forum

Keri Hilson - I Like

posted
Total Posts
41
show more
Pereira006
[Easy]

Hitsound:

00:25:210 (4) - the begin, you don't need whistle, you can see you diff normal, that don't have whistle, so if you wanna keep consistency, remove whistle
00:40:570 (3) - ^ same happen
00:48:250 (3) - Another inconsistency as you style, this slider don't have normal on sampleset and soft on addition, but Diff Normal have, if you wanna keep consistency, add normal on sampleset and soft on addition this object
00:55:930 (2) - ^ same
00:59:770 (3) - I know there no vocal, but I feel the instrument is soo strong here, is make sense add whistle IMO
01:11:290 (3) - missing whistle
01:57:370 (3) - same happen before
02:08:890 (3) - same happen as 01:11:290 (3)
02:54:970 (3) - begin same happen before

there lot inconsistency hitsound

Gameplay:

00:34:330 (4) - Missing NC, because as you style, you put NC every 8/1, look like this missing NC
00:38:650 (1,2) - inconsistency spacing

did you copy-paste on 01:32:410 at 02:33:850 from on 00:15:610 at 01:24:730 ? I mean copy-paste only rhythm is fine but placement, is make me worry, you can't just CTRL + C -> Ctrl + V -> Ctrl + h -> Ctrl + j and leave that... would be nice if you change placement only part on 01:32:410 at 02:33:850 or begin.

The play and follow song look good but copy-paste of placement dunno

[Advanced]

look pretty good, but my problem is again copy-past of placement, same happen as Easy.

[Hard Krfawego i Bathorego]

I don't know this name are allowed, should be Collab Hard, again play look good but copy-past placement same thing happen before
[]
My bigger problem is copy-paste of placement, would be nice if change placement, also the hitsound need improve expect Hard.
Normal and advance made by creator, that should be consistency. Example on Normal 01:05:530 (1) - on begin that addition is soft but on Advanced is auto, no only this part there more parts example and I can't find wich more correct for you. Try be more consistency Hitsound.
Any question or you don't understand my english ask me on in-game and I will explain my best

I will give star icon butt right now try get more opinion BN to look this map if is fine will bubble if is not, you will change placements and get more mods 3-4.
Call me when you done everthing.
good luck
Topic Starter
Bathory Witch
00:34:330 (4) - this will continue vocal and this work fine now, it not missing combo
00:59:770 (3) - em it's not powerful so not need whistle imo

"I mean copy-paste only rhythm is fine but placement, is make me worry, you can't just CTRL + C -> Ctrl + V -> Ctrl + h -> Ctrl + j and leave that..." Andrea used it a lot, for example in map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/123174 and it is very good. also no statement in Ranking Criteria that is urankable to copy&pasta so my pattern good because nice to play and work and good rhythms. :-/

Fixed rest. Nerfed whistle and tried to consistent in evey diff. Let me ask more people for mod. Thanks for mod Pereira! :D

ed: Irrev confirmd:
Pereira006
alright then, No need more mod if copy-paste is fine, just made me worry lol and sometime I forget :P anyway, all look good and nice map

Bubble

Good luck
Nozhomi
Ok will try to check this before the end of the week ^^' just a reminder.
4 days later~

[General :]
  1. Metadata : What the hell is that source ?
  2. Timing : Ok
  3. AiMod : Ok
  4. SB : /
  5. Other: Are you sure about keeping Countdown enable ?
[Mapping / Rhythm :]

- Normal :

  1. 00:27:130 (1) - Move it to 100:116 to adjust perfectly spacing.


- Advanced :

  1. 01:54:490 (4,1) - This overlap looks really bad in play, because it cover a little 01:55:450 (1) - start. Stack them or separe them completly.
  2. 03:00:730 - This strong beat should be clicked to emphasis the vocal, like you did on other kiai.


- Bathory & Perv's Hard :

  1. 02:33:850 (1,2) - I don't understand why you clearly skip vocal on 02:34:330 - / 02:36:010 - when you map it just after when the intensity is the same. Makes no sense.
[Hitsound :]
  1. Ok

The map is k, I won't say anything about copy-paste patterns since they're ofc not unrankable, BUT that's not because someone did it than that's the good example to follow. It was a style, but clearly more "diversity" on patterns is nice nowadays. So just don't be lazy for your next map and avoid copy-paste patterns.
Call me back when you fix adressed issues.
Mukyu~
Topic Starter
Bathory Witch
Source is movie of German OST for move. Video, site film.
Countdown: Yes, is sound good when enabled.

Normal: Fixed, 01:43:930 (1) - this too.
Advanced: Fixed.
Hard: Fixed.

Thanks!
Nozhomi
Hard : 02:34:330 - what about this one ? Since you did it for 02:36:010 - would have more sense to do both. Also you totally broke the spacing between them.

About souce, I see the point but since the music have also it own clip https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fpoIxKkJ1G4 with a different version (not movie ver.), I still think you should not put it into source. Ask a QAT about this before pushing this set futher.
Krfawy
I think *THIS* is enough to ensure. o/
shARPII
After digging a little bit, I think it's fine to keep the movie as source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Like_%2 ... on_song%29
The song has been created for the movie and then, added in a new album release as bonus track.

For me, the source should be the movie/game/album which release the song for the first time so it makes sense here.
Topic Starter
Bathory Witch
I thenk those sliders are good and follow they spacing song and vocal so no change Nozhomi. :o

I watch was move and was nice. :D
Nozhomi
Fine I don't have more to add here.
GL during qualified phase~
IamKwaN
May I ask why L in like isn't capitalized?

There should be another source regarding to current title other than those mentioned above, I guess. Would be appreciated if you could provide it.
Smokeman

Bathory Witch wrote:

"I mean copy-paste only rhythm is fine but placement, is make me worry, you can't just CTRL + C -> Ctrl + V -> Ctrl + h -> Ctrl + j and leave that..." Andrea used it a lot, for example in map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/123174 and it is very good. also no statement in Ranking Criteria that is urankable to copy&pasta so my pattern good because nice to play and work and good rhythms. :-/
something something, dont justify your mapping based on old maps, something something...

Sure it's not unrankeable, but regarding the quality put in ranked maps this past year, you should be able to guess some sort of quality standard (or quality minimum) as an unwritten rule.

If this wasn't the case then i could just start mapping circles only on white ticks and call it an easy dif. Do the same with some circles on the red ticks, call it a normal and i got myself a "rankable" map. I bet this kind of map would be the most boring thing you could play but... 2007 mapping kinda made the same thing right /s ?

and btw pls dont compare copy pasting the EXACT SAME THING MULTIPLE TIMES (4-5 mb?) to fill in the same verse and the chorus, with "copy paste" styles of people like andrea.

This is ridiculous...
Krfawy
Nie wiem kto bardziej z naszego duetu na to zasługuje, ale i tak jedynie w ten sposób mogę skomentować jak bardzo zjechaliśmy z tytułem. :|

Shiirn
When a mapper maps something, there should be an intended experience that they want to provide for the player. This varies wildly depending on the mapper's personal investment into the song, how much they like it, and how much they understand it, but when you get right down to it, every single map from every single mapper has origins based in the thought process of "I want the player to feel like this while playing".

I can safely guess in this case it was "I want the players to fall asleep."



Because repeating the same thing over and over is a very effective lullaby.
IamKwaN
Please give me a response regarding to my post here within the next 24 hours or else I have to temporarily pull this set out of the Qualified session until a valid metadata proof is given by you.
semaphore

IamKwaN wrote:

Please give me a response regarding to my post here within the next 24 hours or else I have to temporarily pull this set out of the Qualified session until a valid metadata proof is given by you.
oh boy
IamKwaN
Krfawy told me the mapper would be away from keyboard for a while, so let's wait for the creator to have the metadata fixed (aka change the Title to I Like) before moving it forward. Good luck with requalification.
riffy
In case you need proofs, here you can have one. It's official VEVO YT channel, so it is pretty trustworthy.
IamKwaN
Or this from the movie official website:



o/
Topic Starter
Bathory Witch

Krfawy wrote:

Yes is good comment on I how mistake title L in title here.

ed: Masz zmapować tego Harda szybciej matołku.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply