1. Euphoria (4,92 stars, 1220 notes)

XTheSabreGamerX wrote:

Modded, Observed and tested. Everything is timed well and I think this is ready for Qualified state!

1. 00:10:972 (1) - use same shape, also move the middle anchor of 00:10:972 (1) - to the center
2. 00:12:344 (1) - center anchor
3. 00:13:715 (1,3) - same shape, it has to be perfectly symetrical
4. 00:17:829 (1,2) - ^
5. 01:03:086 (1) - maybe ctrl+j this? i mean, it would have more flow
6. 01:46:972 (1,3) - same shape
7. 02:18:515 (1) - maybe ctrl+h for better flow and make a blanket with 02:17:658 (2) - ?
8. 04:19:201 (1,2) - i think these 2 aren't doing a perfect blanket
9. 05:09:944 (1,2,3) - the flow here is a little weird imo
10. 05:18:001 (10) - maybe move this a slighly down to make a blanket with 05:17:486 (9,1) - ?

Kagetsu wrote:

random mod from #modreqs

[Euphoria]

1. 00:10:972 (1) - use same shape, also move the middle anchor of 00:10:972 (1) - to the center
2. 00:12:344 (1) - center anchor
3. 00:13:715 (1,3) - same shape, it has to be perfectly symetrical
4. 00:17:829 (1,2) - ^
5. 01:03:086 (1) - maybe ctrl+j this? i mean, it would have more flow
6. 01:46:972 (1,3) - same shape
7. 02:18:515 (1) - maybe ctrl+h for better flow and make a blanket with 02:17:658 (2) - ?
8. 04:19:201 (1,2) - i think these 2 aren't doing a perfect blanket
9. 05:09:944 (1,2,3) - the flow here is a little weird imo
10. 05:18:001 (10) - maybe move this a slighly down to make a blanket with 05:17:486 (9,1) - ?

yeah... my points are a little nazi, but that's because your map is good and i can't find much more since i'm a noob mapper/modder lol

Good luck with this ^^

1. You have missing skin files in [Hitobjects] set: lighting.png
2. You also have missing skin files in [Slider] set: sliderb.png and sliderfollowcircle.png

1. 01:35:315 (4) - I would add a new combo here since this slider velocity is lower than the previous note at 01:34:972 (3).
2. 01:53:657 (5) - The end of this slider is unsnapped. Just drag the slider back and forth in the time frame and it should fix itself.
3. 04:20:315 (3) - This slider sounds weired compare to the 1st kiai section at 01:33:001 (3) due to different sounds. I would just revamp the pattern at 04:19:886 (2,3) somehow. Also, 04:20:572 (1) is not perfectly stacked with the start of 04:19:886 (2).

BeatofIke wrote:

Hi Katty Pie. Amazing map you got there. Just a few things to mention, before I move this map forward:

[General]

1. You have missing skin files in [Hitobjects] set: lighting.png
2. You also have missing skin files in [Slider] set: sliderb.png and sliderfollowcircle.png

[Euphoria]

1. 01:35:315 (4) - I would add a new combo here since this slider velocity is lower than the previous note at 01:34:972 (3).
2. 01:53:657 (5) - The end of this slider is unsnapped. Just drag the slider back and forth in the time frame and it should fix itself.
3. 04:20:315 (3) - This slider sounds weired compare to the 1st kiai section at 01:33:001 (3) due to different sounds. I would just revamp the pattern at 04:19:886 (2,3) somehow. Also, 04:20:572 (1) is not perfectly stacked with the start of 04:19:886 (2).

Thank U for mod :3 All done

Okoratu wrote:

01:34:629 (1,2) - obvious 1/3
ike please doublecheck snapping in the wub part before moving this forward

I don't have the necessary freetime to take care of this so i hope this isn't bothering you, i just don't want this thing to go unnoticed and would advise doublechecking snapping

Vopla wrote:

small mod

• 00:12:172 - There's a strong audible drum here, is there a certain reason why there aren't any circles on this spot?
  00:17:658 - ^
  05:00:172 - ^
  05:16:629 - ^

I really liked the hitsounding! It just feels really weird for such big drums being left out. Maybe there's a reason that I haven't figured out but here we go with my first mod.

1. 00:25:029 (2,4) - nazi, stack
2. 00:36:001 (2,3) - better to stack, may cause confusion
3. 00:43:029 (2,3,4) - an awkward flow(in fact antijump) imo, try this? http://puu.sh/mDTsC/7cac111e86.jpg
4. 00:46:457 (4,1) - make this distance a bit larger? the drum sound quite emphasizes
5. 01:28:972 (1) - 01:29:486 (2) - extend to blue tick at least thanks, it sounds like broken now
6. 01:29:829 (3,4) - the rhythm just goes wrong here, should be like http://puu.sh/mDTAN/d9fa0e878b.jpg
7. 01:39:772 (5,1) - swap nc and nc at 01:40:458 (5) - ? just my view
8. 02:33:772 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - try a decreasing ds on this stream, works better
9. 04:03:344 - why no note? why not extend 04:02:744 (1) - ????????????
10. 04:16:801 (2) - same as01:28:972 (1) -
11. 04:17:144 (3,4) - again, same as 01:29:829 (3,4) -
12. 04:27:086 (5,1,5) - same as 01:39:772 (5,1) -

Minakami Yuki wrote:

1. Just some complaints.
2. My personal suggestions.
3. Highly recommended.
4. Unrankable, you have to fix it.

Euphoria

1. 00:25:029 (2,4) - nazi, stack
2. 00:36:001 (2,3) - better to stack, may cause confusion
3. 00:43:029 (2,3,4) - an awkward flow(in fact antijump) imo, try this? http://puu.sh/mDTsC/7cac111e86.jpg
4. 00:46:457 (4,1) - make this distance a bit larger? the drum sound quite emphasizes
5. 01:28:972 (1) - 01:29:486 (2) - extend to blue tick at least thanks, it sounds like broken now
6. 01:29:829 (3,4) - the rhythm just goes wrong here, should be like http://puu.sh/mDTAN/d9fa0e878b.jpg
7. 01:39:772 (5,1) - swap nc and nc at 01:40:458 (5) - ? just my view
8. 02:33:772 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - try a decreasing ds on this stream, works better <--- I don't like ._.
9. 04:03:344 - why no note? why not extend 04:02:744 (1) - ????????????
10. 04:16:801 (2) - same as01:28:972 (1) -
11. 04:17:144 (3,4) - again, same as 01:29:829 (3,4) -
12. 04:27:086 (5,1,5) - same as 01:39:772 (5,1) -

Minakami Yuki wrote:

seems you havent change the rhythm at 01:29:829 (3,4) - also 04:17:144 (3,4) - , imo it's very obvious that the beat is at 01:30:001 - and 04:17:315 - , i cant see any reason why you dont choose to follow the music. Can you give me some explanation of keeping it?

also, extend 04:16:286 (1) - to 04:16:715 - ?

Minakami Yuki wrote:

Approved!

1. You have to add SliderBorder yo your skinset. You can do it by editing your .osu difficulty and adding something like SliderBorder: 255,255,255 (where 255,255,255 can be replaced with any RGB colour you want.(
   
   Code

   [Colours]
   Combo1 : 77,253,218
   Combo2 : 28,238,255
   Combo3 : 155,255,255
   Combo4 : 32,32,255
   Combo5 : 128,128,255
   SliderBorder: 255,255,255

2. I believe that the animation of the sliderball does not work the way you intend it to. There are 10 frames and they are identical. Either add a working animation or remove the unnecessary frames.

• 
  Poggo
  

1. 00:12:172 - even though it's already been offered once, I'd like to make sure that you don't want a circle here. The beat is really strong and in spite of the fact that it's a slow part I'd strongly suggest to have it clickable.
2. 00:25:886 - there is a certain number of extended sliders which ignore beats like the one I linked. If you want more examples, 00:31:544 (1) - this one has a clear stop at 00:31:715.
   Note: 00:32:915 (1) - there are more than that, so I'd like to hear from you why it is done that way. Probably it's better to focus on stronger beats instead of using extended sliders that sound unnatural?

1. 01:56:572 (7) - probbly could use a new combo to emphasize the 1/3 beat here.

Bakari wrote:

Greetings.

I am sorry, but we've got a few things to consider before pushing this forward. Points in bold are the reasons why it was disqualified.

[General]

1. You have to add SliderBorder yo your skinset. You can do it by editing your .osu difficulty and adding something like SliderBorder: 255,255,255 (where 255,255,255 can be replaced with any RGB colour you want.(
   
   Code

   [Colours]
   Combo1 : 77,253,218
   Combo2 : 28,238,255
   Combo3 : 155,255,255
   Combo4 : 32,32,255
   Combo5 : 128,128,255
   SliderBorder: 255,255,255

   <--- done
2. I believe that the animation of the sliderball does not work the way you intend it to. There are 10 frames and they are identical. Either add a working animation or remove the unnecessary frames.

<--- done

[Euphoria]

• 
  Poggo
  

1. 00:12:172 - even though it's already been offered once, I'd like to make sure that you don't want a circle here. The beat is really strong and in spite of the fact that it's a slow part I'd strongly suggest to have it clickable.
2. 00:25:886 - there is a certain number of extended sliders which ignore beats like the one I linked. If you want more examples, 00:31:544 (1) - this one has a clear stop at 00:31:715.
   Note: 00:32:915 (1) - there are more than that, so I'd like to hear from you why it is done that way. Probably it's better to focus on stronger beats instead of using extended sliders that sound unnatural?

Shadren

1. 01:56:572 (7) - probbly could use a new combo to emphasize the 1/3 beat here.

Pretty interesting mix of styles. Good luck on re-qualification.

Feel free to contact me if you want something translated/explained better. The post is written in English, so that everyone is free to join the discussion.