newtoniorock8 wrote:

Hi ` #in-game request :3

Salad

00:03:736 (3) - Ctrl-G made this on purpose sorry ><
00:04:198 (1) - move at x:376 yep same
00:11:352 (5) - move at x:408 x:296 instead
00:11:582 (1) - move at x:488 i dont want jump here because relax music so let me keep ><
00:28:659 (2) - Ctrl-H then move at x:100 tweaked a little bit
00:32:582 - add note here at x:300, don't forget to add hitsound sure
00:41:582 - add slider here with reverse arrow to 00:42:044 at x:276 , then add note at 00:42:275 (2) - x:64 like: on purpose of break here, somehow weird to map in salad lol

<.

00:55:890 (1) - change this to single notes , (1) at x:112 , (2) at x:312 , (3) at x:52

Platter

00:03:736 (3,1) - add hdash or just move this at x:264 1/4 hdash isnt allowed in platter
00:35:582 (1) - move reverse arrow at x:332
00:42:621 (4) - move at x:352
00:42:736 (5) - move at x:240
00:42:852 (6) - move at x:464 fixed those 3 in my own way
00:55:890 (1) - change this to single notes , (1) at x:144 , (2) at x:336 , (3) at x:60
00:58:659 (5) - move reverse arrow at x:356

Rain

Goodjob :3

WildOne94 wrote:

Hey Xinely owo/

Here for the mod request you asked for :3

General
I'm not so sure with the timing points that change the hitsounds to whistles. for e.g when i was looking at the Salad diff it sounded better removing the ones such as at 00:32:813 -. but that's just my opinion :3.
This song has a video credits outro right? Try find the video and include it in . i know but i think ctb player wont use video to play lol
I will try my best to boost Rain 0.24 more to reach that "I" icon x3

Salad

00:04:198 (1) - it seems just a tad far. suggest moving it to x:380 y:256 x:396 instead because x:380 catchable w/o dash
00:07:659 (3) - this note seems too easy. Imo the flow and placement would be better at x:300 y:256 giving it a glide intentionally to give dash for next slider, let me keep this one as easy pattern ><
00:11:582 (1) - this would be better if the jump was a little bit larger as it goes into a nice slow part then. Suggesting x:456 y:140 ok
00:21:736 (3) - the sound in the music is better at 00:21:967 - for this circle note. here is how it should look. (4) is just a suggestion slider let me keep, personally im fine with this ><


00:27:967 - add a circle note here
00:28:198 (6) - sounds a lot better as a slider to the next red tick. Goes better with vocals. Or what does sound better for me with a bit more changing of notes is this


00:31:198 - add a circle note here
00:41:352 (1) - bit of a big gap here (no sex jokes intended) Maybe fill it up with a slider like this? or insert a break imo this is fine enough sorry ><


00:44:582 (3) - When i was playing i had to stall a bit for this note for the next little jump. Try moving it right slightly more. (or removing it sounds good too) yep it's on purpose for the jump because the cymbal
01:06:967 (1) - add claps to the reverse in the middle and end here like you did at 01:11:582 (2) - whistle instead, the music is weak ><
01:08:582 (3) - ^ maybe same but not too essential yep whistle
01:08:813 (1,2,3,4) - could extend these out a bit more for harder jumps. seems a bit easy imo i'll consider and fix it if someone tells this again
01:15:044 (2) - add circle note here for that little sound you can hear in the music (sorry this is a late suggestion as i thought i pasted this one earlier) there is a slider D:

Platter

Hard to find faults in this one
00:05:121 (2,2,4) - the start of the (2) sliders sound better with a clap at the start. (and then the (4) too) it will ruin my consistency :<
00:18:275 (3,4,5) - spread these out more. Or maybe just (5). (i moved 5 to x:420 y:328 which felt nice) sure
00:23:813 (3) - move 3 right a bit for a nicer jump. Might i suggest x:316 y:136 (or further right maybe) x:296
00:39:621 (2) - since the 3 slow notes here are well... slower i think you can make 2 pushed over to the left more for a better jump between them. a little bit far
00:44:352 (3) - would be better if (3) and (4) were space out more. Try (3) as x:280 y:272 and (4) x:132 y:252 fixed it but i dont fix the suggestion below since i tweaked already
00:44:813 (1) - ctrl + h this and put at x:0 y:307. Feels like a nice jumps and fits the music nice too (just felt like there should have been a hyper near the start of kiai and chorus)
01:11:929 (3) - same as 00:39:621 -
01:13:429 (4) - hmm it's missing a jump around here somewhere. Maybe move this (4) right a bit more for a bigger jump?
01:25:428 (1,2,3) - This is just me but i don't really like these 3 reverse sliders when coming to play ;w;. i would change like the last one (3) and remove the reverse and have like this instead. (maybe at 00:09:736 (1,2,3) - too) it's same with previous, i wanna keep lol

Rain

Yeah like the others say. It's pretty much poyfect .
00:13:429 (3) - move (3) right more (or even all the way right). It would be could to have some nice smooth gliding hypers on the quiet part moved a bit but no hyper
00:14:582 (5,1) - maybe hyper from (5) to (1) ? it would make it nice imo. i dont want a hyper for relax part
00:19:659 (2) - this one can definitely move right some more for a bigger jump. even on the quiet part
00:28:198 (1,2) - spread these out a bit more for a little bit of a bigger jump. even with the increasing space at 00:29:121 (3,4) - i still think these should be a bit bigger. it just felt too easy when playing moved (2) a little bit further
00:37:890 (3,4) - maybe hyper from (3) to (4) ?
00:42:159 (2) - move this right a bit more as it is quite easy to get to and would feel like a better jump
00:58:659 (2) - this sounds better as a slider from here to 00:58:890 (3) - which would need to have removed to circle slider let me keep ><
01:15:044 - i know u wanted a bit of a break here but adding a circle note here sounds better imo. let me keep too since i only want to map the cymbals
01:27:045 (4) - i kind of like the idea of having 2 finishes. sounds really cool. so maybe add one here too not fit with the Background music

Best of luck Xinely :3/
Any questions then pm me or leave a message in my inbox
Also let me know if you want a GD cup ;3

DragonSlayer96 wrote:

o/ here for my mod

General

Is the inaho.png and slaine.png suppose to be combo bursts? if so, please name one comboburst-0.png and the other comboburst-1.png for them to be used as combo bursts they were for SB but im lazy to make SB lol, removed

Salad

00:18:275 - you can add a note here or make a slider from here to 00:18:506 - sure


00:03:506 (2,3,1) - ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ how you go into the song like this <3333333

Platter

00:03:736 (3,1) - hyper 1/4 HDash in Platter literally makes disqualification so i'll keep like this ;w;
00:13:429 (1,2) - bigger jump increased
00:17:813 (2,3) - ^ increased as well

don't be afraid to poke me in game or forum post me if you need anything

Also I can say for a fact I do have the video enabled and do not play with the background dimmed at all Xinely so a video would be nice if you don't mind adding one. sadly but my connection isnt good and xxdeathx's mapset has quite big size video in my sight :<

GAMI wrote:

hi eli-sama <3 (mod request using PM) gami \:DDD/

Salad

00:02:121 (3) - pindahin ke 216 aja kak 224 deh, tadi coba, ketangkep rada di tepi xD
00:07:659 (3) - 332 owo 344 deh ><
00:16:659 (3) - kalo mau, agak dijauhin ke 18 yg ini keep dlu deh, soalnya emang supposed low spacing krn relax ><
00:22:198 (3) - 176 terlalu deket ;w;
00:26:352 (1) - ke 96 soalnya agak kejauhan kak 72 deh, emang kubuat harus ngedash, cymbal :3
00:31:890 (1) - mundurin ke 96 jg kak nice
00:37:198 (3,1) - ini note ngga kejauhan ya kak? kecilin sedikit dong kak jaraknya ;w; sengaja biar dash lol
00:50:121 (4,1) - ini juga kak, kurangin jarak dashnya dong ;-;
01:23:582 (1) - majuhin ke 224 & 01:24:505 (2) - ctrl+g & pindahin ke 416 majuin (2) doang deh, yg itu emang biar ketangkep pake dash xD
01:27:275 (6) - 160 kak ok

Platter

00:02:352 (1) - ctrl+g entar hyperdash lol, sengaja kok ini kecil krn musicnya pelan
00:16:659 (3) - ke 188 kak? 208 deh :3
00:38:813 (4) - ctrl+g aja kak entar 1/4 hyperdash lol, segini aja cukup, kan cuma platter xD
00:45:159 (2) - ini di ctrl+g terus note yg 00:45:506 (3) - dimajuhin ke 120 kesusahan lol, gedein spacingnya instead
01:07:890 (4) - ctrl+g & 01:08:582 (5) - dipindahin ke 440 ok

Rain

00:02:352 (1) - ctrl+g ? owo entar hyperdash lol, gedein spacingnya instead
00:06:390 (2) - ^ gedein spacing instead xD
00:08:236 (2) - ^ gedein juga xD
00:47:006 (2) - & 00:47:352 (3) - sama kayak suggest di atas sure
00:47:813 (4,5,6) - di ctrt+g terus dipindahin ke 416 udah xD
01:23:928 (2) - ctrl+g gedein instead xD
01:22:082 (2) - ini di ctrl+g & note 01:22:428 (3) - pindahin ke 192 digedein lol
01:20:236 (2) - dimajuhin ke 280 & note 01:20:582 (3) - di taro di 252 keep dlu deh soalnya abis HDash di stanza, takut kesusahan

sorry kak kalo ngga nge-bantu uwu

anyways, good luck kak :3

examination wrote:

Hi Xinely owo From my Queue~

[Salad]
Widescreen support

00:05:121 (2) - move a bit left to increase the DS
00:21:736 (2,3) - Follow the vocal here sounds better add note on 00:21:967 - instead

SPOILER

00:24:275 (2) - This note is not needed here, delete this and the flow will be better somehow i prefer to keep
01:05:121 (1,2) - Use a pattern like 01:06:967 (1,2) will fit the song better, also it follows what you do in the previous part. add note on 1/2 instead

[Platter]
From my point of view, CS 3.6 is a bit hard as a platter diff
check AIMod
00:40:659 (5,6,7,8) - the straight angle feels a bit weird, try use a pattern like this

SPOILER

00:52:198 (1,2) - better if you use a slider like 00:48:506 (1) it's fine,let me keep :<
01:04:198 (3) - A triple sounds better
01:13:198 (3) - Try place this note at 01:13:198? i think wrong timeline lol

[Rain]
00:22:429 (9,1) - cut down the DS here / add the DS to make a HDash i dont want hdash on relax lol
00:39:621 (2,3) - ctrl + G on both of them, the flow will be better [color=#FF0000]let me keep, i feel the flow is fine either :<[/color]
00:57:275 (7) - ctrl + G
01:26:813 (3,4) - make them also 1/4 sliders here~ sounds overmapped :<

Hope my mod will be helpful ww
Good luck with this set

1. Your tags are incorrect. It should be Aldnoah and not Alnoah.

Manuxz wrote:

Hi Xinely owo/ Sorry for the delay, I was a little busy uwu

Mod requested PM

Salad

00:24:506 (1) - I think you could get more out this part by removing the reverse of this slider and try something --> http://puu.sh/gyHLV/69efcf7c06.jpg And if you do what I said I recommend using this pattern --> http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2883454 (Do not forget to place the corresponding Claps) great
00:31:659 (4) - Move at x: 212 to improve the symmetry xD
00:32:582 (2) - Move at x: 365 ^
00:40:198 (2) - As in 00:24:506 (1) -
00:41:582 - You could add a Spin here, although it would be very short so I leave it to your judgment let me add and ask kurokami to judge this, personally the spinner is catchable for me and that was a nice idea xD
00:49:198 (2) - Move at x: 100 to improve the symmetry
00:53:121 (3) - Move at x:110, maybe o.o
00:56:813 (4) - I think if it moves to x: 288 would be more consistent with previous jump distance
01:02:352 (2) - The tail of this slider ends in x:256 let me keep mine here
01:05:813 (2) - Move at x: 152 to improve the symmetry :v
01:08:582 (3) - x:160 (?
01:09:275 (2,4) - Move (2) at x: 261 and (4) at x: 250 uwu
01:21:736 (1) - Add a jump? It is rare that there isn't a leap here, because basically put a jump in every finish along the map x.x

Platter

00:08:236 (2) - Move at x: 165 o.o this spacing is close already so let me keep
00:13:890 (2) - Move at x: 252 to improve the symmetry 232 instead
00:20:352 (3,4) - Move (3) at x: 239 and (4) at x: 336 fixed (3) but no for (4) because too close ><
00:54:736 (2) - Move at x: 384 to improve the symmetry
01:00:275 (2) - Move at x: 224 ^

Rain

00:32:236 (2) - Move at x: 343 ;w; ok

Well, I really like this diff, so not much problems imo, fits my taste o3o

I hope you serve something, good luck with the map x3

Kurokami wrote:

o/

[General]

1. Your tags are incorrect. It should be Aldnoah and not Alnoah. wtf i am LOL fixed

[Salad]
00:05:467 - It would be nice to have a note here as well. This one is almost as strong as 00:05:582 and because of this (3) feels off though it isn't.
00:07:313 - ^
00:09:159 - ^ yeah i know but since this is easiest diff, i'd like to keep 1/2 gap rhythm to be friendly with newbie
00:13:429 (1,2) - Add a repeat to (1) instead to follow the music? The vocal starts on red tick anyway.
00:18:736 - Since you mapped 00:18:275 this tick feels really empty. It would be nice to follow the vocal with a 1/2 triplet.
00:20:813 (1,2) - Well, just if you accepted previously.
00:22:429 - Again a nice but empty vocal.

[Platter]
00:02:121 (4,1) - A higher dash would be nice here. :3
00:03:736 (3,1) - Little bit different pattern and it can be HDashed. i have trauma with HDash 1/4 and you know better to avoid it since i dont want to give IS for BNs :<
00:21:967 (2) - Ctrl+g on this? i'd like to keep this since the first vocal on head is not really high so i feel low spacing would be nice, and vocal on next slider is high so better give a dash \:D/
00:42:852 (6,1) - A HDash can be added to here as well. trauma LOL
00:46:659 (1,2) - Maybe make this dash a little bit bigger to follow the vocal.

01:14:352 (1,2,3) - This part is only mapped on this difficulty. It would be nice to make it consistent across difficulties. omg i didnt realize this, nice catch

[Rain]
00:02:121 (3,1) - This jump can be higher to follow the high pitched sound.
00:04:890 (3,4) - This timed jump is tricky. You should make the distance smaller a bit.
00:14:582 (5) - Ctrl+g? literally same reason as Platter
00:27:967 (7,1) - A HDash would be nice at this point.
01:27:390 (1) - This spinner starts at different time on every difficulty, since this can cause DQ it would be better as fixed.

Lazy and Tired. \o/
[]

My previous mod lost due wrong key press. I tried to gather the suggestions again but maybe I missed something. o.o Anyway, good luck for now and feel free to poke me when 12+ reached. :3

General

1. Difficulty Spread : ☑
2. Unsnapped objects : ☑
3. Audio bitrate over 192 kbps : ☑
4. Metadata Issues : ☑
5. Timeline Issues : ☑
6. Combo Colors : ☑
7. Unused hitsounds : ☑
8. Hitsounds Issues : ☑
9. Inaudible hitsounds : ☑
10. Application of every mods :

Salad

1. 00:08:813 (2) - Missed whistle on the head
2. 00:28:890 - I'd add note here to follow the drum sound from the background, as it sounds pretty empty.
3. 01:00:506 (2) - Whistle on the head
4. 01:24:505 (2) - How about moving this to a bit right to have a small jump?

Platter

1. 00:18:967 (1) - I'd move this to the right slightly since the jump is a bit hard to platter
2. 01:05:121 (1) - This sounds pretty awkward without whistles. Consider adding whistle on each of reverse and tail of the slider
3. 01:07:313 (2) - Whistle on the head
4. 01:07:659 (3) - Whistle
5. 01:20:813 (2) - I feel like this part is lack of movement. How about moving this to a bit left?

Rain

1. You can use another epic name for a diff since it's a highest diff of the mapset
2. 00:08:813 (3) - Whistle here
3. 00:59:928 (2) - This isn't that much fun imo, I'd try something like this
4. 01:13:890 (4) - how about moving this to a bit left? I kinda expect a little more space between (4) and (5)

Gaia wrote:

why am i not on the list of modders Dx

美醬 是傻瓜 :I