zgsdmm wrote:

Oni

00:23:337 - remove -I feel like this is a good place to add a finish because of the cymbal crash
00:23:757 - add a k -fixed
00:26:904 - add a d -fixed
00:33:617 - remove -nope
00:33:827 - add a k -^
00:50:610 - add a k -^
00:51:029 - remove -fixed
00:56:169 - remove -fixed
00:59:421 - add a k -fixed

01:00:260 - remove -finisher fits well at this part
01:00:575 - remove -nope
01:01:309 - remove -^
01:01:519 - remove -^
01:00:470 - add a d -^
01:00:680 - add a d -^
01:01:414 - add a k -^
01:01:729 - k -^
01:02:358 - add a k -^
01:02:778 - add a k -^
http://puu.sh/hoNVV/53d67e214e.png I tried to do here like this...I am not sure it is appropriate... -good idea, but it doesn't really suit this section

02:13:057 - add a d -inconsistent with the following parts
02:13:267 - remove -nope
02:25:015 - add a d -^
04:01:099 - add a d -fixed
04:41:484 - add a d -nope

It's too hard for me... I do it through my feeling,so I'm not sure if that's right to mod.

Firce777 wrote:

sorry for bad english
[Muzukashii]
it looks like easier oni, not muzukashii.
00:51:869 (65,66,67,68,69) - i think it's too hard for muzu, i'll recommend this -fixed
00:55:225 (78,79,80,81,82) - ^ change it to easier parts for same reason, and almost 2-combo parts in this diff should be fixed -good! fixed all 2-note combos
01:11:169 (133,134) - change to O　　O -changed to this instead
01:43:897 (1) - change the spinner end to 01:45:155 - , and add o at 01:45:575 - ,and long break time is not necessary for taiko imo -good idea, but I'd like to have the spinner go into the break rather than just a single note
03:39:491 (1) - see 01:43:897 (1) - -fixed spinner time, did not add the note
05:02:778 (81,82,83,84,85,86,87,88) - well, let's see other modders about this. i have no idea. -I might change this to a slider

by the way, i'm really worried about 3-combo parts is too hard, ooo or xxx is ok. but other parts maybe too hard. although you use them very well. but hey! this is not oni~ -I think the 3-combo parts are ok since this is a low bpm map

[Oni]
01:27:008 (1) - delete this -fixed
03:05:924 (3) - finish sound is not necessary -fixed

oni seems ok, but i think finish notes maybe too many, let me feel a little abuse.
after all, this diff is ok. -I will keep this in mind

good luck~

guineaQ wrote:

ay just passingby

--------------------
-You forgot preview point
to set one: Timing on the top bar (not the timing tab in the editor itself, but the gray bar) -> set preview bla bla bla

-And yeah apparently no letterboxes allowed as well

-and I'm not 100% sure but I'm 99% sure you are not allowed use SV changes in Kantan :<
(well especially the transition from 04:08:442 - is VERY awkward even if this was higher diff)

You should review SV changes in higher diffs and ask Ono or MMzz about this SV changes in lower diffs (I haven't modded Taiko that much so I don't know taiko ranking criteria inside out like standard)

nice song owo/

Btw, I'm not the best at modding easier diffs (still kinda new to it), and they are really good, not much to point out. Sorry if they ended up too short

1. Change HP to 3? Long and slow-bpm map, I think it fits better than HP4.
2. 01:31:729 - k
3. 02:17:463 - ^
4. 05:02:778 - Feels kind of wrong, consider changing it.

1. 01:19:980 - Add single
2. 02:21:134 - k
3. 03:37:603 and 03:38:022 sounds off-beat.

1. OD4 fits better imo
2. 01:08:652 - k
3. 01:09:071 - Move here 01:08:862 ?
4. 02:00:890 - Move k k to 02:01:309 (sounds more correct imo)
5. 02:11:589 - d
6. 02:12:428 - k
7. 02:15:994 - Add single
8. 02:30:890 - k
9. 03:00:260 - Consider changing this to notes/make spinner longer, kind of akward to have a drumroll and then a spinner right after.

1. 00:39:491 - Move here 00:39:281 ?
2. 00:39:701 - add single?
3. 00:44:736 - Same as above (this fix is just a suggestion, feel free to ignore)
4. 00:53:862 - k
5. 01:08:652 - ^
6. 01:12:008 - ^
7. 01:18:722 - ^
8. 01:21:869 - ddk
9. 01:25:435 - k
10. 01:30:470 - Move here 01:30:575 (if you want it to follow the vocal)
11. 01:31:099 - Same as above
12. 01:42:218 - k
13. 02:25:015 - Add single
14. 02:30:890 - k
15. 02:40:959 - ^
16. 02:47:673 - ^
17. 04:23:337 - ^

Jona wrote:

Mod as requested :3
Btw, I'm not the best at modding easier diffs (still kinda new to it), and they are really good, not much to point out. Sorry if they ended up too short

[Kantan]

1. Change HP to 3? Long and slow-bpm map, I think it fits better than HP4. -fixed
2. 01:31:729 - k -fixed
3. 02:17:463 - -fixed
4. 05:02:778 - Feels kind of wrong, consider changing it. -I agree, changed to this

[Futsuu]

1. 01:19:980 - Add single -fixed
2. 02:21:134 - k -fixed
3. 03:37:603 and 03:38:022 sounds off-beat. -removed the first note, I think the other note is fine

[Muzukashii]

1. OD4 fits better imo -fixed
2. 01:08:652 - k -fixed
3. 01:09:071 - Move here 01:08:862 ? -moved and extended
4. 02:00:890 - Move k k to 02:01:309 (sounds more correct imo) -good idea, but I think it's better the way it is
5. 02:11:589 - d -nope
6. 02:12:428 - k -fixed
7. 02:15:994 - Add single -nope
8. 02:30:890 - k -fixed
9. 03:00:260 - Consider changing this to notes/make spinner longer, kind of akward to have a drumroll and then a spinner right after.-changed to this

[Oni]

1. 00:39:491 - Move here 00:39:281 ? -nope
2. 00:39:701 - add single? -nope
3. 00:44:736 - Same as above (this fix is just a suggestion, feel free to ignore) -fixed
4. 00:53:862 - k -fixed
5. 01:08:652 - ^ -nope
6. 01:12:008 - ^ -nope
7. 01:18:722 - ^ -nope
8. 01:21:869 - ddk -nope
9. 01:25:435 - k -nope
10. 01:30:470 - Move here 01:30:575 (if you want it to follow the vocal) -nope
11. 01:31:099 - Same as above -nope
12. 01:42:218 - k -fixed
13. 02:25:015 - Add single -good idea, but I prefer this
14. 02:30:890 - k -nope
15. 02:40:959 - ^ -nope
16. 02:47:673 - ^ -nope
17. 04:23:337 - ^ -nope

Awesome map, GL dude!!

binaryfruit wrote:

Howdy! Mod request via pm.

If I remember correctly, only your hardest diff can have a special diffname (i.e. you should name them kantan/futsuu/muzukashii/nova)... but I personally think that rule is silly and your diffnames are fine so you can leave that be xD
BN's and QAT's may not agree though

5 minutes is pretty long! I'm only going to mod the hardest diff.

Intro is good, I feel the first verse would be improved if you made it a little more dense:
00:39:281 - ddd -added the dons at 00:39:491 instead
00:40:959 - put something here -added d
00:44:316 - d -added k instead
00:46:204 - k -added d instead

01:10:750 (58) - This SV is cool, but it feels out of place to have this big kat going faster than the approaching SV (what I mean is, this one note doesnt seem to be accenting anything, so I don't think it should have so much SV on it). Why don;t you change 01:10:540 (57) - to 1.15 SV, and 01:10:750 (58) - to 1.2 SV, then the chorus to 1.25 or so? -good idea, but I've already received quite a bit of positive feedback regarding the sv changes. Changing it to what you've suggested works, but it doesn't have the same surprise effect. I will keep this in mind though

01:45:575 - map this? I know there's not much going on here but it's such a long break... -I really want to keep this break since I think it fits with the song. I just want to map whatever suits the song since I don't really care about approval.

02:03:197 - k -fixed

02:33:617 (30) - see above^

03:23:127 (62) - hm, why not make this k k k, to match the cymbals? -changed to k k d instead

03:43:224 - see above^

04:31:938 - ddk? -fixed

Good luck with your rank!

ghm12 wrote:

mod from #modreqs

mod

[General]
Check AIMod, you have almost every possible conflict error with "Nova" difficulty, because the title on that diff is wrong (It's Little Nova, and you put only "Nova"). By the way, this issue makes the import works wrong, you DEFINITELY need to fix it. -fixed
Source should be "東方Project", since ZUN call touhou as it -fixed
You should also put the original song on tags (including the japanese one)
Remove the "Saigyouji.Yuyuko.full.1708688.jpg" from "taikyuyuko" folder. I'm sure it's useless, since there's a equal image in the song's folder. -fixed
Use this code in every .osu file, for a better position bg:

[Events]
//Background and Video events
0,0,"Saigyouji.Yuyuko.full.1708688.jpg",0,65
//Break Periods
2,105775,117801
2,223257,235284
//Storyboard Layer 0 (Background)
//Storyboard Layer 1 (Fail)
//Storyboard Layer 2 (Pass)
//Storyboard Layer 3 (Foreground)
//Storyboard Sound Samples

-fixed
I would suggest to finish the second kiai in 03:01:099 -, and the last one in 04:36:764 - -fixed
About diffnames, I'm not sure if you can use it. You should take a look here, and the names don't point the diff by itself in my opinion.

[Mini Nova]
00:23:337 - Did you forgot a finish here? -fixed
00:41:379 - This Inherited Line is useless, please delete it -fixed
00:42:848 - ^ same -fixed
00:51:029 - maybe a k? -fixed
00:54:386 - maaaybe a k? -fixed
00:56:904 - Finish? -fixed
01:00:260 - Finish? -fixed
01:06:973 - k d K? Fits better for me -fixed
01:26:064 - d k k here? -fixed
01:43:687 - Finish? -fixed
02:24:176 - k? -fixed
02:29:631 - k? -fixed
02:32:778 - Since it's a Kantan (At least should be), I think you shouldn't use 1/2 notes -fixed
02:53:966 - k? There's a reasonable sound!-fixed
02:55:015 - d? I mean, here it's a lot beat -fixed
04:15:155 - k to match vocal maybe? -fixed
04:21:029 - d? low beat -fixed
04:53:337 - d? it's a low beat, then use k on 04:53:966 - -fixed
04:56:064 - k? high sound -fixed
05:00:680 - maybe k d? -fixed
05:02:778 - This slider should end in 05:03:407 -, then spin starts in 05:03:617 - and finish in 05:10:330 -, and maybe add a low volume there (reducing 60%) -fixed

Well, I'm dropping to mod this map.
To be very honest, I didn't like the "Mini Nova" diff, because there are some notes that doesn't follow the song in a good way, and also there are some weird spacings, making a bit weird to listen and play. I would recommend trying to listen the whole map and fix what sounds a bit weird, and of course, nerfing a bit, it should be the easiest difficulty of the set. -I will try to nerf the easier difficulties a bit more
When I was going to mod the "Little Nova" one, I just saw the SAME problems. I didn't look the last two diffs, but man, if they have the same problem, your map would be ranked in something like 5 years. Take a look in every difficulty and fix what definitely sounds weird, because uh, you definitely need to. -I'm sorry to hear that, but I will definitely take a closer look at my difficulties.

Julie wrote:

Yay here you go flaus :3!! GL~

[General]

- In your skin, you have 3 hitsound unuse, "taiko-soft-hitnormal", "taiko-soft-hitwhistle" and "taiko-soft-hitfinish". You only used Normal sample set xD. You can change them here http://puu.sh/hIOKa.png (in the timing setting) or here http://puu.sh/hIOLj.jpg (on the left) if you still wish to use your soft sampleset.

- Unconsistent Kiai in "Super Nova", all your other difficulty 1st kiai start here 01:12:008 - , while "Super Nova it start here 01:11:169 - .

[Mini Nova]

02:32:778 (41,42,43,44,45) - Not suggested for your Mini Nova, the only part that is 1/2 without break

03:11:799 (7) - delete not important sound for Kantan, the sound is really low and is repetitif

03:10:120 (5) - and 03:12:638 (8) - ^ try choose part that will be easy to play for beginner, there to much rhythmn changing, and picking random sound to map ><

03:21:554 (20) - Really not suggest, and is the ONLY one that is on blue stick xD.

04:09:281 (17) - delete no new sound

04:47:673 (84) - move to 04:47:883 - , since your mapping these 04:46:204 - 04:46:624 - drum sound.

05:03:722 (1) - start spinner here 05:03:827 - , not new sound on blue stick.

[Little Nova]

00:42:638 (19) - Suggest removing drum roll, there no drum stream sound only a triplet xD. And add a tapable note here 00:43:477 - ? Like you did for Kantan, important tap note~. -fixed

00:45:575 (22) - I think accidently put in the wrong space? I think you wanted it to put it here 00:45:365 - for vocal and sound. -fixed

01:09:701 (54) - delete -fixed

01:20:820 - map this too if your going to match all the vocal here 01:19:141 (75,76,77,78,79,80,81) - -fixed

02:07:813 (12) - delete, no important new sound, the new sound is really minor xD -fixed

02:12:008 (21,22) - k? make it different from 02:11:799 (20) - , due to the piano -fixed

02:18:512 (37) - move to 02:18:302 - , since you been following the piano here 02:17:463 (34,35,36) - . -fixed

02:33:197 (79) - k, different drum then 02:32:778 (77,78) - -nope

03:27:743 (46) - delete, too long~ Also leave break for this note 03:27:952 (47) - -fixed

03:59:211 (5) - move to 03:59:001 - , like part before matching vocal, and if your going to say piano, this 03:59:421 - also have piano xD. -N/A

04:39:596 (121) - the snare sound is here 04:39:701 - , since the sound I think your trying to match, isn't fully snap on blue stick ;w;...so suggest put it for that drum instead. -N/A

04:41:274 (125) - the sound your mapping for this 04:40:540 (123,124,126) - is here 04:41:379 - -N/A

[Nova]

I'm going to supoose this should be muzukashii right? If yes try avoid kkd or ddk or kdd or dkk, muzukashii player can't really these pattern, these are oni pattern. You might see some ddk in muzukashii, which is what I think the limit, but they won't abuse you, only a few. Most triplet in muzukashii should be ddd or kkk.
01:03:197 (103,104,105) - , 01:07:183 (116,117,118) - , 01:15:575 (141,142,143) - , 01:17:883 (151,152,153) - ,01:18:512 (155,156,157) - , 01:22:288 (170,171,172) - , 01:29:001 (194,195,196) - , 01:31:309 (204,205,206) - , 01:31:938 (208,209,210) - , 01:35:715 (223,224,225) - , 02:25:435 (80,81,82) - , 02:29:421 (96,97,98) - , 02:32:148 (109,110,111) - , 02:34:456 (118,119,120) - , 02:37:813 (132,133,134) - , 02:40:120 (142,143,144) - , 02:51:239 (183,184,185) - , 02:57:952 (212,213,214) - , 03:00:260 (223,224,225) - , 03:23:966 (57,58,59) - , 04:02:568 (12,13,14) - , 04:05:924 (18,19,20) - , 04:10:120 (32,33,34) - , 04:13:477 (46,47,48) - , 04:20:190 (70,71,72) - , 04:23:547 (82,83,84) - , 04:27:533 (99,100,101) - , 04:32:778 (117,118,119) - , 04:33:617 (122,123,124) - , 04:36:973 (135,136,137) - , 04:40:330 (151,152,153) - , 04:42:638 (162,163,164) - , 04:43:687 (1,2,3) - , 04:49:351 (22,23,24) - , 04:50:400 (27,28,29) - , 04:53:757 (41,42,43) - , 05:00:470 (69,70,71) - . -fixed triplets

00:25:645 (6,7,8,9,10,11) - You're following vocal here, change this 00:26:274 (8) - to d, should be like this one 00:25:645 (6,7) - instead of this 00:26:904 (10,11) - -I find that this suits it better

00:43:057 (43) - d, different drum from these 00:43:162 (44,45) - -nope

00:48:092 (52,53) - start a note here instead 00:47:883 - , since your mostly mapping the vocal? And piano sound so nice *^* -this kinda throws off the timing of the section

00:53:862 (71) - heeh? what is this map for? There is no new sound here nor new vocal. Map this 00:53:966 - instead, vocal + pianooo *^* (even if your not mapping for piano XD, but vocal~) -I rather just remove the note without changing anything else

00:54:386 - Important piano + vocal, suggest adding a note. -doesn't really suit the section

00:57:743 - ^, really feel empty and losing rhythmn. -fixed

01:00:575 (94) - no new sound, doesn't play well on a blue stick xD. -fixed

01:01:099 - same reason as 00:54:386 - -fixed

01:07:708 - another triplet here? have drum sound~ -i'll keep in mind

01:08:862 (125) - lolol, make this slider so it fit in the editor mode, like your last point can also be reach in the editor mode (just in case it dont go unrankable because of baka reasonn in editor xD) You can make it curve or anything it will still be a simple drum roll in taiko :3.
And between, I don't suggest making a drum roll here, since there no drum stream, just some few drum notes that could be map. -fixed,I want to keep the drum roll

01:32:568 (211) - k, since you put all k on snare lolol -fixed

01:33:617 (215) - finish for cymbal? Since you also did it here 01:30:260 (200) - xD -fixed

02:00:890 (4,5) - uhh I'm not sure if those are random or mistake www, move it here instead 02:01:309 - for vocal like you did here 02:00:260 (2,3) - . -it was intentional

02:08:442 (25) - ohh a note for pianoo, how about this one 02:08:652 - , it has important piano note + vocal~ -I don't like mapping too many parts at once

02:21:764 - add a note there is a drum sound, can hear a triplet pretty clearly, even when playing. -fixed

02:33:197 (114) - k for snare. -the guitar is more prominent

03:00:680 (226,227,228,229) - all k, keep your snare consistent, like look how you did this 03:00:260 (223,224,225) - . -I think this suits it better

03:04:876 - to 03:12:848 - really to tricky to play, all same rhythmn and sound ><. -I'm keeping this

03:11:590 (20,21,22) - map for lower volume sound but your not mapping the rest. Either delete or map the rest. -nope

03:23:337 - d, same sound as 03:23:127 (55) - . -fixed

03:25:855 - d, continue the piano sound, important one -fixed

03:31:729 (85) - move it here 03:31:938 - , not new sound much, is just, except that instrument that start here 03:31:519 - . Can delete this 03:32:148 (86) - if your adding a note. -doesn't play well

03:57:113 - to 04:02:568 - confusing rhythmn, sometimes mapping for vocal, then don't map for vocal and sometimes map for piano, then don't map for piano. Keep it consistent x.x. Really to confusing and note feel randomly placed xD. -I disagree with this

05:03:092 (83) - delete, you didn't put a note here in "Super Nova"-nope

[Super Nova]

00:23:757 - to 00:29:211 - either follow vocal or piano, it feel like you made your own rhythmn here xD. -Since this is an Oni difficulty I was trying not to follow the vocals or piano too closely throughout the song, I'll keep this in mind

00:39:911 (34) - add finish, also cymbal sound like this 00:40:120 (35) - -I don't think this deserves a finish

00:50:820 (61) - isn't better move it here 00:51:029 - , it has piano + vocal -I feel like there's too long of a pause between phrases here, but I will keep this in mind

00:53:862 (73) - move to 00:53:966 - , no new sound there, instrument and vocal are at 00:53:966 - -I feel like this note helps resolve the other blue tick note at 00:55:540 but I will keep this in mind

00:56:064 - add a note, continue the piano sound here 00:55:225 (78,1,2) - -I don't think this fits with my mapping style at this section

02:05:295 (17,18,19) - kdd or dkk , make these 2 02:05:400 (18,19) - different from 02:05:295 (17) - -fixed

02:23:337 - missing important piano + vocal here -that was intentional, but I will keep it in mind

02:33:197 (29) - k, since all these drum you put k xD -I think the dons are better for the build-up here

02:47:358 (97) - ^, kkddd :3 -fixed

03:00:785 (160,161,162,163) - all these dsame drum as 03:00:680 (159) - -I really don't like having the drum roll there

02:29:841 (11,12,13,14,15) - dkkdd? 02:29:945 (12) - k for snare -I don't think the snare sound is prominent enough for me to put a k here

05:01:309 (288,289) - remove finish, cymbal sound only here 05:01:729 (290) - -fixed

Sorry took me some time~ ><

mrdumpling64 wrote:

just thought i'd pop in.

custom diff names for taiko are not allowed in this circumstance (unless your diff is made by a guest mapper or it is the hardest diff in a mapset/approval diff). i know the diff names make the degree of difficulty obvious, but the idea of using custom names other than for the reasons i wrote above is already controversial in Taiko.

i suggest you change back to Kantan-Futsuu-Muzukashii-Oni (or Super Nova). you can ignore me if you want, but your change of having a qat intervene increases.

Flaus wrote:

Thanks NoLifePlayer for the mod!

1. 00:40:959
2. 00:44:316
3. 02:06:973
4. 03:39:701
   The green lines AFTER these are useless (most are only present in Oni). 03:04:875 and this one too. I've probably missed others.
   
5. Kiai time lengths are inconsistent.
   
6. Certain important taiko people are pretty against breaks in taiko :p

1. 01:28:267 (152) - You can probably delete this to not overdo this part. It does hurt spread with Muzukashii a little.
   
2. In the kiais, I notice that you start of with simple normal patterns liek d k d ddd k d etc, but around 01:25:434 you begin to have doubles, 5plets, kkd patterns etc. Meanwhile Muzukashii looks the same as it did for the first half. Since Kiai is just a verse repeating twice (musically, not lyrics) it'd be wise to keep both halves looking similar. Some additions can be made to spice it up a bit but spread must always be a priority.
   
3. 02:04:246 (12,13) - k d like in Muzu (and other diffs) to follow vocals?
4. 02:06:973 (20,21,22,23,24,25,26) - I don't really know what you're following here. Applies to other diffs.
   
5. For the second kiai, my complaint is that it's harder than the last kiai, plus it's super different from the first once despite the song doing the same thing as the first chorus. Going a little crazy for 143 bpm lol. Meanwhile Muzu is about the same as the first kiai, which obviously won't work. When you fix the first kiai, make this second one similar, but add some things if you'd like.
   
6. 03:24:176 (68) - k? Snare hit.
7. 03:27:952 (83,84,85,86,87,88) - It'd be nicer if the notes mapped to piano instead of the small hi-hat hits,
   
8. This 3rd kiai is nicer than the others! Maintains an identity throughout.
   
9. 05:03:406 (315,316) - k for both? More snare hits.

• OD5 here as well. 4 is super low.

1. 02:05:399 (14) - Since Oni has a triplet, this can be 1/2 so it's not a jump from Futsuu.
2. 02:12:008 (29) - Deleting this sounds nice and makes nice spread.
3. 02:18:092 (47) - Should be kkk for spread.
4. 02:25:539 (73) - Remove since Oni also has kkd, plus kkd is weird in Muzu.
5. 02:57:113 - From here on (in kiai) there's too many notes, hence Oni needs to be nerfed so this doesn't look like it actually would be needed.
6. 03:06:973 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - This part has more notes than Oni lol.
7. 03:22:602 (53) - Not needed since Oni has a note here.
8. 03:23:966 (58,59,60) - ^ d k?
9. 03:27:008 (69,71) - ^ delete?
10. 03:34:665 (93,94,95,96,97,98,99,100,101,102,103,104,105) - Close to Oni, far from Futsuu. Delete notes?
11. 03:59:420 (6) - Extra note on Muzu.
12. 04:32:777 (120,121,122,123,124,125,126,127,128,129,130,131) - Touching toes with Oni here (like the other kiai)
13. 04:36:973 - Notes get way to dense for Muzu after this part.