CelsiusLK wrote:

[General]

1. SB- 02:25:741 - I think it better to make this part flash only 2 times to make it consistent with the 2 emphasized beat here , the flash after that is a bit redundant for me But there's a small guitar sound, it'd feel really empty without it.
2. Suggestion on 3rd kiai , suggest end kiai here first 02:31:018 - then start kiai again here 02:35:463 - and end it here 02:42:130 - and the last start kiai here 02:44:352 - then end it here 02:48:796 -
   SPOILER

   
   This is just my suggestion depend on how tone the music is there Well, i just can't abandon strong tracks that deserves kiai time. Despite it is a full chorus at this part.
3. There is thumb.db file in SB folder and it doesn't seem to do anything with sb so I think you can delete it I thought i already deleted it with Krauv's SB mod, but i'll check the files again.

[Hard]

1. 00:26:574 (1,3) - Aesthetic - fix stack I tried my best here, hopefully it's a perfect stack for now.
2. 00:37:130 (5) - NC for change in spacing ? It doesn't seems big for a NC, it can be noticeable to players. So i'm keeping this.
3. 00:45:463 (4,1) - Aesthetic - fix stack Okay
4. 00:48:241 (6,7) - Make spacing a bit consistent with 00:47:685 (4,5,6) - (use ds 2.00x there ) This is on purpose, i did use x2.0 spacing, but this is the results.
5. 00:53:241 (1,2) - You can use different pattern here , using the same pattern at the same place is kinda a bit feel repetitive for hard It'll be more repetitive if done another pattern
6. 00:57:963 (2,3) - Ctrl+G these notes would make flow a bit better here imo It's the same flow and playstyle imo, but okay
7. 01:26:018 (6) - NC for change in spacing ? Same reason
8. 01:31:574 (4,6) - Aesthetic - fix stack I tried my best here too, fixed~
9. 01:36:852 (5) - x56 y72 ? this would make flow a bit better for hard and make spacing here 01:36:852 (5,6,7) - somehow more consistent Great idea! Okay
10. 01:41:574 (5) - Curve the another way so it flow with (1) better if you aware about flow at (4)->(5) try this I liked the way you made a slider curve on another position, it's good imo. But i prefer the current one, which passes on symmetry and simple flow. Thanks for the efforts.
    SPOILER

    
11. 01:47:407 - Leave this beat empty feel weird for me and it can make the player misclick this so suggest adding a note here Okay
12. 02:04:630 (2,3) - I think it's okay to make spacing here same as 02:04:352 (1,2) - since the beat here really support it somehow also better make spacing here 02:04:908 (3,4) - consistent with 02:04:352 (1,2) - Hmm... I've fixed here a little bit.
13. 02:32:685 (5,6,1) - I suggest stack the triplet at (5)'s tail , it play better that way like what you did here 02:35:463 (1,2,3) - But the 1/4 streams is coming up next, so this might be a warn for players to know. Keeping this.
14. 02:34:074 (4,5,6,7,8) - The curve here can be a bit better here Nice, okay
    SPOILER

    
15. 03:05:463 (2,2) - Aesthetic-Stack ? Nahh.. not probably making a stack here, making a square formation.
    

[Normal]

1. 00:27:963 (3,4) - 1/2 slider sound better imo I guess a triple 1/2 circles feels best for Normal diffs.
2. 00:32:407 (3,4) - ^ ^
3. 01:15:463 (1) - tbh follow the white tick here sound a bit better But following a bit of vocals might be better as well.
4. 01:22:130 - Sound weird to ignore this downbeat , try this I mainly follow the vocals here, but thanks for the efforts.
   SPOILER

   
5. 01:26:018 (3,1) - Stacking 1/2 feel hard for normal diff imo Doesn't look REALLY that hard.
6. 01:24:352 - This might sound better
   SPOILER

   
   why ignore some downbeat when you mapped them in first part of music? Mainly following the vocals here.
7. 01:30:463 (3,4) - 1/2 slider sound a bit better here imo Same reason
8. 02:04:352 (1,2,3,4) - 1/2 slider sound better imo Right here, okay
   SPOILER

   
   
   The three continous 1/2 circles here play a bit weird for me like the 1/2 slider would fit it better so you need to consider those notes I'll think about it...

[Easy]

1. 00:35:463 (3) - Curve another way so it flow with 00:37:130 (4) - better Okay, make a blanket here too
2. 01:18:796 (2) - I'd make something like this so it flow better for beginner Pretty good and wise idea, but i prefer the current one to resemble the rhythm a bit for beginners to play easily.
   SPOILER

   
3. 02:21:018 (4) - x384 y220 so it flow with 02:19:907 (3) - better A bit the same as the current one, but i'll keep this.
4. 02:34:352 (4) - Move tail a bit so it head to (1)'s head which make the flow here nice Okay
   SPOILER

   
5. 03:06:018 (1) - It better to put this note around center so it more easy for beginner to play Okay

Good luck

1. 00:33:241(1) Move it 1 grid up (Grid size 4). More Aesthetic imo
2. 01:36:018(1) Maybe make all of the slider look round, not just the second half (The edge looks kind of weird with the hitcircle inbetween)

1. 00:19:907(2,3,4) Bring in some movement, other than straight up & You could increase the distance between 1 & 2 a bit more
   Example:
   SPOILER

   
2. 01:17:685(1,2) But 3,4 and 1 a bit higher and to the right, to make it fit better
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 01:30:468(3,4) But it slightly closer to 4, The difference between 3 & 4 is slightly bigger than 4 & 1
4. 02:26:574(1) Is slightly below the center of the storyboard effect. Why not moving it to the center? (move to x:68 & y:292)

• 
  I honestly had troubles even finding something within this diff

1. 03:00:185 Might be something general, but I think the spinner should start 1/2 earlier than it does now. (Also, I didn't want this to be completely empty :$ I could not find any other things bothering me, good job on this one!)

Mono98 wrote:

Hello, this is my entry for you M4M queue. Keep in mind that I am not too skilled at modding, so please excuse that if you will (^^) (I already noticed that I won't have too much work modding this after the testplays)

[Easy]

1. 00:33:241(1) Move it 1 grid up (Grid size 4). More Aesthetic imo Okay
2. 01:36:018(1) Maybe make all of the slider look round, not just the second half (The edge looks kind of weird with the hitcircle inbetween) It's on purpose for making one instead of full simplified blanket, so i'll keep this.

[Normal]

1. 00:19:907(2,3,4) Bring in some movement, other than straight up & You could increase the distance between 1 & 2 a bit more
   Example:
   SPOILER

   
   Since some modders before you mentioned this, i'll curve.
2. 01:17:685(1,2) But 3,4 and 1 a bit higher and to the right, to make it fit better
   
   SPOILER

   
   Okay
3. 01:30:468(3,4) But it slightly closer to 4, The difference between 3 & 4 is slightly bigger than 4 & 1 It looks really fine by the looks if it.
4. 02:26:574(1) Is slightly below the center of the storyboard effect. Why not moving it to the center? (move to x:68 & y:292) But during playtime, it is already on the center for the SB effect.

[Hard]

• 
  I honestly had troubles even finding something within this diff

1. 03:00:185 Might be something general, but I think the spinner should start 1/2 earlier than it does now. (Also, I didn't want this to be completely empty :$ I could not find any other things bothering me, good job on this one!) I wasn't following the vocals here, started it on the second beat. Which is stronger than the previous one for a spinner to start.

Good luck!

jloughman14 wrote:

Hello from Jloughman14's and DahplA's Modding Team! Country song say whaaaa?! whaaaaaaa

Easy

01:36:018 (1) - Try and blanket the previous slider a bit cleaner with this. Well, some modders before you complained this, so i guess i'll change it.

Normal

00:59:907 (1) - No need for NC Okay

Hard

AR 7.5-8 I think it's too high for a Hard like this one. So i'm keeping it AR7.
00:20:741 (4) - Delete Okay
02:34:074 (4,5,6,7,8) - Even this out a bit more Changed a bit here.

Wow, this was an amazing mapset. I don't know if you even needed me for this but hey, anything to help out! Please vote on how good my modding was on my queue page. My Modding Queue

_Unreality_ wrote:

Hello from mod req

[Easy diff]

01:21:574 (4,1,2,3) - I think it's too hard for beginners. Try replacing the blanket But at least it's visible and readable, i'll keep this.
02:28:241 (2,3,4) - ^ ^
02:33:241 (3) - delete finish clap Removed only clap.
Nice map Good Job ty


[Normal diff]

00:20:463 (2,3,4) - Delete 3combo circle (note ) Following vocals here.
00:24:907 (2,3,4) - ^ -You've got the rhythm closed . 2-3-2-3 . It is better to remove the extra notes. Which empty space ^
00:39:907 - Omg Add clap note. Strong percussion music can not be ignored . https://imgur-archive.ppy.sh/T9zjSho.png I skipped this for following vocals, i don't have any intentions for the other song tracks, since it's a bit intense than this beat.
00:43:241 (3,4,1) - ^ O-o ^
00:43:241 (3,4,1) - ^ In normals much better on the Voice of not paying attention . Then it will be easier for beginners to play. ^
00:48:241 (4,1,2) - ^ ^
01:09:352 (3,4,5) - Try to cut . It's too long and complicated for beginners. Okay
01:29:352 (2,3,4,1,2) - Difficult place for beginners. But it looks fine and readable, i don't think it's really that hard.
02:46:018 (4,1,2) - add note Same reason.


[Hard diff]

02:04:908 (3,4,5,6,7) - try to simplify I don't understand you here, but this pattern seems okay for the rhythm here.

No more problems . good job ty


Good Luck

Lally wrote:

hello o3o

[Hard]
03:00:463 (1) - you're 1/2 late with BS and spinner and kiai should start at 03:00:185 - Well... some modders complained this too, so i'll change it for now.

[Normal]
01:13:796 (2,3) - use a slider here Okay
01:22:407 (1,2,3) - what about a reverse slider here? As expected, okay~
02:06:296 (4) - i would use 1/2 and not 1/4 rhythm here :V Ouch, okay :V
03:00:463 (1) - you're 1/2 late with BS and spinner and kiai should start at 03:00:185 - Okay, same reason.
03:05:463 (1,2) - just to be sure i would delete this 2 But... there's a beat that's probably cannot be ignored, so i added (2) here. Keeping this.

[Easy]
00:57:685 (2) - try to place it like that is nicer,and ofc fix the spacing after Sure, okay

SPOILER

02:52:685 (3,1) - dun wanna be nazi but is not dat perfect Changed a little bit here, ofc it doesn't look perfect lol
03:00:463 (1) - you're 1/2 late with BS and spinner and kiai should start at 03:00:185 - Okay, same reason.

k call me back o3o

1. sorry about but i had a typo mistake BS = SB so you should resnap 03:00:463 - flash + immage to 03:00:185 - where is supposed to be

1. 03:05:463 (1,2) - this will be fine because is more than 1000 ms in 100 BPM so it's ok
2. i would low the HP to 4 to have consistency like in the others diff

HabiHolic wrote:

Edit : No Pick. i think your map is good! Nice! have this

Ranked