forum

Smooth - I Try

posted
Total Posts
9
Topic Starter
Trust
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
uNable
Draven: smooooooooooooooooth
[Poithu]
Hope this makes it to ranked.
PrivatHansi1
Ez SS
Adventure
Hi~ i from modding queues

This is difficult, mapping style you're so difficult for modders to search for errors on the map. but I found some errors on this map.
I immediately take an example, the first reply 00:16:302 (5) - the distance should be fitted from the previous and for kiai time (1). 01:28:371 - 01:50:440 - 02:11:130 and to kiai time the others were eliminated, because it is too short.

Good Luck ;)
Zerss


hey~ from my modding queue
even though it's more than 7:00 drain all diffs, i'll still mod all of the diffs


    General

  1. The easy/normal and another/insane star difference is very low compared to normal/hard and hard/another, will make recommendations about it
  2. Letterboxing isn't something really liked, I'll let you the choice to keep it
  3. All diffs except Insane have Widescreen support, this is used for Storyboards, since there's no storyboard, disable it!
  4. Also, maybe you should invert names between Insane and Another, as far as I know, Another is harder than Insane

    Easy

  1. CS2
  2. 00:29:061 (2) - well, it's something aesthetic, but i love to put the end on the other side of the first part - example
  3. 00:32:164 (3,1) - that looks horrible, please do something else
  4. 01:12:854 (2,1) - nazi -> you can improve the blanket
  5. 02:05:613 - at this point, NCs are inverted (example: 02:05:613 - should be at 02:06:992 -) until at 02:12:509 -
  6. 02:09:751 (1) - You could do something less "plain" like this
  7. 02:14:233 (4,2) - make these overlap
  8. 02:42:854 (1,1) - ^
  9. 02:53:889 - inverted NCs, don't forget to put one at 02:56:647 -

    Exote's Normal

  1. You should put some kiai
  2. Some NCs are weirdly putted, try to do something regular, since sometimes, it's some aren't here, some are inverted, etc.
  3. 00:21:820 (3,4) - I don't recommend to put two circles like this, it's really hard, for beginners to read, I'd recommend to put a slider instead.
  4. 00:21:820 (1,2) - Imo these one are better to read. You can keep it
  5. 01:03:371 (1) - Add more space between the spinner and the note, it's unrankable since the "Normal" player doesn't have time to think about switching from spinner to the circle
  6. 01:08:199 (4,5) - The blanket could be improved, same for the copy/pastas
  7. 01:47:682 (1) - This slider isn't looking good and is really hard to read for beginners, please do something else
  8. 01:50:096 (4,5) - Same about the two notes
  9. 02:09:751 (1) - Well, for this slider, you could so something simplier like this
  10. 02:16:992 (2,3,4) - This part flows weird imo
  11. 02:23:027 - Put a circle here
  12. 02:34:061 - ^ and transform (3) & (4) to make a slider
  13. 02:59:406 - Put an uninherited point here and volume -> 5%

    Raose's Hard

  1. 00:15:613 (2,3) - these notes are too close to each other imo, try to add more distance
  2. 00:31:475 (4,1) - ^
  3. 00:33:716 (3) - do it like this
  4. 00:34:751 (2,3) - that distance snap change tho, i'm ok to do like 1x -> 1.2x -> ... -> 2x, but just like 1x -> 2x, it's a bit too much, try to do something else
  5. 00:44:233 (1) - Add more distance
  6. 01:42:164 (1) - like this
  7. 01:56:475 (2) - ^, won't tell the rest
  8. 02:22:164 (1) - Make the end with more points, it'll look much nicer

    Another

  1. I see many not-perfect stacks, try to correct them, if you don't know how to, ask me, or ask in #modhelp
  2. 00:04:233 (1,3) - That stack looks horrible
  3. 00:19:061 (5,1) - For players like me, distance between these objects is actually 0x because I don't move on the (5) slider, and for a NC, that's a pretty bad idea
  4. 00:30:440 (1,2) - If you want to make them overlap, make them overlap like this
  5. 00:34:578 (1) - Try to do something like this instead
  6. 01:54:233 (5,1) - Distance problem
  7. 02:01:130 (6,1) - Improve the blanket
  8. 02:12:509 (1,1,1) - Those overlaps! lol, imo you should put (2) like this (it's an example)
  9. 02:14:923 (5,1) - Distance thing
  10. 02:40:096 (1,2) - (1)'s end overlapping with (2) weirdly
  11. 02:48:027 (5,1) - Distance problem

    Insane

  1. CS4.5
  2. 00:31:820 (1,2) - That distance tho xD
  3. 00:31:475 (5,3) - Overlap
  4. 01:28:027 (8) - I'd recommend to move the red point a bit down
  5. 01:45:440 (2,3) - Improve the blanket
  6. 01:55:958 (1,2) - ^
  7. 01:50:440 (1) - Looks nicer like that
  8. 01:55:958 (1,2) - Improve the blanket (for this kind of blanket, use many points to make it more accurate!)
  9. 02:05:096 (4,1) - In this diff, there's a lot of not-perfect stacks like these ones, it could look a lot nicer if they'd be corrected
  10. 02:08:889 (4,1) - Well, for this, just move (1)'s end on (4)'s end, don't forget to correct the next overlapped note and its blanket
  11. 02:21:302 (3) - As the other one
  12. 02:23:544 (1,1,1) - Well, the idea is good, but the overlap doesn't looks nice, try to do something else :/
  13. 02:30:440 (1,2) - Imo you should add more distance, even though the blanket will be destroyed, because you're seeing that overlap more than the blanket
Good map, but imo it still needs more mods, and then, you'll be able to rank it.
If you have any questions about my mod, ask me on IRC directly, I can help you! :)
Exote

Zerss wrote:

    General

  1. The easy/normal and another/insane star difference is very low compared to normal/hard and hard/another, will make recommendations about it - to begin with, the SR system is VERY broken, I almost never trust that. I can't map the Normal any harder than that, the long 1/4 chains are just enough, however Trust, you can decrease the circle usage and put some sliders in the Easy.
  2. Letterboxing isn't something really liked, I'll let you the choice to keep it

    Exote's Normal

  1. You should put some kiai - I haven't even hitsounded yet.. I'll do put kiai and HS tho.
  2. Some NCs are weirdly putted, try to do something regular, since sometimes, it's some aren't here, some are inverted, etc. - yea I really forgot to fix em, now it's cool
  3. 00:21:820 (3,4) - I don't recommend to put two circles like this, it's really hard, for beginners to read, I'd recommend to put a slider instead. - emphasize stuff, it's not that hard tbh, anyway that's not an easy.
  4. 00:21:820 (1,2) - Imo these one are better to read. You can keep it
  5. 01:03:371 (1) - Add more space between the spinner and the note, it's unrankable since the "Normal" player doesn't have time to think about switching from spinner to the circle - done
  6. 01:08:199 (4,5) - The blanket could be improved, same for the copy/pastas - see the approach line? it's perfect
  7. 01:47:682 (1) - This slider isn't looking good and is really hard to read for beginners, please do something else - it's appealing to me, but simplified it a bit
  8. 01:50:096 (4,5) - Same about the two notes - same emphasize stuff
  9. 02:09:751 (1) - Well, for this slider, you could so something simplier like this - o wow that's good, okay
  10. 02:16:992 (2,3,4) - This part flows weird imo - ya it's too str8, made it more gay jk :>, now it's better
  11. 02:23:027 - Put a circle here - okay
  12. 02:34:061 - ^ and transform (3) & (4) to make a slider - it's the emphasizing stuff, but if those circles are actually unrankable, oh well I'll transform them
  13. 02:59:406 - Put an uninherited point here and volume -> 5% - I'll fix it along with the hitsounds
thanks
Edit 1: I'll put the code here when I'm done with the HS.
Topic Starter
Trust
Ok really sorry for the delay been trying to figure out what to do with this set. I'll revive it shortly and update with a mod reply in a little bit.

@Zerss: I fixed the inverted NCs for Easy but disagree mostly with the aesthetic points. As for the distance "problems" in Another and Insane, that really just seems like a personal shortcoming those patterns are very simple to play through.
Slocker
please finish it
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply