IOSYS - Bad Apple & Good Orange

posted
Total Posts
50
show more
Topic Starter
TKiller

lepidopodus wrote:

Taiko map done. Taiko Oni lvl. 8 so pretty hard one.
it's easier than G.O.A (1 lvl easier, whee) :]

I played it 3 times before submitting just because I liked it.
sveta-insane
star~
DiamondCrash
General;

Do a full submission, I needed to update the diffs after downloading, and I don't get the Taiko diff.

Easy;

00:24:871 (1,1) - Any need for 2 spinners here?
00:41:393 (1) - I feel this spinner is FAR too short for an Easy. Map through it.
00:45:741 (1,2) - Spacing.
00:59:437 (4) - This really doesn't fit. Remove a repeat and extend by 1/2.
01:03:132 (2,3) - Make them symmetrical. Also, spacing.
01:24:219 (1,1,1) - Please don't make these repeats overlap.
01:43:132 (1) - 1/2 longer.

Normal;

This is not a Normal. This is a Hard. 1/4 repeating sliders in a normal?!
00:24:871 (1,2) - Snap to 1/3
00:41:828 (2,3) - Spacing.
00:45:306 (4,1) - ^
00:48:784 (4,1) - ^
00:57:480 (4,1) - ^
01:17:045 (1,2) - ^
01:39:654 (1,1) - ^

Insane;

01:06:610 (1,1,1,1) - These 2x sections are impossible to read.
Topic Starter
TKiller
I guess, done, ignoring all "spacing" comments.
Vpalach
:O
Doomsday
Hey :)

  1. Timing looks close enough.
  2. "Lepidon! - Taiko Oni" isn't in the .osz. I can get it by saving the .osu for it manually though. Try full submitting again? (even though Sushi is having this trouble in one of his maps too, and full submitting didn't work, but it is worth a try).


[EASY]

Nicely made, apart from a few nitpicks I can make.

00:24:871 (1,1) - Here, I would just have 1 long spinner, instead of 2 shorter spinners.
00:48:350 (1) - Replace this spinner with something else? For an easy, this spinner is a bit too short imo (Or make it longer if you can).
00:54:871 (1) - ^

[NORMAL]

This is a pretty tough Normal, I must say. Then again, Easy wasn't a walk in the park for an easy so it leads on alright, I guess.

Nothing really bothered me. Seems nice.

[DBF'S HARD]


Dig it

00:39:654 (1) - I think something else would fit better here instead of this spinner. the other spinner works fine though.
01:10:089 (1,2,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2) - Remove or tone down these jumps? I found these really awkward to do and I had a hard time reading them. I would remove them, but if you really don't want to, Toning them down would help out.

[INSANE]

Hmm. Not keen on this one, I'm afraid.

00:09:219 (1,2) - Remove this little jump? Out of all the intro, this is the only jump here, and it threw me off since it comes out of nowhere. Is there any way you could close it down?
00:15:306 (1,2,3) - switch the slider ends on (3)? I thought it was a stream with these, even though it's a jump between the (2) and (3). If you switched the slider ends on (3), It would be much more intuitive (And remove 00:16:067 (4) too if you do that).
00:27:154 (3) - Make this 1/4 shorter? Or even better, make it symmetrical with the other slider? fits with the music better to me.
00:38:784 (5) - Remove this 0.5xBPM bit? It doesn't make much sense to me, especially since the other sliders mapped to the same vocal line were all fine with 1xBPM.
01:06:610 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This stream doesnt't really fit with the music too well to me. Is there another way you could map this that would fit a bit better?

[LEPIDON! - TAIKO ONI]

A nice, solid taiko difficulty. I really liked the rhythm's you used in the Intro too :)

Hmm. The easier difficulties for this were pretty good. On the harder side, but they were nice, and as it got harder, I liked it less. Hard was alright, but it had some silly spacing, and Insane was full of silly jumps and streams. Maybe it's just me, but Insane just doesn't work for me. Easy/Normal/Hard are alright though in their own right though, It's just insane.

Not enough to stop me from starring it though
Topic Starter
TKiller

Doomsday wrote:

[INSANE]

Hmm. Not keen on this one, I'm afraid.

00:09:219 (1,2) - Remove this little jump? Out of all the intro, this is the only jump here, and it threw me off since it comes out of nowhere. Is there any way you could close it down?

huh, it was pretty readable for me, but I can agree that it's sudden, reworking probably

00:15:306 (1,2,3) - switch the slider ends on (3)? I thought it was a stream with these, even though it's a jump between the (2) and (3). If you switched the slider ends on (3), It would be much more intuitive (And remove 00:16:067 (4) too if you do that).

pretty nasty Takuma's jump, I like it and got it in 3 tries but some people seem to not get it :|

00:27:154 (3) - Make this 1/4 shorter? Or even better, make it symmetrical with the other slider? fits with the music better to me.

I'll disagree I think, it's more interesting for me like this

00:38:784 (5) - Remove this 0.5xBPM bit? It doesn't make much sense to me, especially since the other sliders mapped to the same vocal line were all fine with 1xBPM.

you are just bad with 0,5 sections :D Jokes aside, I find it fitting music a lot

01:06:610 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This stream doesnt't really fit with the music too well to me. Is there another way you could map this that would fit a bit better?

eh, there was a much better pattern but DC made me remove it saying he, Larto (and Gens if memory serves me well) don't like that. Probably I should try using this new cool thingie with sliders, might work

[LEPIDON! - TAIKO ONI]

A nice, solid taiko difficulty. I really liked the rhythm's you used in the Intro too :)

indeed, I like this one pretty much
I'll kudosu when I'm ready with fixes.
rockleejkooo
star :3
Lesjuh
Offset 534

Insane
Orange combo colour can be difficult to see sometimes because of the video. I suggest you make it darker,replace or remove it.
00:23:350 (2) - How is this slider following the music?
01:02:697 (5) - Slider's beginning point completely hidden, make it visible because it's quite confusing.

DBF
First 40 seconds have alot spinners, I suggest removing some because they get annoying.
00:39:437 (3) - Make this a single beat

Normal
00:24:871 (1,2,3) - Don't do this on a normal difficulty. I'm referring to the spacing.
01:24:219 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - Make the distance between these beats shorter.
01:37:045 (1) - Too short for a Normal difficulty ;(

That's it!
braian5234
star"!
JoXeR
:) Star
tieff
[Normal]
01:39:664 (1,2) - Jump...

Fix and I'll bubble.

Bubbled!
Kotya
*_*
Andrea
IRC Modding.

- Changed a short spinner on Easy to a slider.
- Added an important new combo on Insane difficulty on a really slow slider for make it easier to read.

Ranked~
Verdisphena
Congratz :3
[DBF]
Grat'z!
Ekoro
Finally ! :o
dNextGen
8-)

DNR
inb4 mediocre pear.
Shiro Weasley
:oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops::oops:
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply