Nwolf wrote:

I was made to look at Oni so two things:

02:20:608 (5,6,7,8,9,10) - Remove 1/4 idk why these are here, they kinda kill the impact of 02:22:790 (21,22,23,24,25,26) - Yeah I think I was going a bit too much for momentum rather than listening to the music. Changed it to just k k k
02:24:222 - Add don cause ^ Added don!
and then 02:29:336 (63,64,65,66,67,68) - these could be made 1/2 for the same reason I removed the first one but I'd like to keep the second ddk since it carries some momentum into the next section and feels good to play in with the 1/2 notes


idk if you wanna kd this or not, just things I noticed. Not a real mod

OzzyOzrock wrote:

@Lno Proper spread is a stupid rule? If you cannot respect what is the most important rule in taiko sets then you do not deserve a qualified map. Oni is no longer a diff where you can satisfy your mapping cravings, it is now the end of the map's base spread.

1. Remove bookmarks.

1. Don't have to set high HP since this song is long. maybe 5.0 is better?
2. 02:37:517 (42,43) - Beginner players might be confusing by this scroll changes. I recommend to delete 02:36:972 (41) -, and move 0.80x green line to 02:37:517.
3. 01:38:608 (4,5,6) - change to Ddd for making variety simple patterns. and (4,5,6) is lower pitch sound than (1,2,3).
4. 03:27:699 (4,5,6) - ^

1. difficulty spread between Futsuu and Muzu is bit big of a relatively than K-F. consider to add about 50~100 notes for making some 1/2 patterns.

1. 00:26:199 (40,41) - delete these notes for 2/1 break since Muzu needs 2/1 or 3/2 breaks. I think this part doesn't have it enough.
2. 00:34:927 (79,80) - ^

tasuke912 wrote:

Hi.
[ General]

1. Remove bookmarks.

The only bookmarks I have are the ones on the collab and I'd like to keep them there to show where the mapper changes
[ Kantan]

1. Don't have to set high HP since this song is long. maybe 5.0 is better? The reasoning was high bpm and a harder set but I'll side with you here, I like having the lower HP for the Kantan
2. 02:37:517 (42,43) - Beginner players might be confusing by this scroll changes. I recommend to delete 02:36:972 (41) -, and move 0.80x green line to 02:37:517. I agree, I wish I could have kept the note in there but no matter how I tried to work it it looked odd. Changed it all!
3. 01:38:608 (4,5,6) - change to Ddd for making variety simple patterns. and (4,5,6) is lower pitch sound than (1,2,3). I changed 01:36:427 (1,2,3) - to Ddd instead since I think that one sounds lower after a few tries of the Ddd on them both
4. 03:27:699 (4,5,6) - ^ Changed 03:25:517 (1,2,3) - to Ddd instead on this one too!

[ Futsuu]

1. difficulty spread between Futsuu and Muzu is bit big of a relatively than K-F. consider to add about 50~100 notes for making some 1/2 patterns.Added some more 1/2 patterns where they fit in with the other difficulties and changed a section so it matched another with the 1/2!

[ Muzukashii]

1. 00:26:199 (40,41) - delete these notes for 2/1 break since Muzu needs 2/1 or 3/2 breaks. I think this part doesn't have it enough.
2. 00:34:927 (79,80) - ^ Deleted the first two notes but only the second note on the second suggestion. I feel like 00:35:336 - is a really important beat to have mapped so I'd like to keep that one in there, but the break is still there!

You may call me back when you are done.

DakeDekaane wrote:

I'm really concerned at the varying note density and pattern difficulty in Oni. I get it's a collab, but the difference between both mappers is quite considerable in some sections and hurts the map. I'll put a few examples, but in general, the kiai is where this is more noticeable.
[notice]01:36:427 - vs 01:45:154 - You have to agree music barely changes its intensity, yet we have a noticeable density/difficulty change. Lno and I spoke for a bit and changed both of the kiai times a tad so that they are more consistent density-wise now with your suggestions in mind


Also, in Oni:
02:11:063 (58,59,60,61,62) - I have mixed feelings about this. First, this would work better as ddd K, the 1/2 pause will help the big note to have a stronger emphasis. I agree with it working better as ddd K so I made that change, the emphasis shows a lot better now!

But that won't be working with 02:15:495 (63,64,65,66,67) - . I listened to the parts at 02:11:063 (52,53,54,55) - and 02:15:495 (57,58,59,60) - a couple times over to see if there was a way to make them consistent but the drums here are played in two different ways so I think it's going to have to stay as is :c

Alternatively, I'd want to suggest to change them to normal notes as they're not really strong, up to you.. We talked it over a bit and think that the notes at 02:11:336 (55,56) - and 02:15:699 (60,61) - land on significant enough beats to warrant a finish so we'd like to keep them as K's

I hope we can reach an agreement soon and move the map forward. It's really good overall.

Thank you kindly for your mod and comments!