Hi~ This is an M4M with MrSergio for
the queue, but I'll mod some other difficulties too here, since you seem to be looking for more mods.
[General]
* 128kbps mp3? You should be able to find a better quality one! Btw, isn't this same as
https://osu.ppy.sh/b/795627 this? I don't know about metadata, but maybe you can take the mp3 from there and make sure which artist name is correct.
* The volume is a little too loud overall. It's fine to use loud volume for the highlight parts, but you can probably reduce more for the start(about 50% or below) 00:20:334 - 70% 00:32:334 - 60% and so on.
* The gap between Normal and Hard could be too big. I suggest to get another GD between them.
[Easy]
* I hope you would use consistent combo for the overall map. I'll give you some examples later below.
* Also I recommend to NOT use grip snap for easier difficulties unless you're making a symmetry pattern or something. Since the distance between notes are very close, those little distance error(up to 0.05x in this case) are pretty much visible.
* 00:05:065 (4) - NC here and remove from 00:06:613 (1) -
* 00:14:355 (1) - Expand the spinner to 00:16:335 - . It fits much better imo.
* 00:22:668 (2) - This is inconsistent with the later ones( 00:25:501 (2) - 00:28:168 (2) - etc). So try to make them have same distance.
* 00:36:334 (1) - 00:47:001 (1) - Remove NC and add on 00:45:668 (3) -
* 01:04:334 (1) - Wrong distance! Do not make jumps on Easies and I think you just mistook there :3
* 01:08:001 (2,3) - Same as before, you should make this consistent with 01:10:834 (2,3) - and 01:13:501 (2,1) -
* 01:14:334 (1) - Also remove NC from here and add on 01:15:001 (2) -
* 01:18:668 - 01:20:001 - I think you can fill these out, since this part is kinda one of the hightlight parts and too much break on them is too boring imo.
* 01:36:334 - 01:37:668 - Unused green lines.
* 01:41:668 (3) - NC here and remove from 01:43:001 (1) -
* 02:03:001 (1,2) - Stacking isn't recommended for an Easy diff. I strongly suggest to seperate them (RIP heart shape)
* 02:13:668 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6) - Same consistency issue. If you want to make diverse rhythm patterns, at least not on this diff. It's too confusing to use different rhythm for the same parts.
* Also 02:21:668 (5) - NC here
* 02:22:334 (6,1) - Nothing very wrong here, but it's better to put them closer when they have enough time gap. This is almost like a screen-crossing movement which is not very satisfying for beginners.
* 02:22:834 - Also, I think this big gap isn't very necessary, considering how you managed this part before( 01:16:168 (3) - ) You can at least make them consistent. Consistency is very important to improve the map's quality.
* 02:25:334 - 02:26:668 - Same, how about filling them out?
* 02:32:334 (1) - You can fill this spinner out with some notes imo, and I think the break from 02:37:668 - here is a bit awkward. Since there is a good break on 02:59:001 - , I suggest to just map them out.
* 02:45:668 (1) - If you're NOT going to map the break out, I suggest to remove this note since it's pretty much irrelevant to the next part and is included on the break part.
* 02:53:668 (3) - NC
* 03:09:001 (1,2) - Reverse NC
* 03:12:001 - Remove break here. This short break is pretty meaningless and rather confusing.
* 03:17:668 (3) - 03:28:334 (3) - NC
* 03:39:001 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - Same, please make it consistent with each other.
* 03:50:668 - 03:52:001 - Fill them out
* 03:52:334 (3) - NC here. I know you're not NCing this since you want to keep the NC with the patterns, but for easier difficulties, NC should especially go with the consistent term.
* Also I suggest you to learn how to make prettier sliders. They look kinda untidy and could be improved.
[Normal]
* I don't recommend to use too much twisted slider patterns, as it's hard to read the actual length. I want to say same thing for Easy, but it's not very significant.
* 00:05:065 (1,3) - The walls are sticking to each other and it looks bad, seperating them would be better.
* 00:12:807 (1) - Remove NC and 00:14:355 (3) - Add NC
* 00:22:668 (2,3) - and so on - I suggest you to use
this rhythm for ALL of those parts, or at least represent 00:22:834 - this beat, since I think it's much more important than 00:23:001 - this? You're not hesitating to use 1/2 rhythms for this diff so why not? You even represented those beats on Easy.
* 00:29:668 (1,2,3,4,5) - This pattern looks to be twisted too much. One suggetion is to loosen the curve of eash sliders and change 00:30:168 (2) - this slider as same as 00:29:668 (1,3) -
* 00:35:001 (5,1) - Reverse NC
* 00:38:834 (4) - Would be better to use 3/2 slider like 00:33:501 (3) - since the voice keeps coming out. Too awkward to leave them with a long break.
* 00:38:334 (2,1) - Try to stack those. It makes the map much cleaner.
* 00:45:668 (5,1) - Reverse NC
* 00:54:001 (5) - Add NC here, or, I think it's better to put a circle 00:53:334 - here and put another note from 00:53:668 - since this beat is too important to be represented with a slider end. Clicking is stronger than slider ends.
* 00:59:001 (3) - NC
* 01:01:668 (1,3) - This sounds too noisy compared to 01:02:168 (2,4) - those. I suggest to use this rhythm x2:
http://puu.sh/lnwsZ/2db14c2254.jpg* 01:19:001 (1) - Remove NC
* 01:23:834 (2) - Don't think too intense rhythm is necessary here imo, just remove this and put a circle on 01:24:001 -
* 01:39:001 - This part feels too intense compared to how the song is there. For example, you can just bind 01:39:001 (1,2) - them as a 1/1 slider and it still plays pretty well. 01:41:334 (4) - You can just put one circle here and it's still good. It's a Normal diff, so you don't need to fill everything out. This applies to the whole part, so think over and try to find what you can fix more to make it easier.
* And the NC term is ruined as well, try to keep 2 downbeats-term NC, unless it's a must-be-emphasized-pattern or something.
* 01:54:668 - A lot of drums on the background. Add note? It's not an Easy diff anyway.
* 01:57:334 (1,2) - Reverse NC
* 02:05:668 (3) - NC
* 02:32:334 (1) - Same as Easy, you can fill this out. Too vague and short break after this.
* 02:45:668 (1,2) - From here the song has more drums appearing, so using same simple rhythm as before is too boring. At least, you can add a circle on 02:48:001 -
* 03:12:168 - Remove break
* 03:25:668 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1) - Double the NC term please.
* 03:39:001 (1) - Should be better with 1 circle.
* 04:16:501 (4,5) - lol this distance
* And you know what? 04:15:001 (1,2,3,4,5) - this is a little confusing since 04:15:001 - 04:15:501 - 04:16:001 - are all melodies, and you represented them as a click, which is a good way to represent them. BUT, you used 04:16:334 - as a slider end which is the same level of melody. Since 04:16:501 - this is not even a white tick, it's a little out of the 'Normal' rhythm as well. So I suggest this instead:
http://puu.sh/lnx4I/7e1cf1ed9d.jpg[MrSergio's Hard]
* Yeah... definitely the gap between Normal is too big... your diff is even a harder one than regular Hard diffs. I think it's better to ask the creator to find another GD between your diff and Normal.
* 00:17:668 (4) - NC?
* 00:18:334 (6) - Since you don't hesitate to use 1/4 gap after a trembling slider, why not expand this by 1/4 more? It has same drum for 00:18:584 -
* 00:44:001 (1,2) - NC should be reversed imo
* 01:04:334 (1,2,3,4) - 02:11:001 (1,2,3,4) - These could have bigger scale imo, with more circles instead of sliders, since it's a very strong part.
* 02:10:168 (2,3) - Could have more distance as like 02:08:834 (2,3) -
* 02:34:168 (2) - This sv change is too confusing and sudden. It's not an Extra diff, so I suggest to just use 1.00 sv there.
* 02:56:251 (1) - There are many good drums to map, so why not just fill them out with notes?
* 03:12:251 - Remove break here, this short break isn't necessary and only confusing imo.
* 03:35:001 (3,1) - Make these two notes to be in 1 independent comboset maybe?
* 04:04:334 (3) - NC? because the NC term is inconsistent there...
* lol my m4m part is done xD
Oh well... seems that the gap between Hard and Insane is too big as well... might be better to get one another GD between them I guess...
Leaving Insane to be modded to many other good modders, good luck!
Jujuba wrote:
(and i'm no "he" ;-;)
I think "he" is used on internet to point someone if you don't know she/he's actual gender. Just like I said now, I can't decide which I should use, so it has been a kind of rule on the internet, I guess.