forum

Muramasa - Swinging (TV Size) [Taiko|Osu]

posted
Total Posts
87
show more
Sallad4ever
Thanks :)
Don't trust the star rating >.<
Download: Sallad's Hard.rar
Please do a full submit cause I'm using a custom hitsound

Hope you like it :D
EDIT : please use the BG for my diff, you can use it for your diff too if you want :D
Topic Starter
roflninja
done, added that bg to one of my difs so the pics alternate :P
NaomiMinette
roflninja vs. :lol: FIGHT! xD lol (I just had to x.x), but anyway...

Blue = suggestions/minor issues
Green = might want to fix this
Red = you MUST fix this

[General]
Three Hard diffs o.o

[Normal]
00:28:606 (3) - I dunno... Maybe move this to a white tick forward? (Fix the spacing if you do.)
00:48:095 (4) - Might sound better if you made this end on a white tick.

[Hard]
01:07:983 (3) - Is this note really needed?
01:17:728 (1) - Lol, this doesn't end the same as Normal.

[Teras' Hard]
This feels like an Insane...

00:25:092 (7) - Did you really have to slow this down? :?

[Sallad's Hard]
Why is this the only diff with different combo colors?

01:17:808 (1) - Err... Shouldn't this end the same as Normal and Teras' Hard?

Nothing really to complain about. ★~
Topic Starter
roflninja

Blazevoir wrote:

roflninja vs. :lol: FIGHT! xD lol (I just had to x.x), but anyway... xD

Blue = suggestions/minor issues
Green = might want to fix this
Red = you MUST fix this

[General]
Three Hard diffs o.o they all vary in skill level

[Normal]
00:28:606 (3) - I dunno... Maybe move this to a white tick forward? (Fix the spacing if you do.) yeah, ok
00:48:095 (4) - Might sound better if you made this end on a white tick. I like this how it is

[Hard]
01:07:983 (3) - Is this note really needed? ture, deleted
01:17:728 (1) - Lol, this doesn't end the same as Normal. woops, my bad

[Teras' Hard]
This feels like an Insane...

00:25:092 (7) - Did you really have to slow this down? :?

[Sallad's Hard]
Why is this the only diff with different combo colors?

01:17:808 (1) - Err... Shouldn't this end the same as Normal and Teras' Hard?

Nothing really to complain about. ★~
Thanks Blaze

NaomiMinette
Rofl @ the attachment xD

And you're welcome :)
Sallad4ever

Blazevoir wrote:

[Sallad's Hard]
Why is this the only diff with different combo colors? First is because I like those color and it's fine because it didn't clash with video or the BG ;)

01:17:808 (1) - Err... Shouldn't this end the same as Normal and Teras' Hard? I actually end the spinner when the singer's voice start to fade out and beside I want it to end in that place :P
Thanks for your mod Blaze :)
Teras

Blazevoir wrote:

Blue = suggestions/minor issues
Green = might want to fix this
Red = you MUST fix this


[Teras' Hard]
This feels like an Insane... Really? I'll rename it to insane then so people don't come up with this later.

00:25:092 (7) - Did you really have to slow this down? :?Yes I did. :P
Roflninja just delete the other diff nao xD

Download: Muramasa - Swinging (TV Size) (roflninja) [Teras' Insane].osu
loser101_old
Normal
More like an Easy

Hard
More like a normal (have to fix it a bit)

Tera's Hard
This an Insane

Sallad's Hard
Great Hard
banvi
hi :D
Easy
01:04:709 (1) hwo about adjust this slider more symmetrical?
Hard
00:02:887 (7) 1 grid left & 1 grid down?
01:11:578 (2) 1 grid up?
Tera's
00:03:367 (6) 1 grid down?
00:03:846 (1) 1 grid up?
00:11:034 (1) remove new combo & 00:11:194 (2) new combo?
00:28:127 (7) 1 grid right & 2 grid down?
00:36:274 (4) 1 grid left?
00:37:712 (8) new combo?
00:45:220 (5,6) spacing
01:01:833 (6) 1 grid left?
01:05:986 (1) ^
01:08:383 (1) remove new combo?
01:12:217 (4) new combo?
01:13:654 (2,3) spacing
01:14:932 (2,3) ^
01:16:050 (4) new combo?
Sallad's
00:12:312 (6) 1 grid down & 1 grid right?
00:18:702 (3) 1 grid left?
00:28:606 (1) ^
01:04:709 (2,4) this silder sound is loud for me ;_;

overal nicemap ~star :)
Teras

banvi wrote:

hi :D

Tera's
00:03:367 (6) 1 grid down?
00:03:846 (1) 1 grid up?
00:11:034 (1) remove new combo & 00:11:194 (2) new combo?
00:28:127 (7) 1 grid right & 2 grid down?
00:36:274 (4) 1 grid left?
00:37:712 (8) new combo?
00:45:220 (5,6) spacing
01:01:833 (6) 1 grid left?
01:05:986 (1) ^
01:08:383 (1) remove new combo?
01:12:217 (4) new combo?
01:13:654 (2,3) spacing
01:14:932 (2,3) ^
01:16:050 (4) new combo?
Left most of the suggestions. But I fixed some of the combos, thanks. ^^

Download: Muramasa - Swinging (TV Size) (roflninja) [Teras' Insane].osu
Topic Starter
roflninja

banvi wrote:

hi :D
Easy
01:04:709 (1) hwo about adjust this slider more symmetrical?
Hard
00:02:887 (7) 1 grid left & 1 grid down?
01:11:578 (2) 1 grid up?
all done, thanks again banvi
Sallad4ever
Halo banvi :)
I appreciate the nazi but no change please

As for the sliders in 01:04:709 (2,4), good observation, I'm using an SB hitsound there, but I'm sure I make the volume same with the the other :)

Thanks for your mod banvi
Zetsubou Sensei
Hey! >.> maybe I shouldn't mod you maps xD

[Normal]
00:28:447 (x) - add a note here (sounds better with the beat)
01:07:264 (1) - shorten this spinner to end at 01:09:980?
01:17:488 (1) - extend this spinner to end at 01:20:523
Seems fine.

[Hard]
HP Drain Rate: -1
Overall Difficulty: -1
00:08:319 (x) - add a note here
00:20:459 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - move this back 1/4 tick and add a note at 00:20:859 (then remove the clap from 5 and put it on 6)
Seems fine.

[Teras' Insane]
00:40:907 (x) - add a note here
Seems fine.

[Sallad's Hard]
00:50:811 (x) - add a note here
Seems fine.

Overall...Lol this song is catchy. Its well done! Keep going!

~STAR + Kudosu STAR!! GOOD LUCK!
Topic Starter
roflninja

Zetsubou Sensei wrote:

Hey! >.> maybe I shouldn't mod you maps xD

[Normal]
00:28:447 (x) - add a note here (sounds better with the beat) done
01:07:264 (1) - shorten this spinner to end at 01:09:980? I'll think about that one
01:17:488 (1) - extend this spinner to end at 01:20:523 ok
Seems fine.

[Hard]
HP Drain Rate: -1 ok
Overall Difficulty: -1 I like this where it is
00:08:319 (x) - add a note here ok
00:20:459 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - move this back 1/4 tick and add a note at 00:20:859 (then remove the clap from 5 and put it on 6) moved back 2 ticks, but yeah, done
Seems fine.
Thanks for the mod
Sallad4ever
Added
Thanks for the mod Zetsubou :)
Download: Muramasa - Swinging (TV Size) (roflninja) [Sallad's Hard].osu

Be sure to delete the osb file and do a full-submit
Mashley
I'm not going to do a complete mod because the timing is wrong. It should be:
188 bpm
1,009 offset
Topic Starter
roflninja
done on all difs,
Teras, Sallad4ever : you might want to double check your notes, they should be fine though
Sallad4ever
Yup :)
Change the timing and adjust every timing section, here you go
Download: Muramasa - Swinging (TV Size) (roflninja) [Sallad's Hard].osu

Also, please add my name in the tags :(
Mapper 31
hi :)
May I make Taiko diff?
Mapper 31
Teras
Kay. Fixed the sections. And I didn't add a note at the place Zetsubo Sensei said. It sounds off to me then.

Download: Muramasa - Swinging (TV Size) (roflninja) [Teras' Insane].osu
Topic Starter
roflninja
samiljul: that was fast, added
Teras: updated, thanks
Leorda
Ahai

[General]
1) Your video dimensions is unrankable, maximum is 640x480 (current 704x396)
2) Your difficulty spread is N-I-I-I-(I). You need to delete one Insane difficulty. Last time, BAT was accident don't know if the map was 3 or more Insane, so you have to delete it, the BAT is already recover the memory
3) You need a easy difficulty so the new player enjoy this map

[Normal]
Overall Difficulty are too high

00:18:562 (3) - Remove whistle and add clap?
01:17:445 (1) - Silence this spinner??

[Hard]
01:12:498 (1,1) - Combine this into one?
01:17:604 (1) - This spinner are not silence correctly

[Teras' Insane]
00:01:966 (6) - Move 1 grid up?
00:51:115 (6,1,2,3) - Not stacked together

[Sallad's Hard]
Fine~

Not bad
STAR
Topic Starter
roflninja
Thanks Leorda, all done (I'll leave Teras' and Sallad's for them to fix up)
One of mine is a hard, and Sallads is a hard, I don't know what that "I" shit is about
I'll try to find another video then
Teras

Leorda wrote:

Ahai

[General]
2) Your difficulty spread is N-I-I-I-(I). You need to delete one Insane difficulty. Last time, BAT was accident don't know if the map was 3 or more Insane, so you have to delete it, the BAT is already recover the memory
Tell me. Why do mappers have ranked maps that have 3 I's then? My diff is counted as a insane. Sallad's hard is a hard, Roflninja's Hard is a hard. The I I I stuff doesn't decide how a map this. This is a TV Size.... which means that the amount of stars are in most cases FALSE. So you shouldn't base your judging of the diffs by looking at this really.
Also, the Normal diff is below 3 stars. So it meets the requirements for an easy diff.
James2250
Not going to get into the whole I I I debate, will let the BAT's decide that

I would make the final spinner end in the same place on every diff

Normal:
01:17:445 (1) - I would start at 01:17:604

Hard:
I say that the overall diff is too high for a hard
00:24:626 (3,4) - spacing?

Taiko:
fine to my limited knowledge

Teras' Isane:
looks nice

Sallad's Hard:
I would just make the kiai time like all the others seeing as the other 4 have it the same way but up to you

*star*
Topic Starter
roflninja

James2250 wrote:

Not going to get into the whole I I I debate, will let the BAT's decide that

I would make the final spinner end in the same place on every diff will look into it

Normal:
01:17:445 (1) - I would start at 01:17:604 ok, done

Hard:
I say that the overall diff is too high for a hard lower 1, this was mentioned before, but i liked it were it was
00:24:626 (3,4) - spacing? placed differently

Taiko:
fine to my limited knowledge

Teras' Isane:
looks nice

Sallad's Hard:
I would just make the kiai time like all the others seeing as the other 4 have it the same way but up to you i think it's fine, up to Sallad

*star*
Thanks for modding
Sallad4ever
Update some stuff
I like my kiai time so I won't change it :(
Thanks for the mod Leorda and James2250 :)

Download: Muramasa - Swinging (TV Size) (roflninja) [Sallad's Hard].osu
ShanaTan

Leorda wrote:

[General]
1) Your video dimensions is unrankable, maximum is 640x480 (current 704x396)
This is what it says on the Official Ranking Submission Criteria

Try to keep osz files under 10mb, or 20mb if you include video (please remove the audio track from video files to save space. It is recommended for the video's dimensions to not exceed 800x600.)

If I'm not interpreting that the wrong way it would seem that the maximum video dimension is not 640x480 but 800x600 =P

Gogo!
Topic Starter
roflninja
Thanks nekoo[], ill see if i can strip the audio without osu! hating the finished vid (last time i tried it started skipping frames)
ShanaTan
Here's the video without audio if you want it 10mb reduce, lol =P
http://www.mediafire.com/?f3kwd82p9413d69

Let me know if it's weird, anyways I'm off to bed, ciao.
Teras

Nekoo[] wrote:

Here's the video without audio if you want it 10mb reduce, lol =P
http://www.mediafire.com/?f3kwd82p9413d69

Let me know if it's weird, anyways I'm off to bed, ciao.
Good job. xD
Topic Starter
roflninja

Nekoo[] wrote:

Here's the video without audio if you want it 10mb reduce, lol =P
http://www.mediafire.com/?f3kwd82p9413d69

Let me know if it's weird, anyways I'm off to bed, ciao.
Thanks Nekoo[], vid works great :)
aRiskOfRain
Hard;

01:07:232 (2,3) - Spacing.

Concerned about the diff spread, but I believe that has been mentioned.
Topic Starter
roflninja

DiamondCrash wrote:

Hard;

01:07:232 (2,3) - Spacing.

Concerned about the diff spread, but I believe that has been mentioned.
fixed. the difficulty spread lies, don't beleive it. My hard could probably pass as a normal+ ...
thanks for modding
Muya
Sallad's Hard
00:28:615 - (1,2) 1grid right

Teara's Insane
good.

Hard
00:41:221 - (1) remove new combo
00:41:860 - (3) add new combo

Normal
00:23:349 - (1) remove new combo
00:33:881 - (1) 1grid up
EvianBubble
Hai thar. Started modding last night but got too tired, so ... yea :S My bad

Normal
00:28:774 (4) - Move one grid down
00:33:881 (1) - Move one grid up
01:17:604 (1) - How about gradually fading out the volume of this spinner instead of just cutting it off at the end?

Hard
How about lowering overall difficulty since it's just supposed to be "hard"? It's been mentioned before so I suppose you can keep it :S
Although I can't find anything technically wrong with this map, starting around 00:43:774 (1) it starts to become repetitive and not that interesting - a note every beat, slider a beat long / repeat, etc. until around 01:06:753 (6). How about following the lyrics or something, since it's the chorus and Kiai time, to make it more interesting and fun to play?
On a brighter note, I do like how you mapped from there until 01:09:626 (1) and your design between the spinners
Same suggestion on the final spinner as above as well

To my limited knowledge of really hard difficulties, the other two seem fine :S Sorry gaiz OTL

Regarding the difficulty spread, I do believe Normal could pass for an Easy+ (it didn't seem that hard to me), and Hard DOES seem in the hard - hard+ category, so I think it should be OK? :S

+1 star for you :)
Lizbeth
All good

I have a few suggestions for Teras's diff, no big deal, but i ll just post

00:18:402 (1) - shorten by 1/2 beat, then move to next white tick, and add circle at 00:18:402
00:58:455 (1) - remove new combo?
01:07:232 (2) - shorten by 1/2 beat, then move to next white tick, and add circle at 01:07:232

star!
AdRon Zh3Ro
Seems nice...
Teras
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply