1. Hard (3,66 stars, 274 notes)
2. Hero (5,81 stars, 409 notes)
3. Insane (4,88 stars, 371 notes)
4. Normal (1,99 stars, 134 notes)

Lolicore_Komari wrote:

hello~

From My Modding Queue!

[Extra]

00:02:862 (5,1) - I think this whistle isn't match with song. Fixed

00:12:685 (5) - make same DS on here, that will help for solid flow Fixed

00:16:410 (4) - ^ Fixed

00:29:789 (2) - ^ Fixed

00:18:781 (9) - this slider's shape is weird I think, make more straight please. Fixed

00:54:344 (4,5) - Ctrl + G Done

00:54:683 (6) - ^ Done

00:55:699 (4) - weird shape I think Fixed

00:57:223 (3) - copy 00:56:969 (2) - this and rotate 90, that will make better flow I think Done

01:02:812 (1) - make this shape like 01:03:150 (2) - this Done

01:05:521 (7) - weird shape I think Fixed

01:15:513 (1) - change this to normal curve slider Fixed

01:19:069 (7) - make clearly straight, please Fixed

01:24:827 (11) - for the slider's end, 01:26:182 - or 01:27:536 - is better for following music. Done

finishing diff is only one, so I only mod one diff.

some < shape slider is weird, but I think this is good seed.

good luck!

Thanks for the useful mod Really appreciate it.

Ben wrote:

Hi, i wanted to help out since the song sounded so pretty

Insane

00:50:449 (5) - Would move this closer to the note before Done
This difficulty is coming along nicely, cannot wait to see the end product !

Extra

00:11:330 (1) - remove hitsounds Removed the finish sound
00:34:022 (7) - Try this http://puu.sh/lMmr7/1029857f5a.jpg Changed that my own way
01:12:972 (3) - would move this left abit and line it up with the direction the slider afterwards is facingChanged that a bit

Really good stuff so far, keep up the good work!

Thank you for the mod and for the nice comments, you gave me more inspiration to map

- Drummer- wrote:

eyo

[General]
check AImod

[Insane]
00:13:023 (8) - nc Done
00:13:701 (1) - remove nc Done
00:14:378 (3) - nc Done
00:46:893 (3) - nc here too Done
00:51:296 (3) and 00:51:973 (6) are not necessary as this spot is quiet Fixed

[Hero]
00:34:530 (6) - here could be a triple I'll leave it as it is
00:51:296 (1) - same as in Insane Done
01:08:569 (4) - nc Done
01:29:609 (1) - move this a bit further away from 4 Done

overall try to put nc on first beats x)

nice map

eclipselotus wrote:

Well, have some HS suggestion here

INSANE

00:00:492 use whistle instead clap until 00:11:499 it hear better Done, you're right
00:11:668 use clap instead finish Done
00:38:764 remove finish Done
00:40:119 ^ Done
00:43:337 add clap Done
00:51:973 remove finish Done
01:02:812 move finish to end of slider Done
01:08:231 move clap to end of slider That doesn't sound good
01:19:069 remove finish and add to 01:19:408 Done
01:26:182 to 01:34:310 i prefer put the clap at each end of slider only Done

00:52:312 to 01:19:408 kiai please :3


HERO

00:00:492 use whistle instead clap until 00:11:499 it hear better
00:51:973 remove finish Done
01:02:812 move the finish to 01:03:150 Done
01:07:384 ^ 01:07:892 Done
01:35:326 remove clap Done

00:52:312 to 01:19:408 kiai please :3 I totally forgot kiai mode, thx xD

==============

Btw here the 192 bitrate ver (mp3 fixed) Thanks <3

Good luck and nice map ^^v

Mazziv wrote:

You should check out the ranking criteria page and read some of the rules:
The mapset must have a well-designed spread of difficulties, containing at least an Easy or a Normal difficulty.

[Hard]
Check AImod pls
since aimod is telling you the spacing mistakes,i wont mention them in the mod

00:02:524 (2,1) - ugly overlap
00:05:233 (2,1) - ^
00:05:911 (1,2) - copy the first slider and ctrl+k/j/h it
00:13:531 (5,2) - overlap v:
00:13:531 (5,1) - why break the flow here?
00:16:072 (2,3) - blanket
00:16:072 (2,3) - overlap
00:30:974 (2) - move it a bit down to something like X179 Y277
00:31:652 (4) - ^but to x251 y49
00:31:652 (4,5) - have the same spacing as 00:31:990 (5,6) - but 00:31:990 (5) - is only 2 ticks away from teh previous slider and
00:32:329 (6) - is 4 ticks away from teh previous note,ya know?
00:44:183 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - try to make it to look like a circle not some hexadecaoctagon
01:02:642 (7) - remove the NC here
01:03:150 (1) - NC here
01:03:150 (1,4) - overlap v:

[Insane]
00:06:249 (2) - why dont ctrl+g here already?
00:17:596 (3,5) - overlaps
00:20:475 (3,6) - stack them
00:23:523 (4,6) - stack
00:27:926 (1,3) - stack
00:27:926 (1,3) - overlaps imo
00:35:716 (7,2) - ^
00:39:442 (1,4) - ^
00:40:966 (4,1) - stack
00:57:562 (1,4) - stack
00:58:917 (2,4) - overlaps v:
01:04:166 (5,7) - ugly overlap
01:04:505 (7,2) - stack
01:05:860 (4) - stack
01:07:892 (1,3) - stack
01:10:940 (6) - ctrl+g
01:20:424 (3,3) - stack or move the single note further away

Vabl wrote:

This is my first attempt modding, and I'm new to mapping as well, so this entire post may be irrelevant, but maybe I can get feedback on how to give feedback on mapping?? c:

In "Hard," the transition from the half note sliders to quarter note singletap things seems a bit abrupt to me. After the slider reverse arrow thing. Meh
And the outro here was handled very well, which is my main problem with "Insane." The outro is all straight sliders coming from not straight sliders and it seems awkward.
The whistles at the beginning of each phrase as well in the intro are a bit weird to listen to. Maybe it's just me being all musical but hearing such a hard DING in a quiet section of a song, but I dun like it :c

"Hero" is so goooood
I don't have any problems with it
Except maybe the difficulty
Because I'm not good enough to FC it...but that will change!
I shall play this song forever when it becomes ranked and become #1 c:<

Side note:
I really like this song
And the background is so prettyyyyy
I don't even like orange

[ Nemesis ] wrote:

Also wie schon gesagt Modde ich nur Normal und Hard.

Normal
Generell
Du benutz ein viel du hohes Slider Tempo und noch dazu sind das CS auf 4, mach das Slider Tempo Maximal auf 0,8 und
das CS kannst du eig. auf 3 oder 3,5 runterschrauben, du kannst es auch so lassen aber ich finde für eine Normal Diff passt
ein größeres immer besser. Was mir auch aufgefallen ist, die Slider besonders am Anfang sind totall komisch platziert, versuch
besonders bei der Diff Normal beim Aimod keine Warnings zu haben. Du mapst die Normal auch durchgehen auf Divisor 1/1 was
willst du bei Easy machen?
Eig. bestehen die meisten Normal Maps aus diesen hier: https://gyazo.com/316a66ced43564c7c101027d06e18a2c
Versuch auch auf jedem großem Weißem Strich einen Hit bzw. einen Slider zu haben CS geändert

00:03:201 (1) - NC
00:08:620 (1) - NC
00:14:378 (1) - NC
00:33:345 (1,3) - Bei denen machst dus kurz richtig
00:40:795 (4,1) - Overlapp am ende des Reserve slider vllt.? Jup
01:14:327 (1) - Zu nah am Spinner, ich würde den Spinner kleiner machen Passt nicht

Hard

00:00:492 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - zu viele grade Slider, mach ein paar gebogene oder eckige,
die combo kannst du auch bis auf 4 durchlaufen lassen. Done und combos bisschen geändert
00:23:861 (6,7) - bleib bei deinem spacing mach es erstmal nicht größer Hab das ned bemerkt, danke ^^
00:42:659 (4,5,6,7,8) - zu viele hits, versuch bei max. 4 hits hintereinander zu bleiben nope, soll einen gewissen aufbau haben
00:44:182 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - same^
00:45:876 (1,2,3,4) - richtig Hier ist es auch das Ende des "spannenden" ^^
01:17:714 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - wirklich zu schwer für ne Hard diff Hast Recht
01:17:714 (1,2,3,4) - mach doch hier einen jump aber mit dem gleichen Spacing wie immer,
ein kleines Dreieck mach ich immer ganz gerne. Passt nicht

Nach dem Spinner finde ich ist es die gleich Tonlage wie am Anfang,
nur das dus am Ende besser machst, versuch das Ende so ähnlich wie den Anfang zu machen. Habs versucht

Hoffe ich konnte Helfen!

1. The Normal difficulty can't be more than 2 stars because there is no easy difficulty:
   

   The lowest difficulty must be below 2.0 stars

   For you the lowest difficulty is Normal and it's 2.1 stars so you should make it easier (hopefully it will be better if you fix the distance changes)
2. http://puu.sh/mpEUL/32c33f0a3c.png - this should be removed because there should be no Slider Velocity change on a normal (except in a few cases where BPM changes can happen etc. but this is not the case)
3. http://puu.sh/mpEYY/5ca4f733cf.png - this is unrankable because you can only use an inherited and uninherited timing point at the same time if you use slider velocity change, but you didn't use slider velocity change, so you should remove it
4. http://puu.sh/mpF2t/47c75b38a6.png - same as first suggestion, remove it
5. 00:00:492 (1,2) - the distance is too big between these, on the Normal difficulty you have to use distance snap! put them closer - example: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303230 (you'll have to replace the upcoming objects a bit
6. 00:11:330 (1) - this NC looks unnecessary I think you should remove it because it doesn't make sense, it's part of the previous pattern (considering the sounds)
7. 00:11:330 (1,1) - because of the slider velocity change the distance here is surprising, so hopefully you'll fix this when you remove the slider velocity change
8. from here 00:11:668 (1) - you keep changing the distance between the objects, as I said earlier, you have to use equal distance between the notes, if you used 1,00 spacing in the beginning then keep using it, and don't change it to 0,50 and 0,60 and etc.
   Wrong distance:
9. 00:11:668 (1,2,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) -
10. 00:48:248 (2,1) -
11. 01:02:473 (3,1) -
12. 01:07:215 (7,1) -
13. 01:08:908 (2,3) -
14. and also the ending because of the SV change
15. 00:25:215 (4,5,1) - try to use a different pattern, it is quite confusing because you put (1)'s sliderend at the same place as (4)'s sliderend
16. 01:24:843 (1,1) - there isn't enough time for players to recover, you didn't leave enough space between the spinner and the next object so you should end the spinner here 01:26:204 -
17. Although you might want to consider removing the spinners and mapping them, because at this BPM it might be harder for players to recover with only 2/1 space between the spinner and next object, you should ask for opinions.
18. 00:26:231 (1,2) - this doesn't look nice and it doesn't flow well either, bad flow: http://puu.sh/mpHgh/ed71293c3a.jpg examples for good flow: http://puu.sh/mpHps/de7c74b1bf.jpg and http://puu.sh/mpHwI/380a9aa3e8.jpg - although the best would be to change the whole pattern around here because it's very messy
19. 00:28:603 (1,2,3) - these kind of patterns look the nicest if you do it like this: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303534
20. 00:37:748 (5,1,2) - this is confusing because the reverse arrow is closer to the previous circle than the slider start and also bad flow between (5) and (1)
    bad flow: http://puu.sh/mpJ9m/ab5f08227b.jpg
    try it in a different way, example: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303583 00:38:764 (1) - was placed where 00:37:409 (4) - is, the flow is also better like this
21. 00:49:264 (1,3) - this overlap doesn't look nice (and it's visible while playing), you should try it differently: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303599 (of course fix distance)
22. 00:34:361 (3,5) - try to avoid overlaps like this as I mentioned before
23. 00:33:345 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - these are all so close to the center you should use the field better! example: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303649 and https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303668 - of course this is just an example, you can do it on your own way
    
    Hitsounds (apply it for the rest of the difficulties as well):
24. To be honest I think you shouldn't use custom hitsounds, it doesn't really make sense to use these ones and it doesn't fit to the song.
25. 00:00:492 (1) - until 00:22:168 (4) - try to use soft whistles (not with custom hitsounds but with simple SOFT ones)
26. 01:26:885 (1) - from here you should use soft whistles again
27. 01:14:327 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - at this part there are too many loud hitsounds

Mystyk wrote:

Hi! M4M. Sorry not the full mod (yet?) but it is already tiring to mod one difficulty X_X

[General]
I think you should change the background because this red background with the girl doesn't have any connection with supercell (also after you've changed the background, change the combo colors to something more fitting). Nope, the girl represents a hero

[Normal]

1. The Normal difficulty can't be more than 2 stars because there is no easy difficulty:
   

   The lowest difficulty must be below 2.0 stars

   For you the lowest difficulty is Normal and it's 2.1 stars so you should make it easier (hopefully it will be better if you fix the distance changes) Pretty close now XD
2. http://puu.sh/mpEUL/32c33f0a3c.png - this should be removed because there should be no Slider Velocity change on a normal (except in a few cases where BPM changes can happen etc. but this is not the case)
3. http://puu.sh/mpEYY/5ca4f733cf.png - this is unrankable because you can only use an inherited and uninherited timing point at the same time if you use slider velocity change, but you didn't use slider velocity change, so you should remove it
4. http://puu.sh/mpF2t/47c75b38a6.png - same as first suggestion, remove it
5. 00:00:492 (1,2) - the distance is too big between these, on the Normal difficulty you have to use distance snap! put them closer - example: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303230 (you'll have to replace the upcoming objects a bit
6. 00:11:330 (1) - this NC looks unnecessary I think you should remove it because it doesn't make sense, it's part of the previous pattern (considering the sounds)
7. 00:11:330 (1,1) - because of the slider velocity change the distance here is surprising, so hopefully you'll fix this when you remove the slider velocity change
8. from here 00:11:668 (1) - you keep changing the distance between the objects, as I said earlier, you have to use equal distance between the notes, if you used 1,00 spacing in the beginning then keep using it, and don't change it to 0,50 and 0,60 and etc.
   Wrong distance:
9. 00:11:668 (1,2,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) -
10. 00:48:248 (2,1) -
11. 01:02:473 (3,1) -
12. 01:07:215 (7,1) -
13. 01:08:908 (2,3) -
14. and also the ending because of the SV change
15. 00:25:215 (4,5,1) - try to use a different pattern, it is quite confusing because you put (1)'s sliderend at the same place as (4)'s sliderend
16. 01:24:843 (1,1) - there isn't enough time for players to recover, you didn't leave enough space between the spinner and the next object so you should end the spinner here 01:26:204 -
17. Although you might want to consider removing the spinners and mapping them, because at this BPM it might be harder for players to recover with only 2/1 space between the spinner and next object, you should ask for opinions.
18. 00:26:231 (1,2) - this doesn't look nice and it doesn't flow well either, bad flow: http://puu.sh/mpHgh/ed71293c3a.jpg examples for good flow: http://puu.sh/mpHps/de7c74b1bf.jpg and http://puu.sh/mpHwI/380a9aa3e8.jpg - although the best would be to change the whole pattern around here because it's very messy
19. 00:28:603 (1,2,3) - these kind of patterns look the nicest if you do it like this: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303534
20. 00:37:748 (5,1,2) - this is confusing because the reverse arrow is closer to the previous circle than the slider start and also bad flow between (5) and (1)
    bad flow: http://puu.sh/mpJ9m/ab5f08227b.jpg
    try it in a different way, example: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303583 00:38:764 (1) - was placed where 00:37:409 (4) - is, the flow is also better like this
21. 00:49:264 (1,3) - this overlap doesn't look nice (and it's visible while playing), you should try it differently: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303599 (of course fix distance)
22. 00:34:361 (3,5) - try to avoid overlaps like this as I mentioned before
23. 00:33:345 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - these are all so close to the center you should use the field better! example: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303649 and https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4303668 - of course this is just an example, you can do it on your own way
    
    Hitsounds (apply it for the rest of the difficulties as well):
24. To be honest I think you shouldn't use custom hitsounds, it doesn't really make sense to use these ones and it doesn't fit to the song.
25. 00:00:492 (1) - until 00:22:168 (4) - try to use soft whistles (not with custom hitsounds but with simple SOFT ones)
26. 01:26:885 (1) - from here you should use soft whistles again
27. 01:14:327 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - at this part there are too many loud hitsounds Nope, many people enjoy the hitsounds

I hope you understand everything, I also tried to show you examples, but if you have any questions find me in-game or ask in your reply.

ByBy13 wrote:

IRC

10:19 -Inyafaze-: Heya c: So did you already take a look at my map? :p
10:47 ByBy13: nah
10:47 ByBy13: but I can take now
10:47 ByBy13: a look
10:47 -Inyafaze-: That'd be nice :p
10:48 -Inyafaze-: here's the map again
10:48 *-Inyafaze- is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/870679 supercell - Hero (Cut Ver.)]
10:48 ByBy13: oki
11:03 -Inyafaze-: So what do you think?
11:03 ByBy13: I've saw the higher diff
11:03 ByBy13: needs more improvement
11:03 -Inyafaze-: what especially?
11:04 ByBy13: well rhythms
11:05 -Inyafaze-: meh
11:05 -Inyafaze-: Where exactly?
11:08 -Inyafaze-: Because i asked some people for rhythm and no one said they were wrong or anything like that, but when you say it im curious :p
11:09 ByBy13: oh
11:16 *ByBy13 is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/870679 supercell - Hero (Cut Ver.) [Hero]]
11:16 -Inyafaze-: okay
11:17 ByBy13: 01:15:005 (1,2,3,4)- these sounds really terrible in my opinion.It really ignore the vocals and also something from the song. why you don't use circles instead of 1/4 sliders?
11:19 -Inyafaze-: 01:15:342 - okay till here i could make a stream then a circle you're right
11:19 ByBy13: or you can try [https://gyazo.com/0f6949dc4bca52611dec1829733488f2 this rhythm]
11:20 -Inyafaze-: guess that's good
11:20 -Inyafaze-: problem is, that I've gtg now, do you mind writing it down on the thread's site?
11:21 ByBy13: I can post the log
11:21 -Inyafaze-: Well i mean if there's more
11:21 ByBy13: 01:15:005 (1,2,3,4)- same as above
11:21 ByBy13: well I will point some 
11:22 -Inyafaze-: Well write me and post the log then, if you want, bye C:
11:22 ByBy13: okay :)
11:22 ByBy13: I will post now if you want

Just gave some tips.I will do a mod proper mod tomorrow for whole mapset