i think you forget that a pop means i think this needs more discussion, not all of my changes need to be applied-Kazu- wrote:
Next time if you wanna do s u g g e s t i o n s, make sure not to pop the bubble and give the mapper the chance to decide your s u g g e s t i o n s are useful.Taikocracy wrote:
please do me a favor and fix the spread between backfire's inner oni and the hell oni, there's no reason one diff's intro should be a lot more dense than the other even if it's a gd this suggestion doesnt make sense at all. First of all, yes, there is a reason for a diff being lot denser than the other and that's exactly what popped on your head but wanted to say "uhh better mention that being a GD isnt a good reason so maybe he will eat it lololol". Different mappers, different ways to make a section, he went for another rhythm and both are fine imo. Also, I just can't believe you are actually caring about spread on two Inners, it has nothing to do with learning curve at this point, if you can play backfire's Inner you can aswell play mine as there is no much difference (come on there is 85 more notes to play)
along with that the use of 1/6 in the last kiai of the hell oni is fairly inappropriate, while i see that it's used for the sake of emphasizing sounds in the background, doing it 2-3 times or 8-12 times per 4 bar phrase both takes away the emphasis from using 1/6 in the first place and also over-saturates every single one of those sounds. i suggest deleting 01:45:287 (169,170,171,172) - and 01:45:594 (174,175,176,177) - for example, and doing that throughout the entire kiai. this leaves that last 1/6 for actual emphasis. makes no sense for me, I want to emphasize the scratches with these 1/6 patterns, it has nothing to do with anything else
it'll be a while before i check this back because i'm on vacation as i've said before but you can shoot me a message on osu when this stuff is fixed and probably let the mania bn rebubble, i'll have to do a more thorough check for a qualify
edit: or you can just wait till i get home, but that'll be in at most 5 days
edit #2: you're probably going to want to fix the creator name in the metadata too
okay yeah you're right about the inner oni thing so let's move to the 1/6
you say you're emphasizing "scratching." ok so let's use that as the base for your 1/6: 01:46:056 (181,182,183,184) - what purpose does this 1/6 serve? or 01:51:287 (247,248,249,250) - this one, where the rhythm you are emphasizing is better reflected on a 1/4 beat as oppose to a 1/6? 01:57:748 (326,327,328,329) - this one as well, where the sound you're emphasizing comes up 01:55:287 (295,296,297) - here, 01:56:210 (307,308,309) - here, and 01:54:056 (280,281,282) - as 1/4 instead?
>those sound sarcastic but they're genuine questions, sorry if the tone sounds rather sarcastic/condescending, that was not the intention
i truly think your 1/6 usage needs more discussion because while you defended some of them, the others' placement seems more random than anything else to me
if you disagree with my points, feel free to get a different taiko bn to look at this, seeing as i'm just 1 bn. if another bn is in favor of the 1/6 usage, they can rebubble it if they would like to.