Chaoslitz wrote:

[captin's Extra]

1. 00:23:350 (7,8) - Flow is weird when 00:23:350 (7,8) - 00:23:513 (8,1) are having opposite direction, it is better to keep the downward movement when the jump is slightly moving down, I would suggest you to place 00:23:676 (1) below 00:23:513 (8) for a smoother flow this works fine for me as is because it relies more on direct back and forth jumps rather than circular
   
   eg

   
2. 00:30:850 (6,7) - It is fine to use 1/4 sliders in my opinion. However, due to the calm part start at 00:31:502, it is not suitable to make a large distance of jump before it, so I would recommend to reduce the spacing
3. 00:58:730 (1) - 00:58:893 is a strong beat, may consider to use note or slider head to emphasis instead of slider end
4. 01:01:502 (1,2,1,2) - In my opinion, the music here is not strong enough to use 1/4 sliders to represent, but the one in 01:02:154 (1,2,1,1) is fine as there are drums in background music, so I recommend to change 01:01:502 (1,2,1,2) to me, this is one of the most defining patterns of the map, so i'm very reluctant to change this.
5. 01:18:458 - How about adding a note here, to represent the end of vocal been stated multiple times i leave this unmapped for the effect with the instrumentals and the break
6. 01:39:002 (11,12) - May consider changing this into streams, since the pitch is start decreasing from 01:39:002, it is not really suitable to use 1/4 sliders when it represent a stronger beat then normal streams this is intended to set this apart from the stream before, since the drum enters here again
7. 02:16:991 (1) - Same as 00:58:730 (1)
8. 02:19:763 (1,2,1,2) - Same as 01:01:502 (1,2,1,2), the music is not that strong which is suitable to use 1/4 slider to represent same answer
9. 03:11:447 (5,6) - 03:11:284 (4,5) is in upward movement, so i would suggest to keep this flow by placing 03:11:611 (6) higher than 03:11:447 (5) doesn't really change much in the actual flow but w/e
   
   eg

   
10. 03:27:589 (1,2,1,2) - Same reason as mentioned above ~
11. 03:41:937 (1,2) - The jump here is too large compared to those in other chorus like 01:15:850 (1), music isn't strong enough to use such a large jump and moreover, it will become difficult for players to hit the following streams 03:42:100 (2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) accurately, so consider to reduce the distance
12. 04:09:328 (1,2,3,1) - There is a back and forth movement in 04:09:328 (1,2,3), so it is better when 04:09:817 (1) is placed near 04:09:980 (2) to keep this flow instead of making sharp movement to bottom doesn't make any difference at all because of how people play constant jump sections like this. as long as angles are sharp they will still be easy to hit

I am not going to comment a lot about usage of the 1/4 sliders in captin's Extra, but I would like to see more mods in order to get more opinions from different players/modders to see if it is appropriate, so that we can push it forward

Gaia wrote:

mapping is a happy thing! |ω･)و ̑̑༉

P A N wrote:

BAM

Lolparty wrote:

DQ is coming shortly don't worry

deetz wrote:

where's the response to captin's post then?

auux wrote:

This is just issues according to the QATs... We need people to be experimental. There are way worse maps currently ranked, *cough* *cough* chocobo *cough* *cough*