forum

SHK - Identity part.II [OsuMania]

posted
Total Posts
80
show more
Topic Starter
paperlens
so which one is right :D

Soul Evans wrote:

people these days and their qualified maps getting Kwan'd, makes me a little nervous about my meta-data

or else i will get kwan'd
btw I love your avatar Soul Evans
IamKwaN
find me the official album track list and then i can requalify this map

Soul Evans wrote:

people these days and their qualified maps getting Kwan'd, makes me a little nervous about my meta-data

or else i will get kwan'd
yea because i believe im the only QAT who check maps on my own accord nowadays, as we rely on people's reports before taking down maps since the change to the QAT
SpectorDG
"II" "2" both are fine lmao

first rank is SHK - Identity Part III . . .
Akasha-
By in-game: Idenity part II



By album: Identity part.II



(http://soundholick.com/xe/?document_srl=615)

By image (made by SHK): Idenity part.2



Again, i'm totally confused right now
Topic Starter
paperlens
btw http://blog.naver.com/PostList.nhn?blog ... egoryNo=88 SHK's blog it shows "Identity Part.II"
IamKwaN
change to one of those below and then poke me if you need me~

Identity Part.II
Identity part II
Identity part 2
Identity part.2
Akasha-
title should have dot nearby "part" or "Part"
IamKwaN
i am okay with everything listed above, leave him to choose probably
Topic Starter
paperlens

IamKwaN wrote:

i am okay with everything listed above, leave him to choose probably
all ok now
Identity part.II
after our discuss that seems most appropriate
ReQualify pls if you think that's good
IamKwaN
yap
Soul Evans

paperlens wrote:

so which one is right :D

Soul Evans wrote:

people these days and their qualified maps getting Kwan'd, makes me a little nervous about my meta-data

or else i will get kwan'd
btw I love your avatar Soul Evans
ahaha thanks~
IamKwaN
Requested by creator.
Akasha-
SHK - Identity part.II [OsuMania modding]


[Generals]
- BPM: Okay
- Offset: Okay
- AiMod: Okay
- Tags: Okay
- BG: Okay
- Kiai: Okay
- Metadata: Okay
- Folder’s problem: None
- Hitsound: Okay
- Timing: Okay
- Other: Okay

Rebubbled

Congratulations!


Topic Starter
paperlens
thank you for your help KK!

biemote

paperlens wrote:

thank you for your help KK!

这图需要重P成粉短发性药(不
-[ AmiShici ]-
LMAO
Feerum
Hi!

Before i requalify i would like to discuss about one pattern in your Map.

I did keep an eye on this Map while it was in Qualify and a lot of player didn't like your 1/8 JS in the SHD difficulty.
I think you know which one i mean, it's this one:


Basically i don't have anything against it but what is really disturbing for the most and really uncomfortable to play are following:


The really dense JS is here already enough i think so there is no need to add triple jacks into this 1/8 jumpstream.
I will not tell you to remove this 1/8 JS because i think it fit good enough into this but i would like to suggest you some other Pattern which remove the tri-jacks from it and makes it better to play:

[SHD]
My first suggestion would be follwoing:

This one contains [12][13][34][24] (and this repeats all the time)
I kinda like these pattern because they are not that easy to hit and still remove the pretty evil tri jack from your pattern.


My 2nd suggestion would be following:

This one contains [12][23][34][14] Jumps which goes full on comfortable play.
the disadvantage here is that these Pattern are also very mashable which makes it very easy to pass.

Tell me what do you think about it.
I really highly suggest to remove at least the tri-jacks from both JS.
I don't know if you saw the feedback to your Map but the most dislike these JS.

Should you apply the change to the 1st JS don't forget to arrange the 2nd one at 02:38:099 - too :D
Topic Starter
paperlens

Feerum wrote:

Hi!

Before i requalify i would like to discuss about one pattern in your Map.

I did keep an eye on this Map while it was in Qualify and a lot of player didn't like your 1/8 JS in the SHD difficulty.
I think you know which one i mean, it's this one:


Basically i don't have anything against it but what is really disturbing for the most and really uncomfortable to play are following:


The really dense JS is here already enough i think so there is no need to add triple jacks into this 1/8 jumpstream.
I will not tell you to remove this 1/8 JS because i think it fit good enough into this but i would like to suggest you some other Pattern which remove the tri-jacks from it and makes it better to play:

[SHD]
My first suggestion would be follwoing:

This one contains [12][13][34][24] (and this repeats all the time)
I kinda like these pattern because they are not that easy to hit and still remove the pretty evil tri jack from your pattern.


My 2nd suggestion would be following:

This one contains [12][23][34][14] Jumps which goes full on comfortable play.
the disadvantage here is that these Pattern are also very mashable which makes it very easy to pass.

Tell me what do you think about it.
I really highly suggest to remove at least the tri-jacks from both JS.
I don't know if you saw the feedback to your Map but the most dislike these JS.

Should you apply the change to the 1st JS don't forget to arrange the 2nd one at 02:38:099 - too :D
thank you for your suggestion but I won't change this part
1. my pattern is easier to read than these
2. 1st suggestion, I used this pattern before, this pattern has similar feeling as the pattern I use now, but it's harder to read.
3. 2nd suggestion, I simply don't like that pattern, makes no sense maybe.
4. tri-jacks in 150BPM is not even a problem for 4.8stars map.
5. I'm not the man who listens much to the players now.
Hydria

paperlens wrote:

5. I'm not the man who listens much to the players now.
How to lose all respect 101 ft. paperlens
stankill
5. I'm not the man who listens much to the players now.

mania mapper in a nutshell
Topic Starter
paperlens
yes you guys are right, but that doesn't change anything, maybe change this map into unrank only
and I will be truely sorry for KK and Feerum then
Akasha-
Do not graveyard this.
SpectorDG

paperlens wrote:

yes you guys are right, but that doesn't change anything, maybe change this map into unrank only
and I will be truely sorry for KK and Feerum then
Just don't give up . . I don't know who you are but i can't just sit by to see that . . I know what feel you feeling

Don't replay my mistake
Feerum
paperlens explained me IRC why he wants to keep these pattern.
I'm totally fine with this.

Re-Qualified
Pope Gadget
I'm telling you, those bursts really are not okay. They are an unnecessarily huge difficulty spike in comparison to the rest of the chart, and quite simply it's unfair.
RoX2_Fang


Why not Add Note "헉"? jk
Another Lie

Pope Gadget wrote:

I'm telling you, those bursts really are not okay. They are an unnecessarily huge difficulty spike in comparison to the rest of the chart, and quite simply it's unfair.
Agree with that, it is harder than Shana's map C18H27NO3
See those
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5473274 Shana's map 5.15 Stars
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5473282 Yours 4.9 Stars (those bursts are make it harder)
Topic Starter
paperlens

RoX2_Fang wrote:



Why not Add Note "헉"? jk
trust me , I really want to add that
RoX2_Fang

paperlens wrote:

RoX2_Fang wrote:



Why not Add Note "헉"? jk
trust me , I really want to add that
lolololol
Ayachi-

Another Lie wrote:

Pope Gadget wrote:

I'm telling you, those bursts really are not okay. They are an unnecessarily huge difficulty spike in comparison to the rest of the chart, and quite simply it's unfair.
Agree with that, it is harder than Shana's map C18H27NO3
See those
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5473274 Shana's map 5.15 Stars
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5473282 Yours 4.9 Stars (those bursts are make it harder)
ok bro
biemote

Another Lie wrote:

Pope Gadget wrote:

I'm telling you, those bursts really are not okay. They are an unnecessarily huge difficulty spike in comparison to the rest of the chart, and quite simply it's unfair.
Agree with that, it is harder than Shana's map C18H27NO3
See those
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5473274 Shana's map 5.15 Stars
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5473282 Yours 4.9 Stars (those bursts are make it harder)
nope.In my option,it's quite normal cuz id2's BPM is much lower than shana's map/////

cuz the 12 34 pattern makes the star difficult fly much higher with note density than other reasons,
it's quite normal this map's star difficult is lower than C18H27NO3

this is a good map i think.....hmmmmmm

it will be a pity if we just focus on the star(maybe PP) and ignore the map quality.
biemote

Pope Gadget wrote:

I'm telling you, those bursts really are not okay. They are an unnecessarily huge difficulty spike in comparison to the rest of the chart, and quite simply it's unfair.
poi?

difficulty spike is unfair but NOT FORBIDDEN OR UNRANKABLE

hmmmmm........
Another Lie

biemote wrote:

cuz the 12 34 pattern makes the star difficult fly much higher with note density than other reasons,
it's quite normal this map's star difficult is lower than C18H27NO3

this is a good map i think.....hmmmmmm

it will be a pity if we just focus on the star(maybe PP) and ignore the map quality.
If your point in "map quality" i'm absolutely say his map are good (Including Identity Part. III) but, i'm pointing to that chart (not PP and star) it will be difficult even rank 4k like me can pass that with A -_-
lullaby bunny
I have to ask, but, is there a reason why the mappers did not just do a conversion of the official o2jam notechart? o2jam mobile has a very good chart for identity part II and identity part II SHD. I can't really agree with the mappers choice. I only post because this is literally my favorite o2jam song and would like to enjoy it in mania.
CommandoBlack
I want to be explained why this got ranked. I see so many things wrong with this in my opinion. I want to make my mapping better so if this is considered good enough to be ranked, I want to know why.
[Crz]Makii
主难度又没有抓音不准,又没有overdose overmap,又没有sb排列,不知道有什么好喷的。

CommandoBlack wrote:

I want to be explained why this got ranked. I see so many things wrong with this in my opinion. I want to make my mapping better so if this is considered good enough to be ranked, I want to know why.
isn't it a good map??every place can show there music perfectly.

DON'T JUDGE A MAP WITH YOUR OWN HABIT THANKS.

看了三个box里的话,嘛我觉得现在的players都太急躁 有个打不了的地方就说“怎么这么屎”。关于这个我也是挺夫妻。。
以后请继续加油!还想看到你更多的rank歌曲 :)
Topic Starter
paperlens

[Crz]Sword wrote:

主难度又没有抓音不准,又没有overdose overmap,又没有sb排列,不知道有什么好喷的。

CommandoBlack wrote:

I want to be explained why this got ranked. I see so many things wrong with this in my opinion. I want to make my mapping better so if this is considered good enough to be ranked, I want to know why.
isn't it a good map??every place can show there music perfectly.

DON'T JUDGE A MAP WITH YOUR OWN HABIT THANKS.

看了三个box里的话,嘛我觉得现在的players都太急躁 有个打不了的地方就说“怎么这么屎”。关于这个我也是挺夫妻。。
以后请继续加油!还想看到你更多的rank歌曲 :)
其实那个秒杀段的确很屎()
感谢w 虽说估计不会再rank图
Please sign in to reply.

New reply