StarForYou wrote:

Hi M4M from facebook

[General]
Consider to regulate the BG from 1024x683 to 1024x768 ok

[Easy]
-Easy既Setting(Circle size/HP etc)用整數比較好, 我建議CS->3 ok
-Easy既Object應該要用同一個Distance, 即係應該用Distance Snap去Map Easy. (Check下AIMod =>http://puu.sh/oqlcb/d613379a4b.png)
checked
-其實Map Easy個Distance唔使咁細, 用1.10x既Distance已經幾好睇. 如果Stack住既話打落同睇落都唔係太好 => http://puu.sh/oqlwz/a9f5c227ee.jpg ok
-00:14:463 (2) - 一種Slider最好唔好放Easy到, 容易DQ+新手唔多識玩. 用翻d簡單既Slider會好d~! ok
-未Map完? o.o 打算整2:30唔知得唔得

[Normal]
-建議AR->5, OD->5, HP->4 ok
-Normal都係要用Distance Snap(所有Object應該要用同一個Distance) ok
-00:10:129 (1) - Cancel NC ok
-00:10:796 (2) - NC ok
-00:13:129 (1) - Cancel NC ok
-00:13:463 (2) - NC ok
-00:18:796 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - 太臃腫, 好難打同好難讀圖, 試下=>http://puu.sh/oqlOd/52e160b36c.jpg ok
-00:22:796 (1) - Cancel NC ok
-00:23:463 (2) - NORMAL千祈千祈唔好唔好用變速 ok
-00:45:129 (1) - Cancel NC ok
-00:45:796 (2) - NC ok
-注意下NC既時候 xdd ><
-00:59:463 (3) - 試下放左小小, 個Flow會舒服d ok
-01:35:129 (4) - 咁樣會唔會好睇d? w => http://puu.sh/oqmcd/2d8b0bc5ba.jpg ok
-01:43:463 (5) - 個尾唔​​係太明顯, 可能會Fake到新手, 依種Slider可能會好少少=>http://puu.sh/oqmeK/d7bde0c6c1.jpg fixed
-01:44:129 - 加個Note會好d, 有個好明顯既Downbeat ok
-02:26:463 (5,1) - Blanket ok
-02:28:462 (4) - 試試 => http://puu.sh/oqmzK/dff70a149d.jpg ok
-未Map完 xd 同樣想整2:30就算:P

[Hard]
-Normal同Hard既Gap好似太大 (? 應該唔影響rank吧..
-00:10:129 (1) - Cancel NC ok
-00:13:463 (1,2,3,4) - Hmm個Distance真係好怪, 放遠d會好d ok
-00:18:796 (1,2,1,2) - As well ok
-00:19:629 (1) - Cancel NC ok
-00:37:963 (1) - 放遠小小 ok
-01:04:796 (1) - Cancel NC fixed
-01:05:463 (1,2) - Blanket ok
-01:34:463 (5) - 個Rhythm唔同, 放遠d會易讀d ok
-01:35:129 (1,2) - , 01:36:629 (1,2,3) - ^ ok
-注意一下Spacing...好亂... 尤其是01:38:796 (1) - 到 01:48:796 (1) - ... fixed
-01:50:129 (2,3,4) - Distance好似大左小小 還可以啦
-02:30:796 (3,4,5,1,2,3,1) - 可能因為AR低, 所以都幾難讀 :< 試下唔好張d Note放埋一齊, 如果唔係會好難讀 fixed
-02:40:129 (3,5) - Blanket ok
-03:37:796 (1) - 放遠小小ok
-03:45:297 (4) - 放近小小 0.0ok
-04:05:796 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6) - 盡量令個Distance一致d會整潔好多ok

[Insane]
-00:03:463 (5) - 有變速最好加NC, 如果唔係Player唔知道就好易Slider break (其實我覺得0.5太慢, 0.75可能好d) 加了nc
-00:21:046 (1) - Cancel NC ok
-00:35:963 (1,2,3) - Hmm隔開d會好好多 ar9應該讀到的
-00:45:629 (1) - 放高少少睇落舒服d 問題不大
-00:52:796 (2,3) - 個Flow有點怪, 試下用其他方向既Slider代替依個 fixed
-00:55:129 (2,3) - 可以既話blanket佢 ok
-00:57:129 (6,1) - Blanket changed
-01:06:296 (5) - 好難讀...唔知係1/2定1/4, 不如Stack個Note同Slider? ok
-01:09:463 (1,2,3) - Blanket個01:09:296 (7) - 會好好睇 我覺得宜家都ok
-01:25:796 (1,2) - Blanket ^
-01:35:629 (2) - 放高少少個Flow會好多 fixed
-01:58:796 (1) - 個Wave Shape唔多好睇 => Try http://puu.sh/oqoPB/f7671e55f3.jpg fixed
-02:09:463 (7) - 放左少少Match翻個Slider尾既方向xd fixed
-02:16:129 (1) - 個Wave Shape唔多好睇 x 2, 參考下上面果個 fixed
-02:44:129 (1,2) - Blanket fixed
-03:59:463 (4) - 變速NC~ ok
-04:09:463 (7) - NC ok

[Expert]
-張圖好好玩<3, Test Play完好爽wwww
-00:08:796 (6,1) - 放遠d, 突然太近有少少怪 我諗問題不大
-00:12:629 (6,1) - 點解突然又咁遠? 放近少少~ fixed
-00:21:046 (1) - Cancel NC可以令Player知道個Rhythm既分佈 fixed
-00:21:713 (2,3,4) - Hmmm點解要變速? fixed
-00:28:295 (1) - 放遠少少易讀d 我覺得ar9.3讀到
-00:29:463 (1) - 放遠少少易讀d x 2^
-00:37:962 (2,3) - Blanket fixed
-00:45:463 (3,1,2,1,2,1,2,3,4,1,2,1,2) - NC有d亂, 建議只NC 00:45:463 (3) - fixed
-00:52:796 (6) - 放遠少少睇落舒服d 我想距離少少變化
-00:56:796 (1,2,1) - Cancel NC (? fixed
-00:59:796 (1) - and 01:00:963 (1) - Cancel NC and 01:01:463 (1) - NC 我覺得呢到問題不大
-Hmm 唔係好明你點樣放NC 0.0
-01:16:296 (5) - 你Insane有放NC但依個Diff冇bo 0.0 fixed
-01:59:796 (1) - 1.25~1.5已經好夠, 2.0太快... 改左做1.5
-03:02:463 (5) - NC, just like 01:49:128 (1) - ok
-Great Map

Good Luck With Your Map!

• [Expert]

1. 00:10:795 (1,2,3) - 這邊應該是2個1/2拍的NOTE不是3連打
2. 00:16:463 (1) - 不必要的NC
3. 00:18:796 (2) - NC在這會比較好
4. 00:52:629 (5,6) - 不覺得這邊有點難打嗎..
5. 01:08:295 (1,2,3,4) - 這連打應該到01:09:046 - 才結束
6. 01:12:129 (3,4) - 這邊可把blanket用的好點
7. 02:40:796 - 這邊應該擺NOTE而不是用sliderend
8. 大問題大概就這些

• [整體]

1. 把所有3/4滑條尾靜音, 因為那邊不該有音
2. 副歌的NC非常亂, 試著把NC擺在長白線根需要強調的地方
3. 03:52:129 - 這邊也可以擺kiai
4. 直線跳有點多呢, 在做圖的時候避免直線跳, 畢竟對玩家來說很難打, 而且也有不少mapper不喜歡, 一個例子:01:54:795 (4,5,6) -

SnowNiNo_ wrote:

From my queue

• [Expert]

1. 00:10:795 (1,2,3) - 這邊應該是2個1/2拍的NOTE不是3連打 fixed
2. 00:16:463 (1) - 不必要的NC fixed
3. 00:18:796 (2) - NC在這會比較好 fixed
4. 00:52:629 (5,6) - 不覺得這邊有點難打嗎.. fixed
5. 01:08:295 (1,2,3,4) - 這連打應該到01:09:046 - 才結束 我想強調01:08:796 (6) -
6. 01:12:129 (3,4) - 這邊可把blanket用的好點 no change
7. 02:40:796 - 這邊應該擺NOTE而不是用sliderend 我覺得改了會令人難以讀譜
8. 大問題大概就這些

• [整體]

1. 把所有3/4滑條尾靜音, 因為那邊不該有音 有些地方想刻意強調，如01:27:962 (6) -
2. 副歌的NC非常亂, 試著把NC擺在長白線根需要強調的地方 不把NC放左長白線是為了突出01:19:129 (1,2,3) - ，而且整段副歌的NC都有規侓地放，我想不會導致混淆的情況
3. 03:52:129 - 這邊也可以擺kiai no change
4. 直線跳有點多呢, 在做圖的時候避免直線跳, 畢竟對玩家來說很難打, 而且也有不少mapper不喜歡, 一個例子:01:54:795 (4,5,6) - 我覺得這樣會較有挑戰性

先這樣吧 畢竟NM而已
所以不摸太多 太花時間了XD XD

Expert

1. 00:01:129 (1) - Maybe move this slider back to 00:00:963 or even at 00:00:796 ? The slider feels too short and sudden.
2. 00:10:379 (2) - Ctrl + G perhaps.
3. 00:14:296 (5,6) - Ctrl + G these 2 together. The slider emphasizes the crash more than a note does, Maybe move the note some where else if you decide to Ctrl + G
4. 00:20:129 (2,3) - Same situation as above, the slider emphasizes the crash more than a note does.
5. 00:23:046 (4) - Ctrl + G here as well?
6. 00:28:796 (3,4) - Ctrl + G these 2 as well and move the note elsewhere.
7. 00:34:128 (3,4) - Same as above.
8. 00:45:296 (2) - Ctrl + G
9. 00:56:129 (1) - Could blanket better.
10. 01:07:046 (2) - Ctrl + G
11. 01:20:128 (1,2,3) - If you listen to this closely, you can hear 2 distinct kicks on notes 1 & 3, I totally think you should go about deleting the 2nd note on that triple and at 01:30:796 (1,2,3)
12. 01:40:462 (3) - Move the slider end so that its moving straight and away from 01:40:296 (2) - Looks cleaner.
13. 02:13:462 (1,2,3) - Similar to before, delete the 2nd note on this stack and on 02:18:796 (1,2,3) that stck.
14. 02:16:796 (4) - Ctrl + G this slider and stack it onto the head of 02:15:796 (5) this slider.
15. 02:17:462 (8) - Ctrl + G this slider and re-stack it and add a note at 02:17:713 . Now the reason for this and the suggestion above is because you can hear a distinct kick at 02:17:713 which is too loud to miss. It'll look a little something like this.
16. 02:40:379 (2) - Ctrl + G perhaps.

Ambient wrote:

G'day, from my queue.

Expert

1. 00:01:129 (1) - Maybe move this slider back to 00:00:963 or even at 00:00:796 ? The slider feels too short and sudden. fixed
2. 00:10:379 (2) - Ctrl + G perhaps. keep it
3. 00:14:296 (5,6) - Ctrl + G these 2 together. The slider emphasizes the crash more than a note does, Maybe move the note some where else if you decide to Ctrl + G fixed
4. 00:20:129 (2,3) - Same situation as above, the slider emphasizes the crash more than a note does.fixed
5. 00:23:046 (4) - Ctrl + G here as well? keep it
6. 00:28:796 (3,4) - Ctrl + G these 2 as well and move the note elsewhere. fixed
7. 00:34:128 (3,4) - Same as above. fixed
8. 00:45:296 (2) - Ctrl + G keep it
9. 00:56:129 (1) - Could blanket better.fixed
10. 01:07:046 (2) - Ctrl + Gkeep it
11. 01:20:128 (1,2,3) - If you listen to this closely, you can hear 2 distinct kicks on notes 1 & 3, I totally think you should go about deleting the 2nd note on that triple and at 01:30:796 (1,2,3)fixed
12. 01:40:462 (3) - Move the slider end so that its moving straight and away from 01:40:296 (2) - Looks cleaner. fixed
13. 02:13:462 (1,2,3) - Similar to before, delete the 2nd note on this stack and on 02:18:796 (1,2,3) that stck. fixed
14. 02:16:796 (4) - Ctrl + G this slider and stack it onto the head of 02:15:796 (5) this slider. I think it would be break the flow and there are not a big problem
15. 02:17:462 (8) - Ctrl + G this slider and re-stack it and add a note at 02:17:713 . Now the reason for this and the suggestion above is because you can hear a distinct kick at 02:17:713 which is too loud to miss. It'll look a little something like this.
    actually I want to avoid add note between the sliders , it is not smooth.
16. 02:40:379 (2) - Ctrl + G perhaps.keep it

I skimmed through the other diffs but couldn't find anything worth mentioning, Expert is super fun to play and should get there with a bit more polishing.
GL!

General

1. Disable letter box during breaks ?
2. Add "megpoid" in tags
3. move preview point to 01:16:796 -

Expert

1. Unsnapped note
2. Reduce OD
3. 00:45:129 (1) - remove nc
4. 01:12:129 (3) - move the first anchor point inside so it becomes more curved and then make blanket 01:12:629 (4) - should look like http://puu.sh/oO4P5/312935fb61.jpg
5. 01:12:629 (4) - add clap in middle
6. 01:15:463 - add clap
7. 01:49:045 (4,1) - since theres a jump between those , there should be jump between these also 01:49:378 (4,1) -
8. 02:01:129 (1) - remove nc
9. 02:23:046 (9) - move to 390,232 to make blanket with 02:22:796 (8) -
10. 02:31:129 (3,1,2) - i think u should remove nc , but if u really want nc then start it from (2)
11. 02:50:129 - missing clap
12. 03:02:713 (4,1) - make jump between these , same reason as above
13. 03:40:796 (6) - add nc

Insane

1. Disable widescreen support
2. 00:55:129 (2) - move it right to x:94
3. 00:58:463 (5) - missing clap
4. 01:20:463 (6,7) - they are too close ;w;
5. 01:25:796 (6,7) - nazi blanket
6. 01:35:463 - add clap
7. 01:35:796 - remove clap
8. 02:16:129 (1,3) - make proper blanket
9. 02:48:796 - missing clap

DeRandom Otaku wrote:

Hi ~ from my queue

General

1. Disable letter box during breaks ?
2. Add "megpoid" in tags
3. move preview point to 01:16:796 -

All fixed~

Expert

1. Unsnapped note fixed
2. Reduce OD I think 8.5 is fine
3. 00:45:129 (1) - remove nc fixed
4. 01:12:129 (3) - move the first anchor point inside so it becomes more curved and then make blanket 01:12:629 (4) - should look like http://puu.sh/oO4P5/312935fb61.jpg ok thx for detail
5. 01:12:629 (4) - add clap in middle fixed
6. 01:15:463 - add clap fixed
7. 01:49:045 (4,1) - since theres a jump between those , there should be jump between these also 01:49:378 (4,1) - I think it is fine
8. 02:01:129 (1) - remove nc since there are long distance, I think I should keep it
9. 02:23:046 (9) - move to 390,232 to make blanket with 02:22:796 (8) - I think it is not necessary
10. 02:31:129 (3,1,2) - i think u should remove nc , but if u really want nc then start it from (2) removed nc
11. 02:50:129 - missing clap fixed
12. 03:02:713 (4,1) - make jump between these , same reason as above no change
13. 03:40:796 (6) - add nc not necessary

Insane

1. Disable widescreen support fixed
2. 00:55:129 (2) - move it right to x:94 fixed
3. 00:58:463 (5) - missing clap fixed
4. 01:20:463 (6,7) - they are too close ;w; fixed
5. 01:25:796 (6,7) - nazi blanket wat
6. 01:35:463 - add clap fixed
7. 01:35:796 - remove clap fixed
8. 02:16:129 (1,3) - make proper blanket fixed
9. 02:48:796 - missing clap fixed

Thats all from me ~ GL

Ayyri wrote:

Hello~

NM. from Bow Queue

Keep in mind, these are my suggestions, don't change something I mentioned unless it seems good to you!

If I didn't make a box for something, that doesn't mean I didn't look at it. It just means I didn't find anything wrong with it.

Easy

00:11:963 (2) - This note comes too early. Move to 00:12:129 - no change because it will break the flow
00:30:629 (2) - ^ Move to 00:30:796 - fixed
00:33:296 (1) - This note comes too late. Move to 00:33:129 -
After you move 00:33:129 (1) - Move 00:33:129 (1,2) - further apart since the distance between them was widened. fixed
00:35:963 (4) - This note comes too late. Move to 00:35:796 - and extend it to end at 00:36:796 - keep it same reason as above
00:38:629 (2) - ^ Move to 00:38:463 - and extend to end at 00:39:463 - fixed
01:07:963 (2) - This note comes too late. Move to 01:07:796 - and extend to end at 01:08:796 - fixed
01:10:629 (2) - ^ Move to 01:10:463 - and extend to end at 01:11:463 - fixed

Hard

00:00:796 (1) - Have the spinner end at 00:02:463 - to allow a newer player to be able to hit the first note more easily.fixed

Insane

00:06:629 (2) - NC. SV change.
00:11:963 (2) - ^
00:17:296 (2) - ^
I think the music are clearly remind player SV changed
00:22:129 (2) - ^
00:22:796 (5) - ^
fixed
01:07:463 (2) - ^
01:10:129 (3) - ^
03:56:296 (3) - ^
03:57:629 (3) - ^
03:59:463 (4) - ^
04:00:796 (5) - ^
actually I think suddenly NC is ugly and I think it is not necessary

Expert

00:22:129 (4) - NC. SV change. fixed
00:22:796 (3) - ^ no change
00:23:463 (1) - Add normal whistle to the slider slide. fixed
00:24:796 (4) - NC. SV change. fixed
00:30:129 (4) - ^ fixed
01:58:462 (3) - ^ fixed
03:25:463 (2) - ^ no change
03:37:296 (7) - ^fixed

I remember mapping this song.

1. Your way of putting combos is kinda inconsistent, I can see you doing an NC on every 2 downbeats but in some places you didn't, so I'm kinda curious for the reason here.
2. 00:37:463 (1,2) - 01:20:129 (1,2) - 04:01:463 (2,3) - Blanket can be improved here.
3. 00:40:129 (1,2) - Sounds better as 3 1/1 sliders.
4. 00:42:463 - Feels off for not having anything here, you can make either a circle here or a slider from 00:42:129 (3) to express the drum roll sound.
5. 00:45:463 - Finish sounds good here, actually I think these downbeats 00:45:463 - 00:48:129 - 00:50:796 should be clickable.
6. 00:53:463 - I don't hear any cymbal sound so I think just a whistle is enough.
7. 00:58:796 - In music sense, downbeat shouldn't be skipped.
8. 01:49:463 - 02:48:129 - 03:33:463 - These should be clickable with the same reasoning as before and a finish can be added here.
9. 02:18:796 (1,2) - This would sound better if 02:19:463 (2) starts on 02:19:129 because that way it can capture vocals properly.
10. 02:52:129 (1) - Guitar is starting to build up here so I prefer a denser rhythm.
11. 02:54:796 - 02:58:796 - Should be clickable.
12. 03:28:463 (1) - 03:52:129 (1) - In Easy you need at least 4 white ticks to be left empty to be considered rankable, and also because players in this level will have a sufficient recovery time after spinning.
13. 03:36:129 (2,3) - Try not to put 1/2 rhythm in Easy, especially with 180 bpm.
14. 03:57:463 - 03:58:796 - These should be clickable so they can capture vocals properly.
15. 04:20:129 - Would be nice if you can use a lower volume for spinner's end.

Electoz wrote:

Hi

[Easy]

1. Your way of putting combos is kinda inconsistent, I can see you doing an NC on every 2 downbeats but in some places you didn't, so I'm kinda curious for the reason here. fixed some NC problem. I think it is my silly mistake since I am not good at mapping lower diff.
2. 00:37:463 (1,2) - 01:20:129 (1,2) - 04:01:463 (2,3) - Blanket can be improved here.
3. 00:40:129 (1,2) - Sounds better as 3 1/1 sliders.
4. 00:42:463 - Feels off for not having anything here, you can make either a circle here or a slider from 00:42:129 (3) to express the drum roll sound.
5. 00:45:463 - Finish sounds good here, actually I think these downbeats 00:45:463 - 00:48:129 - 00:50:796 should be clickable.
6. 00:53:463 - I don't hear any cymbal sound so I think just a whistle is enough.
7. 00:58:796 - In music sense, downbeat shouldn't be skipped.
8. 01:49:463 - 02:48:129 - 03:33:463 - These should be clickable with the same reasoning as before and a finish can be added here.
9. 02:18:796 (1,2) - This would sound better if 02:19:463 (2) starts on 02:19:129 because that way it can capture vocals properly.
10. 02:52:129 (1) - Guitar is starting to build up here so I prefer a denser rhythm.
11. 02:54:796 - 02:58:796 - Should be clickable.
12. 03:28:463 (1) - 03:52:129 (1) - In Easy you need at least 4 white ticks to be left empty to be considered rankable, and also because players in this level will have a sufficient recovery time after spinning.
13. 03:36:129 (2,3) - Try not to put 1/2 rhythm in Easy, especially with 180 bpm.
14. 03:57:463 - 03:58:796 - These should be clickable so they can capture vocals properly.
15. 04:20:129 - Would be nice if you can use a lower volume for spinner's end.
    All fixed, thank you so much for remind downbeat problem.

Sorry but I think I used too much energy so I guess I'll stop here lol, maybe I'll continue other diffs later and hope this helps~

Hou Rearu wrote:

from queue

General

1. sometimes flow direction changes way all of sudden,but I guess it is okay

Expert

1. 00:13:463 (1,2) - stack these, or avoid stack here 00:13:796 (3,4) - I think it is fine
2. 00:16:796 (1) - CTRL+G may be? I think it is not smooth
3. 00:23:296 (5) - just circle instead I do slider here since it's expert diff, I would prefer harder pattern.
4. 00:26:795 (1) - note miss, at red tick I don't want to follow it and there are obvious rhythm changed
5. 00:32:129 (1) - ^ ^
6. 00:44:796 (6,1) - avoid this overlap, or somehow change 6, kind of weird tbh. fixed
7. 00:51:129 (3) - ctrl+g and then decrease spacing on 2 next no change
8. 00:53:463 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - remake this part, by making vocals with sliders, I mean sliders instead of circles and backwards what wrong there ?
9. 00:55:129 (1,2,3,4) - just my opinion, they are f*cking worst, during playthrough As I said before... I prefer tricky pattern
10. 01:04:129 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3) - hard to read may be? remove stacking 4,5 may be? changed other pattern
11. 01:05:963 - notemiss It is not obvious so I should stress the drum beat
12. 01:05:463 (1) - sure endcircle wants be clickable, so stong not huh I think it's fine
13. 01:48:795 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - does this spacing between 4.1 makes any sense? really It is make sense imo
14. 01:55:629 - notemiss I want to follow the vocal instead of the rhythm
15. 02:00:129 - 02:05:463 - make spacing more consistant for this calm part, no reason for big jumops here. The inspiration from arcwinolivirus's coma and it's expert diff so I think it appropriate.
16. 02:40:629 (3) - 2 circles instead I want to keep it because three sliders seems more smooth
17. 02:53:463 (1,2,3) - doesn't really suits music tbh I think it is fine
18. 02:56:463 (3,1,2,3,4,5) - awkward flow tho I think it is fine
19. 03:02:129 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - Does it even make sense? i mean stream ends aactually at 2, may be make it same way as on insane? I think it is fine
20. 03:17:796 (6) - slider end wants be clickable But 03:17:963 - is no any rhythm so I think a long slider is appropriate
21. 03:20:463 (4) - ^ fixed
22. 03:21:463 (2) - ^ fixed
23. 03:27:463 (1,2) - move them above 03:27:129 (2) - to have smth like oval flow no change
24. 03:39:963 (5) - doesn't really make sense. something wrong? I don't get your question
25. 03:40:129 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6) - may be make in a bit different way with gradual increasing of spacing, and make sure it doesn't rise above the first one, sounds as shit, but i thing way more comfortable if you get what i mean and try it. I think it is good enough
26. 03:47:297 (2,3,4,5,6) - sliders with doubles at each edges are actually hell, I'd avoid it really I think it is fine
27. I guess ending would be more suitable if it will be gradual decrease spacing and SV since 04:13:463 - to 04:20:129 - , it doesn't really make sense later I think pattern change would solve the problem so I will consider your point

can't mod more for now and this one isn't really good, cuz i am lack of time now, but i had at least to start, I'll mod the rest diff in a few days
P.S i was about to say, oh, you are going to map full version of map you have mapped short and thats nice, but u aren't? it is just another Hikari with ranked COMA o_O what a coincidence

Crimmi wrote:

Thank you for applying at the #modreqsea! Feel free to ignore or reject any parts of this mod that you deem unfit and vice versa.

General (Metadata, Timing, etc.)

_________________________________________________________

1. Your BG "bg" is a bit misleading in the sense that it shows only "ensou" as the artist which contradicts with your current artist placement which is "ensou feat. GUMI." Use this alternate BG provided here to avoid that. (It's only 2px off so be sure to adjust it) But I found two ranked map they are using same title and bg so I think it is fine and I like my BG I think no more picture better than it so I want to keep it.
2. Why is there kiai in the beginning of Hard, Insane & Expert but omitted from Easy and Normal? fixed

Easy

1. 01:18:453 (2,3) - Perhaps you can properly blanket (3) here, plus the spacing is a bit weird so double check that if you can~ fixed
2. 01:28:119 (4,1) - This blanket could be a bit neater around the slider end of (4).fixed
3. 01:41:453 (5) - New Combo.fixed
4. 01:49:453 (1) - Add a finish?fixed
5. 02:24:129 (1) - Move this to x:388|y:176 to properly fix that blanket.fixed
6. 03:02:463 (6,7,1) - Suggestion.changed to your suggestion

Normal

1. 00:24:629 ~ 00:45:129 - There are some hitsounds missing in this time frame, perhaps you forgot to hitsound them? fixed, thx for your reminding~
2. 01:02:129 (2,3,4) - Suggestion.fixed
3. 01:07:963 (1) - Listening to this, I think it'll sound better if it was stretched to the red tick, following the drums as it starts better on the white tick like this -----> *click* fixed
4. 03:37:796 (1,2) - I think you should double check this section since the flow is a bit awkward, making the player going down a curved slider towards and slider curving upwards. changed to other pattern

Hard

1. 02:28:463 (1) - Remove this finish since there's nothing supporting it there. fixed
2. 03:15:963 (3) - Suggestion.fixed

The higher diffs are okay in my eyes, but the lower difficulties need some aesthetic polish.

GL~

Kinshara wrote:

Hi! M4M from my queue! [Long map x_x Hope it's okay if I just mod expert & insane! D:]

Expert

1. Try getting a better quality bg for your mapset [ask ringating for help, if necessary] fixed
2. Try adding a silent slider slide to cancel out the rough slider noise. Add this file to your folder: http://puu.sh/pgICH/f8eec177a3.wav fixed.thx for providing hitsound
3. 00:05:795 (2,3) - If you ctrl+G these two, you will get a nice circular flow... but you should probably move 00:06:129 (1) - closer. Maybe a pattern kinda like this: http://puu.sh/pgJdW/1239fe8a79.jpg I changed 2 3 but keep the distance because I think it is fine in expert diff
4. 00:14:629 (2,3,4,5,6) - this direct back and forth pattern is very choppy and almost uncomfortable to play. Try a different pattern here? I want to keep it because I prefer some tricky patterns.
5. 00:15:712 (2,1) - These two overlap a little unappealingly. Maybe move 1 so that it stacks with 00:16:463 (3) - deleted 00:15:713 (2) -
6. 00:32:129 (1) - Consider this rhythm so you can catch the bass at 00:32:296 - : http://puu.sh/pgJWT/a03b5f551f.jpg I think it is fine
7. 00:44:796 (6,1) - Although slider leniency is convenient, this kind of still is a really big jump. I would suggest moving the stream a little closer fixed
8. 01:12:629 (4) - Try this rhythm so you can have the snare on a slider head (which provides more emphasis since players can click the slider head but not the slider end): http://puu.sh/pgK7j/b753466f45.jpg similarly here as well 01:13:963 (2) - all fixed
9. 01:28:796 (4,5) - Banket 4 around 5 a little better? I think it is fine
10. 01:48:795 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - While this type of pattern is cool (and you see it a lot in maps nowadays), it's a little too gimmicky and difficult for this map (and doesn't quite fit tbh). You can still separate the two streams but bring them closer: http://puu.sh/pgKoe/48bdb31509.jpg similarly here 03:02:129 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - all fixed
11. 02:42:796 - You can make this section a lot more interesting by manipulating slider velocity... like you can slow the sv down in areas such as 02:42:796 - 02:44:796 - 02:47:463 - etc etc. and increase the sv in areas like 02:44:129 - 02:45:129 - etc etc. (sv changes are beautiful in the eye of the beholder, so manipulate it how you like, this is just a suggestion) It is good suggestion, I will consider about this
12. 02:43:129 (2,3,4) - you could try a pattern like this here: http://puu.sh/pgKIo/d14767fe33.jpg I think it is fine
13. 03:20:796 (5,7) - blanket 7 around 5 a little better? ok

Insane

1. 00:09:463 (1,2,3,1) - It's recommended that you don't cover up slider repeats with previous objects (chance that players won't see it). You should either move this slider away or try a different rhythm/ placement. I think it is readable
2. 00:14:296 (1) - instead of creating a new slider here, why not copy, paste + ctrl+G this slider: 00:13:796 (2) - . It'll make it neater. fixed
3. hmm, some NC suggestions - In hard/insane/extra difficulties, it is usually recommended to start NCs every major white tick. So... start a NC at 00:44:129 (5) - 00:48:129 (7) - 00:52:129 (4) - etc. etc. I will check it but some places I want to keep for emphasis the rhythm
4. 01:28:129 (1) - Ctrl+G this slider for better circular flow (and then move it a little farther away for distance) 01:28:796 (4) - 01:35:796 (3) - 02:30:463 (3) - 02:43:463 (3) - 02:52:129 (1,3) - these too[these are just suggestions] probably no change
5. 01:44:463 (1,3) - you can do a better pattern here...considering the kind of patterns you use...how about something like this: http://puu.sh/pjtrK/d7ca931d90.jpg changed in my way, thx for suggestions
6. 02:54:129 (3,1) - blanket kinda like so - http://puu.sh/pjtCd/f56a93d3f8.jpg fixed
7. 03:51:463 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - try a pattern like this for the streams (it'll be better to play too imo) - http://puu.sh/pjtIo/4bd8dc8767.jpg no change because I want distance for reading
8. 04:12:296 (2,3) - i would ctrl+G for better flow towards the stream fixed

Insane is pretty good! I think the major problem in your extra/ insane is you are very erratic with your beat placement. Try to place your objects in such a way as to emphasize stronger ones (possibly by increasing the distance). Erratic placement can also make the map more difficulty/ annoying to play.

Good luck!

Hope this mod was useful!

Lucyyyyyyy wrote:

Sorry for my english xD
but lets start with the mod for the expert difficulty:

1. 00:00:960 (1) i would not start with a Spinner, in my opinion its really anyoing after retrrying the map serveral times.
I think it is fine
2. 01:38:796 (1) i would not start a new combo
why
3. 01:39:797 (3) i would do a curved slider
nothing wrong here
4. 01:49:046 (4,1) rly change this there is a small space between 4,1 it rly is bad to play (how i would change it, before: http://puu.sh/pEtYf/1e569b84e8.jpg , after: http://puu.sh/pEu4G/8cebc68170.jpg)
It is readable and playable, at least I can play it.
5. 02:00:129 () - 02:10:796 () just optional: because it is a slowed down section (the voice) i would do smaller jumps aswell, its kinda helping the player to take a little breath.
no change
6. 02:40:129 (1,2,3) i would do a smaller jump after each slider end its a bit hard to jump that far after the slider like this for example: http://puu.sh/pEukM/451405095f.jpg
ok, fixed a bit
7. 03:02:379 (6,1) same then 4. remove this little gab.
no change
8. 03:04:046 (4,1) move 1 a little but away its rly hard to see.
I think it is fine
9. 03:38:796 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) You really need to get smaller jumps here its just 1/4 between those it is to hard to play in my opinion (compared to the rest of this map
please this pattern is common in expert
10. 4:02:129 (1,2,3,4,5,1) same here
no change
The rest is really beatifull made good job

yoshiFTW69 wrote:

Expert:

00:47:463 (1) - I feel this shouldn't be a new combo
03:40:379 (1) - I don't think this should be a new combo
03:40:796 (6) - Then this should be a new combo

Insane:

00:25:963 (1) - No new combo
00:31:296 (1) - Here too
03:51:463 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I think one more note to this stream will sound better at 03:52:046

Hard:

01:32:463 (4) - I think this slider should stop at 01:32:796 It sound weird
02:25:796 (4) - this too, increase to 02:26:129 ^
03:49:963 (3) - this reverse slider should be changed to one full slider I feel weird if I change it

Normal:

01:06:796 (2) - This should be the new combo, not 01:07:796 (1) - or 01:06:129 (1) -
03:04:129 (6) - new combo

Easy:

------


Great map!

1. For some reason, your combo colors are inconsistent. Make them consistent across your difficulties, please.
2. Your Expert has higher HP drain than the Insane. Both are rather high and I suggest you lower the Insane by a good amount.

1. 00:00:963 (1) - The sound you are mapping this spinner to starts at 00:00:629 instead. Also, drag it to the red tick since where it cuts off seems kind of random.
2. 00:03:796 (2,3,4,1,2,3) - Spacing should be larger between these two triples to emphasize the downbeat like you did at 00:09:128 (2,3,4,1,2,3)
3. 00:12:795 (1,2,3,4,5) - Spacing should be increased slightly here to represent the intensity of the entrance of the percussion sounds.
4. 00:15:629 - You're ignoring a kick here that the slider should end on instead of completely pass over.
5. 00:21:046 (6,7,8,9,10) - Either have a change in spacing here or keep it 100% consistent. What you have currently is a slight change that doesn't affect it in terms of playability but simply makes it look sloppy.
6. 00:33:628 (1,2) - Since these are two totally different sounds (kick and snare), I highly recommend spacing them as opposed to stacking them to represent that.
7. 01:02:129 (7,1) - This feels really awkward being stacked. I get why you have a gap in the timeline but playability wise I highly recommend not stacking these due to how awkward it feels for no reason. It's not an awkward part in the song and thus shouldn't play awkward.
8. 01:05:963 - Here is another vocal and percussion sound that you ignore by having a slider that is simply too long.
9. 01:07:379 - There is no sound on this tick, so the triple here is overmapped. Delete the note on this tick and reposition objects accordingly.
10. 01:09:129 (1) - The slider velocity for this feels really high considering that nothing particularly intense happens here.
11. 01:13:963 (2,3) - Same as the point I mentioned earlier. I recommend not stacking these two.
12. 01:24:379 - Since you're mapping to the percussion, you shouldn't ignore the kick that occurs on this tick.
13. 01:28:129 (1,2,3,4,5) - The spacing of these objects feels rather low and underwhelming in comparison to the rest of this kiai time. I recommend increasing it a tad.
14. 01:33:129 (4,1) - You should have a break in flow here to better represent that this is a 1/1 gap and not a 1/2 gap.
15. 01:35:796 (4,5) - Spacing should be larger here considering you have a finish hitsound which is meant for intense moments.
16. 01:46:795 (4) - If you want to keep consistent with the pattern you have going, you should NC here, especailly considering it's a downbeat as well.
17. 01:48:379 - Since you're mapping to percussion, don't ignore this kick on this tick.
18. 01:52:546 - Another overmap. Delete the note on this tick since it is literally mapped to nothing.
19. 01:54:963 (5,6,7,1) - This pattern plays extremely awkwardly. For one, your 1/1 gap has the same spacing as the 1/2 gap, and overall it just doesn't play well. Consider swapping the positions of 01:55:795 (1,2) on the timeline.
20. 01:59:462 (3,4,5) - What happened to the hitsounds on this triple?
21. 02:17:713 - Another kick you ignored.
22. 02:31:463 (5) - You should NC here so you don't have such a massive combo.
23. 02:58:629 (4,1,2,3) - This circle doesn't flow into the triple very well. Consider flipping the triple across the horizontal axis and positioning it accordingly.
24. 03:01:463 (1,2) - For the climax of the guitar solo, your spacing here is very underwhelming. Consider greatly increasing it.
25. 03:46:297 (3,4,1) - I recommend having a break in flow here to better represent the difference between the 1/2 and 1/1 gaps.
26. 04:07:296 (4,5,6,7) - Pretty underwhelming spacing considering this is the climax of the entire song.

Smoothie World wrote:

[General]

1. For some reason, your combo colors are inconsistent. Make them consistent across your difficulties, please.
2. Your Expert has higher HP drain than the Insane. Both are rather high and I suggest you lower the Insane by a good amount.

[Expert]

1. 00:00:963 (1) - The sound you are mapping this spinner to starts at 00:00:629 instead. Also, drag it to the red tick since where it cuts off seems kind of random.
2. 00:03:796 (2,3,4,1,2,3) - Spacing should be larger between these two triples to emphasize the downbeat like you did at 00:09:128 (2,3,4,1,2,3) but this pattern play comfortable to me
3. 00:12:795 (1,2,3,4,5) - Spacing should be increased slightly here to represent the intensity of the entrance of the percussion sounds. I tried it but feel weird and it's not necessary, so I would keep it.
4. 00:15:629 - You're ignoring a kick here that the slider should end on instead of completely pass over. I know but it is not a problem.
5. 00:21:046 (6,7,8,9,10) - Either have a change in spacing here or keep it 100% consistent. What you have currently is a slight change that doesn't affect it in terms of playability but simply makes it look sloppy. that's fine to me
6. 00:33:628 (1,2) - Since these are two totally different sounds (kick and snare), I highly recommend spacing them as opposed to stacking them to represent that. I want to mix the Cyrus and mania rhythms in this map.
7. 01:02:129 (7,1) - This feels really awkward being stacked. I get why you have a gap in the timeline but playability wise I highly recommend not stacking these due to how awkward it feels for no reason. It's not an awkward part in the song and thus shouldn't play awkward. but I feel stacking is better.
8. 01:05:963 - Here is another vocal and percussion sound that you ignore by having a slider that is simply too long. actually I want to emphasize the vocal at 01:05:463 -
9. 01:07:379 - There is no sound on this tick, so the triple here is overmapped. Delete the note on this tick and reposition objects accordingly. I want to keep continuous, and it sound no any problem.
10. 01:09:129 (1) - The slider velocity for this feels really high considering that nothing particularly intense happens here. I just want to make a intense happen here
11. 01:13:963 (2,3) - Same as the point I mentioned earlier. I recommend not stacking these two. same as the point I mentioned earlier, no change here
12. 01:24:379 - Since you're mapping to the percussion, you shouldn't ignore the kick that occurs on this tick. add note here will be weird when playing, and ignore the kick wouldn't make any errors
13. 01:28:129 (1,2,3,4,5) - The spacing of these objects feels rather low and underwhelming in comparison to the rest of this kiai time. I recommend increasing it a tad. I don't feel anything here...
14. 01:33:129 (4,1) - You should have a break in flow here to better represent that this is a 1/1 gap and not a 1/2 gap. why...? 1/2 gap sound batter
15. 01:35:796 (4,5) - Spacing should be larger here considering you have a finish hitsound which is meant for intense moments. I add note at 01:36:462 - because I don't want to start at red line.
16. 01:46:795 (4) - If you want to keep consistent with the pattern you have going, you should NC here, especailly considering it's a downbeat as well. I don't want to add so much nc because it is ugly, I would avoid this
17. 01:48:379 - Since you're mapping to percussion, don't ignore this kick on this tick. I should emphasize 01:48:129 (1) - and 01:48:463 (2) -
18. 01:52:546 - Another overmap. Delete the note on this tick since it is literally mapped to nothing.
19. 01:54:963 (5,6,7,1) - This pattern plays extremely awkwardly. For one, your 1/1 gap has the same spacing as the 1/2 gap, and overall it just doesn't play well. Consider swapping the positions of 01:55:795 (1,2) on the timeline. I like straight jump.
20. 01:59:462 (3,4,5) - What happened to the hitsounds on this triple? not sure what you mean actually, but I changed the hitsounds
21. 02:17:713 - Another kick you ignored. no change
22. 02:31:463 (5) - You should NC here so you don't have such a massive combo. actually I was nc at 02:31:296 - but it seems weird
23. 02:58:629 (4,1,2,3) - This circle doesn't flow into the triple very well. Consider flipping the triple across the horizontal axis and positioning it accordingly. I am lazy too make a new pattern.. I tried so many pattern in this place, this is the best pattern I map so far, maybe change it when I have new idea
24. 03:01:463 (1,2) - For the climax of the guitar solo, your spacing here is very underwhelming. Consider greatly increasing it. The rhythm are obvious being down here
25. 03:46:297 (3,4,1) - I recommend having a break in flow here to better represent the difference between the 1/2 and 1/1 gaps.
26. 04:07:296 (4,5,6,7) - Pretty underwhelming spacing considering this is the climax of the entire song. actually what you mean about underwhelming? I think this pattern is comfortable.

Apply these suggestions to the other difficulties as well since chances are you made similar mistakes in those as well, and then I'll check responses and stuff.

AyanokoRin wrote:

Hi sorry for more than 4 months late w

Insane

00:04:463 (4) - this flow is a bit off as it forces the cursor to harshly switch direction, move 00:04:463 (4) to the left and it should be alright I think harshly switch direction would be more challenge

00:24:629 (2) to 00:34:796 (1) - why such low SV ? the music is in the same state as 00:34:796 (1) so the SV should be the same I want to make some unique things lol, and it seems not bad imo

01:43:463 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - I hear nothing on 01:43:629 (3,6)… maybe remove it and make 01:43:546 (2,5) kicksliders ? Even doubles would be playable imo due to the relatively big gap there are obvious drumbeat here

01:44:129 (5) - NC there, not at 01:44:463 (1)

01:49:462 (9) - NC seems weird

01:55:629 - having a gap there just feels… empty. If you want a gap somewhere, put it at 01:54:963 since it makes for a fine transition between 2 phrases. But here making 01:55:463 (4) a slider would fit the music better imo I move 01:55:796 (1,2) - to the far a bit

02:09:129 - needs to be clickable imo not necessary

02:14:629 (4) - consistency error : this should be the same as 01:21:296 (9,1)

02:18:796 (5,1) - consistency error here as well : there was no NC here in previous kiai. Also if you decide to put NC it both, put it at 02:18:796 (5) and not not 02:19:129 (1) removed nc

02:32:129 (9) - NC nope, nc at the stream end is good idea but there are not appropriate

03:40:796 (9) - ^ ^

03:52:129 (9) - ^ ^

04:02:463 (5,6,7,8) - I don’t really get why this stream’s DS is so low, this is technically the phrase’s climax so you want to have a bigger spacing for this. ( or also keep your spacing for 04:02:129 (1,2,3,4,5) and change direction + spacing at 04:02:546 (6) ( example ) fixed as your example

Expert

Wow, that one way way better than the Insane, especially when it comes to consistency

01:55:629 - same as the insane, the gap here feels weird I really feel that good... feel more emotional

03:21:796 (8) - the gap here is very weird as well since the sliders before build up the song and then there’s… nothing, turn 03:21:796 (8) into a slider I want to separate this part 03:19:796 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - and this part 03:22:129 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) -

04:04:296 (2,3,4) - the way it resets the flow here is pretty weird since 04:04:296 (2)’s positioning appeals for 04:04:463 (3) - to be around below 04:03:796 (5). If you do this you can also reposition 04:04:629 (4) to lead into 04:04:796 (5) more naturally. I want to make it weird actually, since it is expert diff I think it would be fine.

04:30:879 - Maybe put a spinner until 04:34:129 ? not necessary

Aaand that’s all I gotta say, I’m gonna happily tilt on this when it’s ranked ~~
if I can get my mouse to work back until then .w.

Good luck for the rest of your mapping :3

Doyak wrote:

Please, you didn't read my rules. I definitely wrote Sum of drain time of all diffs < 10 min. This map has like more than 20 minutes. So no mod for this map, sorry.