forum

Girls' Generation - Echo

posted
Total Posts
51
Topic Starter
_llkey_18
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on lunes, 17 de mayo de 2010 at 18:08:52

Artist: Girls' Generation
Title: Echo
Tags: SNSD
BPM: 121
Filesize: 11000kb
Play Time: 03:25
Difficulties Available:
  1. Loud!!! (4,75 stars, 411 notes)
  2. Normal (2,7 stars, 246 notes)
Download: Girls' Generation - Echo
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
hope you guys enjoy xD any help (comments , mod ,etc..) will be really appreciatee
i will work hard for rank this pretty song xD

changed to stong colour to fix brightness , fixed transparency on hitcircle and reduce size, added number , approachcircle etc...
Hurude Rika
checked it
zaru-d
your skin is cuuute

good map~
Alace
+2 OD for normal diff (easier to read )
it`s good enough for a new mapper
lxy
:lol:
Cyril Scarlet
* Just Suggestion. if you feel weird please ignore this ^^

and I'm not good about Sounds and Timing , sorry for can't help about this two.


Normal

  • 00:08:637 (1,2,3) - down 2 Grid
    00:45:580 (1) - remove new combo ?
    00:51:530 (1) - ^
    00:52:026 (2) - add new combo ?
    00:53:513 (1) - remove new combo ?
    01:37:150 (5,6) - Left 1 Grid
    01:47:563 (2) - Down 1 Grid
    03:08:885 (5,6,7) - up 1 Grid


Loud


  • 00:30:951 (6) - try to set new 6 for 100% stack point ?
    00:40:621 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Move down 1 Grid Lv3.
    00:54:505 (4) - move right 1 ?
    00:55:249 (5,6) - up 1 ?
    01:34:670 (7) - I think not need to add Break time to this point (for me)
    01:41:613 (1) - move last □ in slider down 1 grid for same point with line (2)
    02:05:414 (7,8,9,10) - right 2 grid
ZHAO YU
Good!
star!
cloness
lol
Snowy Dream
★star★
Axey
;)
Kensei Akio
;) Star
kioukiou
No problem for me.

Star.
Secu_old
WTF!!! you are the best KEY your map rulz
Avfunny
Nice map :)
northa
42342
Sumeragi Amane
very good map :)
idk how to mod it :(
i cant find any mistake .
00:23:637 (4) -I think 00:23:761 is better
dont give kds
:)
star
Cheery
Stard :)
Sure
[Skin]
approachcircle.png needs.


[Normal]
How about change diff's name? ex> Quiet or what you like.

01:25:249 (4) - 1 grid down
01:37:150 (5,6) - 1 grid left
03:25:249 (1) - finish


[Loud!!!]
Fine!!!


Very nice map. :)
gdeath
[Normal]
03:25:249 (1) - add finish

[Loud!!!]
01:34:670 (8) - remove this break
03:22:274 (5) - what about new combo?

nice map and song
Star~
LKs
general

The biggest size of "STAR2.PNG" is 50x50 , i think you should fix it

Normal

[01:25:249] move 1 grid down?
[01:48:059] clap

Loud!!!

[00:18:059] whistle?
[01:34:670] too short break, remove
[02:47:811] (1,2) spacing too close

This is a pretty map , but the normal-whistle dose not fit the song imo

star~
AdRon Zh3Ro
Good map, only the colours is hard to see :P
Utena
Nice map, hit sounds are fine for me, the skin is cute, If i were to complain about anything it would be the brightness, i though it was kinda hard to see the beats sometimes xD maybe pick a bit stronger colors for the beats?! I dunno... overall nice map :) indeed star
Garven
[Skin]
I wouldn't recommend having so much transparency with the hit circle. It's probably the root of a lot of the complaints about hit circles being hard to see (I agree with them). Add some grays in there so you can't see through the circle onto a white background. Also the way osu! resizes the images, some of the text is being covered up by the hitcircleoverlay.
comboburst-1.png ends up really tiny compared to the rest of the comboburst images. Enlarge her and get rid of the unnecessary transparencies.


[Normal]
I'm not liking the combo changing so frequently during the "echo echo" choruses, but that's more up to you for that.
Same with the kiai fountain spurting on every "echo."
03:09:877 (7) - You may as well make the straight up and down instead of at a very slight angle.

[Loud!!!]
Still not liking the kiai fountain use, but eh.
00:16:075 (4) - Line this up with the end of 3 and the 1 afterward.
02:35:662 (5) - Maybe have this slider curve down one grid point to line up with the 6 afterward.

The maps are fine technically, though they really get samey after a while. Not sure what to tell you for that, though.
JamesLeao
Loud:
00:23:266 (3,4) - hmmmm
01:15:084 (1) - remove new combo
01:40:125 (1,6) - clap

Normal:
Fine

whoa , first map yep ? nicely done , i'm feeling comfortable :roll: star 4 u
Ignacio_old
:)
Colin Hou
[Normal]:
  1. seems good to me
[Loud!!!]:
  1. 00:23:637 (4) - this should start at 00:23:761
that's all I can find :3

btw, I have to remove the skin to mod lol
LaunchedthousandShip
got a ss on normal and s on Loud!! on first try x)

Its good enough to be ranked, although, there may still have problems, but to me, all fine. Just one thing, you use repeat patterns too much. Its OK for a normal or easy diff, but for hard or insane, try to make more patterns. Well, it still good, even with many repeat patterns. Also, I dont like skins, but this one is OK to me. Get this rank, nice map.
MaxwellDemon
As many modder before me have already noted, the skin does have some issue. Aside from that, there is also that because you skinned the hit circles, but didn't skin other parts of the hitcircle like numbers, approach circles, etc., it is highly recommended that you skin them as well. If you really don't want to, then at least set the default skin as the standard. You can get this option like this:

Song Setup > Storyboarding

It is underneath skinning, just simply choose Default.

Also, for your hitcircle.png, try to crop it into a circle, because right now, a little bit of that actually is outside of the hitcircle overlay.

I also think the offset is late. XD XD
It sounds more like 8,380 than 8,390.

Anyway, I didn't notice anything wrong than those things, so here is a star for now. :3
DJPop
Mod by requested.


First, notes are freaking hard to read because of the skin D:

~Normal~
00:40:621 (1,2,1,1) - Why combos are different?
00:56:489 (1,2,1,1) - ^
01:18:803 (1) - remove new combo
01:44:092 (1,2,1,1) - Why combos are different?
01:59:960 (1,2,1,1) - ^
02:31:695 (1,2,1,1) - ^

~Loud!!!~
Fine.


+Star
Topic Starter
_llkey_18
thankss all for mod it ^_^ i going fix skin part
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply