Just because I am a BN who's mainly modding standard doesn't mean that I have no clue how taiko works. I may not be that great at it and confident to nominate taiko maps, but that still doesn't change the fact that I provided arguments that are sensible and are supported by logical statements. Every mod counts and my mod's priority isn't any lower than QAT's, taiko BN's or anyone else's in this thread.PatZar wrote:
i don't need to read your mods wafu, your mod is useless for me, i need taiko qats not you.
Genocide 2333-[ Dumpling ]- wrote:
I wanna commit Genocide on all your maps
yaWafu wrote:
There are few things I'd like to say before this gets to the Ranked section as I think it is not 100% ready.
[Oni]
[*]00:08:859 (44) - Is much more quiet than 00:08:663 (43) - 00:09:055 (45) - or 00:09:251 (46) - , removing it would highlight these three sounds instead and 1/1 spacing would be provided as these are needed in this kiai. I got the reason why... but still i want to emphasize the additional my own sound at 00:08:859 (42,44) -
[*]00:11:996 (64,65,66) - The middle note also seems to be off, 00:11:996 (64) - is a longer sound, so you might here it for a longer time, but doesn't give you any reason to map a sound that is not there on 00:12:094 - , you should remove the note as well. same as above, i still hear the 00:11:996 (62,63) - background sound that i can't ignore it, and if i delete the middle it will be a boring pattern in kiai 1/2 spam from 00:11:408 (59,64) - , and yes if i delete both, the sequence is jerk for me.
[*]00:16:114 (92,93,94) - This doesn't seem to be necessary. It's too quiet and a gap would give some rest after a difficult part of the map. I suggest to remove these, but keep 00:16:114 (92) - . the heck? the background heard clearly, why you still want to delete last both?, i want to get a bit climax at this last second kiai, to get more Flow here.
[*]01:02:388 (299,300,301,302) - This looks quite insensibly to me. There's no reasonable sound to follow on 01:02:486 - yet 01:02:682 - is completely ignored. I recommend you to remove 01:02:486 (300,301,302) - and add kkd on 01:02:584 - , which also flows better with the following 1/4 pattern. kkd is bad for me at this section, and i decided using dkk here.
[*]01:02:192 (298) - Just a little detail, can be ignored completely, but d sounds better to me. Probably depends on each person, but the pitch in music feels a bit deeper than for a kat, not important though. since i've changed 01:02:192 (293,297) - as k k , so i won't be a problem.
[*]01:05:918 (318,319,320,321,322,323,324) - As explained previously, spread issue. It's probably even harder than Inner Oni again. I'd recommend something simple like k ddkkd, which would involve removal of 01:06:016 (319) - , but that's only good, because there's no sound reasonable to follow behind it.
[*]01:19:055 (385) - This is same as 01:02:192 (298) - , as I said previously, feel free to ignore, this is just how I hear it. nope just nope
[*]01:19:741 (389) - No reasonable sound to follow again, you should remove it. it will be a boring pattern 1/2 spam here.. so keep
[/list]
[Muzukashii]Other diffs look fine to me. I don't like some rhythms on Kantan, but I guess they should be playable.
- I like the difficulty, there don't seem to be any insensibilities, but it's too friendly. The HP doesn't work at all. You are passing just after playing 1/3 of the map. Once you reach kiai, you don't have to play. This might be caused by HP drain settings or the kiai in the beginning. You should take a look on this or get a feedback from other people, but not playing for almost 1/3 of the map while stil passing it is quite edgy.
.
17:28 PatZar: hi
17:29 PatZar: do you up for mod?
17:29 ikin5050: uh
17:29 ikin5050: i guess
17:29 ikin5050: i finished school so i havae nothing to do
17:29 ikin5050: might as well
17:29 PatZar: gg in korean
17:29 PatZar: anonghaseo
17:29 *PatZar is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1299817 SAKURA*TRICK - Won(*3*)Chu KissMe! [TV Size]]
17:29 PatZar: mod this
17:29 PatZar: Lite Oni only
17:29 PatZar: tyty
17:30 ikin5050: ok
17:30 ikin5050: my vpn is only on korea btw
17:30 PatZar: wtf
17:30 ikin5050: im downloading now
17:30 ikin5050: ill do it right now aight
17:30 PatZar: korean vpn for porn?
17:31 PatZar: gimme some
17:31 ikin5050: nonononon
17:31 ikin5050: porn is blocked in korea
17:31 PatZar: rip
17:31 ikin5050: so i gotta switch to HK first at night ;)
17:31 ikin5050: china blocks everything though
17:31 ikin5050: and korea has good gaming servers
17:31 PatZar: so, actually where do you live
17:31 PatZar: lol
17:32 PatZar: the netherlands
17:33 ikin5050: i actually live in china now
17:33 ikin5050: used to live in netherlands
17:33 ikin5050: moved to shanghai
17:33 ikin5050: and moving to Glasgow for university aftersummer ;)
17:34 PatZar: china or hk?
17:34 PatZar: both are differnet :v
17:34 PatZar: im chinese anyway
17:34 ikin5050: live in china
17:34 PatZar: just can't speak mandarin, only sg mandarin
17:34 ikin5050: btw 00:03:172 have you tried smth like k ddk k d
17:34 ikin5050: in my mind it sounds better
17:34 ikin5050: i cant speak chinese either except for in taxi
17:35 PatZar: 00:03:761 (9) - deleted this
17:35 PatZar: according in Oni
17:35 PatZar: i want to sync it
17:35 ikin5050: 00:06:408 could add more notes like dddkkd to account for all the sounds, maybe not nessecary though
17:36 PatZar: wait, use oo:oo:oo -
17:36 PatZar: use strip
17:36 ikin5050: okay
17:36 PatZar: 00:06:408 (21) - since this is for Lite oni, that i want to make a bridge between muzu and oni, so it doens't look nessecary for adding like 1/4 stream
17:37 ikin5050: maybe you might want to change the doubles
17:37 PatZar: and deleted this 00:07:290 (26) -
17:37 ikin5050: cuz now theyre repetitive
17:37 ikin5050: 00:14:937 - this one is kinda un nessecary
17:37 PatZar: probably, i won't, since 00:06:408 (21,29) - are the same
17:37 PatZar: oke deleted
17:38 ikin5050: 00:33;369 - not sure why double, it doesnt play bad but i cant hear sound ;w;
17:39 PatZar: deleted the middle one
17:40 ikin5050: 00:38:074 - this sounds very much like kdddk to me, idk if you want to keep it like this its fine but if you make kdddk you might need to mvoe 00:37:682 2 ticks to the right
17:40 ikin5050: 00:42:780 - here and on 00:43:565 - youre missing clear drum sounds, i know youre following vocals but still
17:41 PatZar: yes it is, but since this is a Lite Oni, so it doesn't matter.. and sync with Oni
17:41 ikin5050: 00:50:231 - here i feel needs a note since drums indicate 1/4 stream, dont need to make stream but at least add note so 1/2 filled
17:41 PatZar: i thnk, they're not should be there,
17:42 PatZar: 00:50:231 - if i add it there, the sound should be good, but the consistency from 00:47:878 (184) - will broken
17:44 ikin5050: 00:53:957 - maybe move to 00:53:369 to have more emphasis on the big K
17:44 ikin5050: 01:11:212 - why is there no note here?
17:44 ikin5050: 01:27:682 - could be a note here
17:45 PatZar: 00:53:663 - i can clear no so additional sound here, and i think 1/2 kkdk is cool here since the sound is support for it too
17:45 ikin5050: why is sv 40.50?
17:45 PatZar: 01:11:212 (285) - added
17:45 PatZar: 01:27:682 - i think this is fine
17:46 PatZar: 40.50?
17:46 ikin5050: nvm my computer did something really weird
17:46 ikin5050: idk
17:46 PatZar: http://puu.sh/w1C9H/a7c214a935.jpg :v
17:46 PatZar: ok
17:46 ikin5050: it changed to sv 40.5 somehw
17:46 PatZar: oke hwhwhwahuehau
17:46 ikin5050: its quite good diff
17:46 ikin5050: idk why people need lite oni
17:46 ikin5050: but whatever
17:47 PatZar: muzu to oni is exteremly huge gap
17:47 PatZar: so i need one lite oni to make a bridge
17:47 PatZar: :v
17:47 PatZar: so that's all?
17:47 PatZar: you can post it and i will you kudasa
17:47 ikin5050: oh ok
17:47 ikin5050: yea thats all
17:47 ikin5050: i mean im not BN or anything but i dont see any other problem/potential thing
17:48 ikin5050: if you want to do a collab fun map sometime hmu
17:48 ikin5050: cuz i wanna map camellia
17:48 *PatZar is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/862338 Camellia - d:for the DELTA]
17:48 PatZar: wubwubwubwubwubwu
17:49 *ikin5050 is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/646688 Camellia - DARK THUNDER [Taiko Thunder]]
17:49 ikin5050: started this one already
17:49 *ikin5050 is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1023091 Camellia - Enantiomorphs [Optical Isomer]]
17:49 PatZar: it directs me to here
17:49 *PatZar is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/646688 D(ABE3) - MANIERA]
17:49 ikin5050: this one has cool last drop
17:49 *ikin5050 is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1035719 Camellia - DARK THUNDER [BLACK TEMPEST]]
17:50 PatZar: downloading both
17:50 ikin5050: ill post the chatlog when i come home from dinner
17:50 ikin5050: talk later
17:50 PatZar: oke
すべてフィクストthzz wrote:
as requested in-game :3
[Lite Oni]わからないことがあれば聞いてください。
00:03:761 (9) - remove.
00:03:565 (8) - K.
00:03:172 (5,6,7) - はドラムなので、ボーカルを拾う必要はないと思います。加えて00:03:565 (8) - に強いアクセントがあるため、これを強調すべきでは?- 00:29:055 (117) - D. シンバルがあり、加えて曲の境目でもあるので。
- 00:57:094 (225) - remove. 00:56:898 (224) - が強調されるべきなので、そのためにこのノーツは外すのがよいかと。また、曲に何の音も鳴っていないのも理由の一つです。
- 00:57:682 (226,227,228,229,230,231,232,233,234,235) - dkdkdkdkdk.....に違和感。00:58:467 (230,231) - をCtrl+Gなど、配色にバリエーションが欲しいです。
- 01:12:780 (295) - remove. 00:57:094 (225) -と同じ。
- 01:23:957 - ~ 01:25:329 - unrankedではないですが、念のため緑線を削除。
good luck
君のmodのありがとう!感謝しますCharlotte wrote:
日本語で大丈夫みたいなので日本語でやります。
[ about][ General]
- d is don note
- k is kat note
- D is big don note
- K is big kat note
[ Lite Oni]
ゲーム内でも指摘しましたが一応、全てVol100%から上手い具合に調節してください。 はい、すべてdiff80%volume
MuzukashiiからOniまでOD5なので、Oniを5.5に変えると良いでしょう。おけ。Good luck
00:04:545 (11,12,13,14) - このKiaiの偶数がkd ddで固定されてるので変化付けでkd dkも混ぜるとより良いです。
00:34:741 - 1/1 2連あるのが少し奇妙なのでここ埋める方が個人的に好みです。そう思うだ、しかし俺はほんとここ休憩したい
00:53:172 - dに変更、00:53:369 - k追加。00:53:761 - d追加。より流れが良くなります。すべてkに変更00:53:369 (206,207,208) -
00:58:270 - ここから1/4のddkに変更。Kiai timeなので長い1/2よりは良いかと。follow the vocal
01:08:663 - 01:09:839 - ここまでの1/1のどこかに1/2notesを入れてください。少し単調に感じます。
01:12:976 - ここからは2回目のKiaiの頭と同じなのでもう少し一貫性保った方が良いかもしれません。おけ、少し変更をパターン