1. osu! forums
  2. Beatmaps
  3. Ranked/Approved Beatmaps
show more
posted

Z3nx wrote:

shionelove wrote:


RIP
shione strikes again,
It's kinda following the 1/8 piano grace pattern here, so it might be an error on the mapper's part
I said might since there is a chance that he omitted the 1/8 grace since the notes snapped to 1/8 is kinda faint, thus mapping to the 1/2 piano instead, whilst using a 1/4 to map to the background instruments ( but tbh it's kinda unlikely that this is the intention )

just my two cents


boop

kinda feel like 1/4 now so idk what's my stand on this, imma just leave that there

meanwhile in another topic,

- Offset -

the offset feels kinda early for the music 03:15:574 - ( cymbal is heard after the timing tick )
aaand another example would be piano chords after heard after the timing tick again 02:47:259 -
more examples 00:57:036 -

basically the whole thing feels slightly early

Edit : After checking for a bit, +5 offset to all timing points should be ok to fix this

- Background -

The girl/woman in the background seems squished, i assume it's because you scaled it instead of cropping it, which makes the woman look disproportionate

I couldn't really crop much due to the head and text so i had to put black boxes, well if you wanna change it, here it is

my summary

Offset : It's not unrankable since it can be change by online offset adjusting also it's maybe quite ambiguous to make sure for now.

Background : yeah, your own is better imo too.

i will ask to pporse to use your own if the map will be disqualify. thanks to feedback!
posted
Don't be so scared at timing, it didn't hurt

And next time, maybe cut off the useless blanks in hitsounds, it could save a lot of time for downloading and disk space



29ms/1534ms :?
posted

OniJAM wrote:

Don't be so scared at timing, it didn't hurt

And next time, maybe cut off the useless blanks in hitsounds, it could save a lot of time for downloading and disk space



29ms/1534ms :?
lmao i would better to pointed out them since i heard it from mapper too....

anyway thanks to make sure about them o/
posted
If there is any timing issue, I didn't notice it while playing, so I don't think it is much of a problem
posted
05:21:641 (321641|3) - end to 05:24:337 -

I think violin sound and piano sound ends here…
posted
SORRY just want to tell u :

04:08:495 (248495|6,248495|0,248495|3,248495|5,248495|1) - the sound is same with 04:09:844 (249844|5,249844|6,249844|0) - then why 04:08:495 - 5 note and 04:09:844 - just 3 note ?
posted

Shinzo- wrote:

SORRY just want to tell u :

04:08:495 (248495|6,248495|0,248495|3,248495|5,248495|1) - the sound is same with 04:09:844 (249844|5,249844|6,249844|0) - then why 04:08:495 - 5 note and 04:09:844 - just 3 note ?
no the sound is not same

04:08:495 (248495|6,248495|0,248495|3,248495|5,248495|1) - piano+drum
04:09:844 (249844|5,249844|0,249844|6) - drum
posted
Wow :3
Suwako's first qualifying o/

but here is a problem...
01:31:081 - add note because it just 3 notes...because the others have 4 notes 01:29:732 - 01:32:429 -
01:40:350 - 01:41:699 - just have 2 note for mayor piano sound which is not consistent with 01:37:654 - 01:39:002 - 01:43:047 - that using 3 note for mayor piano sound...
02:05:687 (125687|5,125687|1) - the sound is increasing... it means should be no jack pattern
02:07:710 (127710|3) - why only 1 note?
04:34:113 - has a loud finish sound... and only use 1 note?
04:35:125 and 04:35:462 - why just note if 04:34:787 - and 04:34:450 - have 2 note?
why not add note at note at 04:20:799 and 04:21:136 - just like you did in 04:19:450 - 04:19:787 - 04:15:405 - 04:15:742 - and so on...)
04:32:091 (272091|4,272091|2) - one of those note must change into LN... just like 04:30:742 (270742|1) - and 04:29:394 (269394|5) - and so on...
04:33:439 (273439|0,273439|6) - ^
  1. 01:12:542 (72542|0,72542|6,72879|1,72879|5,73216|4,73216|2) - i've try to heard this with 25% playback rate
    and i found that the sound is not actually on the white line... listen more carefully with the hitsound... its not sound at the same time with the music
    it will be neat when you move it forward by 1/6...


and this too... :

RuberusuScarlet wrote:

05:21:641 (321641|3) - end to 05:24:337 -
I think violin sound and piano sound ends here…
hm... only that... i hope it helps... :3


OniJAM wrote:

Don't be so scared at timing, it didn't hurt

And next time, maybe cut off the useless blanks in hitsounds, it could save a lot of time for downloading and disk space



29ms/1534ms :?
I dont agree with word "next time"...
many maps get DQ because this simple things such as 5ms delaying HS which is very hurt... this problem is not simple too...
i dont think this map should go on...
posted
5ms delayed is unrankable issue, must be DQ'd for nowadays because it is written in RC
blanks is not unrankable, it is just a waste, just my suggestion. If one thousand maps are using this kind of HS, it will waste 1GB space of my laptop. But this won't be the reason for disqualifcation. So I said just take care next time
posted

RuberusuScarlet wrote:

05:21:641 (321641|3) - end to 05:24:337 -

I think violin sound and piano sound ends here…
the sound pitch of 05:24:337 - is highest but after part still remained violin sound too.

i don't think it's necessary to dq, but good point owo

05:24:337 - のピッチが最も高いのは事実ですが、実際に音がなくなるという話ではないと思います. しかし, 良い指摘だと思います!
posted
If this gets DQ'd for whatever reason, I suggest shifting all the timing points forward by 5-6ms. It sounds a tiny bit early to me as it is.
posted

Takane6 wrote:

Wow :3
Suwako's first qualifying o/

Thanks xD

but here is a problem...
01:31:081 - add note because it just 3 notes...because the others have 4 notes 01:29:732 - 01:32:429 -

Do you know that's not even DQ problem owo ( i'm sorry if you intended normal mod )

01:40:350 - 01:41:699 - just have 2 note for mayor piano sound which is not consistent with 01:37:654 - 01:39:002 - 01:43:047 - that using 3 note for mayor piano sound...

^

02:05:687 (125687|5,125687|1) - the sound is increasing... it means should be no jack pattern

^. you can think it's stylish pattern rather than jack.

02:07:710 (127710|3) - why only 1 note?

^. the pattern flows quite well if column is 4 and 1 note

04:34:113 - has a loud finish sound... and only use 1 note?

^

04:35:125 and 04:35:462 - why just note if 04:34:787 - and 04:34:450 - have 2 note?

^

why not add note at note at 04:20:799 and 04:21:136 - just like you did in 04:19:450 - 04:19:787 - 04:15:405 - 04:15:742 - and so on...)
04:32:091 (272091|4,272091|2) - one of those note must change into LN... just like 04:30:742 (270742|1) - and 04:29:394 (269394|5) - and so on...

^

  1. 01:12:542 (72542|0,72542|6,72879|1,72879|5,73216|4,73216|2) - i've try to heard this with 25% playback rate
    and i found that the sound is not actually on the red line... listen more carefully with the hitsound... its not sound at the same time with the music
    it will be neat when you move it forward by 1/6...


hear carefully in 1/6 beatsnap. at least 1/6 beatsnap is more confuse than current to hear.

and this too... :

RuberusuScarlet wrote:

05:21:641 (321641|3) - end to 05:24:337 -
I think violin sound and piano sound ends here…
hm... only that... i hope it helps... :3

:3


OniJAM wrote:

Don't be so scared at timing, it didn't hurt

And next time, maybe cut off the useless blanks in hitsounds, it could save a lot of time for downloading and disk space



29ms/1534ms :?
I dont agree with word "next time"...
many maps get DQ because this simple things such as 5ms delaying HS which is very hurt... this problem is not simple too...
i dont think this map should go on...

I think you misunderstand a lot. he pointed out 1534ms is unnessary to use.

but you can read ranking criteria says hitsound should be longer than 100ms and at least it follows well even long.
next time, if you want to do normal mod.. then you can do before the map got qualified.. that's what i want to tell to you
posted

Takane6 wrote:

Wow :3
Suwako's first qualifying o/

but here is a problem...
01:31:081 - add note because it just 3 notes...because the others have 4 notes 01:29:732 - 01:32:429 -
01:31:081 - this sound is not same with 01:29:732 - 01:32:429 -
there is only drum sound. the others is drum + piano.. plz one more listen to this part


01:40:350 - 01:41:699 - just have 2 note for mayor piano sound which is not consistent with 01:37:654 - 01:39:002 - 01:43:047 - that using 3 note for mayor piano sound...
hey i know that. but it is my intention. if added note at 01:40:350 - 01:41:699 -, then this part is very uncomfortable. so i used just 2 note. plz remember. we make map for more fun, not for art

02:05:687 (125687|5,125687|1) - the sound is increasing... it means should be no jack pattern
?? they are same sounds..

02:07:710 (127710|3) - why only 1 note?
for comfortable playing. plz Do not care about the number of notes.

04:34:113 - has a loud finish sound... and only use 1 note?
for pattern balance. i think it's enough.

04:35:125 and 04:35:462 - why just note if 04:34:787 - and 04:34:450 - have 2 note?
why not add note at note at 04:20:799 and 04:21:136 - just like you did in 04:19:450 - 04:19:787 - 04:15:405 - 04:15:742 - and so on...)
it's my style. this problem is really heavy? it's unrankable issue? i don't know why u pointed it out.

04:32:091 (272091|4,272091|2) - one of those note must change into LN... just like 04:30:742 (270742|1) - and 04:29:394 (269394|5) - and so on...
no. why MUST ??? plz don't ask about pattern. consistency of pattern is important. yes i know. but it's not absolute RULE. when u played in this part, it's really weird? awkward? uncomfortable? plz respect mapper's pattern.

  1. 01:12:542 (72542|0,72542|6,72879|1,72879|5,73216|4,73216|2) - i've try to heard this with 25% playback rate
    and i found that the sound is not actually on the red line... listen more carefully with the hitsound... its not sound at the same time with the music
    it will be neat when you move it forward by 1/6...

i think that currently located is good...


if i injure ur mind, really sorry..

but currently this map's located is Qualified. so i think... u should mention only unrankable issues....
plz tell me about only unrankable issues..
if this map is sent to DQ, then u can mod about pattern.

and..the number of notes is not important.
eh..yes important..i mean, it's not unrankable issues.. it's mapper's style.

that's all.
posted
asdsf congratulation!!
why got so many yellow thingy asdjsalkfhsa I don't get it huhuhu ;~;
posted
Woah this really identic conflict... x_x grats anyway o/
Just waiting for QAT... =w=
posted
Grz :)
posted
gratz pporse :)
posted

pporse wrote:

Shinzo- wrote:

SORRY just want to tell u :

04:08:495 (248495|6,248495|0,248495|3,248495|5,248495|1) - the sound is same with 04:09:844 (249844|5,249844|6,249844|0) - then why 04:08:495 - 5 note and 04:09:844 - just 3 note ?
no the sound is not same

04:08:495 (248495|6,248495|0,248495|3,248495|5,248495|1) - piano+drum
04:09:844 (249844|5,249844|0,249844|6) - drum
ohhh oops x_x my bad xD it just feel akward for me ...
anyway, Congrats ^0^ ;)
posted
everyone, thank you :D
posted

pporse wrote:

everyone, thank you :D
:)
show more
Please sign in to reply.