Mapping is a VINXIS thing.
forum
Primastella - Koigokoro
posted
Total Posts
119
canadian tire xdddddddddCherry Blossom wrote:
Mapping is a VINXIS thing.
It's perfect and should stay ranked.
Disqualification Notice
Hello!
Unfortunately, the Quality Assurance Team has decided to disqualify this beatmap. The following is a list of reasons and examples for the disqualification. We do not outline every issue in detail, so make sure to take the idea behind each reason and apply it to the entire beatmap as issues might be found in more than the spots mentioned below. If you have any questions, please reply to this post and we will do our best to clarify any misunderstandings.
General
Unsuitable Background
Emphasizing problems
Difficulty is generally unpolished
Unsuitable Background
- Due to visibility of the character’s underwear, we consider your background unsuitable for all age groups. Please change it.
Emphasizing problems
There are several instances, where the spacing changes severely in patterns, even though the intensity of the music doesn’t change as much. This results in weak notes being overemphasized while stronger notes lack emphasis. Remember to stress the stronger beats with bigger spacing in order to get your patterns to compliment the music better. Moreover, because of the lack of emphasis, some of the patterns appear as unpolished.
- 00:20:806 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) -
- 00:58:306 (4,1) -
- 02:20:806 (1,2,3,4,5) -
Difficulty is generally unpolished
The overall appearance of the patterns on this difficulty leaves an unpleasant impression of untidiness and randomness. We believe that this would result in negative feedback from players and questionable gameplay experience. Therefore, we consider the patterns unacceptable.
- 00:29:806 (2,3,4,1) -
- 00:38:806 (2,3) -
- 02:35:377 (3,1,2,3,4) -
There are several patterns where the music got ignored heavily, making the patterns unfitting and not enjoyable to play.
- 00:01:949 (1,1,1,1,1) -
- 00:16:949 (3) -
- 01:06:663 (5) -
The structure and complexity of the “Relaxing” difficulty are an overkill, in terms of difficulty spread of the set. Taking into consideration a relatively simple Normal, the structure of this difficulty is too complicated and intense. Consider simplification of the difficulty.
- 00:49:306 (2,3,1,2,3,4) -
- 01:43:092 (1,2,3,4) - the structure is too complex
- 02:33:663 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) -
If you happen to have concerns about this disqualification, you can contest the decision with this form. Before using this form, please read the instructions carefully.
The Beatmap Nominators may handle this mapset after the issues have been addressed.
Good luck!
###MF
it's not worth the silence
let see
Sadly
D.Q. Angel
pantsu flashes are sexual and were always considered nsfw, its totally reasonable
well now that's its out in the open again:
[Hard] CS+1 OD+2 to ensure agricultural density is maintained.
[Hard] CS+1 OD+2 to ensure agricultural density is maintained.
Blue Dragon wrote:
[General][Insane]
- What's up with that unnecessary panty shot in the BG? Can't you find a more suitable BG for this map?
there's probably more but this map DEFINITELY needs more work
- 00:11:806 (10) - forgot a clap hitsound here?
- 00:12:663 (4) - ^
- 00:14:806 (1) - Why the NC?
- 00:20:806 (1,2,3) - Why is the spacing for strong beats lower than the spacing for red tick beats? If you're going for intensity-based mapping, then you're doing the opposite of what it should be.
- 00:38:806 (3,1,3,4,5) - aren't stacked properly
- 00:51:020 (6,7,8) - Why ignore the 1/4s?
- 00:51:985 (2,3) - I'm pretty sure this is overmapping.
- 00:55:413 (2,3) - ^
- 00:58:306 (4,1) - Why the anti-jump here? That makes no sense since the intensity is much higher in this beat.
- 01:04:735 (6,7,8) - Why ignore the 1/4s?
- 01:09:127 (2,3) - overmapping
- 01:09:663 (4,5,6,7) - not sure what you can do about this one and it's mostly personal preference, but the flow here seems pretty weird to play
- 01:31:842 (2,3) - overmapping
- 01:33:663 (5,6,7,8) - This flows extremely awkward..
- 01:33:877 (6,7,8) - 1/4s ignored again
- 01:35:806 (6) - I'd make this beat much more interesting by placing it at 190;286.
- 01:45:556 (2,3) - overmapping
- 01:47:592 (6,7,8) - 1/4s ignored again
- 01:54:449 (1,2,3) - I'm pretty sure the intensity doesn't change here to make such a big difference in spacing..
- 01:55:949 (x) - Why did you skip this beat? ... and apparently every other strong beat in this section? This feels so awkward to play, it's like you're making your own rhythm in the song and ignoring what the song has to offer.
- 02:23:377 (3,4,5) - flows really weirdly
Hello DarnessAngel,
Gratz for making another Koigokoro as pretty good map, i feel sad that it was DQ. My few personal feelings about your mapset:
Wish it will help you to polish diffs and rank up this map asap.
Good luck my friend!
Gratz for making another Koigokoro as pretty good map, i feel sad that it was DQ. My few personal feelings about your mapset:
General
General
Background is slightly NSFW.
CS Value
In my personal opinion after playing hard difficulty, changing CS value into 4 would be a great idea. I think DoubleTime players will not feel bad with this but additionaly, playing this nomod would make it more fun due better jump spread and better playground visibility (sorry if it sounds weird, hard to take this feeling properly from my heart ^^).
Additionaly Relaxing CS4 vs Hard CS3 following into Insane CS4 looks strange.
117's Normal
While playing it i had weird idea - i am missing something in circle flow to the music.
00:41:377 (1,2) - In this moment, placing 2 additional notes would fill in my opinion missing beats. What you think about this: http://puu.sh/iUgBm.jpg ?
02:08:806 (1) - This one note is placed right when vocal starts and at same moment right before break time. In my opinion ending on slider before and leaving vocal without any notes fits better to this pattern.
Relaxing
00:29:806 (2,3,4,1) - Swapping 3 and 4 can create better flow in this pattern (example: http://puu.sh/iUhlu.jpg)
00:38:806 (2,3) - Insteed of slider 2 i could place 2 notes following to slider 3 (example: http://puu.sh/iUhFs.jpg)
00:49:306 (2,3,1,2,3,4) - Sliders 3,1,2,3 i could place in follow line (example: http://puu.sh/iUj1Y.jpg) which makes it less complicated and created flow into next combo
01:43:092 (1,2,3,4,1) - What you think about making this pattern simple like example above?
02:35:377 (3,1,2,3,4) - Here is my idea or changing this pattern:
Image: http://puu.sh/iUi85.jpg
(3) - X:256, Y:320
(1) - X:192, Y:256
(2) - X:128, Y:192
(3) - X:192, Y:128
(4) - X:256, Y:192
General
Background is slightly NSFW.
CS Value
In my personal opinion after playing hard difficulty, changing CS value into 4 would be a great idea. I think DoubleTime players will not feel bad with this but additionaly, playing this nomod would make it more fun due better jump spread and better playground visibility (sorry if it sounds weird, hard to take this feeling properly from my heart ^^).
Additionaly Relaxing CS4 vs Hard CS3 following into Insane CS4 looks strange.
117's Normal
While playing it i had weird idea - i am missing something in circle flow to the music.
00:41:377 (1,2) - In this moment, placing 2 additional notes would fill in my opinion missing beats. What you think about this: http://puu.sh/iUgBm.jpg ?
02:08:806 (1) - This one note is placed right when vocal starts and at same moment right before break time. In my opinion ending on slider before and leaving vocal without any notes fits better to this pattern.
Relaxing
00:29:806 (2,3,4,1) - Swapping 3 and 4 can create better flow in this pattern (example: http://puu.sh/iUhlu.jpg)
){kind=link}
00:38:806 (2,3) - Insteed of slider 2 i could place 2 notes following to slider 3 (example: http://puu.sh/iUhFs.jpg)
){kind=link}
00:49:306 (2,3,1,2,3,4) - Sliders 3,1,2,3 i could place in follow line (example: http://puu.sh/iUj1Y.jpg) which makes it less complicated and created flow into next combo
){kind=link}
01:43:092 (1,2,3,4,1) - What you think about making this pattern simple like example above?
02:35:377 (3,1,2,3,4) - Here is my idea or changing this pattern:
Image: http://puu.sh/iUi85.jpg
(3) - X:256, Y:320
(1) - X:192, Y:256
(2) - X:128, Y:192
(3) - X:192, Y:128
(4) - X:256, Y:192
Wish it will help you to polish diffs and rank up this map asap.
Good luck my friend!
inappropriate background? really? LOL better shield the children from the existance of underwear.
DarknessAngel should just replace the BG with a strike witches pantsu shot and say "they're not panties, so it's rankable" Kappa
DarknessAngel should just replace the BG with a strike witches pantsu shot and say "they're not panties, so it's rankable" Kappa
Why do QAT's need to hide behind that profile? lmao no ballz kekeke
Honestly Idgaf about this particular bg but there are so many worse bgs ranked out there. If you truly want to make this game suitable for all ages (lol) then dq all those hundreds/thousands of NSFW maps too or stop making up new rules constantly.
I was under the impression that was a swimsuit; nevermind I guess.
No one's "hiding" behind anything; it's long been a problem now that anytime a map was DQ'd, the QAT member who posted the disqualification notice would be treated as a scapegoat as if the entire takedown of the map was that person's decision alone, which it wasn't. Placing blame on someone for faults pointed out within a map when it's removed from Qualified is not the purpose of the posts, so to prevent abuse and such, a generalized QAT account was made to handle all DQ notices.Mazziv wrote:
Why do QAT's need to hide behind that profile? lmao no ballz kekeke
well its your problem if you cant ,,take the blame'' for it.
It's not an individual decision though, its not as if a single QAT member just decides to DQ a map. It's the quality assurance TEAM after all.
Sidenote: Can someone explain to me why qualified maps give PP? I'm feeling some of that post PP loss depression from this DQ
Sidenote: Can someone explain to me why qualified maps give PP? I'm feeling some of that post PP loss depression from this DQ
the point has been completely missedMazziv wrote:
well its your problem if you cant ,,take the blame'' for it.
please keep re-reading the post until you get it
1. no one would play them if they didn't give ppLitharrale wrote:
Sidenote: Can someone explain to me why qualified maps give PP? I'm feeling some of that post PP loss depression from this DQ
2. would be kind of weird to 'activate' pp only after the map got ranked
can confirm i only play the osu g a m e solely for the pp
Cut useless QQ. Just took random QQer top ranks and saw full of DT farm.
You are helpless in this case, insteed of QQ you could actualy give usefull informations to help make this mapset ranked faster.
If you realy want your damn DT-#balanced-PP, help creator, not just QQ.
You are helpless in this case, insteed of QQ you could actualy give usefull informations to help make this mapset ranked faster.
If you realy want your damn DT-#balanced-PP, help creator, not just QQ.
I wouldn't mind helping out with the issues pointed out by the QAT (and others that I can see in the map), so if you want to get it ranked that'd probably help a lot.
Yet this is fineQuality Assurance Team wrote:
Disqualification Notice
Unsuitable Background
- Due to visibility of the character’s underwear, we consider your background unsuitable for all age groups. Please change it.
?http://puu.sh/inF4o.jpg
retarded weeabo logic gg
DNA: Do not link to the old BG, thanks.
Quality Assurance Team wrote:
we consider your background unsuitable for all age groups.
actual lol
but seriously tho, what happened to ringatings (spelling w/e) edited bg? you know the censor with the butterflies?
Quality Assurance Team wrote:
Unsuitable Background
- Due to visibility of the character’s underwear, we consider your background unsuitable for all age groups. Please change it.
ahahahahahaha
hey guys, can you please stop complaining about the BG issue?
[–]houndbluedragon 11 pontos 5 hours ago
that was worded really badly but it's a kind of valid issue
I mean, there are thousands and thousands of generic anime wallpapers on the internet, why pick exactly one that has something suggestive on it?
btw I agree with Anxient, should just use Ringating's BG and go with it. easy fix, win4win
[–]houndbluedragon 11 pontos 5 hours ago
that was worded really badly but it's a kind of valid issue
I mean, there are thousands and thousands of generic anime wallpapers on the internet, why pick exactly one that has something suggestive on it?
btw I agree with Anxient, should just use Ringating's BG and go with it. easy fix, win4win
QATs are so funny
old ranking system was way better than this, same for old BATs
I'm fine if you say this is not a quality map and it needs more work, but not if more than half ranked beamaps are mapped exactly like this. Just rank it as the rest, ora just don't rank any of these maps. Don't try to find random stuff to change for no reason like the rhythm things in the [Relaxing] difficulty, please lol
this will get ignored as everything in this game
no one cares. but it's important to expose our own thoughts
don't take it as an offence, DNA. same for QATs. I just dislike the way work on this game, but I also know it's not as easy as everyone thinks.
old ranking system was way better than this, same for old BATs
I'm fine if you say this is not a quality map and it needs more work, but not if more than half ranked beamaps are mapped exactly like this. Just rank it as the rest, ora just don't rank any of these maps. Don't try to find random stuff to change for no reason like the rhythm things in the [Relaxing] difficulty, please lol
this will get ignored as everything in this game
no one cares. but it's important to expose our own thoughtsdon't take it as an offence, DNA. same for QATs. I just dislike the way work on this game, but I also know it's not as easy as everyone thinks.
The only issue that bugs me with this ranking system is the fact that the BNG and the QAT are two totally different things and don't interact with eachother.
At least with the old system, everyone gave a green light, not just half of the people.
The qualification part o the system is great though imo.
At least with the old system, everyone gave a green light, not just half of the people.
The qualification part o the system is great though imo.
lol rip my 351pp score
I expected that DQ, to be honest, haha.
Good luck on requalifying your map, that was funny to spend 30 mins playing this map with HDNCSD :3
I expected that DQ, to be honest, haha.
Good luck on requalifying your map, that was funny to spend 30 mins playing this map with HDNCSD :3
lmao this is what i expectedQuality Assurance Team wrote:
Unsuitable Background
- Due to visibility of the character’s underwear, we consider your background unsuitable for all age groups. Please change it.
Blue Dragon wrote:
hey guys, can you please stop complaining about the BG issue?
[–]houndbluedragon 11 pontos 5 hours ago
that was worded really badly but it's a kind of valid issue
I mean, there are thousands and thousands of generic anime wallpapers on the internet, why pick exactly one that has something suggestive on it?
btw I agree with Anxient, should just use Ringating's BG and go with it. easy fix, win4win
Why? Nobody has replied about the ridiculous hypocrisy even though it may not be the biggest of concerns. Just sweep it under the rug like always I guess.
Cherry Blossom wrote:
lol rip my 351pp score
why do you torture yourself like thisCherry Blossom wrote:
I expected that DQ
Can you guys chill for a bit untill the mapper is back or at least wait for the mapper's reply.