ztrot wrote:

I've looked over this once again, all the changes i asked for have been adjusted! bubble for you as request of the creator I'm revoking for silly reasons imo but whatever as long as the mapper is happy 8D

• Давай, ОД4, пожалуйста! ХD

1. 00:08:501 (1,2) - По моему то я бы дал серкла и после слайдера.
2. 00:31:727 (1,2) - Тоже само xD
3. 01:10:437 (1,2) - И ещё раз .3.
4. 01:23:985 (1) - Очень короткий слайдер, можешь сделать что-нибудь иное, пожалуйста?
5. 01:38:018 (2,3) - Не давай стаков в нормале, это очень трудно играть и считать!
6. 01:58:340 (4) - Я бы дал серкла вместо слайдера. :v

diraimur wrote:

k eventually I kinda screwed this up

Krfawy wrote:

Also would be nice to set AR8.3-8.5 in Insane I believe.

Krfawy wrote:

Нормаль

• Давай, ОД4, пожалуйста! ХD //было в оригинале, дирай менял статы за меня

1. 00:08:501 (1,2) - По моему то я бы дал серкла и после слайдера. //окей
2. 00:31:727 (1,2) - Тоже само xD //эм не, не подходит здесь, путает ритмы (00:33:905 (6) - 00:35:840 (1) - )
3. 01:10:437 (1,2) - И ещё раз .3. //переделал паттерн, но не применено, путает ритм впоследствии (01:14:550 (1,2) - )
4. 01:23:985 (1) - Очень короткий слайдер, можешь сделать что-нибудь иное, пожалуйста? //ещё один длиннный слайдер? нуок //алсо, спиннер, не слайдер
5. 01:38:018 (2,3) - Не давай стаков в нормале, это очень трудно играть и считать! это обычно нормально, но я не умею это правильно использовать -:\
6. 01:58:340 (4) - Я бы дал серкла вместо слайдера. :v //если только один, то почему бы и нет..

I cry tbh xD

Arphimigon wrote:

So what is happening now?

diraimur wrote:

Arphimigon wrote:

So what is happening now?

nobody knows yet ;w;

CMC wrote:

We've got DETERMINATION
To represent the nation
Fooooooooor theeeeeeeeeeeeeee wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiin!

HappyRocket88 wrote:

[ Arphimigon's Insane]

1. don't leave it as a monotonous insane. Just had an idea
2. Hp + 0.5 same reason as Hard diff. ok
3. 00:21:566 (5,6) - The spacing here is rather big comparing to the jumps you managed before and as long as 6 isn't the strong beat, what's the reason of placing it too far? idk patterning i guess, nerfing!
4. 00:23:985 (5) - NC here to follow properly the way you managed NC in this diff. sure, why not!
5. 00:51:566 (1) - Remove NC here just as well as you managed in the first pattern 00:47:210 (1,2,3) - Consider doing the same in these 00:54:953 (1,1,2) - yus will do!
6. 01:22:292 (1) - This spinner should start here 01:22:171 - to follow slightly better the vocals. sure!
7. 01:34:630 (1) - Remove NC here. there's no need to play with new objects when the diffs plays better if you kept consistent the NC fixd!
8. 01:34:630 (1,1) - http://puu.sh/m7se8/c2b7c43dec.png as long as the're not strong beats, what's the need to create such as a big jump here? Consider doing the same here 00:55:921 (2,1) LOL Derp on my side! That should never had been so high!

HappyRocket88 wrote:

[ Firmatorenio's Normal]

• 
  IMPORTANT

1. HP +0.1. I know this go in your preferences but it would be way better if you used rounded numbers over Normal difficulties because the current 3.4 looks a bit weird imo. //my preferences is in fact hp4
   []
2. 00:23:985 (8) - NC here to keep consistency in the way you managed NC in the diff. //uh no, what good will do a 1-note combo?
3. 00:57:856 (1,2) - Honestly the way these two sliders flow is a bit bad because, besides the blanket among them is not so clean. It would be better if you tried out something more smoother to improve the readability of those sliders. //the flow is intended, i increased the distance between (1) and (3) though
4. 01:23:985 (3) - This slider should end here 01:24:711 - to highlight better the instruments / vocals in this segment. //wow, nice
5. 01:31:001 (3,4) - Ctrl + G this to improve the rhythm. It's quite awkward to make downbeats in the white ticks and make the sliders tart on the white tick. It would be more intuitive if all the slider started in the white tick as long as this is a lower diff that should lead players to realize where strong beats are. Consider doing the same here 01:27:130 (3,4) - 00:48:421 (4,5) - 00:52:292 (4,5) - //my rhythm suits for the song better, as well as i don't find any strong enough beats to accentuate here; just because it's a white tick doesn't mean it's strong enough
6. 01:41:405 (1,2,3) - The was you placed these sliders is making a weird flow because isn't really intuitive to the players to follow those sliders when the sliders shapes suggest something different. It would make more sense if you tried out to create a more perceptive flow as well as you did in the previous patterns. //huh no, it's an intended pattern, i'll make them look a bit better though
7. 01:45:276 (8) - This circle creates an over map pattern because there's no strong beat that needs to be emphasized there. It would be better if you removed that circle and place the spinner exactly in the white tick since the vocals reside there. //that vocal needs to be pressured, and just the spinner doesn't give that pressure
8. 01:45:276 (1) - Remove the clap and the finish of this slider since it sound way over set due to the noisy sound they produce together. //replaced with a whistle; what's up with you people calling spinners sliders?
9. 01:54:469 (3) - Remove the clap of this slider too. ^ //moved the clap to the head and put a whistle on the end

HappyRocket88 wrote:

I was asked to mod this trough PM :u Merry Christmas!thank you, you too!

Popping because there's no hitsounds in the easy diff i want to kill myself
confirmed here with the Aibat why
;-;

[ General]

1. Add to tags "Flight to the Finish" because this was the episode where the song firstly appears. done
2. Add to tags "Songs of Ponyville" because is the album name where the song releases. done

[ Easy]

1. 01:01:727 (3) - This note is so off screen fixed
2. 00:31:727 (1,2) - Ending the sliders' ends on the red tick plays a bit weird because the vocals suggest that the strong vocals go over the white ticks. It would be better if you made those sliders end here 00:32:695 - and here 00:34:630 - applying to 00:31:727 (1) - and 00:33:663 (2) - respectively. I disagree, I didn't follow vocals.
3. 00:55:437 (2,3) - Ctrl + G these to don't have the same flow direction of the previous pattern 00:51:566 (2,3) - ayyy ok
4. 01:34:147 (2,3) - ^ ^
5. 01:37:534 (1,2,3,4) - The use of 1/1 in this segment flows a bit weird because the vocals / instruments doesn't support a constantly 1/1 rhythm. It would be make more sense if you replaced these two objects 01:37:534 (1,2) - with a 2/1 slider and a note. Consider doing the same here 01:39:469 (3,4) - The whole pattern should look like this yeah thats better i guess
6. 01:43:340 (3,4) - DS problem here, it should be 1x or 0.97x at max regarding spacing in these two objects. ok i have no idea how i messed that up
7. 01:58:824 (1) - Remove NC here since it's kinda unnecessary according on how you manage the NC in the whole set. nu its there for effect

DON' FORGET TO ADD THE HITSOUNDS! pls i want to kill miself

[ Hard]

Honestly I really well made hard. ty

1. HP + 0.5 just for the sake of having rounded numbers on the diff. I see no reasons by setting the HP over 4.5 since this is the hard diff. honestly i dont think its that big of a deal but will do anyway
2. 00:21:808 (6) - This should be properly stacked under 00:21:324 (4) - to keep consistent the DS here. remade pattern

s y m m e t r y sucks </3
no

HappyRocket88 wrote:

[General]
Ranking Criteria states that if you use non-standard slider velocity changes they MUST be added in the beatmap description to advertise playhers the weird decimals some diffs manage.
just wanna say that i checked and found that there was only 1xSV through all the mapsets... unless im blind (and I am slightly but still)

[Arphimigon's For the Win!]
00:55:921 (3,4) - http://puu.sh/m9jM5/7ecbe137da.png I didnt fix this in the last mod!? ok
01:14:066 (5,6,1) - These should've been stacked as well as the upcoming triplets. Just for the sake of keeping consistency here.[/list]
(this is blue ok) I disagree with this statement cus the non-stack was for flow simplicity and the stacks later were for the patterning but w/e i'll find something for them both to work

Arphimigon wrote:

just wanna say that i checked and found that there was only 1xSV through all the mapsets... unless im blind (and I am slightly but still)

HappyRocket88 wrote:

Recheck

[General]
Ranking Criteria states that if you use non-standard slider velocity changes they MUST be added in the beatmap description to advertise playhers the weird decimals some diffs manage. You wrote it by yourself, "...slider velocity changes must be added in the beatmap description...". There are no sv changes on this whole set.
[Easy]
I asked too many others BNs about the current size of the CS of this diff and we agreed it should be, at least, 3. This goes to lead new players into a comfortable circle size that not confuse due the spacing this difficulty manages. Even though I highly disagree that newer players wouldn't able to play cs 3.5, I'll change it anyway. CS and SV are basically two things that should matter most of the time. If SV is low, CS can be high. If CS is high, SV should be low, since they play the same but only different mapping area you get. Yeah, sensivity and tablet area matters, but its a very subjective thing. I'll lower to CS3 anyway, I'm just not really satisfied with it. (rip whole set being 3.5)
00:31:727 (1,2) - Despite you said: "you weren't following vocals" the strong beats reside over the white ticks which should be emphasized to improve the rhythm. Ending the sliders on the red tick play a bit weird imo. I still didn't understand whats wrong with them, I used 3/2 rhythms for quite a bit on this map and this one is also probably 3/2 unless the song we are listening to are different.
01:39:469 (1) - Remove NC here to have consistency with the way you managed the NC in this diff. whoops, fixed.

[Hard]
I'm honestly confused with the increasing of DS among the notes in the kiai. If there's no SV change, what's the reason of increasing the DS by 0.20x in the notes? It would be better if you increase the SV in the kiai to lead players the kiai will have bigger spacing and some harder patterns. Consider doing the same with both kiais. I'll go ahead and say I disagree with this, just because I've used higher spacing on some parts doesn't mean I should increase SV, in fact if you want to emphasis it more you should use slower SV with higher spacing on kiai's on some songs, and SV is already as high as it is, increasing on kiai would be too unplayable. SV changes aren't necessary things to do anyway.

HappyRocket88 wrote:

<thing about SVs>

HappyRocket88 wrote:

[Normal]
00:23:985 (8) - I still believe this object should have NC to keep consistency in the way you managed NC. //I still don't understand what good it does, I only see 2 ill side effects: ruined looks and slightly increased drain
01:15:759 (4) - Ctrl + J to improve the flow in this segment. //i would, but sorry, not enough space
01:31:001 (3,4) - I honestly believe starting the sliders in the red tick doesn't highlight properly the beats. Thus, it would be better if you kept consistency in the way the sliders started in the white tick throughout the kiai. Look how you placed the sliders over the kiai time
<...>
This would have played better if you had done same here to don't break the way you built up the patterning on the start of the kiai. If the music and the instruments is the same through the kiai, what's the reason to make different rhythm flows? Consider doing an uniform rhythm in both kiais, this imply to give a look of these patterns. 00:52:292 (4,5) - 01:27:130 (3,4) - 01:31:001 (3,4) - //I changed some of them, but not all of them; one actually ruined the looks

CMC wrote:

WE GOT DERMINATION
TO REpREsEnt THE nATION!

Firmatorenio wrote:

I'd put my own placeholder, but am scared they'd mute us for spamming.
Shot another star to increase the chance of some bn coming randomly by 0.0000142843%

Kathex wrote:

Sad more one beatmap perfect for get ranked is going to be forgotten because a shit system.... and you try to make this system different, they say ure a totaly nonsense...

R.I.P. dear ponys

Gero wrote:

I'll post my mod later, sorry for delay but I'm quite busy in real life.

diraimur wrote:

real life takes priority

*ahem*

Arphimigon wrote:

diraimur wrote:

real life takes priority

*ahem*