forum

Diao ye zong - Mad Party ~ A Magusnificent Plan

posted
Total Posts
17
Topic Starter
Natteke desu
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 8 ноября 2015 г. at 20:31:43

Artist: Diao ye zong
Title: Mad Party ~ A Magusnificent Plan
Source: 東方project
Tags: めらみぽっぷ meramipop RD-Sounds 魔女達の舞踏会 ~ Magus 改 ZUN Revision
BPM: 120
Filesize: 11922kb
Play Time: 06:25
Difficulties Available:
  1. Magician (4,87 stars, 1271 notes)
Download: Diao ye zong - Mad Party ~ A Magusnificent Plan
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
asd
Kroytz
le moderoo
00:03:491 (1,2) - minor complain but (2) just feels too close to (1) seeing as how all the other slider are spaced fairly apart.
00:08:491 (2,1) - I guess the same can be said here too but both of these don't need to be fixed.
00:23:824 (2,3) - how come these are spaced but the other similar ones are stacked?
00:27:991 (3,4) - why (4) so close to touching (3)? ;;
00:28:491 (4) - space more for emphasis? maybe just move it down-right a little more so that slider leniency doesn't make this feel so under-powering. 00:29:991 (3,4) - like these two are spaced fine cuz SL doesn't really factor. idk, this all seems nit-picky tho lol
00:31:491 (2,3) - ^
00:34:491 (4) - repeat slider like you have here 00:36:491 (3) -
00:39:491 (1,2,3) - these could be 120° rotated something like: http://puu.sh/l6pAn/d279d2eb01.jpg and then the (4) circle in the center
01:10:991 (4,1) - i'd rather see these two play out as a slider kinda like this http://puu.sh/l6pHm/7abff15cb7.jpg but then youd have to move that curved slider elsewhere
01:55:491 (1) - seems kinda weird having another horizontal slider. maybe try different shapes with red points or make this another curve slider but not so horizontal
02:13:491 (1) - space for emphasis?
02:15:991 (1,2,3,4) - same here : x
02:39:552 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2) - dude, i love yummy streams
02:49:987 (1,2) - spacing here feels just a little off when you compare the relationships between all your current sliders.look at (8)->(1) and (2)->(3) and then you see (1)->(2) looks just a taaad off. I'm sure it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things but I think it can be slightly improved? idk lol
02:53:030 (3,4) - same here I think (4) can be spaced slight further or have a different direction or something. I understand if you don't change though cuz your ideas make sense too. These just my thoughts.
03:06:509 (5) - for this being an emphasizing beat I'd expect it to be emphasized tbh but the only emphasis I see is 03:06:726 (6,7) - when it's sort of dying down the voice already
03:13:465 (1,2) - emphasis like this is sugoi for the above
03:20:422 (4) - kinda weird spot I think because of the change in instrument. I think more emphasis would be better on the right side of the screen than so close to (3).
03:40:204 (8,9) - watch out for that spacing, looks rather high over here.
03:49:770 (1) - maybe curve slider a tiny bit more? ;;
04:00:856 (7) - i really like this section and especailly the stream leading to 04:03:900 (1) - nice
04:14:770 (4) - I think increasing the spacing here just a little more would be good cuz the spacing decrease is slightly too much from (3)->(4) coimpared to 1->2 and 2->3 (leniency)
04:32:161 (2) - y u no fast slider???? ;;;;;
04:39:770 (1) - i think the SVs in this section should be slightly tweaked throughout because it seems rather hard to read or may be inconsistent. I mean, 2.00 SV is quite high up there just saying. juuust sayin'. I'd go with 1.5 personally.
05:07:161 (1,2,3,4) - man this looks ugly yo, cant you just make it into a square?
06:01:509 (1) - man u should just cut the mp3 lol fuuuuk this boringass shit again xDDD
06:07:509 (1,2) - since you already have the square pattern from before, you can just copy pattern and rotate maybe 15° and make it bigger like a whirlwind or smth
06:24:009 (1,2,3,4,1) - could just make a star pattern already jeez xPP (a perfect star I mean)
I guess I was kinda nit-picky at first but it sort of came around once it got exciting.

Yo this map is pretty cool. Love the sliders n stuff, well done! :)
EncoreW
hi noob mod here

[Lunatic]

the noob testplay

hmm...Lunatic is a lackluster diffname in a app map i think, try to change a cooler one?

here is a little advice about combo color
combo 2 and 3 too close i think yes too close

00:01:491 (1) - to 00:24:491 (4) - 06:01:509 (1) - 06:25:009 (1) - 01:53:491 - to 02:16:991 - this 3 parts really similar (even the same) so i think can you use 2 same combo color in this 2 parts? because only piano and vocal here so i think 2 combo color is enough, like combo color 1 and 2 in this two parts, and use maybe 4 another combo color in 00:25:324 (1) - to 05:53:683 (1) - this part? because add the other musical instruments since 00:25:324 (1) -

if you are lazy or dis agree what i said, just ignore that :D

hitsounds
only 40% and 50% volume in this song (just use 10% and 5% in spinner at 05:53:737 (1) - , so it's equal to 40% and 50% the whole song) , i think it's not reasonable, try to add more green lines to change volume in some part because in this song, 2 different volume is not enough

for example 00:25:491 (2) - since this part (still 01:53:491 - ), i think volume should be louder than before because add a new musical instruments (although i don't know its name), and 50% in kiai maybe a little too light, try louder like 70% even 80%

02:20:834 (1) - ro 02:27:334 (2) - stronger and stronger by NC plz

since 02:30:857 (1) - here, this part needs louder volume because the carnival is coming, 40% can't reflect these obviously

maybe you need a normal-hitwhistle hitsound, not default, because this kind of whistle appeared here maybe not suitable

if you are lazy or dis agree what i said, just ignore that :D

patterns
just some little advices

00:36:491 (3,4) - this 0.75x go to 1.00x, i think no sense here, in other words not very necessary, and if you still change speed, just do the same thing at 00:42:491 (4,5) - 00:44:491 (3,4) - 01:14:491 (4,5) - 01:16:491 (3,4) - plz

01:40:324 (1) - why change speed here...and so substantially, i think this and 01:32:991 (5) - can be the same, to be honest i think 01:32:991 (5) - can use a different speed slider to instead this circle because of higher pitch suddenly

03:30:748 (3,4) - 04:28:030 (3,6) - not a perfect blanket, and so on

04:18:465 (1,2,1) - i think every slider keep 10 or 15 degree wiill be more beautiful, more beautiful? if you agree with me, do the same thing at every double 1/8 sliders pattern plz

04:39:770 (1) - omg too quick, especially after a long spinner i think, because my hand a little tired after this spinner so i didn't react this and 100 on this slider not 300, when i react this slider, i think that where is my slider ball? lol

05:00:204 (7,8,9,10,1) - keep the same spacing?

a lot of fun to play, GL 8-)
Asahina Momoko
o/

general

  1. song's title is a bit wrong, it needs space between ~ and A so pls copipasta dis "マッドパーティー ~ A Magusnificent Plan" (comes from here

Lunatic

  1. 01:08:991 (5) - ctrl+g makes flow better for me
  2. 01:26:491 (4,5) - put them like this would be fine to see
  3. 01:40:324 (1,2) - the vocal sound on 1st slider is louder than 2nd one, so how about swapping their sv? also the scale changes high to low, so put them like this works fine i guess
  4. 02:28:084 (1) - remove nc or add nc to 02:28:834 (1) - ?
  5. 02:40:748 (1,2) - how about exchange the slider and circle? the sound that's extended starts at 02:40:748 - so to put a slider there fit to music i guess
  6. 03:01:617 (3,4) - ^
  7. 03:07:378 (1,2) - hmm no strong sound here, so make them more close might be better to play
  8. 03:40:313 (9,1) - bad to play here, you should make spacing consistent with 03:40:204 (8,9,1) - so how about stack 03:39:335 (5,8) - and put 03:40:313 (9) - like this?
  9. 04:06:291 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - some 1/6 ? i have no idea it's acceptable to put them as 1/4 for playing comfortably
  10. 04:09:987 (7,8,9,10,1,2,3,4) - ^
  11. 04:17:088 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ^
  12. 04:24:117 (3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - ^

that's all, good luck!!
Topic Starter
Natteke desu
not that much changes from kroytz mod about beginning i like to keep it as it is, because idk i don't feel like something more spaced will fit (your mod was mostly about them), some changes about mid part were made tho
T-Mac :
i'd like too keep current cc because i usually use them and i don't think that these colors could affect some problems also it's dang russianmapping meme, i'll think about hitsounds, but at the moment i don't feel like changing volumes, also i did mostly everything from patterning part of mod
Asahina Momoko:
meta+ many stuff about jumps (some of them weren't mentoined in your mod, but i made them considering your suggestions) , as for 1/6s i don't think that something like this would fit so i'd keep it as it is

Thanks guys that was kinda helpfull, if somebody need full replies feel free to punchmyface and i'll spread them out




i blame bss
Lama Poluna
Какие моды, го ранкать уже.


/me summon nominators
Topic Starter
Natteke desu

Lama Poluna wrote:

Какие моды, го ранкать уже.


/me summon nominators
я жду тайко
EncoreW
GO GO
-kevincela-
Current Priority: +12 (528 maps higher on the list)
Topic Starter
Natteke desu
wow, thank you kevin
let's wait for ono's diff before moving it further now!
Andrea
Cool map 8-)
ceLy
T T
too hard for me to mod..
Good Luck~
Okoratu
i intended to bubble this but then i found stuff that is most likely no
[general]
can you mute the pause sound that comes when the pass symbol displays in the middle of both breaks mainly 05:57:333 -
it sounds dumb

02:31:074 (2,3,1,2,1,2) - are snapped wrongly
stuff like 02:35:965 (1) - 02:36:001 -
this song is swing for the most part, mapping 1/4 over swing music sounds lol
you just do this all the time and it's like really confusing me, are you simplifying this whole song to 1/4 ???

no idea what to do with this you objects basically map a different song where the swing concept doesn't exist
Topic Starter
Natteke desu
02:35:965 (1) - as for this it's better at blue tick because of that bell sound (at least for me)
anyways, it was mapped in this way because 1/16 snaps is something what people hate, moreover i decided to go with half vocals/half strong beats, so i believe in this case simple 1/4 is more apporitate to go with. Tho i'm okay with resnapping whole diff if it's needed, i guess i'll ask for some opinions at first.

Btw, it's still wip because i'm waiting for taiko diff so it's a bit too early to talk about qualifying it
Len
02:33:610 (2) - on 02:33:601 -
02:33:755 (3) - on 02:33:737 -

im waiting till it gets ranked
Topic Starter
Natteke desu
lo
Liiraye
I love playing this...
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply