forum

Memme - Starving Days

posted
Total Posts
50
show more
Sonnyc
[Beginner]
  1. 00:09:728 - Weird rhythm selection here. I believe you can found a way to map this out.
  2. 01:02:593 (3) - Another weird rhythm selection. Making 01:02:755 clickable insteaed the current spot feels more natural.
  3. 01:44:106 (3) - Similar as above. Making 01:44:269 clickable instead the current spot will work more natural.
  4. 01:49:133 (4) - This sharp slider didn't felt cool enough compared to your overall slider usage.
[Standard]
  1. 00:29:998 (1,3) - Maybe a symmetry in shape would worked more cool?
  2. 01:16:052 (5) - Starting 1/2 earlier would fit the song better than now.
  3. 00:42:647 (4) - 01:34:539 (4,1) - Inconsistent rhythm setting. Personally I prefer the later, since it gives an emphasize by ending at 01:34:539 and constructs a lower density, making a difference before the kiai start. Oh, also you can start the kiai with a new combo this way.
[Hyper]
  1. 02:09:728 (1,3) - Not a cool slider overlap if you ask me. I recommend you to at least make the tail of (3) have a higher visibility than the current status. What you've done at 01:59:512 (1,3) will be enough.
[Another]
  1. 01:02:593 (2) - Consider moving 1 grid right to make the follow point invisible, for a higher intuitive readability.
[Extra]
  1. 01:21:242 (5,6,7,8) - Personally this spacing felt a little random. Mind adding an NC for (5) and (7) respectfully for random leniency?
  2. 01:36:485 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - In my personal feeling, (5,6,7) having a larger spacing than (2,3,4) would be more logical to emphasize the whistle sounds better.
  3. 01:38:431 (6,7,8,1,2,3) - Similar opinion here.
  4. 01:41:350 (12) - This is similar with the following, 01:36:160 (12) - 01:46:539 (12) - 01:51:728 (12) - but unlike these, since this was appearing after no 1/4 rhythm before, it only makes me feel that you are not following the major beat you were following in the stream. Double true a beat exists in 01:41:350, but I highly doubt if it's something worth mapping even by inserting a big jump. Btw, I'd personally suggest removing all those (12)s to make your rhythm selection more clear ;w;
Zectro
Hai hai, M4M Round, I'll try my best! :3

[Extra]
  1. 00:35:836 (3) - use 0,4x ds here since it looks llike it is a bit too far out
  2. 00:36:161 (6) - ^
  3. 00:43:944 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Could look a bit more polished/better imo
  4. 01:34:863 (1) - Could be changed into a better looking shape
    the rest of this diff seems fine, very polished and nearly ready for ranking in my eyes.
[Another]
  1. 00:53:674 (2,3,4,5,6) - You should remake this stream with "Convert slider to stream"
    Other than that this diff seems fine to me, only maybe you should consider using od 7.5 instead
[Hyper]
  1. 00:52:863 (5,6) - Kinda confusing since it's right after 00:50:269 (4,5) - which is an actual tripple and there is no nc (specially for new players)
  2. 01:38:431 (4) - maybe fix this overlapping on 01:39:079 (2) - , looks a bit off
    This is once again a very well made and clean diff, can't really say much else about it
[Standard]
Don't seem to be able to find anything here, modding easier diffs isn't really what I am the best at

[Beginner]
Nope, after looking into this one for a long time, I haven't been able to find anything here either!


Great job on this mapset, I hope my mod can at least be useful in some tiny way.. :c
Sc4v4ng3r
Hello~ M4M from your queue~

  1. Unrankable issues
  2. My opinion which I highly recommend changing it
  3. Small suggestions/Nazi

[General]
  1. All clear!
[Beginner]
  1. 00:09:890 (2,3,1) - My personal taste, but I don't see how's the flow here is better than something like this(basically following the circular motion), as right now the flow kinda forces beginners to cancel off their motion kept from the previous notes.
  2. 01:49:133 (4) - Could be just me that hates these kinds of slider shapes, but it doesn't really 'visually appeal' beginners, as the sharp curve near the tail of this slider may arouse confusion. I don't know, maybe it is fine after all...
  3. Going to stop here, mentioning more will be just a pile of Nazi mods ;-;
[Standard]
  1. 01:20:917 (4,5,6) - I found this rhythm to be awkward to play as it skips the prominent sound at 01:21:079 - as unclickable, and expressing the hold on the instrument with 01:21:242 (5) - this note, when it actually starts on 01:21:079 - . I would go for this instead, which does both of that.
[Hyper]
  1. 00:14:431 (1,3) - Damn these 2 notes are really close to each other, kinda confused me for a bit o.o Just a personal taste, considering the distances of other notes, IMO this should be bit more further apart to avoid possible confusion.
[Another]
  1. 02:03:566 (2) - This could potentially have a jump, as it emphasizes the same instrument like 02:03:404 (1) - does, and it goes along with 01:58:215 (1,2) - these 2, leaving this as no jump doesn't feel right.
  2. I feel bad to find so less things on every difficulty :/
[Extra]
  1. 01:45:566 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - My opinion here, but the stream here plays out bit 'bland' for me, it doesn't really give much 'impact' like with other streams in the difficulty. Well of course, right now it is fine, but I feel it will be bit more intuitive if the curve was bit more harsher on (6,7,8,9), which does go along with other streams in the difficulty.
Mapset itself looks really nice already, and it is already starred by Asphyxia o.o
That is all from me. Sorry I couldn't help out much ;-;
GL!
FCL
M4M from your queue
http://puu.sh/kX445/db324cc792.osz my map (yea, i have map limit now, so you can check her, white mod in PM and then copy it and send mid on forum when i will be able upload map)
or you can mod this mapset https://osu.ppy.sh/s/353986, but this is less preferred for me

Okay, my mod:

  • [General]
  1. it is not so important, but maybe make different CS in Beginner and Standart?

  • [Beginner]
  1. 00:33:890 (3) - ctrl+H would be better, imo
  2. 00:34:539 (4) - ^sane
  3. 00:36:485 (3) - idk why you use this form. Form like 00:37:133 (4) - would be better
  4. 01:25:133 (2,3,4) - my suggestion http://puu.sh/kX4P2/147037c7fc.jpg
  5. 01:35:188 (2,3) - it's looks weird, maybe make straight (3) silider

  • [Standart]
  1. 00:40:377 (1) - not critical, but you can make this blanket better
  2. 02:22:863 (2) - make form like 02:21:566 (1) - ?

  • [Hyper]
  1. 01:35:512 (3,4) - blanket would be better
  2. 01:43:782 (1) - don's looks good, maybe tight elbow slider?

  • [Another]
  1. 00:01:458 (1,2) - it's uneven blanket, i guess
  2. 00:11:188 (5) - move on 508;256 for better spacing
  3. 00:11:836 (1) - imo, this sladerwawe looks rough
  4. 00:50:269 (9,10,11) - make like 00:49:782 (6,7,8) - , it's illogically for me
  5. 01:00:809 (6) - make straight silder, like 01:00:323 (3) -
  6. 01:03:404 (6,1) - uh, bad flow for me
  7. 01:42:323 (9,1) - make better blanket
  8. 01:44:917 (5,1) - ^
  9. 02:11:674 (3,4) - uh, spacing too much for me, make a little bit less

  • [Extra]
  1. 00:12:647 (3,4,5,6,7) - imo, this stream is too curved
  2. 01:49:458 (4,5) - i think that spacing here should be like a 01:49:133 (1,2) -

Good luck!
Kalibe
Okay, here's my part ( from your queue )

general:

your colours are so green and so similar, could you add grey colour or smth? :3

[Beginner]

00:14:431 (1) - imo this blanket will be more neat : http://puu.sh/kX5k1/72d7d33f41.jpg
00:31:296 (3,4) - hmm, i have idea : http://puu.sh/kX5vt/592c26809e.jpg ?
00:39:079 (3) - curve this slider to emphasised the music?
00:42:971 (1,2) - NC swaps
01:44:106 (3) - http://puu.sh/kX5GU/406a18739b.jpg ???
01:49:133 (4) - whether this slider is specially?
01:56:917 (3,4) - (3) - x: 170 y: 135 (4) - x: 262 y: 98
02:09:890 (3) - x: 88, y: 167
02:16:377 to 02:26:755 - maybe end here 02:16:377- will be nice proposition?

[Standart]

00:16:377 (5) - down this a little? x: 283 y: 60
02:03:890 (2) - x: 410 y: 170
02:03:890 (2) - curve this mayb?

Nice diff :3

[Hyper]

00:42:647 (5) - http://puu.sh/kX6Fn/1c8307d79f.jpg ?
00:57:728 (3,4) - http://puu.sh/kX6Md/2d37d53620.jpg
01:02:917 (3,4,5,1) - try this pattern mayb? : http://puu.sh/kX6Vf/89554d3528.jpg
01:44:917 (5) - you should curve this, it's good to play
01:59:998 (3) - move this a Little to down, because 01:59:512 (1) - end are not symmetric to (3)
02:10:377 (3) - like in the previous, but to up

[Another]

00:35:350 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - confusing to play :? 01:27:242 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - same
00:35:998 (7) - ^ and NC mayb?
02:11:836 (4,1) - whether these jumps are so big?

And that's all. Sorry for short mod, but you know so good to play. GL with that ᕙ༼◕ ᴥ ◕༽ᕗ

And ye, sorry for nazis-mod ;w;
alacat
yahoo :)

[General]
  1. Nothing!

[Easy]
  1. 00:09:890 (2) - ここの始点が少し違和感があったので00:09:242 (1,2) - こういった音取りはどうでしょう?
[Standard]
  1. 00:03:242 - ここの音が他のところと比べて大きい音があるのでここだけでも音とってもいいと思います。

[Hyper]
  1. Perfect :3
[Another]
  1. 01:02:593 (2,3) - この2つの位置を逆にして、01:02:755 (3,4) - でジャンプさせてみてはどうでしょう!
  2. 01:36:485 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - どっちの3連打も同じ配置ですが音がかなり違うので後者の3連打をキックスライダーなどで音を取ってみてはどうでしょう?または、スペーシングを後者だけ空けてみるなどなど・・・
  3. 01:41:674 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - ^・・・以下略
  4. 02:03:079 (7) - 形そのままで02:02:431 (3) - の終点にスタックさせてみてはどうでしょう?次の02:03:404 (1,2) - の入りへの流れがよりよくなると思います。
  5. 02:25:296 (1) - 個人的に、流れ見やすさを考えるとこのあたりがいいかなって思いました。
[Extra]
  1. Asphyxiaと同じ意見でOD高いほうが好きです!
  2. 00:36:647 (4,5,6,1,2,3) - (6,1)のジャンプがほぼ真横なので上か下に移動するように(1,2,3)を移動してみてはどうでしょう?叩きやすさ/流れも良くなると思います。
  3. 01:03:404 (1) - ここはNew comboいらないと思います。
  4. 01:39:241 (6) - 音が伸びてるので1/2のスライダーより3/4で音を取ったほうが自然になると思います。
  5. 02:04:052 (4,5,1) - (1)に強い音があるので(4,5)の間を狭くして(5,1)の間で大きいジャンプにしてみてはどうでしょう!
(•̀ᴗ•́)و(•̀ᴗ•́)و(•̀ᴗ•́)و
Battle
[Beginner]
00:13:458 (3,1) - Probably can be blanketed a little bit better, really a minor thing

[Standard]
00:31:296 (3,4) - This is just personal opinion, but I would make the 1-2-3 part move in a way so that you can make it curve upwards instead of downwards to increase flow
01:14:917 (2,3) - Blanket can be fixed, also DS is .86 compared to the usual .8 so it's pretty far from the usual DS

[Hyper]
00:14:431 (1,3) - Maybe fix, a little too close, so it doesn't feel like 3 is like imitating the curve or w/e
00:52:215 (2,3,4) - I dunno about this, they are single taps but then right after these single taps it goes into a triplet, and it might be hard to distinguish the two for hard players :v, maybe make the 3 go somewhere else to make it a back and forth motion?
01:21:890 (1,2) - Make more parallel?
01:24:160 (5,2) - Fix stack
01:38:431 (4,2,3,4) - with the triplet stacked, it touches the slider end of 4, maybe move the triplet down a bitt?
02:09:728 (1,3) - Maybe find a way to make this overlap cleaner looking?

[Another]
00:24:809 (1,2,3,4) - 00:28:701 (1,2,3,4) - , for these two, I'm kinda curious on why you didn't make it like the rest, there isn't changes in the music (not any that I can hear at least) so maybe map these like the rest?
01:33:566 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Maybe make the spacing from 5-6 the same as the spacing from 1-2?
01:53:350 (2,4,1) - The only problem I have is that 1 overlaps the other notes FAR more than the rest of them did, maybe make them so they make a little triangle pattern with the edges touching?

[Extra]
00:11:512 (6,1) - Maybe move down 1 a little so the slider end of 6 is more inside the 1?
Rest looks really nice to me~

Hope this mod at least get's 1 thing accepted :o
Topic Starter
Gamu
Thank you for modding!

Applied some suggestions. Sorry, but I can't reply because there are too many mods and I'm lazy lol.
Asphyxia
がんばれ!(づ。◕‿‿◕。)づ
Topic Starter
Gamu

Asphyxia wrote:

がんばれ!(づ。◕‿‿◕。)づ
Thank you ヾ(๑>◡<)ノ"
alacat
Let's go!! :3

~(‾▿‾~)
Kalibe
Oh Yeah !(^3^)!
Seijiro
Soo good
Battle
gz \o/
Chewin
noooo i love this! Epic job mate C:
Topic Starter
Gamu

alacat wrote:

Let's go!! :3

~(‾▿‾~)
おおありがとうございます~ζ*'ヮ')ζ

Kalibe wrote:

Oh Yeah !(^3^)!
Yay!

MrSergio wrote:

Soo good
thank you :3

Battle wrote:

gz \o/
thank you \:D/

Chewin wrote:

noooo i love this! Epic job mate C:
wow thank you <33
Asahina Momoko
yay gratz \:D/
Nathan

Asahina Momoko wrote:

yay gratz \:D/
Natsu
gratz gamu :3!
-Nanaka-
えりーとまっぱー
Sylith
oh wow
congratulations!
zyoi
grats moe Gamumu o3o
Topic Starter
Gamu

Asahina Momoko wrote:

yay gratz \:D/
YAY (∩・▽・∩)

sukiNathan wrote:

Asahina Momoko wrote:

yay gratz \:D/
YAY (∩・▽・∩)

Natsu wrote:

gratz gamu :3!
thank you natsu~ :3

-Nanaka- wrote:

えりーとまっぱー
もっと上手くなりたい

Sylith wrote:

oh wow
congratulations!
thank you :D

Enjoy wrote:

grats moe Gamumu o3o
thank you moe Enjoy!
meii18
Omedeto Gamu (~=3=)~
Mao
Gratz! :3/
Hula
Can't disqus so,

Map's great 10/10.
Topic Starter
Gamu

ByBy13 wrote:

Omedeto Gamu (~=3=)~
Arigato byby ₍₍ (ง ˘ω˘ )ว ⁾⁾

Mao wrote:

Gratz! :3/
Thanks :3

Hula wrote:

Can't disqus so,

Map's great 10/10.
thank you!
Please sign in to reply.

New reply