Hi!
I hope my mod is useful:
[General]
- Try making use of different sound sample sets. You only use normals. I would at least use soft set during the verse and normals/drums during chorus in this case unless you have your own hit sounds.
- Maybe reduce kiai. Dont take it for the first chorus at the start, to make it something special during the second one.
- Try reducing the volume of hitsounds a little. The hitsounds overpower the song imo
- Also your choice of hit sounds is questionable. Almost every other note is a whistle or a finish. This can get tedious for the player to hear. Try listening to the music and only emphasize whats interesting. sometimes less is more than you imagine
- If youre not sure about timing/offset. ask in the offset thread for an individual review. I think your offset is fine though.
[Fortune]
- 00:00:064 (1,2) - i dont think this should be mapped. and if you are thinking otherwise at least reduce volum on the hitsounds and remove the finish sound.
- to map the timing of the song correctly you have to reset the bar at 00:10:064 (1). this is where you need a new uninherited red timing section to start counbting from 1 again. btw. the beat is 4/4 of this. not 3/3 and not 6/6. You dont have to use anything else other than 1/4 beat snap divisor for this map with some exceptions if you want to map some advanced stuff.
- 00:37:791 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - noone will be able to play this right. is this mapped in 1/6 after 1/4? 00:39:759 (8) - doesnt even end on spot. 00:39:609 (6) - this should be the end of the stream. right on the 1/4 white tick as it is.
00:56:200 (3) - this doesnt seem to follow the pattern anymore. maybe fix if not intended
- 01:26:086 (2) - there is no note on this tick. either you delete this and make it only a single note finish or make it more fitting to the harp/piano/w/e by mapping a slider/reverse/end in 1/8 from 01:25:973 to 01:26:086. reverse would be on 01:26:029. try it. the way you mapped it though feels off since the last note of the song is played on 01:25:973. what you hear after is only the sustained tone and reverb
- overall i like how you mapped the repetition of lyrics by taking a pattern and repeating it with variations. but i can imagine after the 3rd time it would get annoying for some people. consider this in your style. please dont change it though if youre certain about your design. just sharing my point of view.
[Insane]
- 00:00:064 (1,2) - same issue as in Fortune
- 00:09:154 (3) - you kinda ignored the music here proceeding with your pattern.
- 00:10:064 (1) - again this should be a red timing section. (keep in mind if you change red timing sections within one diff then you have to do the exactly same in all the other diffs! and you dont need to do this if you still are comfortable mapping. it is not an unrankable issue if you dont get this red timing section implemented)
- 00:17:336 (2,1) - nasty 1/4 jump considering the diff. maybe ctrl G 00:17:336 (2)
- 01:18:473 (1) - for almost 5 seconds straight the same pattern. i know the music suggests something like that. but how about mixing it up a little? maybe change directions after 3 repetitions or something. maybe introduce a slightly different pattern each 2 reps. something like that. or add a slider after some reps
- 01:25:973 (1,2) - same as in Fortune.
Hope I could help you out =]