at 00:28:948 (1/4 notes). However since that is overkill for the hard, a note will suffice in my opinion.
Applies to places such as: 00:35:718 (4), 00:42:385 (4) - 00:49:052 (5) - etc.
2) 00:28:635 (3) - I feel that with a short slider, I would not try and go for a blanket, but perhaps change the direction of the slider end. If you applied the above point then applying this is much more important. The advantage of not blanketing is that you have more pathways for note placement. Yes, but if it flows well and isn't to repetitive, why not blanket?
3) 00:31:552 (3,4,5) - I know there is a sound at 4, and that maps the vocals as well. However, I feel that it feels much nicer if you removed (4). For newer players this would be nice, but the current setup works as well. The blue tick sounds are the core of this diff. However, if I have to make an easier diff to cover the spread better, I'll be sure to skip that beat.
Applies to places such as: 00:44:885 (3,4,5) -
4) 00:54:781 I am curious as to why you do not map this part. Since there are a lot of vocals that can be mapped here, I feel that it is a waste not to map it. If you decide to, use a slower slider velocity. Simply because I primarily follow drums and this section is calm enough that I want players to just listen to the music
5) 01:14:260 (7) - Since this starts on a new large white tick, wouldn't you make this a new combo? Broke consistency here to make it more readable
6) 01:32:385 (1,2,3,1,2) - Thanks to the stack created by (3,1,2) the triangle formed by 1,2 and 3 are not aligned properly. You can either keep it as it is or you can move (1,2) to a newer location, which removes the stack and does allow for an improvement in flow. The sharper angle at 01:32:385 (1,2,3) - compared to compared to 01:31:760 (2,1,2) - justifies using a smaller spacing imo. I had tried what you suggested before, but I just feel it doesn't play as well
7) 01:45:823 Possible area for a spinner? Want to keep it calm, but I did decide to add a spinner at the beginning of the song
8) 02:00:302 (1,1) - Regarding what I mentioned about in point 1 about blankets with short sliders, here I do not feel that it works here as well (the blanket is off by the way). If you want to keep it, blanket it properly, or position slider 1 like so: osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528560. The advantage of this is that it neatly flows into the next slider nicely. I like the back and forth flow here, so I decided to fix blanket
9) 03:11:760 (3,4,5,6,1) - The distances between 3 and 4, and 4 and 5 are different. If that was intentional, then leave it. I assume the stacking of 5,6,1 would have affected the distancing. Somewhat intentional to give (1) more emphasis, but also because DS would cause things to look too squished
10) 03:18:427 (3,1) - I would tuck 1 underneath the start of slider 3 like so: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528585. I assume you intentionally did not do that to improve with reading. However, tucking note 1 underneath slider 3 means that the flow is actually much nicer, but at the cost of making reading more difficult. Yeah, for readability reasons, but also, I think some sharper flows suits this section well
Otherwise very nice.
Lunatic
1) 00:51:135 (2,3,4) - When playing them I hit them fine, I just wanted to point out that I have been seeing this kind of pattern for triplets nowadays, where notes 3 and 4 are a bit of a distance away from 2. I am curious as to why you do this? I am not saying this is wrong but I find it weird, especially when I use distance snap to map. Two reasons: specifically for my map, I wan to give emphasis to the blue tick sound that's prevalent in the map. In general, this is done because with slider leniency on (2), the distance between (2) and (3) actually feels a lot closer than what DS indicates. Similarly, if you've ever seen a series of kicksliders (1/4 sliders) used in insanes or extras, the DS between them is usually gigantic, but the spacing feels natural to the player.
2) 00:54:781 I am curious as to why you do not map this part. Since there are a lot of vocals that can be mapped here, I feel that it is a waste not to map it. If you decide to, use a slower slider velocity. same reason as above
3) 01:06:552 Curious as to why you do not map this part, especially when you have vocal bits here? I feel that not mapping vocals is a waste. I was going to mention this in the hard difficulty but I could not find a suitable rhythm that would work. I thought about this many times, but in the end I preferred to undermap these few beats to contrast more with the kiai section. The 3rd kiai is different since it's the last chorus of the song and there's a drum solo right before. I will consider this some more though.
Applies to: 02:26:641
4) 01:38:010 (2) - I like this slider to be perfectly straight: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528641. The current one is fine, but I like it to be straight. eh, but I didn't make any of the other sliders straight either lol
5) 01:45:823 Possible area for a spinner? see above
6) 03:27:739 Considering that this is an insane difficulty, I was thinking you can map this part, with a low hitsound volume and a slow slider velocity, which builds up as this part goes on. True, but I want to keep breaks across all diffs consistent
Normal
Good
Final thoughts
Despite the points I have put up, this is a very nice map. I cannot find fault with the rhythm and I am happy to say that I like the hitsound pattern. It is really nice.
I was very anal with some things, but that makes a huge difference.
Good luck, and have 2 stars. Thanks for the mod and stars! Sorry I didn't accept much
Testplays: First Sightread
Hard: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528449 (careless misses)
Lunatic: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528110 (sliderbroke but nothing of major concern)
Note that whatever I say is my own opinion so you do not have to follow everything I say.
General
1) 03:14:260 This part has a lot of energy, so it would be nice to have kiai on it. I am worried that this may not be implemented as around 33% or more of the map is kiai time. Yes, I tried to reflect this with a different mapping style, but I would like to save the kiai for the chorus sections
Hard
1) 00:29:052 Here there is a vocal bit; since I like mapping to vocals, I would make this part clickable by adding a note here. Another effect it has is that for me it continues the flow. I do know that this is a hard difficulty so you may argue that doing so may make the map more difficult. Yeah, the difficulty spread is the reason I didn't map it. This already uses a lot of 1/4 rhythms, so I want to include breaks where possible to try and compensate.
If I wanted to map the vocals fully at this part: I would have added notes at 00:28:948 (1/4 notes). However since that is overkill for the hard, a note will suffice in my opinion.
Applies to places such as: 00:35:718 (4), 00:42:385 (4) - 00:49:052 (5) - etc.
2) 00:28:635 (3) - I feel that with a short slider, I would not try and go for a blanket, but perhaps change the direction of the slider end. If you applied the above point then applying this is much more important. The advantage of not blanketing is that you have more pathways for note placement. Yes, but if it flows well and isn't to repetitive, why not blanket?
3) 00:31:552 (3,4,5) - I know there is a sound at 4, and that maps the vocals as well. However, I feel that it feels much nicer if you removed (4). For newer players this would be nice, but the current setup works as well. The blue tick sounds are the core of this diff. However, if I have to make an easier diff to cover the spread better, I'll be sure to skip that beat.
Applies to places such as: 00:44:885 (3,4,5) -
4) 00:54:781 I am curious as to why you do not map this part. Since there are a lot of vocals that can be mapped here, I feel that it is a waste not to map it. If you decide to, use a slower slider velocity. Simply because I primarily follow drums and this section is calm enough that I want players to just listen to the music
5) 01:14:260 (7) - Since this starts on a new large white tick, wouldn't you make this a new combo? Broke consistency here to make it more readable
6) 01:32:385 (1,2,3,1,2) - Thanks to the stack created by (3,1,2) the triangle formed by 1,2 and 3 are not aligned properly. You can either keep it as it is or you can move (1,2) to a newer location, which removes the stack and does allow for an improvement in flow. The sharper angle at 01:32:385 (1,2,3) - compared to compared to 01:31:760 (2,1,2) - justifies using a smaller spacing imo. I had tried what you suggested before, but I just feel it doesn't play as well
7) 01:45:823 Possible area for a spinner? Want to keep it calm, but I did decide to add a spinner at the beginning of the song
8) 02:00:302 (1,1) - Regarding what I mentioned about in point 1 about blankets with short sliders, here I do not feel that it works here as well (the blanket is off by the way). If you want to keep it, blanket it properly, or position slider 1 like so: osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528560. The advantage of this is that it neatly flows into the next slider nicely. I like the back and forth flow here, so I decided to fix blanket
9) 03:11:760 (3,4,5,6,1) - The distances between 3 and 4, and 4 and 5 are different. If that was intentional, then leave it. I assume the stacking of 5,6,1 would have affected the distancing. Somewhat intentional to give (1) more emphasis, but also because DS would cause things to look too squished
10) 03:18:427 (3,1) - I would tuck 1 underneath the start of slider 3 like so: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528585. I assume you intentionally did not do that to improve with reading. However, tucking note 1 underneath slider 3 means that the flow is actually much nicer, but at the cost of making reading more difficult. Yeah, for readability reasons, but also, I think some sharper flows suits this section well
Otherwise very nice.
Lunatic
1) 00:51:135 (2,3,4) - When playing them I hit them fine, I just wanted to point out that I have been seeing this kind of pattern for triplets nowadays, where notes 3 and 4 are a bit of a distance away from 2. I am curious as to why you do this? I am not saying this is wrong but I find it weird, especially when I use distance snap to map. Two reasons: specifically for my map, I wan to give emphasis to the blue tick sound that's prevalent in the map. In general, this is done because with slider leniency on (2), the distance between (2) and (3) actually feels a lot closer than what DS indicates. Similarly, if you've ever seen a series of kicksliders (1/4 sliders) used in insanes or extras, the DS between them is usually gigantic, but the spacing feels natural to the player.
2) 00:54:781 I am curious as to why you do not map this part. Since there are a lot of vocals that can be mapped here, I feel that it is a waste not to map it. If you decide to, use a slower slider velocity. same reason as above
3) 01:06:552 Curious as to why you do not map this part, especially when you have vocal bits here? I feel that not mapping vocals is a waste. I was going to mention this in the hard difficulty but I could not find a suitable rhythm that would work. I thought about this many times, but in the end I preferred to undermap these few beats to contrast more with the kiai section. The 3rd kiai is different since it's the last chorus of the song and there's a drum solo right before. I will consider this some more though.
Applies to: 02:26:641
4) 01:38:010 (2) - I like this slider to be perfectly straight: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4528641. The current one is fine, but I like it to be straight. eh, but I didn't make any of the other sliders straight either lol
5) 01:45:823 Possible area for a spinner? see above
6) 03:27:739 Considering that this is an insane difficulty, I was thinking you can map this part, with a low hitsound volume and a slow slider velocity, which builds up as this part goes on. True, but I want to keep breaks across all diffs consistent
Normal
Good
Final thoughts
Despite the points I have put up, this is a very nice map. I cannot find fault with the rhythm and I am happy to say that I like the hitsound pattern. It is really nice.
I was very anal with some things, but that makes a huge difference.
Good luck, and have 2 stars. Thanks for the mod and stars! Sorry I didn't accept much