давно я этого не делал
forum
ALiCE'S EMOTiON - Evening Steps
posted
Total Posts
46
Kodora
Topic Starter
нет
Topic Starter
вау. спасибо
good stuff
I've mapped this song before (unsubmitted) and I noticed some minor snapping errors with the maps. Also some parts felt kinda awkward to play.
LC's Insane
00:01:684 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - The gap there and at 00:13:861 feels kinda weird to me, and there's certainly a sound you can map a half beat circle to there, which I'm sure you've noticed, but if that's just your style, then ok, but I think it would feel better to play without the gap.
00:08:743 (1,2) - I feel the same way about these. The first time you use them, it's kinda fitting because there's a sound in the song for the starts of both of those sliders, but here it just feels weird to play. And you keep repeating this for the rest of the intro, again, it doesn't rhyme, but I suppose it's tolerable and subjective, but I for one find it awkward to play.
00:34:949 (4,5) - The doubles you use here and for the rest of this calm part don't rhyme accordingly, the circles should be placed on the beat and quarter beat snaps, not quarter beat and half beat. Just feels really weird to play, should be fixed.
00:49:331 (5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - The stream should begin at the orange 1, not at the purple 5. I can't hear any quarter beat piano in the song until the orange 1, only half beat piano. And if you said that there is a quarter beat piano at the purple 5-8, it's not audible enough. Feels weird.
01:03:802 (1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - Why so many new combos here?
01:12:272 (1,2,3) - Incorrect snapping. The first slider should end at the 4/8 beat preceding the half beat. Second slider should begin at the 3/4 quarter beat preceding the 7/8 beat. The third slider should start at the 8/8 preceding the 1/2 beat. You can halve this slider in half and make it a reverse slider that reverses at 2/8 and ends at the 5/8, it rhymes a looot better that way. You can replace the little stream with a 1/2 and a 2/2 circle. Or you can keep the stream and not use a reverse slider at all, though it would be more fitting with one. The other maps also seem to have this problem from what I saw.
01:15:272 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Hitsounding here is weird. Also, more incorrect snapping. Same thing, Slider 4 should preferably be a reverse slider which reverses at 4/8 and ends at 7/8.
01:20:743 (1) - This is also incorrectly snapped since it should end at a half beat, and not be a reverse slider in the first place, even though it does sound and feel relatively good. Same thing for 01:23:567 (1) -
01:26:566 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Same problem as in 01:15:272.
02:15:449 (3,4) - This could be a triplet.
LC's Insane
00:01:684 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - The gap there and at 00:13:861 feels kinda weird to me, and there's certainly a sound you can map a half beat circle to there, which I'm sure you've noticed, but if that's just your style, then ok, but I think it would feel better to play without the gap.
00:08:743 (1,2) - I feel the same way about these. The first time you use them, it's kinda fitting because there's a sound in the song for the starts of both of those sliders, but here it just feels weird to play. And you keep repeating this for the rest of the intro, again, it doesn't rhyme, but I suppose it's tolerable and subjective, but I for one find it awkward to play.
00:34:949 (4,5) - The doubles you use here and for the rest of this calm part don't rhyme accordingly, the circles should be placed on the beat and quarter beat snaps, not quarter beat and half beat. Just feels really weird to play, should be fixed.
00:49:331 (5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - The stream should begin at the orange 1, not at the purple 5. I can't hear any quarter beat piano in the song until the orange 1, only half beat piano. And if you said that there is a quarter beat piano at the purple 5-8, it's not audible enough. Feels weird.
01:03:802 (1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - Why so many new combos here?
01:12:272 (1,2,3) - Incorrect snapping. The first slider should end at the 4/8 beat preceding the half beat. Second slider should begin at the 3/4 quarter beat preceding the 7/8 beat. The third slider should start at the 8/8 preceding the 1/2 beat. You can halve this slider in half and make it a reverse slider that reverses at 2/8 and ends at the 5/8, it rhymes a looot better that way. You can replace the little stream with a 1/2 and a 2/2 circle. Or you can keep the stream and not use a reverse slider at all, though it would be more fitting with one. The other maps also seem to have this problem from what I saw.
01:15:272 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Hitsounding here is weird. Also, more incorrect snapping. Same thing, Slider 4 should preferably be a reverse slider which reverses at 4/8 and ends at 7/8.
01:20:743 (1) - This is also incorrectly snapped since it should end at a half beat, and not be a reverse slider in the first place, even though it does sound and feel relatively good. Same thing for 01:23:567 (1) -
01:26:566 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Same problem as in 01:15:272.
02:15:449 (3,4) - This could be a triplet.
лучшие моды у нас в клубе
Topic Starter
J1NX1337
Thanks for post-rank modding, I guess?J1NX1337 wrote:
LC's Insane
00:01:684 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - The gap there and at 00:13:861 feels kinda weird to me, and there's certainly a sound you can map a half beat circle to there, which I'm sure you've noticed, but if that's just your style, then ok, but I think it would feel better to play without the gap. — that is. The gap is there for emphasis, esp. 00:13:861, where it outlines the jump
00:34:949 (4,5) - The doubles you use here and for the rest of this calm part don't rhyme accordingly, the circles should be placed on the beat and quarter beat snaps, not quarter beat and half beat. Just feels really weird to play, should be fixed. — I can see that you are more used to triplets than to offbeat doubles. Yes, white + blue feels more complete than blue + red, but the sound you hear is on the blue tick. Besides, do you know 3/4th sliders? It's basically the same thing, except it's shifted 1/2 forward (and it's just slider replaced with two notes): http://puu.sh/gnadz/8ee874bba3.jpg
00:49:331 (5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - The stream should begin at the orange 1, not at the purple 5. I can't hear any quarter beat piano in the song until the orange 1, only half beat piano. And if you said that there is a quarter beat piano at the purple 5-8, it's not audible enough. Feels weird. — there are piano sounds, and they're just as audible as the rest of the stream
01:03:802 (1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - Why so many new combos here? — to denote the change in music, I suppose, and also introduce a player to a new wave of 1/4s at 01:05:214
01:12:272 (1,2,3) - Incorrect snapping. The first slider should end at the 4/8 beat preceding the half beat. Second slider should begin at the 3/4 quarter beat preceding the 7/8 beat. The third slider should start at the 8/8 preceding the 1/2 beat. You can halve this slider in half and make it a reverse slider that reverses at 2/8 and ends at the 5/8, it rhymes a looot better that way. You can replace the little stream with a 1/2 and a 2/2 circle. Or you can keep the stream and not use a reverse slider at all, though it would be more fitting with one. The other maps also seem to have this problem from what I saw. — unfortunately, this is correct snapping, because it fits no other placements (except 1/6 − 1/12 − 1/6, but again, it sounds delayed). I verified this with Charles and he confirmed that both placement and timing are correct[2015 | Feb 25 | 21:25:26] <Charles445> 01:12:576 (2) - rofl
[2015 | Feb 25 | 21:25:28] <Charles445> that's epic
[2015 | Feb 25 | 21:26:15] <TicClick> this is correct, right
[2015 | Feb 25 | 21:26:44] <Charles445> yes
01:15:272 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Hitsounding here is weird. Also, more incorrect snapping. Same thing, Slider 4 should preferably be a reverse slider which reverses at 4/8 and ends at 7/8. — define "weird". By the way, 4 follows piano, which is (I am dead sure about that) on the red tick
01:20:743 (1) - This is also incorrectly snapped since it should end at a half beat, and not be a reverse slider in the first place, even though it does sound and feel relatively good. Same thing for 01:23:567 (1) - it could only end on blue tick in the same manner as 01:10:861 (1), and it's converted to a repeating one to have the middle point of that whistle-like sound, 01:20:875, mapped
01:26:566 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Same problem as in 01:15:272. — same answer as for 01:15:272
02:15:449 (3,4) - This could be a triplet. — could be, but I've been explicitly told by the guest mapper to keep it like that, unless I find a placement good enough to emphasize the very last note 02:15:802 (1), be it a jump or something else. Making it a triplet would make it less special, and also there are beats for 5 notes, not 3+1, so I guess it was an "all or nothing" kind of decision
Whatever then, if you're not gonna agree to my mod, I'm not gonna start arguing over it. I still think the snapping is incorrect and some note placement is excessive or awkward.TicClick wrote:
J1NX1337Thanks for post-rank modding, I guess?J1NX1337 wrote:
LC's Insane
00:01:684 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - The gap there and at 00:13:861 feels kinda weird to me, and there's certainly a sound you can map a half beat circle to there, which I'm sure you've noticed, but if that's just your style, then ok, but I think it would feel better to play without the gap. — that is. The gap is there for emphasis, esp. 00:13:861, where it outlines the jump
00:34:949 (4,5) - The doubles you use here and for the rest of this calm part don't rhyme accordingly, the circles should be placed on the beat and quarter beat snaps, not quarter beat and half beat. Just feels really weird to play, should be fixed. — I can see that you are more used to triplets than to offbeat doubles. Yes, white + blue feels more complete than blue + red, but the sound you hear is on the blue tick. Besides, do you know 3/4th sliders? It's basically the same thing, except it's shifted 1/2 forward (and it's just slider replaced with two notes): http://puu.sh/gnadz/8ee874bba3.jpg
00:49:331 (5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - The stream should begin at the orange 1, not at the purple 5. I can't hear any quarter beat piano in the song until the orange 1, only half beat piano. And if you said that there is a quarter beat piano at the purple 5-8, it's not audible enough. Feels weird. — there are piano sounds, and they're just as audible as the rest of the stream
01:03:802 (1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - Why so many new combos here? — to denote the change in music, I suppose, and also introduce a player to a new wave of 1/4s at 01:05:214
01:12:272 (1,2,3) - Incorrect snapping. The first slider should end at the 4/8 beat preceding the half beat. Second slider should begin at the 3/4 quarter beat preceding the 7/8 beat. The third slider should start at the 8/8 preceding the 1/2 beat. You can halve this slider in half and make it a reverse slider that reverses at 2/8 and ends at the 5/8, it rhymes a looot better that way. You can replace the little stream with a 1/2 and a 2/2 circle. Or you can keep the stream and not use a reverse slider at all, though it would be more fitting with one. The other maps also seem to have this problem from what I saw. — unfortunately, this is correct snapping, because it fits no other placements (except 1/6 − 1/12 − 1/6, but again, it sounds delayed). I verified this with Charles and he confirmed that both placement and timing are correct[2015 | Feb 25 | 21:25:26] <Charles445> 01:12:576 (2) - rofl
[2015 | Feb 25 | 21:25:28] <Charles445> that's epic
[2015 | Feb 25 | 21:26:15] <TicClick> this is correct, right
[2015 | Feb 25 | 21:26:44] <Charles445> yes
01:15:272 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Hitsounding here is weird. Also, more incorrect snapping. Same thing, Slider 4 should preferably be a reverse slider which reverses at 4/8 and ends at 7/8. — define "weird". By the way, 4 follows piano, which is (I am dead sure about that) on the red tick
01:20:743 (1) - This is also incorrectly snapped since it should end at a half beat, and not be a reverse slider in the first place, even though it does sound and feel relatively good. Same thing for 01:23:567 (1) - it could only end on blue tick in the same manner as 01:10:861 (1), and it's converted to a repeating one to have the middle point of that whistle-like sound, 01:20:875, mapped
01:26:566 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Same problem as in 01:15:272. — same answer as for 01:15:272
02:15:449 (3,4) - This could be a triplet. — could be, but I've been explicitly told by the guest mapper to keep it like that, unless I find a placement good enough to emphasize the very last note 02:15:802 (1), be it a jump or something else. Making it a triplet would make it less special, and also there are beats for 5 notes, not 3+1, so I guess it was an "all or nothing" kind of decision
Congrats on the qualify, it's a great song.
Поздравляюшки! >w</
awesome( ˘ ³˘)
А как я все пропустил? Поздравляю :3
SPOILER
Rue wrote:
EvilElvis wrote:
SPOILER
Rue wrote:
EvilElvis wrote:
dunno, website kinda fk'ed
Topic Starter
did you even check the tags?wendao wrote:
no La Cataline in tags? that's quite sad
there are just too many to show last oneswendao wrote:
no La Cataline in tags? that's quite sad
dunno, website kinda fk'ed
ну почему новая страница ._.