Most of the suggests are very helpful, thanks for your modding!Stefan wrote:
heyhey hihi!
[OxO's Oni]
Including Inner Oni here, both difficulties feels really really forced and unnatural to play. This is especially noticeable in the calmer parts of the song. While Smallwu's Oni does also have the same problem in this case compared to the other two difficulties it still feels somewhat comfortable to play. Except of the point above I haven't mentioned anything in both difficulties since I can't really see where they could be modded aside of removing notes. However, Smallwu's Oni seems to need some minor nerfs to be suitable as an easier Oni than OxO's difficulty. I will remind Danny OxO
[Oni]
Like said above, some parts require a nerf so you can justify to have OxO's Oni mapped harder than your Oni.
01:21:269 (31) - remove this note, dkkdk to have if you come from Muzukashii Difficulties feels a little heavy. Change to ddkdk, that will be easily I think
01:22:137 (39,40,41,42,43) - instead of kkkkd, try using kkk D. Nice idea, but change another patterns (last note is D)
01:24:427 (58) - similar reason than 01:21:269 (31) - . I think dkddk is ok
01:27:663 (80) - Remove this note, make a small break before the long combo. Okay
01:31:927 (111,112,113,114,115,116,117,118,119) - Again, this is too hard spread-wise. You could change this to kkddk d d (or generally make ooooo o o as pattern.) Change to ddkdkkkkd, at least they're more regularity
01:35:163 (140,141,142) - You should include a break here instead. having such a high dense level in a small time (from 01:32:874 - 01:37:611 - ) isn't really the best idea for the spread so you need to slack it a bit off. I like your accurate interpretation. Although I'm not follow your suggest, I decide to change another easily patterns
00:12:190 (4) - Why didn't you include a Finish note here? It would just makes sense since 00:11:716 (1,7) - do have them too. Changed
00:14:716 (21) - ^ ^
00:14:874 - To have nothing here seems weird and inconsistent, you should put a d note here. But there's no any loud musical instruments
00:17:242 (35) - another Finish sound missing. Ok
00:24:821 (15) - I find this part sounds less noisy and better emphasized by removing the note. It feels less contributing than the rest of the hitcircles. Removed
00:29:874 (41) - ^ ^
00:32:400 (51) - ^ There's piano sound, keep
01:05:085 (13) - ^ Keep the note is not bad for me
00:36:506 (73,74) - You could remove (73) and make (74) to d since (74) is slightly deeper than 00:36:821 (75) - . Sounds good
In total I had a hard time to understand what exactly are you following when you mapped your difficulty. Sometimes it felt you mixed both, background music and vocals together and switched in-between which feels really weird. While I find the vocals are stronger for the most time you should concentrate on this and less on the bgm. As well, you use a lot of filler notes in your difficulty which makes it looks pretty random and less structured. You should use less notes to create a bigger impact. After all, if you decided to nerf your Oni Difficulty, OxO's Oni looks better to have because it will be noticeable harder than your Oni and the spread feels better then.
I will check the all of the beatmap later, thanks for suggest!
[Muzukashii]
00:05:874 (12) - It sounds pretty weird, I am kinda unsure what exactly are you following but I'd recommend to move it to 00:06:032 - . Okay, moved
00:21:032 (37) - and 00:21:190 - Move (37) to 00:21:190 - and add on 00:21:032 - a d note. 00:21:190 - Sounds pretty important to have. But 00:21:190 only has a very slight piano sound, I think that's less important than drum
00:23:716 (9) - You mainly follow the vocals in the calm part of the song, that works well but this one purely follows the background which makes your rhythm kinda inconsistent. You should leave it to the vocals and focus on that, remove this note as first. I think here's very loud, need a note to follow music
00:24:979 (13) - Pretty much the same case like above. I agree with you at here
00:26:874 (19) - This is good to have since it follows a carrying sound and it would be really odd to keep this empty. Maybe the guitar has buff
00:28:769 (26,27) - Consider removing them since they mainly follows the background sounds. Not agree here, the piano is louder than 00:24:979's . Because that, I don't think they can be ignore
00:37:769 (56) - ^ Agree here :3
Futsuu and Kantan were good so far, nothing to say about them. <3
Good Luck! Also, sorry for the delay.
I will recheck all diffs of the map at the end of the month, sorry for late reply :3
Edit : Reply Oni mod