1. Easy (1.36 stars, 153 notes)
2. Hard (4.4 stars, 284 notes)
3. Normal (2.94 stars, 208 notes)

Shulin wrote:

When will finished-ish become finished?

Lovely map btw

22:44 <Dusty> : oh do you feel like complaining about my hitsounds? i have an pending map!
22:44 <Fuuko> : Hey, I have tons of time.
22:44 <Fuuko> : o>
22:44 <Dusty> : it's probably the worst hitsound job ive ever done
22:44 <Fuuko> : Get ready to be slapped, sir. o>
22:44 <Dusty> : http://osu.ppy.sh/s/21104 if you're brave and bored!
22:46 <Fuuko> : Those hitnormals at the beginning are too loud
22:48 <Fuuko> : I don't have stuff to complain about actually. o_o
22:48 <Fuuko> : Which is bad.
22:48 <Fuuko> : Except that...why the sliderslide isn't silenced?
22:48 <Dusty> : uhh
22:48 <Dusty> : because i was being stupid.
22:49 <Fuuko> : STOP BEING STUPID, STUPID. ~ 
22:49 <Fuuko> : I really don't have stuff to pick at.
22:50 <Fuuko> : Are you becoming a pro or am I too sleepy?
22:50 <Dusty> : huh, really?
22:50 <Fuuko> : Well, yeah. o_o
22:50 <Fuuko> : I was surprised actually.
22:50 <Dusty> : i guess when i turn down the hitnormals it sounds better...
22:50 <Dusty> : :o
22:50 <Fuuko> : Except for those hitnormals at the beginning
22:50 <Fuuko> : Like I said.
22:50 <Fuuko> : And
22:50 <Fuuko> : 00:20:664 (1) - Too loud, that finish.
22:50 <Fuuko> : =_=
22:51 <Dusty> : delete the finish or make it softer?
22:51 <Fuuko> : softer.
22:51 <Fuuko> : I guess.
22:54 <Fuuko> : The internet is mad at me.
22:54 <Fuuko> : It seems.
22:54 <Dusty> : btw post if you want kds
22:55 <Fuuko> : Eeh.
22:55 <Fuuko> : I didn't help.
22:55 <Dusty> : you caught sliderslide and made me turn down volumes :/
22:55 <Fuuko> : That's good. But such a little help.
22:55 <Dusty> : mm your choice
22:56 <Dusty> : could also give a star at the same time y'know :p
22:56 <Fuuko> : Well, sure.
22:56 <Fuuko> : Okay, I gathered enough courage.
22:57 <Fuuko> : Gotta finish this.
22:57  *Fuuko is editing (Mimu - Starduster)[http://osu.ppy.sh/s/26222]
22:57 <Fuuko> : And posted.

Dusty wrote:

ah, feels good to have finished something!

Sakura Hana wrote:

Mod4Mod desu~
[General]
I see that you're using slider tick rate 2, nice, however i can rarely hear sliderticks o.o maybe increase the volume of your custom slidertick sound? The custom slidertick is actually the default slidertick... o_o
Not sure but, the singer goes arythmic pretty often and those sections are mapped to the lyrics.
00:43:164 - Honestly remove this tiny break like you did on Easy, doesnt make much sense to have such a short break OK

[Hard]
00:20:664 (1) - Out of bounds Oops
01:45:075 (1,2,3,4) - I dont know why your mapping the lyrics in this part since the singer is arythmic in this section. :< I've been mapping to the lyrics basically the whole song on this map
02:21:987 (1,2) - I dont like the overlap with the HP bar here, but your call. fixed
02:24:193 (6,7) - It would be easier to switch from blue ticks to white/red ticks if instead (6) was a note and it's end was aligned with (7)'s start with a slider. tried to fix that, dunno if I succeeded (?)
02:43:164 (6) - I dont like the overlap with the score here either D: fixed
02:58:899 (6) - Another hp bar overlap. fixed

[Normal]
01:43:605 (2,3,4) - Due to the spacing i expected these to be 1/4 later. moved (2,3) forward 1/4 in the timeline and messed with the spacing a little to try to fix this
01:49:340 (1) - Pretty harsh, since there's no cue in the music to hint the player here, and the music had stopped so the player might have lost track of the rythm i'd recommend you remove 01:49:340 (1,2,3) OK
01:59:046 (4) - I dont like this hp bar overlap. Moved all the stuff down a bit

[Easy]
00:39:340 (2) - This slider feels completely weird compared to what you were doing in the whole mapset, it's like it doesnt fit there since the style used throughout the map is entirely different. hmm, kept the general slider shape but made it without that red tick, hopefully it looks better
00:53:752 (2) - Dont use kick sliders in the easiest difficulty because new players wont be able to see the repeats. OK, fixed
02:24:928 (1,4) - Align these 2? OK, fixed
02:57:281 (1) - New combo bug from spinner, add a new combo to this note, because the spinner isnt registering an end of combo hitburst. oops, fixed

Rukarioman wrote:

Easy:
01:38:017 - This break seems rather out of place. Maybe map something instead of it for removing an awkward break and for break consistency^^ Maybe make it like in Normal and at least add a spinner. OK, added a spinner

Normal:
02:25:517 (2,3) - Having a jump in a normal? dunno why I thought I had to make this a jump; fixed
02:59:634 (1) - Maybe make the sliderend stack with (4)? OK
03:09:046 (1) - ^

Hard:
01:37:428 (6) - I think this sounds better if it stays in 1/2 rhythm^^ sure
02:24:487 - Felt like a note is missing here.

Contact me for a recheck^^ Lovely map

James2250 wrote:

The mp3 is a VBR and very slightly over the 192kbps average but converting it to a constant 192kbps mp3 saves almost no filespace so I see no reason for new timing etc so it's fine

CBR encoding is not efficient. Whereas VBR and ABR modes can supply more bits to complex music passages and save bits on simpler ones, CBR encodes every frame at the same bitrate.

CBR is only recommended for usage in streaming situations where the upper bitrate must be strictly enforced.

James2250 wrote:

The mp3 is a VBR and very slightly over the 192kbps average but converting it to a constant 192kbps mp3 saves almost no filespace so I see no reason for new timing etc so it's fine

Easy:
02:26:105 (3,4,1) - keep the spacing on this equal

Normal:
01:02:869 (5,1) - space these out more if possible

Everything else looks good
Call me back after fixes and I should be able to rank