Mystery Skulls - Ghost

posted
Total Posts
6
Topic Starter
[ Shamwow ]
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Saturday, January 31, 2015 at 4:34:39 PM

Artist: Mystery Skulls
Title: Ghost
Tags: mysteryben27
BPM: 120
Filesize: 4214kb
Play Time: 03:51
Difficulties Available:
  1. Hard (2.69 stars, 413 notes)
  2. Normal (1.93 stars, 274 notes)


Download: Mystery Skulls - Ghost
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
i wanted to map this song a while ago but i forgot until now. so here it is!

normal: 100%
hard: 100%
Zexion
M4M From your queue:

Note that my bolded suggestions are stronger than the non-bolded ones.
Words in italic are my first impresions


[General]
-Combos are really weird. Both on Normal and Hard many of them are waaay to long, I will point out some of them but you should really make them shorter.
-Add spinners. Kinda boring when there's no score difference on the leaderboards lol
-Your map needs hitsounding. But I'm terrible at that, sorry.


[Normal]
Settings are a bit high for a normal...
-AR -1
-OD -1

-I kinda understand you're mapping the voice, but I don't really like the song starting on a red tick rather than the obvious downbeat in 00:15:945 , consider starting the song there.
-00:18:945 (6,7,8) How about making a blanket for 6 and 7?
Also, there should be a NC here due to the lyrics. Notice how a new line of lyrics start.
-00:20:945 (1,2) Same here, similar as above.
-00:22:945 (5) NC
-00:30:945 (3) NC
-00:39:695 (3) NC

-00:45:945 (3) I really feel some beats are missing due to the drum in the song, try this rhythm or something with more repeating sliders:
-00:47:945 (8) NC, the kiai starts here and not having a new combo its... weird.
Yeah I think a lot more of NC's are missing but if you got the idea from my previous ones I don't need to point them all. For example the combo starting on 00:49:195 (1) is waay to long, so cut it with a NC somewhere in-between, I would use 00:52:195 (6) for a NC.
-01:03:945 (7) And this again, don't use kiai fountains without NC's...
-01:17:945 A spinner would be nice from here to 01:19:945
-01:39:945 (2,3) Blanket 2 and 3?
-02:03:945 (2,3,4,5,6) This is what I'm suggesting on 00:45:945 (3)
-02:07:945 The Kiai start should be clickeable, how about using three circles or a circle and a slider instead of the repeating slider?

In fact I would suggest this a bit more since you can't hear any beats on 02:07:695, therefore nothing should go in there.

The rest seems really nice, really nice beat placement, follows the song really good, but check those NC's in the rest like I suggested to. Also:

-A spinner from 03:44:195 to 03:51:945 would be nice as well. (Kinda common to end songs with spinners)

[Hard]
Repetitive. Needs more 1/4 beats.
Same thing with the NC's.
-00:43:945 (1,1,1,1) I remember seeing this once, but I believe it's not allowed anymore. (Unfair HP recovery) To be on the safe side, delete the NC on the three last beats.
-Why not use a stream in 00:46:070 ? The song is begging for it! And besides, its Hard so you can do that.

-00:47:945 (3) Make sure to NC this. Delete the NC on 00:47:445 (1) because a half beat combo would be way too short.
-00:52:570 Add a circle here?
-00:55:820 Add a circle here
-01:03:445 Use a 1/4 repeating slider to follow the drums or separated circles, the slider seems more fun to me!
-01:11:820 Add a circle here
-Breaks should be consistent between difficulties. Either map normal to begin the break on 01:19:945 or delete some beats in Hard to start the break on 01:17:945
(either way, try to add a spinner like I suggested in normal)
-02:06:070 A stream should go here too, like I suggested before. Notice the drums in this part.
-02:08:945 (7,8,9) How about two circles and then the slider? Idea:
-02:15:820 Add a circle here
-02:23:570 ^
-02:23:820 ^
-02:31:820 ^

Yeah this is getting a bit repetitive. My only complain here is that there are few notes on blue ticks, I suggest you listen to the drum then add circles and make small streams where they are needed.
--A spinner from 03:44:195 to 03:51:945 would be nice as well.

Other than that, this map is really good! I wouldn't be surprised if only a few more mods are needed. Good luck! ;)
Topic Starter
[ Shamwow ]

Zexion wrote:

M4M From your queue:

Note that my bolded suggestions are stronger than the non-bolded ones.
Words in italic are my first impresions


[General]
-Combos are really weird. Both on Normal and Hard many of them are waaay to long, I will point out some of them but you should really make them shorter.
-Add spinners. Kinda boring when there's no score difference on the leaderboards lol
-Your map needs hitsounding. But I'm terrible at that, sorry.


[Normal]
Settings are a bit high for a normal...
-AR -1
-OD -1

-I kinda understand you're mapping the voice, but I don't really like the song starting on a red tick rather than the obvious downbeat in 00:15:945 , consider starting the song there.
-00:18:945 (6,7,8) How about making a blanket for 6 and 7?
Also, there should be a NC here due to the lyrics. Notice how a new line of lyrics start.
-00:20:945 (1,2) Same here, similar as above.
-00:22:945 (5) NC
-00:30:945 (3) NC
-00:39:695 (3) NC

-00:45:945 (3) I really feel some beats are missing due to the drum in the song, try this rhythm or something with more repeating sliders:
-00:47:945 (8) NC, the kiai starts here and not having a new combo its... weird.
Yeah I think a lot more of NC's are missing but if you got the idea from my previous ones I don't need to point them all. For example the combo starting on 00:49:195 (1) is waay to long, so cut it with a NC somewhere in-between, I would use 00:52:195 (6) for a NC.
-01:03:945 (7) And this again, don't use kiai fountains without NC's...
-01:17:945 A spinner would be nice from here to 01:19:945
-01:39:945 (2,3) Blanket 2 and 3?
-02:03:945 (2,3,4,5,6) This is what I'm suggesting on 00:45:945 (3)
-02:07:945 The Kiai start should be clickeable, how about using three circles or a circle and a slider instead of the repeating slider?

In fact I would suggest this a bit more since you can't hear any beats on 02:07:695, therefore nothing should go in there.

The rest seems really nice, really nice beat placement, follows the song really good, but check those NC's in the rest like I suggested to. Also:

-A spinner from 03:44:195 to 03:51:945 would be nice as well. (Kinda common to end songs with spinners)

[Hard]
Repetitive. Needs more 1/4 beats.
Same thing with the NC's.
-00:43:945 (1,1,1,1) I remember seeing this once, but I believe it's not allowed anymore. (Unfair HP recovery) To be on the safe side, delete the NC on the three last beats.
-Why not use a stream in 00:46:070 ? The song is begging for it! And besides, its Hard so you can do that.

-00:47:945 (3) Make sure to NC this. Delete the NC on 00:47:445 (1) because a half beat combo would be way too short.
-00:52:570 Add a circle here?
-00:55:820 Add a circle here
-01:03:445 Use a 1/4 repeating slider to follow the drums or separated circles, the slider seems more fun to me!
-01:11:820 Add a circle here
-Breaks should be consistent between difficulties. Either map normal to begin the break on 01:19:945 or delete some beats in Hard to start the break on 01:17:945
(either way, try to add a spinner like I suggested in normal)
-02:06:070 A stream should go here too, like I suggested before. Notice the drums in this part.
-02:08:945 (7,8,9) How about two circles and then the slider? Idea:
-02:15:820 Add a circle here
-02:23:570 ^
-02:23:820 ^
-02:31:820 ^

Yeah this is getting a bit repetitive. My only complain here is that there are few notes on blue ticks, I suggest you listen to the drum then add circles and make small streams where they are needed.
--A spinner from 03:44:195 to 03:51:945 would be nice as well.

Other than that, this map is really good! I wouldn't be surprised if only a few more mods are needed. Good luck! ;)
thanks for the mod! it might take a lot more mods in my opinion haha, but i'll be optimistic
Ranger
[General]
placement is so good,really. but....you didn`t add hitsound,right?
first, reduce the beat volume and add clap or whistle match the rhythm.
personally, i favor add finish at kiai start point and start the break time :D

[Normal]
◎ 00:20:945 (1) - remove NC
◎ 00:30:945 (1) - remove NC and add NC at 00:31:695 (2)
◎ 00:56:945 (5) - how about make like this? it looks not good i think.
◎ 01:14:445 (3) - ^
◎ 01:15:945 (4) - add NC
◎ 01:39:195 (7) - make slider watch the 01:39:695 (1) . Example
◎ 01:50:445 - add note here? it`s empty.
◎ 01:50:945 - ^
◎ 02:15:945 (8) - add NC and remove NC at 02:16:695 (1)
◎ 02:55:945 (5) - how about make well-rounded?
◎ 03:27:945 (6) - add NC
◎ 03:39:945 (5) - ^

[Hard]
make add or remove NC like Easy diff plz~ ;)

◎ 00:44:195 (2) - add NC or remove NC from 00:44:695 (1), make balanced.
◎ 01:07:445 (6) - expand slider at 01:07:945 (of course, remove 01:07:945 (7)),
◎ 02:05:820 - how about add circle this? it`s more socialize the music.
◎ 03:11:945 (7) - add NC

call me back if you want mod more ( hard diff carry out so lazy cause i`m so sleppy :| )
Good luck for Rank~ :D
Topic Starter
[ Shamwow ]

[Ranger] wrote:

[General]
placement is so good,really. but....you didn`t add hitsound,right?
first, reduce the beat volume and add clap or whistle match the rhythm.
personally, i favor add finish at kiai start point and start the break time :D

[Normal]
◎ 00:20:945 (1) - remove NC
◎ 00:30:945 (1) - remove NC and add NC at 00:31:695 (2)
◎ 00:56:945 (5) - how about make like this? it looks not good i think.
◎ 01:14:445 (3) - ^
◎ 01:15:945 (4) - add NC
◎ 01:39:195 (7) - make slider watch the 01:39:695 (1) . Example
◎ 01:50:445 - add note here? it`s empty.
◎ 01:50:945 - ^
◎ 02:15:945 (8) - add NC and remove NC at 02:16:695 (1)
◎ 02:55:945 (5) - how about make well-rounded?
◎ 03:27:945 (6) - add NC
◎ 03:39:945 (5) - ^

[Hard]
make add or remove NC like Easy diff plz~ ;)

◎ 00:44:195 (2) - add NC or remove NC from 00:44:695 (1), make balanced.
◎ 01:07:445 (6) - expand slider at 01:07:945 (of course, remove 01:07:945 (7)),
◎ 02:05:820 - how about add circle this? it`s more socialize the music.
◎ 03:11:945 (7) - add NC

call me back if you want mod more ( hard diff carry out so lazy cause i`m so sleppy :| )
Good luck for Rank~ :D
thank you!!
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply