Yui Horie - Hikari (TV Size)

posted
Total Posts
63
show more
Sallad4ever
Hi ninja sorry for the delay ;_;

[General]
- I don't like the custom clap, it's too sharp. The normal hitsound (non-costum) just like on Teras' diff, sounds good imo or maybe you can lower the volume of the soft-hitclap file
- Please add something on Teras' diff name, only Teras' as diff name feels like it lacking some impact
- Umm...the tags are too long and I'm too lazy to check it. Well, as long as Teras is on the tags it's fine

[Easy]
00:32:463 (4) - a note on 1/2 beat will confuse novice player especially if the majority of the notes before are on 1/1 beat, so I suggest to move this back 1/2 beat to white tick then lengthen the slider 1/2 beat to red tick
00:57:880 (1) - this is fine cause there are time for the player to pause and the song is there to guide them
01:04:338 (3) - same case as above, my suggestion is to delete this then move 01:04:963 (4) to where (3) was
01:16:838 (3) - NC
01:27:255 (1) - remove finish

[Normal]
00:36:838 (4) - change to finish is better imo
00:56:838 (3) - add finish on the start of the slider and remove the one on the end
01:03:505 (3) - NC
01:16:838 (2) - ^
01:27:046 (1) - remove finish

[Hard]
00:17:255 (5) - this 0.5 slider is very too sloppy, try using 0.7x or 0.8x speed or a spinner
00:36:838 (3) - finish is better :3
00:50:796 (3) - put the whistle on the start and the end only, this sound weird because of the whistle sliderslide
00:51:838 (6) - ^
00:55:796 (6) - ^
00:59:963 (3,4) - if possible please put the start of the (4) slider above the (3) slider
01:27:255 (1) - remove finish

[Insane]

00:17:255 (2) - same problem as in hard diff
01:07:046 (3) - the jump is a little weird, most of your jump on the kiai time is a jump between slider on the end of every lyric. That's why I feel this is a little out of place
01:27:463 (1) - remove finish

[Teras']
00:17:046 (1) - shorten this by 1/1 beat than add a note at 00:20:172
00:27:672 (3) - if you're following the music shouldn't this be a single note and 00:27:984 (4,5) - should be move back by 1/4 beat?

Combo mod
Your combo change from new combo on each lyric to new combo on every 2 stanza on the kiai time. It's better if you make the combo follow the same pattern. New combo on every lyric is good

Good map and Good Luck ninja :D
gowww
8-)
Topic Starter
roflninja

Sallad4ever wrote:

Hi ninja sorry for the delay ;_; it's alright

[General]
- I don't like the custom clap, it's too sharp. The normal hitsound (non-costum) just like on Teras' diff, sounds good imo or maybe you can lower the volume of the soft-hitclap file hmm...
- Please add something on Teras' diff name, only Teras' as diff name feels like it lacking some impact
- Umm...the tags are too long and I'm too lazy to check it. Well, as long as Teras is on the tags it's fine might remove a few then :P

[Easy]
00:32:463 (4) - a note on 1/2 beat will confuse novice player especially if the majority of the notes before are on 1/1 beat, so I suggest to move this back 1/2 beat to white tick then lengthen the slider 1/2 beat to red tick ok
00:57:880 (1) - this is fine cause there are time for the player to pause and the song is there to guide them
01:04:338 (3) - same case as above, my suggestion is to delete this then move 01:04:963 (4) to where (3) was ^
01:16:838 (3) - NC done
01:27:255 (1) - remove finish ^

[Normal]
00:36:838 (4) - change to finish is better imo done
00:56:838 (3) - add finish on the start of the slider and remove the one on the end ^
01:03:505 (3) - NC ^
01:16:838 (2) - ^ ^
01:27:046 (1) - remove finish ^

[Hard]
00:17:255 (5) - this 0.5 slider is very too sloppy, try using 0.7x or 0.8x speed or a spinner ill keep this for now
00:36:838 (3) - finish is better :3 done
00:50:796 (3) - put the whistle on the start and the end only, this sound weird because of the whistle sliderslide ^
00:51:838 (6) - ^ ^
00:55:796 (6) - ^ ^
00:59:963 (3,4) - if possible please put the start of the (4) slider above the (3) slider ^
01:27:255 (1) - remove finish ^

[Insane]

00:17:255 (2) - same problem as in hard diff again, ill keep it for now
01:07:046 (3) - the jump is a little weird, most of your jump on the kiai time is a jump between slider on the end of every lyric. That's why I feel this is a little out of place ok,changed
01:27:463 (1) - remove finish done

Good map and Good Luck ninja :D
Thanks Sallad :)
Teras

Sallad4ever wrote:

[Teras']
00:17:046 (1) - shorten this by 1/1 beat than add a note at 00:20:172 I prefer how it is right now
00:27:672 (3) - if you're following the music shouldn't this be a single note and 00:27:984 (4,5) - should be move back by 1/4 beat? Nah, I love my type of mapping. And I use these alot. So I will keep it as it is. Then about the diff name. I dunno what to call it.
Selee
;)
Derekku
[General]
*mp3 sounds a bit strange (quality-wise). Starts out sounding great (perhaps 320kbps quality), but then for the rest of the song it's low and questionable. Can you try to find a higher bitrate (max of 256kbps) mp3 for this map?
*Are all of the tags really necessary? o-o;
*The ending spots for kiai could be more consistent throughout the difficulties. Right now they end at different spots or in the middle of spinners. =s
*180 offset sounds better, but if you find a new mp3 it won't matter. :c

[Easy]
00:16:422 (1) - expected this to be a lower volume (or gradually decreasing towards silence).

[Normal]
*Difficulty settings are a bit low. I suggest raising drain, overall difficulty, and approach rate one tick each.
00:17:047 - expected a note here
00:45:797 (1) - this is a bit too sudden for a Normal diff, so I suggest removing it.

[Hard]
00:23:088 (6,7,8,1) - (nazi) could you move 6,7,8 up and to the left a grid so that 8 doesn't overlap 1? Actually, do the same for 00:21:846 (1,2) too (since I thought they were a stream).
00:32:463 (1) - Fine as opposed to Normal's.
00:40:171 (1) - A bit short (even for hard).

[Insane]
00:39:130 (6,7) - Actually, I expected 6 to be the longer slider and 7 the shorter one o-o;

[Teras']
*Some evil streams near the beginning; mainly 00:15:588 (8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8), but orz
Topic Starter
roflninja

Derekku wrote:

[General]
*mp3 sounds a bit strange (quality-wise). Starts out sounding great (perhaps 320kbps quality), but then for the rest of the song it's low and questionable. Can you try to find a higher bitrate (max of 256kbps) mp3 for this map? Ill look into is then
*Are all of the tags really necessary? o-o; not really
*The ending spots for kiai could be more consistent throughout the difficulties. Right now they end at different spots or in the middle of spinners. =s ok
*180 offset sounds better, but if you find a new mp3 it won't matter. :c changed for now

[Easy]
00:16:422 (1) - expected this to be a lower volume (or gradually decreasing towards silence). gradually decreased

[Normal]
*Difficulty settings are a bit low. I suggest raising drain, overall difficulty, and approach rate one tick each. ok
00:17:047 - expected a note here added
00:45:797 (1) - this is a bit too sudden for a Normal diff, so I suggest removing it. changed to a slider

[Hard]
00:23:088 (6,7,8,1) - (nazi) could you move 6,7,8 up and to the left a grid so that 8 doesn't overlap 1? Actually, do the same for 00:21:846 (1,2) too (since I thought they were a stream). done
00:32:463 (1) - Fine as opposed to Normal's.
00:40:171 (1) - A bit short (even for hard). leaving this one for now

[Insane]
00:39:130 (6,7) - Actually, I expected 6 to be the longer slider and 7 the shorter one o-o; ill think about that one

[Teras']
*Some evil streams near the beginning; mainly 00:15:588 (8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8), but orz
Thanks for modding Derekku
Beuchi
Revived!!
Derekku
New mp3 offset: 205 (remember to resnap and all that)

Also, the video offset is a bit early. Try using 100 for each of the difficulties. (You can either adjust it roughly in the design tab or by manually editing the .osu files in notepad)
Shiro
Easy
00:16:455 (1) - There's no sound on this spinner too abruptly, try making a decrescendo.
Overall the diff play weirdly because every new combo has different rhythms, it makes the diff inconsistent.

Normal
00:02:496 (5) - This one might be too confusing for new players because of the number of repeats
00:17:288 (3) - This slow down doesn't really make sense, you should place a spinner here instead
00:57:913 (1,2) - Too confusing: the first slider has 3 repeats and the second one starts right after and is stacked, I suggest you don't use all 1/2s here
01:00:621 (3) - Same as 00:17:288 (3) -

Hard
This diff makes bad use of hitsounds. :/
00:17:288 (5) - See Normal's comment.
00:48:538 (5,6) - Make them symmetrical ? (see me ingame if you need help for it)
01:00:621 (4) - Same comment as for Normal, except that one makes a nice pattern with the other slider, so you shouldn't change it

Insane
00:06:038 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1) - This stream makes no sense according to the music. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/33155 this play a lot better and makes a lot more sense
00:10:204 (2,3) - Nothing justifies a jump here, make at least (2) and (3) symmetrical (remember to re-space (4) if you fix it)
00:16:038 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - Ok this stream makes sense but it doesn't play well, consider changing it ?
00:17:288 (2) - Same comment as for Normal and Hard
00:21:559 (9) - I don't understand this note :/ the pattern would play a lot better if it wasn't there, it makes things confusing
00:23:330 (5,6,7) - This hardly makes sense too... it would make more sense 1/2 later
00:24:580 (2,3,4,5) - These don't make sense either :/
00:28:538 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - This doesn't make sense according to the music at all
00:37:913 (2,3,4) - These jumps feels too sudden but it plays fine
00:47:913 (2,3,4) - these jumps make the spacing of (5) confusing
00:49:788 (1,2,3) - sudden, and the spacing of (1) becomes confusing
00:51:246 (2,3,4) - Too sudden

Teras'
Mind renaming this to Teras' Insane ?
Also it's overmapped. None of the streams make sense, the ones that could have made sense being wasted by unneeded notes that were added for the sake of having streams.
00:15:621 (8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This plays terribly bad: sharp angles on a 1/4 stream
00:23:225 (8,9,1) - This is not readable because of the hitburst from (7)
00:56:871 (7) - This slow down is way too sudden and unexpected considering how the whole diff played fast so far, and nothing in the song calls for such a slow down
01:11:246 (6,7,8) - nothing calls for these jumps, I consider it's a spacing error
01:27:288 (14) - Very confusing as well although not as unexpected as 00:56:871 (7)
Teras

Odaril wrote:

Teras'
Mind renaming this to Teras' Insane ? Nah
Also it's overmapped. None of the streams make sense, the ones that could have made sense being wasted by unneeded notes that were added for the sake of having streams. Since it's you modding i won't even take this comment seriously. Cuz from what i've seen in your posts. A lot of maps are overmapped huh.
00:15:621 (8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This plays terribly bad: sharp angles on a 1/4 stream Not really, not bad enough to make me change it.
00:23:225 (8,9,1) - This is not readable because of the hitburst from (7) Why can all the people i've watched play this not miss that note then?
00:56:871 (7) - This slow down is way too sudden and unexpected considering how the whole diff played fast so far, and nothing in the song calls for such a slow down Well, I do think something calls for a slow down here, thanks for your opinion though.. I'll keep that in mind if someone else complains.
01:11:246 (6,7,8) - nothing calls for these jumps, I consider it's a spacing error I suppose you're right, fixed.
01:27:288 (14) - Very confusing as well although not as unexpected as 00:56:871 (7)
Well, same answer for this as for the other slow down.

Thanks for your mod.

Download: Yui Horie - Hikari (TV Size) (roflninja) [Teras'].osu
DNR
Teras

Shit's overmapped.
DiamondCrash

CDFA wrote:

Teras

Shit's overmapped.
Teras
Ups, double post
Teras

DiamondCrash wrote:

CDFA wrote:

Teras

Shit's overmapped.
If you're saying it, give a proper reason. This makes no sense otherwise.

Also, saying this is overmapped is kinda lame. Have a look at the diff v2b made for an instant: http://osu.ppy.sh/s/12035
Jarby
Resnap your inherited sections on all difficulties, you seem to have forgotten.

Teras':

Overmapped Underhitsounded. Yeah, nothing is wrong with how you mapped it, but I find your usage of hitsounds to be particularly bland. Might want to use more than just the clap at the chorus, yeah.
00:40:204 (8) - This is an abomination of a slider. Try again without 21 red anchor points arranged in a misshapen zig-zag.
00:56:871 (7,1) - Increase spacing, that's confusing. It would help if the slowdowns were at around 75% as well.
01:26:246 (10) - New combo for great justice.

Normal:

00:13:121 (1,2,3) - Center these for bonus Jarby points.
00:16:246 (1,2) - This is not how we effectively use spacing. Distance snap, go.
00:52:496 (6,7) - These are not delicious. Please consult RandomJibberish's guide for delicious guidance.

Insane:

This difficulty is basically just a harder version of Hard, right? It's also far worse because of the poorly applied spacing changes and jumps. I don't think it's a good diea to keep this dead weight on your map.

Hard:

00:48:538 (5,6) - These are not delicious. Please consult RandomJibberish's guide for delicious guidance.
Topic Starter
roflninja

Jarby wrote:

Resnap your inherited sections on all difficulties, you seem to have forgotten.

Normal:

00:13:121 (1,2,3) - Center these for bonus Jarby points.
00:16:246 (1,2) - This is not how we effectively use spacing. Distance snap, go.
00:52:496 (6,7) - These are not delicious. Please consult RandomJibberish's guide for delicious guidance.

Insane:

This difficulty is basically just a harder version of Hard, right? It's also far worse because of the poorly applied spacing changes and jumps. I don't think it's a good diea to keep this dead weight on your map.

Hard:

00:48:538 (5,6) - These are not delicious. Please consult RandomJibberish's guide for delicious guidance.
all done, thanks Jarby
Teras

Jarby wrote:

Teras':

Overmapped Underhitsounded. Yeah, nothing is wrong with how you mapped it, but I find your usage of hitsounds to be particularly bland. Might want to use more than just the clap at the chorus, yeah. I do use other hitsounds, so I don't see the problem here. Although..yeah, I have absolutely no idea about what hitsounds I should use in the chorus.
00:40:204 (8) - This is an abomination of a slider. Try again without 21 red anchor points arranged in a misshapen zig-zag. Ugh, good point that. Fixing it
00:56:871 (7,1) - Increase spacing, that's confusing. It would help if the slowdowns were at around 75% as well. Fixed.
01:26:246 (10) - New combo for great justice. Done.
Ty for your mod. ><

Download: Yui Horie - Hikari (TV Size) (roflninja) [Teras'].osu
Sekai
:)
Sekai
._."
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply