1. Hard - 4Key (3.23 stars, 1866 notes)
2. Insane - 4Key (4.56 stars, 2635 notes)
3. Normal - 4Key (1.96 stars, 1151 notes)

Pharos21 wrote:

NM

00:56:565 (56565|1) - uhh... this note isn't suitable for NM. i suggest you use 1/2 beat only
00:58:195 (58195|1,59174|1) - Same as above...
I suggest you delete or move them to 1/2 beat
ps.. only use 1/4 on HD above, but it depend on the song and the mapset all done.

01:05:777 (65777|0,65940|1,66103|2,66103|3) - till 01:12:299 (72299|0,72462|1,72625|2,72625|3) - too monotone.. make variable please

01:16:212 (76212|3,76375|2,76538|1,76538|0) - till 01:22:733 (82733|3,82896|2,83059|0,83059|1) - ^

please at least suggest me a pattern. the song in this part is also a monotone too.
ps. i tried to make a vocal pattern but this is not fun for fingers at all.

01:45:886 (105886|2,106212|3,106538|0) - OK.. ths is too hard for NM. Make 1 LN instead <=ps.. if you found LN like this... Merge it i don't think this is really hard, but i changed them into normal notes.

02:04:473 (124473|3,124636|3,124799|0,124962|0) - Too hard... Move 1 note to avoid hammer ( 02:04:473 (124473|3,124799|0) - ) repatterned

02:09:364 (129364|0,130016|3,130342|2,130668|1) - don't tell me you use this LNs to follow the Vocal.. Change it to Note they are piano not vocal.

02:14:581 (134581|2,135233|3,135559|2,135886|1) - ^ same as above

02:19:146 (139146|3,139473|3,139799|3,140125|3,140125|0,140451|0,140777|0,141103|0) - Spread it.. don't make Hammer (for all Hammer like this.. Change it) waiting for others mention about this.

02:50:288 (170288|0,170451|0) - ^ for all note like this same as above

Overall.. check again and Avoid using = Hammer, Monotone Pattern, 1/4 Beat

[FX] AEM wrote:

Pharos21 wrote:

NM

00:56:565 (56565|1) - uhh... this note isn't suitable for NM. i suggest you use 1/2 beat only
00:58:195 (58195|1,59174|1) - Same as above...
I suggest you delete or move them to 1/2 beat
ps.. only use 1/4 on HD above, but it depend on the song and the mapset all done.

01:05:777 (65777|0,65940|1,66103|2,66103|3) - till 01:12:299 (72299|0,72462|1,72625|2,72625|3) - too monotone.. make variable please

01:16:212 (76212|3,76375|2,76538|1,76538|0) - till 01:22:733 (82733|3,82896|2,83059|0,83059|1) - ^

please at least suggest me a pattern. the song in this part is also a monotone too.
ps. i tried to make a vocal pattern but this is not fun for fingers at all.

01:45:886 (105886|2,106212|3,106538|0) - OK.. ths is too hard for NM. Make 1 LN instead <=ps.. if you found LN like this... Merge it i don't think this is really hard, but i changed them into normal notes.

02:04:473 (124473|3,124636|3,124799|0,124962|0) - Too hard... Move 1 note to avoid hammer ( 02:04:473 (124473|3,124799|0) - ) repatterned

02:09:364 (129364|0,130016|3,130342|2,130668|1) - don't tell me you use this LNs to follow the Vocal.. Change it to Note they are piano not vocal.

02:14:581 (134581|2,135233|3,135559|2,135886|1) - ^ same as above

02:19:146 (139146|3,139473|3,139799|3,140125|3,140125|0,140451|0,140777|0,141103|0) - Spread it.. don't make Hammer (for all Hammer like this.. Change it) waiting for others mention about this.

02:50:288 (170288|0,170451|0) - ^ for all note like this same as above

Overall.. check again and Avoid using = Hammer, Monotone Pattern, 1/4 Beat

Thanks for Modding!

[General]

SPOILER

Add: Captain Earth as the source
and delete it form tags

I love the BG Is Fairy Tail <3
But... I think you need to use one from Captain Earth

[Normal]

SPOILER

01:14:255
01:14:907
Move one of the notes to the beginning of the LN when The beat it's stronger

[Hard]

SPOILER

HP +1

02:00:233 Add note in 1
02:07:081 (127081|1) - Move to 1

[Insane]

SPOILER

00:05:777 Add note
00:48:494 (48494|2) - Move to 1

Danielslz9 wrote:

[General]
[spoilerbox]Add: Captain Earth as the source
and delete it form tags done

I love the BG Is Fairy Tail <3
But... I think you need to use one from Captain Earth do you have a reference(ranking criteria)? I don't wanna change the bg ;w;

[Normal]
[spoilerbox]01:14:255
01:14:907
Move one of the notes to the beginning of the LN when The beat it's stronger ehh I don't think so, it's strong enough.

[Hard]
[spoilerbox]HP +1

02:00:233 Add note in 1 done
02:07:081 (127081|1) - Move to 1 done

[Insane]
[spoilerbox]00:05:777 Add note done
00:48:494 (48494|2) - Move to 1 done


Good Luck this song is beautiful

[FX] AEM wrote:

I love the BG Is Fairy Tail <3
But... I think you need to use one from Captain Earth do you have a reference(ranking criteria)? I don't wanna change the bg ;w;

shionelove wrote:

column 1234

only Insane gets one mod so i mod insane

[Insane]
01:15:641 (75641|0,75641|1,75723|3,75723|2,75804|1,75804|0) - ctrl+h,i don't think here needs hammer ok
01:24:690 (84690|3) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2821742 if LN follow piano : applied 01:25:505 - only and re-patterne. i keep the flow, even the sound is not right.
02:58:603 (178603|2) - add 4 done
03:00:559 (180559|0,180723|0,180886|0,181049|0,181212|0,181375|0,181538|0,181701|0,181864|0,182027|0,182190|0,182353|0,182516|0,182679|0,182842|0) - why only here follow guitar? for flowing.
03:48:087 (228087|0,228087|3,228168|1,228168|2) - move to 23 14,not need hammer too i think listen closely :p

i like consistent pattern
good luck

Abraxos wrote:

Funny how this is my M4M, I've loved this song since the beginning of time when I started playing o!mania

I'll look through insane first, and if I have time I'll do hard too nope no time

General

1. BPM and Offset : ( × ), try 563 as offset. WARNING my mod uses the OLD offset of 560 so mod first change offset later. okkk
2. Aimod : ( ✓ )
3. Kiai : ( ✓ )
4. Metadata : ( × ), i think artist name has a kanji trans, should be ティア, but im not japanese so idk *i will ask someone to confirm this if this is a serious issue.
5. Hitsound : ( ✓ )
6. Video : ( ✓ )

Insane

Insane

1. interesting to see how you used the green lines as increments for the HS. idk if thats fine since im not a hs guru but its ok to me.
2. 00:13:277 (13277|1) - continue piano here? unless you want to have that transition, but i feel just a note at 2 is still fine. that was my first opinion when i tried to add piano, but now i think it should be really complicated so i give up.
3. 00:18:820 (18820|1) - idk if you want to but you could continue the 1/2 stack like this. i feel as though im doing something unholy by re-arranging the patterns doe nice idea.
4. 00:26:648 (26648|2,26648|0,26811|3,26975|2,26975|1) - is there a reason why you chose not to have a note on every 1/2 tick? (almost every 1/2 tick) since theres a piano in the music here you could follow i literally follow just 1 instrument at once. if i add more than 1 it will confuse players. exept for hardcore players like me who doesn't even care lol
5. 00:53:714 (53714|2) - LN till 00:54:040 (54040|3), see 00:51:105 (51105|1) - you could place it on another column doe good point. i was just about to refuse the vocal is strong enough in this part. added.
6. 01:15:806 (75806|3) - is a double? oh thanks, i completely missed it.
7. 01:26:322 (86322|1) - note at 4, since 01:25:507 (85507|1) - has a note i would add a note but the following part is not strong enough so i add only 1 note here. (it's like a fade out part here)
8. 02:12:301 (132301|3,132627|2,132790|1,132953|2,133279|0,133279|2) - why didnt you do 02:15:235 (135235|3,135561|2,135886|1) - here good point.
9. 02:24:038 (144038|1) - triple here i guess, see 02:24:690 (144690|3,144690|2,144690|1) - Fade In part. louder = more dense
10. 03:18:209 (198209|2,198290|2) - guess it could do better, heres what i suggest. the 1+4 spread in the end is not so good with very high bpm stairs, most (not hardcore) players will see (4th column LN note in the end) as a jack.

Rivals_7 wrote:

Hello
This is my respond for M4M via my queue. Thanks for modding my map

1|2|3|4

[General]
I notice this song is from Captain Earth, but what is "fairy Tail" character BG are even related :/ lol, i know but i just find this suitable to the map x) if i find a related one i will change.
Beside of this, all was fine.

Daym, this map is pretty well structured. (though i kinda not agree of having the same pattern structure on each kiai) but still xD.
[Insane]
Jumpstream OwO

00:36:921 (36921|0) - Should be on 2, refer to the similar pattern with same density here - 00:39:041 (39041|1,39041|0,39204|3,39367|0,39367|2,39530|1,39693|3,39693|2) - applied.


00:55:345 (55345|1) - and - 02:18:823 (138823|2) - add "before" HS applied.

00:55:671 (55671|2,55997|2,56323|2) - idk why you leaving this huge beat single noted, its more flowing if this was double :/ yeah it makes sense but i dont want to interrupt the 1/1 beat which is a lot stronger than this beat.

03:01:052 (181052|0,181215|0) - move to 2, less anchoring since this is the only one anchor pattern in this section even though the noise remain the same applied.

03:05:128 - add note on 4 and f8 HS here. i would like to focus on other instrument, single piano is kinda off for me

03:16:704 (196704|0) - move to 4. less anchoring on col 1
03:17:356 (197356|0) - ^ applied.


[Hard]

00:55:345 (55345|2) - and - 02:18:823 (138823|3) - add "before" HS applied.

02:19:149 (139149|3) - make all of these thing double. you may recognize some pattern arent consistent - 02:22:736 (142736|2,142736|3,143062|1,143062|3) - yea it might do a job but this section getting louder and louder so i think it would be better to add double after this beat.

[Normal]
This diff is on 2 stars, I might nerf a bit on this

00:48:334 (48334|3,48497|2) - hmm why is this not stacking while the noise are similar like - 00:45:726 (45726|0,45889|0) - but the difference is this is high pitched
00:53:552 (53552|2,53715|3) - ^ applied.

01:15:889 - the tom roll is ended here, so cut that LN
02:39:367 - ^
03:28:932 - ^ applied.

03:13:606 - you can make this section all SN like before. all the noise are same i think i will keep this

03:16:541 (196541|0,196541|1) - move to right 2 step. To give more widely gameplay to newer player
03:17:193 (197193|1,197193|0) - ^ applied.

03:59:421 (239421|0) - to 2. avoid jack applied.

I can't find anything more
Good luck ^^

FreeezeForward wrote:

F4W's Modding Notice

*From F4W's Mania Modding Queue

These following mods are just suggestions but mostly are recommended. If you reject some (all) of my mods, kindly explain it so I can understand.

1|2|3|4

Metadata

1. Artist: Change "Tia" to "ティア" since it's her kanji, but it's optional because a lot of people don't use her kanji for her song.
2. Source: Change "Captain Earth" to "キャプテン・アース" since it's the kanji of it. Then move the romaji to tags. If you want to find it's source, search the song and artist on Google, Captain Earth kanjis will appear. Also this can be found in Wikipedia
3. Tags: There is Fairytail BG, so add "Fairytail" on tags, but I'm still questioning about the relativity of it to the song. Also add "Anime ED Theme"
4. Kiai Time: 01:24:041 I think it's end should be in 01:26:649 It's not because about the beat/pitch that goes down but it refers to it's beat count (lyric count ends in 56th count not on 64th count). Also have the same conflicts on 02:47:519 and 03:37:084 which the ends are 02:50:128 and 03:39:693 respectively.
   
   all done

Normal

1. 00:13:606 - 00:21:106 This is where you need to nerf your patterns because it's note density is too much for normal. Observe the yellow lines on the left it has the longest lines in the chart. done
2. 00:25:345 (25345|2,25508|0) - Move to 1 and 4 respectively, for hand balance. L-R alternations makes a good hand balance in NM. done
3. 00:28:769 (28769|0,28932|3) - Switch columns, same reason as above. done
4. 01:05:780 Are you serious about repeating patterns? I think it's repetition is too much and it might be unrankable. Try to change patterns because it's note density is constant that makes the chorus charts dull. Same conflicts on other kiai times.
5. 03:08:389 I don't advice too much note density on one column for NM difficulty, i suggest change it to alternations because almost NM players will break their timing here. done
6. 03:39:041 (219041|2,219204|1) - Move to 4 and 1 respectively, four notes with different pitches, suggest 4-1-3-2 note pattern for hand balance. done

Hard

1. 01:05:780 Same as NM, try to change patterns.
2. 03:38:878 (218878|2,219041|2) - Move both to 4, for hand balance. done

Insane

1. 00:22:736 (22736|1) - I think move this to 1, for much more hand balance. done
2. 01:05:780 Same as HD and NM, try to change patterns.
3. 01:42:791 (102791|1,102791|0,102954|0,103117|0) - Switch columns, for hand balance and note density, obviously it's symmetrical well, i don't wanna try to think about hand balance that much since LNs already confuse players.
4. 02:55:345 Add to 2, for the low pitch. it's more comfortable to switch hand instead of the same hand, so i ignored the pitch here.
5. 03:18:171 (198171|0,198212|2) - Switch columns, column 3 notes are off-densed to staircase, so try staircase with hand alternations. i ask many Pros player to play this part, i think it looks fine as it is no need to change anything here.

Good Voice, but kinda dull to over-repeatable patterns, it makes no thrill to players, but still a good song to map. Good luck. Also thanks for your mod.
Kindly reply as soon as possible prior to my mod post above. If there are any questions related to this post, just ask. Happy Modding =w=)b

Hawxx wrote:

I'll be only modding Insane if you don't mind as it's pretty late right now.

For columns I'll be doing 0 | 1 | 2 | 3

Insane

00:02:845 (2845|3,3171|0,3171|1,3171|2,3497|3,3823|1,4149|3,4476|1,4802|3,5128|1,5454|3,5780|2,5780|0,5780|1,6106|3,6432|1,6758|3,7084|1,7410|3,7736|2,8062|1,8389|0,8389|3,8715|2,9041|0,9367|2,9693|0,10019|2,10345|0,10671|2,10997|0,10997|1,11323|2,11649|0,11976|2,12302|0,12628|2,12954|0,12954|3,13606|3,13606|2) - Now, my only gripe with this beginning is that it's literally identical to the 'Hard' difficulty, I'd advise to change the patterns around to make it differ from the 'Hard' difficulty a bit, of course this is mostly an opinion of mine but I think some "freshness" between difficulties is always nice.
00:03:986 - You could add a note here.
00:04:272 - ^
00:04:353 - ^
00:04:606 - ^
00:04:926 - ^
00:05:257 - ^
00:05:291 - ^
00:05:578 - ^
00:08:878 - ^ all done + re-patterned.

00:09:489 - 00:09:693 - You could fill in this bit with notes on each line, this allows you to either put jacks or stairs here. it can be added but confused.

00:09:856 - Could add a note here.
00:10:182 - ^
00:10:508 - ^
00:10:843 - ^ all done + re-patterned.

00:19:978 - 00:20:128 - In between this you can hear more fast played piano which could again allow you to place jacks or some variation of stairs. done + re-patterned.

00:25:640 - You could add a note here.
00:27:146 - ^
00:27:791 - ^
00:28:444 - ^
00:29:747 - ^
00:30:398 - ^
00:31:059 - ^
00:31:174 - ^
00:31:710 - ^
00:32:039 - ^ all done except 1/8 notes

Okay I've kind of skimmed through the rest of it and there's quiet the amount of possible sounds you could map, I'm not saying you really need to but it could make it flow a bit better at certain places as well as raising the star difficulty a bit more (unless you really don't want to raise it too much, but I'd suggest adding some more of the piano notes as they won't increase the density too much)

00:25:345 (25345|2,25345|3,25508|0,25671|3,25671|1,25997|2,25997|3,26160|0,26323|2,26323|1,26649|2,26649|0,26812|3,26976|1,26976|2,27302|2,27302|3,27465|0,27628|3,27628|1,27954|3,27954|2,28117|0,28280|2,28280|1,28606|3,28606|1,28769|0,28932|3,28932|2,29258|2,29258|1,29421|0,29584|3,29584|2,29910|3,29910|1,30073|0,30236|3,30236|2,30562|3,30562|1,30726|0,30889|2,30889|1,31215|3,31215|2,31378|0,31541|2,31541|1) - from here I noticed again that the patterns are very similar to the 'Hard' difficulty again except with some extra notes on some lines, I'd suggest to change the position of them or maybe even mirror the patterns to keep it a bit fresh across difficulties. added notes as you mentioned earlier.

01:05:943 (65943|0,66024|1,66106|3,66106|2,66106|0,66187|1,66269|3,66351|1,66432|0,66432|2,66514|3,66595|0,66677|1,66758|3,66758|0,66758|2,66840|1,66921|3,67003|1,67084|2,67084|0,67166|3,67247|0,67329|1,67410|3,67410|2,67410|0,67492|1,67573|3,67655|1,67736|2,67736|0,67818|3,67899|0,67981|1,68062|3,68062|2,68062|0,68144|1,68226|3,68307|1,68389|0,68389|2,68470|3,68552|0,68633|1,68715|3,68715|2,68715|0,68796|1,68878|3,68959|1,69041|2,69041|0,69122|3,69204|0,69285|1,69367|2,69367|3,69367|0,69448|1,69530|3,69611|1,69693|0,69693|2,69774|3,69856|0,69937|1,70019|0,70019|3,70019|2,70101|1,70182|3,70264|1,70345|2,70345|0,70427|3,70508|0,70590|1,70671|0,70671|2,70671|3,70753|1,70834|3,70916|1,70997|0,70997|2,71079|3,71160|0,71242|1,71323|3,71323|2,71323|0,71405|1,71486|3,71568|1,71649|2,71649|0,71731|3,71812|0,71894|1,71976|2,71976|3,71976|0,72057|1,72139|3,72220|1,72302|0,72302|2,72383|3,72465|0,72546|1,72628|3,72628|2,72628|0,72709|1,72791|3,72872|1,72954|2,72954|0,73035|3,73117|0,73198|1,73280|0,73280|2,73280|3,73361|1) - Here I noticed that a certain set of patterns repeat themselves over and over again, while it's playable and does fit to the beat, I'd recommend switching some note placements up here and there to keep it from being too repetitive.

01:16:378 (76378|3,76459|2,76541|3,76541|0,76541|1,76622|2,76704|0,76785|2,76867|3,76867|1,76948|0,77030|3,77111|2,77193|0,77193|1,77193|3,77274|2,77356|0,77437|2,77519|1,77519|3,77601|0,77682|3,77764|2,77845|3,77845|1,77845|0,77927|2,78008|0,78090|2,78171|3,78171|1,78253|0,78334|3,78416|2,78497|3,78497|0,78497|1,78579|2,78660|0,78742|2,78823|3,78823|1,78905|0,78986|3,79068|2,79149|0,79149|1,79149|3,79231|2,79312|0,79394|2,79476|1,79476|3,79557|0,79639|3,79720|2,79802|1,79802|0,79802|3,79883|2,79965|0,80046|2,80128|1,80128|3,80209|0,80291|3,80372|2,80454|1,80454|0,80454|3,80535|2,80617|0,80698|2,80780|3,80780|1,80861|0,80943|3,81024|2,81106|0,81106|1,81106|3,81187|2,81269|0,81351|2,81432|1,81432|3,81514|0,81595|3,81677|2,81758|0,81758|3,81758|1,81840|2,81921|0,82003|2,82084|3,82084|1,82166|0,82247|3,82329|2,82410|3,82410|0,82410|1,82492|2,82573|0,82655|2,82736|1,82736|3,82818|0,82899|3,82981|2,83062|3,83062|1,83062|0,83144|2,83226|0,83307|2,83389|3,83389|1,83470|0) - ^ all considered

Basically, I think you should try and map more of the ignored background sounds like the piano or some drums, I think it would add a bit more to the fairly easy beginning section, I'd also recommend to mixup some patterns here where it gets repetitive, especially around the very dense bits which is around the chorus I believe, I'm not wanting you to completely scrap it but just mix it up here and there a bit to keep it from being too repetitive, over all very impressive map and it looks very fun to play too!

Hopefully this mod was helpful, I am quite tired so sorry if there's any weird things or spelling mistakes as it's 1:45 am here right now lmao.
Good luck on getting it ranked!

Edit: Straight afterwards I notice a spelling mistake, I knew it would happen.

Hawxx wrote:

No kudosu for this pls

http://static.zerochan.net/Captain.Eart ... 728232.jpg

Maybe this could work as a BG? It's a bit small but at least it's related to the show.