Little wrote:

Hi there!

[General]

1. The spinner at the end is excessively long, and will be tiring for some players - especially in the case of Easy difficulty. I also think it fits the song better if you just remove the spinner and end on the last note of the kiai section.

[Easy]

1. 00:13:414 (1) - The whistle at the end doesn't seem to fit with the hitsound pattern used with the previous iterations of this phrase at 00:02:638 (1) and 00:06:230 (1) Oh yeah, remvoed.
2. 00:15:210 (3) - I think it would be nice to use drum sampleset with soft additions here to highlight the drums. Used it on the tail.
3. 00:18:803 (2) - Remove whistle from end. Ok
4. 00:20:599 (1) - Add whistle on head? ^
5. 00:25:987 (3) - Same as above. ^^
6. 00:32:723 (2,3) - Looks nicer if you make the curve match with (1) like this: http://puu.sh/liV5r/f1a2c0ed1c.jpg It didn't make any big difference tbh.
7. 00:36:764 (3) - Flows slightly better when curved the other direction to lead into (1) a little smoother in my opinion: http://puu.sh/liVd4/7ba7e14a35.jpg ^
8. 00:43:949 (3) - I think it would be nice to use drum sampleset with soft additions here to highlight the drums. Used it on the tail.
9. 00:58:318 (3) - Same as above. ^
10. 01:08:197 (2) - Remove whistle from head? Yeah.
11. 01:09:095 (3) - At most other parts with this rhythm, you used a whistle on the repeat. Would you like to do the same here? :3
12. 01:10:891 (1) - Whistle on head to match 00:27:783 (1) Okay.

[Normal]

1. 00:06:903 (2,3) - I recommend changing the rhythm here to match 00:03:311 (2) The rhythm in the song is the same, and since the beginning of the song is relatively calm, I recommend starting out with fewer clicks so you have room to build up. Okay
2. 00:20:599 (1) - Why is there a red node on the repeat? I'm not sure what difference that makes, but you should probably make it a white node. XDDDDDDDDD, man, this didn't make any difference ;PP
3. 00:31:376 (1) - This is way outside the grid, and comes close to touching the edge of the screen. If possible, try moving it more to the left, starting with the objects at 00:24:191 Well, i tested on many resolutions, and it's okay, i think it isn't a problem almost touch the edge.
4. 00:35:866 (3,4,1) - This rhythm is really awkward to play. I know it follows the vocals, but skipping beat four makes it feel very empty without the clap. I think this will be a more appropriate rhythm: Image It will also help to give emphasis on the downbeat with a circle rather than a weak slider end, espcially if you stack the circle on the head of the next slider like so: Image Changed the rhythm, but didn't use your example.
5. 00:37:887 (4,5) - I think this will be better as a 1/2 beat slider to help emphasize the repeated offbeat vocals.
6. Some of the hitsound suggestions for Easy may apply here. Make sure to check.

[Hard]

1. 00:13:863 (1,2) - Would look nice if you blanketed these: http://puu.sh/ljhoF/68757674d7.jpg Bahh, it's already fine.
2. 00:30:702 (4) - Drum sampleset would fit nicely on the head. sure :3
3. Some of the hitsound suggestions for Easy may apply here. Make sure to check.

Good luck!

[Sc4v4ng3r] wrote:

Well I didn't wanted to mod nothing before my exams, so here it is. Just few quick suggestions from me~

1. Unrankable issues
2. My opinion which I highly recommend changing it
3. Small suggestions/Nazi

[General]

1. Disable widescreen support on Easy and Normal for unification of option. Ya.
2. Why not add 'X-mas' to the tags? Some people may search beatmaps using this keyword. Nice catch.

[Easy]

1. Mostly hitsound suggestions, the pattern and flow looks good already.
2. 00:18:803 (2) - Honestly I don't see what is the whistle at the tail of this slider is following. It kinda feels out of place compared to other upbeats... Well it is not a problem if this was following something at least. Fixed.
3. 00:22:395 (3,2) - A really, really, minor thing. Since you didn't have this kinds of 'just-a-bit-touching overlaps' in the whole map after this, you may want to re-arrange the pattern to avoid that. And yes, it is visible in play mode due to the AR. Okay.
4. 00:25:987 (3) - Possibly you could add a whistle onto the head of this slider as the vocal is strong here. O3O
5. 00:29:580 (3) - You've coulda used drum sampleset on the repeat of this slider as well as it is in the same drumroll like the head and the tail. Just a whisthsakd is already enough.
6. 00:43:949 (3) - Similar to what you've did at 00:29:580 (3) - , you should try to use drum sampleset on the head and the tail(possibly also the repeat if you are taking my suggestion at 00:29:580 (3) - ) for consistency and to emphasize the drumrolls. ^
7. And so on with the 'add whistle' or 'use this' w/e. Just sharing my opinion, I feel the whistles could have been better emphasized if they were just placed every big white ticks in the kiai, but what you have did right now is also fine.

[Normal]

1. 00:29:580 (4,5) - You know, I feel that two 1/1 sliders aren't enough to emphasize the drumroll in the background properly... Just my opinion on this, but you may want to add a circle on the missing red ticks to emphasize the drumrolls. Or at least just the first red tick to avoid a long chain of 1/2 notes. I fell that this isn't needed, just two 1/¹ are fine.
2. 00:34:968 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - Damn all these notes are hard to follow when the previous notes were all on the beat I can see that you are trying to follow here, but this may just throw beginners off as almost none of the notes here are actually on beat :/ I can't think of an example if you insist on following the vocals though... I would just make 00:37:887 (3,4) - these 2 a 1/2 repeated slider which starts at 00:37:662 - . Changed the rhythm :3
3. Well just saying, is changing up the NC patterning at kiai allowed? I didn't know that was possible idk D:

[Hard]

1. 00:45:520 - It feels weird to have the drumrolls here unmapped when 00:43:949 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - these did map it out. Just saying for the consistency's sake. Fixed
2. Other than that, looks all good By far this is the best difficulty out of them all lols yay thanks

That is all from me. GL! tanks o3o

Ipas wrote:

Hello!
It's random pick from Christmas☆Queue 2015!

[General]

1. Looks Clean~

[Easy]

1. 00:15:210 (3) - This slider's body almost touch the default hp bar . Because it's almost, it may affect to custom hp bar skin among players, so I suggest you to move it down lower . Some sort of this case appears in further of the diff, so if you're intend to, make sure you change them all Fixed.
2. Overall, looks fine for me Yayy

[Normal]

1. 00:18:354 (3,5) - This overlap looks untidy for me. It makes section 00:17:007 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - getting very dense in terms of placements . You may need to avoid it if it comes to my suggestion
2. 00:30:253 - As a build-up before the rhythm changed, it sounds good to have a circle here to help 00:29:580 (4,5) - complete the rhythm spread
3. 00:57:644 (3,4) - If you stack them, they will more easier to hit instead being separated like this . Also, players that actually play this diff will start to distress
4. 01:16:279 (1) - This is really almost touched the hp bar . I recommend you to make its placement more lowered
5. 01:17:626 (1,2) - Shouldn't new combo swapped? Fixed all :3

[Hard]

1. Looks clean . But, in my opinion, you may need to reduce some intensity in this diff to make sure that the gap between Normal and this diff is really acceptable . Maybe, you can add more of 1/1 gap like this 01:06:849 (3,1) - to some places that will benefits I've just found 3 places to add gap like this

[]
If you need me, you can call me back I will sdadasd

ByBy13 wrote:

Hello!

[General]

1. Just notice that Glee: The Music is repeated in tags.Be sure that you have to keep one of these two
2. In tags there's 'cut' and 'short ver'.You can add only 'cut version' or 'short version' because in my opinion you don't need to have cut and short both in tags because it is the same let's say
3. Seems that the metadata is alright proof

[Easy]

1. 00:54:726(2,3)- Seems the flow is odd here as I can see.I suggest to move the circle to 443|55 to improve the flow here and also don't forget tomove the next objects to avoid DS errors Fixed o3o
2. 00:56:522(1)- If you listen carefully the music,you will see that the strong beat is on 00:57:420- and not on 00:57:195- and also the vocals are extending a bit to 00:57:420- when there the vocals are finishing with 'know' lyric there and instead so it will feel more natural if you will move the slider's end to 00:57:420- where's the strong beat to emphasize it instead leaving it empty which mean that you have to snap the 3/2 slider to a 2/1 slider Oki.
3. 01:00:114(1)- Honestly saying I would like to see this 3/2 slider with a repeat replaced with 2 1/2 slider to make this strong beat from 01:01:012- clickable instead ignoring it let's say and also as you did at 01:07:298(1,2)- Nice idea, fixed.
4. 01:14:483(1)- Same as above ^ ^^

[Normal]

1. 00:30:253- There's the high pitch of the vocals I mean they are kind of stronger vocals and instead leaving them empty,you can add a note to emphasize the high pitch of the vocals Added.
2. 01:03:257(1,2)- I'd like to swap the combos here since on 01:03:706(2)- there are the reset of the vocals&instruments and not on the previous slider
3. 01:05:053(1,2)- Same as above^
4. 01:06:849(1,2)- Same^
5. 01:17:626(1,2)-^ Fixed all O3O

[Hard]

1. 00:28:457(2)- I'd like to remove the repeat from this 3/2 slider and adding 2 notes after this slider for the stronger beat(clap) from 00:29:131- and the beat from the 00:29:355- because I'd like to emphasize that stronger beat instead leaving it empty I prefer follow the vocals at this part :<
   Nice but some triplets could be 'reduced' for avoiding making a spread gap between normal and hard Okay, added some 1/4 sliders instead of just 3 1/4 notes

I'll star it for now since it is good enough but as I can see you need some improvement in hitsounds.Just get 1-2 mods regarding the hitsounds and then call me back! I'll remap them by myself :3