1. Gero's Easy (1,56 stars, 78 notes)
2. Insane (3,62 stars, 302 notes)
3. Normal (2,08 stars, 145 notes)
4. Vicho's Hard (2,89 stars, 229 notes)

1. 00:36:949 (3) - Try to make the finish on the tail clickable, it feels kind of weird especially with the next 5 sliders starting with finishes
2. 00:52:355 (3) - I think a curved slider would flow better here, if you had something like this the player wouldn't have to shift momentum as much
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 01:26:409 (1) - If you had the tail more around the center it would be easier for the player to spin especially since it starts right after

1. 00:02:895 (2) - Rotate the tail a bit so it carries on more flow from 00:02:085 (1) instead of doing an instant sharp turn to the right
   
   like this

   
2. 00:07:963 (3,4) - I think a 1/2 slider works better here for vocals
3. 00:59:855 (1) - Shouldn't the downbeat here be clickable, it's probably the most important one since it's what gets kiai time going
4. 01:27:625 (4) - NC?

1. 00:19:922 (7) - This should transition better into 00:20:733 (8)
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:57:321 (2) - NC here for the rhythm change?
3. 01:00:463 (1) - Consider using a curved slider to emphasize vocals more
4. 01:27:422 (7) - The very last finish of the song should be clickable imo, plus since it's right before the spinner the player can just hold their w/e button they use to tap which makes it a bit more awkward

1. 00:17:693 (7,8,9) - The sounds you're mapping to here are slightly different compared to 00:17:287 (4,5,6) so I think it would work better as a repeat slider
2. 00:45:868 (5,6,7,8,9) - Jumps should be completely consistent in spacing imo, there's nothing really special in any of these notes
3. 00:52:355 (1,2,3) - Would be nice to have more of a lead-in from 00:51:949 (8) the triple starts pretty close to the bottom of the playfield so it's a tight spot
4. 01:13:436 (1) - This plays a bit awkward since it has a finish and it's stacked onto 01:13:537 (2) the note itself doesn't feel emphasized

sukiNathan wrote:

Hiya requesting M4M from your queue~

[Gero's Easy]

1. 00:36:949 (3) - Try to make the finish on the tail clickable, it feels kind of weird especially with the next 5 sliders starting with finishes You know, it's easy after all, that's why I'd prefer to keep the rhythm easy to read
2. 00:52:355 (3) - I think a curved slider would flow better here, if you had something like this the player wouldn't have to shift momentum as much
   
   SPOILER

   
   Sorry, I'd really prefer to keep it as is
3. 01:26:409 (1) - If you had the tail more around the center it would be easier for the player to spin especially since it starts right after It's fine imo

LexiaLovesU wrote:

Momo don't bubble yet spread between Hard and Normal needs a bit more work ill try to fix it with my mod

Shiro wrote:

Easy:
Hitsounding is bad. If you can't sustain a 1/1 or 2/1 rhythm in an easy or normal, do not go for a drum-oriented 2/1 clap pattern or your hitsounding will be full of flaws and missing samples and it's going to sound horrible. Starting 00:31:274 (1) - the map sounds horrible because of it. They are consistent with the other difficulties so I see no valid reason to say that it sounds horrible... they are fine for me...
00:02:085 (1,1) - This is very lazy and not fun at all. I find that the fact that you provided no resonable reason to this suggestion and just telling me that this was no fun at all to be incredibly rude and more demotivating than helpful...
00:11:814 (1,2,3,4,5) - Why are you making the map much denser for only one measure ? That's just... Ah well, add a circle or a sliderend if you wish at 00:14:247 - to make this less blank.
00:21:139 (2,3) - Imperfect blanket. Nazi stuff... are you serious?
00:23:166 (4,1) - Imperfect blanket. Also it wouldn't hurt to tilt 00:24:787 (1) - upwards so it points to 00:26:003 (2) - . ^
00:26:409 (3) - If this is meant to be symmetric, fix it. Seems like you don't know when some patterns are intentional because if you see carefully you can notice that they are symmetrical as you can see here 00:26:409 (3,3) - so yeah...
00:56:003 (4) - Don't use that kind of slider in an Easy. They're needlessly confusing. What is wrong with them? I always used those kind of sliders on easiest difficulties all the time.
01:03:706 (1,2,3) - I doubt this kind of overlap is a good idea for an Easy. You have the entire right part of the playfield to play with, so to speak, so use it. Style? what is wrong with doing something different for more variation?
01:26:409 (3) - This slider is not aesthetically pleasing to say the least, and will confuse new players. It has enough ticks to see the way of the slider, so isn't confusing at the least by me.

Shiro wrote:

why am I modding omg I was just asked to check the spread but this map needs a lot of work fffffffffffff

General:
Use tick rate 2 <_< Changed on every difficulty.
Hitsound volume is too low. I think it's fine enough, I don't want it to be too high.

Normal:
See my comments above about hitsounds. Hitsounds are completely fine to me, I've always been using this technique since long time and there's no problem with it.
00:47:084 (1) - This slider doesn't make sense. It ends on a strong beat and ruins the comboing. I don't see anything wrong with it if it ends there, also I prefer to add combos where the lyrics actually changes.
00:55:193 (4,5) - Not sure how you messed this one up. What's wrong with it? It's a normal blanket.
00:57:220 (1,2) - And you even copied it so players can notice it twice. Same as above.
01:03:301 (3) - This slider doesn't make sense. It ends on a strong beat and ruins the comboing. Same as I mentioned on the other part where you said the same thing, that's how I map and if you don't like it I can't do anything about it.
01:06:544 (3) - This slider doesn't make sense. It ends on a strong beat and ruins the comboing. ^
01:16:274 (3) - This slider doesn't make sense. It ends on a strong beat and ruins the comboing. ^
01:19:517 (3) - This slider doesn't make sense. It ends on a strong beat and ruins the comboing. ^
01:27:929 (1) - Why would you start this 1/4 after the circle in a Normal diff ?... This is a good point, fixed.

Hard:
AR 7.5 is way too high. Even 7 is pushing it. Are you using decimal settings because they exist? Make AR7 at most and OD 6 or 7. Changed AR to 7, OD stays 6.
Comboing is inconsistent and rhythm are for the most part off. You're ignoring the majority of strong beat in favour of confusing sliderends which lead to several problems in the difficulty. This is Vicho's comboing style, we know everyone has a different point of view about combos so you can't force them to other mappers if you don't like the way they are.
00:11:814 (1,2) - Why is this a jump ? It's a really smal jump and I don't see any problem with it, also that part is kinda intense so it's fine.
00:16:983 (1) - DO NOT EVER USE NEW COMBOS IN THE MIDDLE OF A PHRASE THAT IS THE EPITOME OF WRONG COMBOING WTF. Comboing is meant to represent new phrases in the music and no music has phrases starting on those beats. Remove this new combo. It should go on the red tick before it, but you decide to use a sliderend for it, which makes it impossible to new combo. 00:16:476 (3) - is a bad slider and leads to these problems. Hell there is absolutely no sound at all on 00:16:983 (1) - why is there even a beat here ? Removed the new combo, I agree with that.
00:35:936 (1) - This slider doesn't make sense. It ends on a strong beat and ruins the comboing. No change, same reason as stated in my difficulty.
00:41:612 (3,4) - This should be a jump for consistency. Since he used a stack it's fine anyways.
00:58:233 (1,2,3) - This is way too hard for this difficulty. Rework this. The spacing is confusing, the sliders are confusing, and it offers an abnormal and unwanted difficulty spike. You'd be better off making this a full stream. Reworked it in some way, should be better to play now.
01:11:612 (5,1,2) - bis repetita. Fixed.
01:23:368 (1,2) - New combo should be on (2). Fixed.

Insane:
AR 8.5 is unfitting and abusive. What are you trying to achieve? Make this AR8 OD8, those are fitting. Changed to AR8, OD stays at 7.
00:15:057 (4,5,6,1,2) - Make this a perfect square. If you check the spacing properly, it is already perfect.
00:27:220 (1,2) - If you want better oval flow, you might want to curve those, then curve 00:28:030 (3) - . I prefer this part to be linear personally.
00:30:057 (1,2,3,4,5) - This movement is extremely counterintuitive, I'm sure you can do better. Changed the flow and position of the pattern, should flow better now.
00:39:382 (1,2,3) - These should be jumps for consistency with 00:37:152 (5,6,7,1,2,3) - . Made them as jumps as well, so fixed.
00:39:990 (3,4,5) - Maybe one day you'll learn that these do not play well and never will. They play great for me so I won't change them.
01:13:436 (1,2,3,4,5) - is overmapped, 01:13:841 (5,6,7) - is inconsistent If you listen carefully there's a special sound in the music, I tried to follow that and also give more emphasis to this part since it's the second part of the kiai.

That's just a small sample of issues in this map, I just thought I could make a post since I was asked to look at it. The Hard is too hard and needs a slight nerf. Difficulty settings in both Hard and Insane are horribly chosen. The Normal was okay.
This still needs work. Kudosu this or not, either is fine by me. Hard got a lot of streams changed to sliders so it should be fine to go now, also difficulty settings got nerfed as well on every difficulty. Thank you for taking a look, but next time I would appreciate if you don't go too harsh to mappers and respect their style, because if you don't like something it doesn't mean it's bad, everyone has their own style and you should respect it. I appreciated your mod anyways since I found some helpful suggestions from it and made my map better, but next time I would suggest you to use nicer words, to make you look not that mean, hope you get what I mean. Obviously you're gonna get your kudosu since you were helpful. Thanks again for your feedback and modding.