1. Hard (3.03 stars, 409 notes)
2. Insane (4.3 stars, 634 notes)
3. Kalibe's Easy (1.56 stars, 152 notes)
4. Normal (2.14 stars, 298 notes)

Thank box

Peachtrees and Barney Stinson for extensive moral support
Ringating for nice BG, Kalibe for GD Easy

Exahilosys wrote:

Modding done:

[Insane]

00:15:900 - Maybe move these a bit closer, for readability reasons, since someone might not think of them as a stream and try singletapping. I think SV + approach circles make this kind of obvious, but apparently not. I shrunk this one down a bit.
00:27:501 - Try smothering the entrance to the slider from the stream. are you talking about a flow issue here? If so then I did change this a little.
00:31:486 - Ctrl+G this one? i was trying to sort of keep them like etna sliders. I'm not really a fan of the ctrl-G version
00:34:533 - Huge jump from 3 to 4 here, without any noticable tension on the song. i undid the star so it's just a normal pentagon, hopefully that fixes it a little bit. Not sure precisely what you meant by this though.
00:43:205 - Move the slider under the 2. ?????
00:44:419 - Ctrl+G this one. seems fine to me
00:53:751 - Bad flow from last stream to here. Better turn it so it looks down (like this 00:59:3760). fix
01:04:142 - Unexpected fast mini-stream here. Not a big deal, but could be changed. I don't really have a choice with the 1/6 triplets here. And it feels weird to end slider early or something like that. so I don't think this will change unless absolutely necessary
01:08:751 - Big jump between opposite-facing streams is too hard for this level. I'm a little dubious on the value of changing this since it is an insane, but I did decrease the jump distance here.
01:09:689 - By this point, the player should have understand what these circly streams do, but just in case do the same with 00:15:900. scaled down just a touch and moved around for more flow
01:34:533 - Make that sexy stream a bit more curvy. I agree that it does look ugly, but it's already somewhat hard to tell the differene between the 1/4 and the 1/6 and I don't think I want to increase spacing anymore. There must be a better way to do this... and no, do not ask me to slider-ify this section.
01:42:345 - Not polite to change streaming pace mid-stream. spacing should make this quite clear + I can't just ignore that triplet
01:45:548 - I suggest adding another 3tick stream here and removing the 2 notes. added 4 notes... not entirely sure I like this but the sliders are not really pleasant.
01:50:236 - Maybe start 1-combo here? how did i miss that one??? fixed.
01:50:236 - Try adding a note here. ????? there is a note there!
02:08:283 - Make this one curvy with the belly on the right. fixed up just a touch, maybe not in that particular way
02:15:548 - Better move that 2 a bit closer. fix just a touch

Sweet map and nice song! Try focusing on flow between the streams, usually this is hard to do so don't let it go by.

[-AKiTOSHi-] wrote:

Random pick from #modreqs
thanks for freemod!!!

00:09:220 (5) - move to x:212 y:132 sort of fixed?
00:24:455 (1) - Rotate this slider for the next stream ^^^
00:25:626 (6) - New Combo I always do NCs on measures
00:38:283 (2,3,4) - not balanced with 00:38:751 (5,6,7) - this has been made more consistent
01:02:189 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - I don't like how you streamed there... I'm not good at being consistent haha...
01:04:142 (2,3,4) - hmm. how about use reverse slider since you put there to beat snap of 1/6?? trying to avoid sliders in cases like that unless BNs cri evrytiem about it. I like being able to tap the individual notes.
01:18:361 (9) - New combo here. up to 16 is pretty long. oops. fixed.
01:30:861 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - kinda confusing better use reverse slider in 01:30:861 (2,3,4) - no, per above
01:34:767 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - another confusing stream here. try another pattern instead of streams to other players can easily catch the rhythm of the song. and again... I'm trying to use spacing to make it very obvious.
01:40:626 (7) - New combo here since It's the starting point of your stream. only put NCs on measures... I could do it based on instruments for this song but it'd
01:42:267 (9,10,11,12) - another 1/6. I dunno if acceptable or not, ask pro. not noob like me :3 trying to keep these if at all possible
01:42:267 (9) - ^ If you don't want to change, try put new combo here. interesting... going to have to keep an eye on that
01:47:892 (8) - New combo it dones't need it here!
02:05:470 (10,11) - make them further so they don't trolled with 1/4 and 1/6 asin like spacing confusion? Done.

Nice map here. I felt that it's really smooth with the streams. I want some easier diff too!

Kawaii Muffin wrote:

Hey, from #modreqs
General
[]
You probably need a normal and a hard mapset to go along with this map waiting for insane diff to be good/whatever until make normal/hard (no easy diff.. I'd die testing that... no NC mod in editor...)
Move Preview point to 01:57:736 fix esp. b/c don't want to give song away.

Insane

1. The beginning is really odd to me
2. From 00:01:955 to 00:16:955, The SV is really unfitting. I would keep it at 1.00x. That also makes the slider shorter. Longer sliders seem a bit unnecessary and unappealing there. I had it at 1.3x because the rhythm is stronger here than at the analogous section 01:20:705 or the following section 00:16:955. So I like the contrast. But if another person mentions this I will change...
3. Also from the same place I mentioned above, You have this theme where the slider blankets a hitcircle. Maybe add something different so it doesnt seem repetitive? I would follow the beat of the drums at 00:01:955 the beginning , which are simple 1/2 beats (You can also have some fun with hit sounds when you are listening to the drums!) and then at 00:09:455 I would listen to the piano or just keep with the beat of the 1/2 drums because you can do so much more when you are keeping the beat of the drum rather than the piano. It's really really really hard for me to hear the drum beats here. The piano feels more like the dominant instrument. Although I supppose I can just map piano in normal hard anyways so ... I will switch to drum beat for the 2nd half of that timing section.
4. 00:20:705 (1) - I would remove that bend, the song is flowy~ but if you want to keep that bend in the slider, do it for 00:24:455 (1) as well and etc. fix
5. 00:25:626 (6) - NC NCs go on measures... why are so many people insisting on NCs here, though? They're not particularly long... hmm...
6. 00:46:720 (9) - NC and remove NC on 00:46:955 (1) ^^^^^
7. 00:55:626 (9) - NC ^^^^^^^
8. 01:04:142 (2,3,4) - Omg plzzzzz use a slider, it is really hard to read whether or not it is a 1/4 beat or 1/6, And btw it is 1/8 lol, also, 01:04:142 (2) there isnt a beat there. Try slowing it down to 25% and hear for yourself. you know, begging like that really isn't the best way to get me to change that... also unfortuantely for this map that section is 1/8 timing so i ust inserted minislider even though i hate hate hate minisliders
9. 01:10:626 (9) - NC again.... not changing this
10. 01:14:611 (10) - Really random bending sliders here, remove them, it doesnt fix, and you arent consisntantly using bent sliders, so it felt like as if it was just thrown in there just for the heck of it fix
11. 01:18:830 (12) - NC For sure again, no .... okay, forget it, if the next modder too says that we need more NCs i shall add ncs
12. 01:26:330 (1) - Nice
13. 01:27:970 (7,8,9) - Not nice. Jumping from 1/4 and 1/6 is extremely hard to read. unless if you know the map inside out, barely anyone is going to catch that, Just put sliders in there if you really want to express the 1/6 beats spacing is made more obvious for this. And you're not supposed to be able to sightread SS this!!!!!!!
14. 01:30:861 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - That is impossible to read, use a slider! spacing increased to alleviate this
15. 01:34:533 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13) - Absolutely impossible to get 300s on first run, You need to change this..... Just because you changed the Distance snapping a little doesnt mean you can just randomly jump from a 1/4 to a 1/6 and then BACK into another 1/4 beat.. Sliders please! You're not supposed to be able to SS this first try anyways!!!!! again, increased DS... also added NCs so it's obvious...
16. 01:42:267 (9,10,11,12) - Again! USE A SLIDER >:O this one hanged only because the 1/4 stream is excessively long
17. 02:04:142 (2,3,4) - Look above where I talked about 01:04:142 (2,3,4) fix
18. 02:10:626 (9) - NCno NC frenzy pls

• as requested
  
  Normal

1. 00:01:955 (1,2,1,2) - spacing between these is a tiny bit messy, might want to even this out
2. 00:09:220 (3) - would probably want to add a circle here too for the drums
3. 00:16:955 (1) - missing finish
4. 00:16:720 (3) - could see a circle here work well for the build-up
5. 00:20:236 (4) - why the NC
6. 00:20:705 (1) - would avoid sharp turns like these in sliders for the easiest Diff of your set, they can throw new players off and can actually be a valid DQ reason
7. 00:30:080 (1) - I don't really like this tbh, the song definitely isn't as monotnous as the continous repeat here would suggest (e.g. peak on 00:30:548 (1) - )
8. 00:39:455 (1,2) - try this rythm http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3543876
9. 00:46:955 (1) - 00:30:080 (1) -
10. 01:11:330 (5) - del finish on the tail
11. 01:12:970 (2) - needs a circle
12. 01:18:126 (3) - ^
13. 01:20:236 (1) - unneccessary NC?
14. 01:29:845 (4,1) - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3543902 :c
15. 01:33:830 (1) - honestly not sure if this is long enough for the easiest Diff of the set, kinda risky
16. 01:47:892 (4) - would turn this into a 1/2 to cover the entire peak of the piano right here, having the rythm a little more dense during such an intense part shouldn't be a big bother
17. 01:50:236 (1) - NCcCCCC
18. 02:02:658 (2) - needs a circle
19. 02:11:330 (3) - finish on the tail sounds rather noisy
    
    honestly I think that the density of this could be upped by a bit to properly catch the piano at times. Would personally rather go for that and then map an easy Diff that is 80-90% 1/1 rythm, imo that would be the more elgeant solution
    
    Hard
    
20. 00:15:900 (3,4) - would keep the spacing between 1/4's consistent with the 1/2 in the map (meaning 1.0 spacing)
21. 00:20:236 (1) - remove NC
22. 00:22:580 (1,2,3,4) - very close to each other, probably due to auto-stacking
23. 00:29:142 (2) - would make much more sense to have this white tick clickable since this is the peak of this section
24. 00:54:689 (2) - split this up into multiple 1/4s to have the peaks in the song clickable, alot nice than just having the entire piano covered by one repeat
25. 01:09:689 (2) - ^ not sure if there're more of those but yeah
26. 01:30:080 (1,2,3) - try https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3544090 for a possible rythm, feels more intuitive
27. 01:45:080 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - might be a little to 1/4 heavy for a Hard Diff, kinda risky
    
    done for now, might come back for the Insana c:
    
    Good Luck!

Peachtrees wrote:

• as requested
  
  Normal

1. 00:01:955 (1,2,1,2) - spacing between these is a tiny bit messy, might want to even this out
2. 00:09:220 (3) - would probably want to add a circle here too for the drums Fixed.
3. 00:16:955 (1) - missing finish Fixed for all diffs.
4. 00:16:720 (3) - could see a circle here work well for the build-up This goes back to "can I get an Easy GD".
5. 00:20:236 (4) - why the NC This was done in expert because IMO it sort of sounded like a phrase change. I removed this from Hard and Normal.
6. 00:20:705 (1) - would avoid sharp turns like these in sliders for the easiest Diff of your set, they can throw new players off and can actually be a valid DQ reason Oh for crying out loud this is why I need Easy GD. I was trying to restore some of the expressiveness, but clearly it's not working very well. And of course the 2/1 slider but ... These have been changed to more normal bendy sliders.
7. 00:30:080 (1) - I don't really like this tbh, the song definitely isn't as monotnous as the continous repeat here would suggest (e.g. peak on 00:30:548 (1) - ) made a little better
8. 00:39:455 (1,2) - try this rythm http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3543876 spliced in oddly
9. 00:46:955 (1) - 00:30:080 (1) -
10. 01:11:330 (5) - del finish on the tail Done for consistency with Hard and insane, but yeah... I'll look into this.
11. 01:12:970 (2) - needs a circle Fixed.
12. 01:18:126 (3) - ^ Fixed.
13. 01:20:236 (1) - unneccessary NC? Done for consistency with other diffs. This one was intentionally for emphasis, so I don't think I'll be changing this one. Watch as it's a DQ reason kappa
14. 01:29:845 (4,1) - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3543902 :c Fixed. Oh autostack...
15. 01:33:830 (1) - honestly not sure if this is long enough for the easiest Diff of the set, kinda risky I like my note spinners! But yeah... that would not be pleasant
16. 01:47:892 (4) - would turn this into a 1/2 to cover the entire peak of the piano right here, having the rythm a little more dense during such an intense part shouldn't be a big bother Done.
17. 01:50:236 (1) - NCcCCCC Same issue as 01:20:236.
18. 02:02:658 (2) - needs a circle Fixed.
19. 02:11:330 (3) - finish on the tail sounds rather noisy Same issue as 01:11:330.
    
    honestly I think that the density of this could be upped by a bit to properly catch the piano at times. Would personally rather go for that and then map an easy Diff that is 80-90% 1/1 rythm, imo that would be the more elgeant solution I completely agree. I'll see if I can get an Easy GD. I don't think I can stand mapping an Easy.
    
    Hard
    
20. 00:15:900 (3,4) - would keep the spacing between 1/4's consistent with the 1/2 in the map (meaning 1.0 spacing) Fixed.
21. 00:20:236 (1) - remove NC Fixed. See above.
22. 00:22:580 (1,2,3,4) - very close to each other, probably due to auto-stacking Rearranged slightly.
23. 00:29:142 (2) - would make much more sense to have this white tick clickable since this is the peak of this section Fixed, with slight rearrangements.
24. 00:54:689 (2) - split this up into multiple 1/4s to have the peaks in the song clickable, alot nice than just having the entire piano covered by one repeat Rearranged slightly. Good luck HD players!
25. 01:09:689 (2) - ^ not sure if there're more of those but yeah
26. 01:30:080 (1,2,3) - try https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3544090 for a possible rythm, feels more intuitive IMO this causes more issues than it solves
27. 01:45:080 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - might be a little to 1/4 heavy for a Hard Diff, kinda risky Come on, just this once? I'll keep an eye on this.
    
    done for now, might come back for the Insana c:
    
    Good Luck!

1. I should say your map is kinda neat :3
2. please considering to change ar to 9. if you see, 8.5 is really slow for the slider velocity you used. they don't match. so if you use ar 9 would be better and won't be a problem for spread.
3. 00:09:455 (1) - after this part, I think just place the note like you did at the beginning is more fit for those strong beat such as 00:10:392 (4). I basically mean to move 00:10:392 (4,1,4,1,4) further or reduce the spacing such as 00:11:095 (7,2,3).
4. 00:20:001 (1) - I should say this NC is unnecessary.
5. 00:31:955 (1) - make this slider more slim to be like 00:31:017 (3,4) is more beautilful.
6. 00:20:705 (1) - add any hitsound on head? cymbal there.
7. 00:38:283 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - something similar to this? more beautiful imo.
8. 01:17:892 (8) - just stack on (2). it won't be a problem. it's really more beautiful this way.
9. 01:24:220 (8,1) - these spacing suddenly short and it's weird to play tbh.
10. 01:47:892 (8) - NC
11. 01:51:173 (2) - even it's slow part, I still think this spacing is really to short, just make it similar with you did on 01:53:048 (2).
12. 02:11:095 (12,13,14) - very nazi, move them till 14 stack.

1. 00:22:580 (1) - raise spacing, this is more like unintentional spacing error. 1.4x would be good.
2. 01:05:705 (1) - add some hitsound.
3. 01:21:642 (3) - raise the spacing. it's same as 01:22:580 (1,3,1)

1. since you already have easy diff, better raise ar to 5 for better spread and more fit with slider velocity.
2. 00:56:330 (3,1) - swap NC
3. 00:58:205 (3) - add NC
4. 01:11:330 (5,1,3) - do the same as two lines above. (apply to all case on second chorus.)
5. 01:31:017 (1) - no need NC imo.
6. 01:56:330 (1) - this spinner is dangerous.... probably a dq reason. too short for normal diff, just use long slider or end at 01:58:205 instead and remove that slider.

1. noticeable spacing error. such as 00:03:830 (3,2,3) and go on. please make ALL of them consistency. this is really important because this is the easiest diff.
2. 00:16:955 (1) - no need to stack to make it harder, just place it above that slider.
3. 01:05:236 (1) - I think this NC doesn't necessary. (apply to all of entire map if you agreed.)
4. thing you should do is make the whole spacing of this diff consistency. and avoid the stack on tail such as 02:18:361 (4). VERY hard to play for beginner.

P A N wrote:

m4m brought me here.

[Insane]

1. I should say your map is kinda neat :3 thanks
2. please considering to change ar to 9. if you see, 8.5 is really slow for the slider velocity you used. they don't match. so if you use ar 9 would be better and won't be a problem for spread. I'm not convinced that AR9 fits this song, TBH. I was actually thinking of decreasing (!!!) AR to 8, but clearly people do not seem to like this. I'll keep an eye on AR in general.
3. 00:09:455 (1) - after this part, I think just place the note like you did at the beginning is more fit for those strong beat such as 00:10:392 (4). I basically mean to move 00:10:392 (4,1,4,1,4) further or reduce the spacing such as 00:11:095 (7,2,3). The rhythm is more vigorous at this point, which is why the spacing spikes a bit. Gonna see what happens here, this might become an issue later.
4. 00:20:001 (1) - I should say this NC is unnecessary. Was done for a phrase change, yeah? But in any case, removed.
5. 00:31:955 (1) - make this slider more slim to be like 00:31:017 (3,4) is more beautilful. Fixed.
6. 00:20:705 (1) - add any hitsound on head? cymbal there. Oh for crying out loud, seriously, 1 note hitsounds, why must they be so annoying? And why does Drum hitsound no have cymbal!? fixed.
7. 00:38:283 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - something similar to this? more beautiful imo. Fixed. Lovely!
8. 01:17:892 (8) - just stack on (2). it won't be a problem. it's really more beautiful this way. Fixed. That's what it was supposed to be like, but ... clearly I'm not paying too much attention.
9. 01:24:220 (8,1) - these spacing suddenly short and it's weird to play tbh. Adjusted slightly.
10. 01:47:892 (8) - NC Not enough of a shift in music to justify this IMO. I'll have to see what others think.
11. 01:51:173 (2) - even it's slow part, I still think this spacing is really to short, just make it similar with you did on 01:53:048 (2). Fixed.
12. 02:11:095 (12,13,14) - very nazi, move them till 14 stack. but ... why???

[Hard]

1. 00:22:580 (1) - raise spacing, this is more like unintentional spacing error. 1.4x would be good. Fixed.
2. 01:05:705 (1) - add some hitsound. Fixed on all diffs. Eh.
3. 01:21:642 (3) - raise the spacing. it's same as 01:22:580 (1,3,1) Touched up slightly.

[Normal]

1. since you already have easy diff, better raise ar to 5 for better spread and more fit with slider velocity. Fixed.
2. 00:56:330 (3,1) - swap NC
3. 00:58:205 (3) - add NC
4. 01:11:330 (5,1,3) - do the same as two lines above. (apply to all case on second chorus.) I kinda liked mine better... the way this is here splits up the verse strangely.
5. 01:31:017 (1) - no need NC imo. This was for consistency with higher diffs, where note structure mandates an NC.
6. 01:56:330 (1) - this spinner is dangerous.... probably a dq reason. too short for normal diff, just use long slider or end at 01:58:205 instead and remove that slider. Removed during remap.

[Kalibe]

1. noticeable spacing error. such as 00:03:830 (3,2,3) and go on. please make ALL of them consistency. this is really important because this is the easiest diff.
2. 00:16:955 (1) - no need to stack to make it harder, just place it above that slider.
3. 01:05:236 (1) - I think this NC doesn't necessary. (apply to all of entire map if you agreed.)
4. thing you should do is make the whole spacing of this diff consistency. and avoid the stack on tail such as 02:18:361 (4). VERY hard to play for beginner.

that's all GL

P A N wrote:

m4m brought me here.



[Kalibe]

1. noticeable spacing error. such as 00:03:830 (3,2,3) and go on. please make ALL of them consistency. this is really important because this is the easiest diff. fix
2. 00:16:955 (1) - no need to stack to make it harder, just place it above that slider. fix
3. 01:05:236 (1) - I think this NC doesn't necessary. (apply to all of entire map if you agreed.) you're right
4. thing you should do is make the whole spacing of this diff consistency. and avoid the stack on tail such as 02:18:361 (4). VERY hard to play for beginner.

fix

that's all GL

[ Rizen ] wrote:

Yeah, I'm not that great at mapping these kind of maps

The insane looks great though, what with all the flowers and not

Here's a kudosu(s) though, you've earned it