1. Fire (2.94 stars, 156 notes)
2. Fyah!! (4.93 stars, 39 notes)
3. Water (0.68 stars, 61 notes)

sonnyc wrote:

Thanks for modding

Fyah!!:
00:47:513 (4,5,6,7) - These aren't stacked properly, as it looks very gay in play mode

^ but how should I change this..

St Neon wrote:

In Fyah!! Difficulty, the note stacking gets odd. Exapmle, 1:09:310, you time these stacked notes nicely, but then at 1:10:013, you stack five notes that aren't spaced the same, making it confusing. Try to watch the use, or overuse, of note stacking.

ziin wrote:

awesome song

[water]
good

[fire]
01:23:138 (6) - don't stack Change
01:26:185 (1,2,3) - make a line? Just don't zigzag. Made a line
02:11:185 (3,4,5) - doesn't fit It seems Ok to me..

[fyah!!]
use 1.8 slider speed and slow the 2x section down to 1.5? 1.6x2=3.2 which is quite hard, 1.8*1.5=2.7, which is more easily manageable.
I don't like the streams with no beat in the background. Instead of streams, use jumps? Uh.. I think people could manage it, and that's why it is fyah..

IceBeam wrote:

[Water]
00:36:966- Clap?
00:43:060 (1) - Finish.
00:58:997 (2) - Hm,I'd reduce volume here,or change to soft sampleset,also,add claps so one after each 3 ticks?
01:43:060 (1) - Finish?
01:49:856 - Break seems unnecessary.
01:58:060 (1) - Same thing,soft/claps?
02:05:560 (1) - Finish.

[Fire]
00:58:997 - Same as in easy,I'd like to see reduced volume or soft samplet,and claps after each 3 white ticks from this point.
01:05:560 (1) - Finish.
01:58:060 -

[Fyah!!]
Still,the only things disturb me are 00:58:997 & 01:58:060..Volume is too loud,and notes sound rough.
2x is

Star.

1. The inconsistence between diffs, really bother me, I think you should map all the diffs until here: 02:46:810 - like "Fyah!!".
2. You should get rid of those "( )" in the title, It should be like this: "Park Myung ft. Gill" (Just remove the parenthesis)

1. 00:39:310 (1,2,3,4) - half of (3) is getting covered by (1) try moving it down, like a vertical flip.
2. 02:05:560 (1,2) - These sliders look odd, try this instead.
3. Just an advice for your next maps use 0.75 instead of 0.5, 0.5 is so unexpected and it breaks the flow. Now, If you want to fix it on this map, It'd be great.

1. 01:41:067 (1) - End this spinner here: 01:42:122 - , This spinner is already a bit short to finish it there will fix the problem.

1. Seems fine.

Gonzvlo wrote:

General

1. The inconsistence between diffs, really bother me, I think you should map all the diffs until here: 02:46:810 - like "Fyah!!". Sorry, from next maps..
2. You should get rid of those "( )" in the title, It should be like this: "Park Myung ft. Gill" (Just remove the parenthesis)
   But that is the actual name of the song

Water

1. 00:39:310 (1,2,3,4) - half of (3) is getting covered by (1) try moving it down, like a vertical flip.
   Putted to the down
2. 02:05:560 (1,2) - These sliders look odd, try this instead.
   Used
3. Just an advice for your next maps use 0.75 instead of 0.5, 0.5 is so unexpected and it breaks the flow. Now, If you want to fix it on this map, It'd be great.
   Well, personally I don't think 0.75 is good..

Firel

1. 01:41:067 (1) - End this spinner here: 01:42:122 - , This spinner is already a bit short to finish it there will fix the problem.
   I can't under stand, it's already ending at there

Fya!!

1. Seems fine.

Thanks for the mod!!

1. 00:47:513 (4,5,6) - stack leniency +1 to make them stack
2. 02:35:560 (T) - add 1 note here
3. 02:47:278 (T) - set this section at 02:46:927

1. 02:29:935 (1) - end this at 02:35:560

1. 02:15:403 (T) - set this section at 02:15:052

Colin Hou wrote:

[Fyah!]:

1. 00:47:513 (4,5,6) - stack leniency +1 to make them stack
2. 02:35:560 (T) - add 1 note here
3. 02:47:278 (T) - set this section at 02:46:927

[Fire]:

1. 02:29:935 (1) - end this at 02:35:560

[Water]:

1. 02:15:403 (T) - set this section at 02:15:052

star~

1. 01:15:872 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - I have to admit these notes are deadly difficult for first try. change them to something else plz.
2. 01:30:872 (4) - new combo
3. 01:34:622 (5) - ^
4. 01:57:122 (7) - new combo
5. 01:57:591, 01:58:060 (T) - add notes, finish on the 2nd one. (place jump here XD)
6. 02:17:981 (9) - a bit HP touch, nazi XD
7. 02:29:935 (T) - end the KIAI here

1. 02:28:528 (1) - lol start this at 02:29:935 and end the KIAI here

1. I don't really like the difficulty names... I fail to see how they relate to the song (except for the last one), and I don't really agree with the order... Why would water be easier than fire, when water is stronger than fire in... Everything both are used in ?
2. I think the break placement isn't very fitting... You cut choruses and bridges in the middle. Only the second break (in Easy and Normal) is good in my opinion. Try re-thinking their placement. :/
3. The 0.5 section appears to be random. The song isn't even slower at that part or anything... It just doesn't have bass sounds. If anything, use the soft sampleset, but don't reduce the speed, it's counterintuitive and doesn't fit the song.

1. Map this to the end.

1. This is really hard for a Normal. A lot of rhythms aren't intuitive and some patterns are rather confusing... The difficulty gap between this and Easy is too high anyway. The difficulty settings are way too high.
2. 00:32:278 (2,3) - Using a stack for the first 1/2 of the diff is a bit harsh. Remember stacks make timing more confusing than spaced notes, since the player has to read the approach circle (which will be hidden under hitbursts after a short time) and can't use the spacing to read the rhythm. I tend to use sliders for the few first 1/2 of the map in Normal and Easy diffs, as they are easy to play, and give an indication of the 1/2 rhythm for the rest of the map.
3. 00:43:060 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,4) - Very confusing and unintuitive rhythms for a Normal...
4. 01:14:935 (1,1) - Same.
5. 01:22:200 (4,5,6) - Same... Except it's even worse because they are circles... That kind of rhythm is extremely difficult to hit for new players, especially because the spacing is hard to discern from 1/2 spacing.
6. 01:23:606 (1,2,3,4) - Same.
7. 01:41:067 (1) - Why does this start on a blue tick ? Also, it's too short for a spinner in a Normal diff imo
8. 01:43:060 (1) - Same rhythm ever again
9. 02:11:185 (3) - same
10. 02:14:935 (1) - This appears too soon after the spinner. New players need a (long) recovery time after spinners to readjust their aim. Placing an object so soon after the spinner doesn't leave room for the player to do that.
11. 02:16:810 (1,1) - same...
12. 02:23:372 (2) - I tend to think repeat sliders with more than one repeat are confusing, since the other repeats wouldn't always be expected, and due to the usually low slider velocity, the cursor covers the repeat arrow.
13. 02:29:935 (1) - Making a more continuous decrescendo for this spinner would sound a lot better.
14. 02:43:763 (1) - Too short spinner as well imo... for the same reasons as above. Just delete the last note and extend the spinner to there.

1. This is... Way too hard for a Hard. There are too many 1/4 (that don't even fit the song imo).
2. You need to use tick rate 2 for the speedup to be readable.