Heya, I mainly came here to tell you that the
offset should be a bit less, like
-4ms if not more; I also had a look at the Extra and Another so I'm actually contributing something too, I hope it helps ^^
[Extra]
- 02:24:350 (5,6) - Those are really close, might be easily confused with being only 1/4 apart as there are a lot of higher spaced 1/4s and 02:23:660 (1,2,3,4) is really high spaced and the song doesn't have any less intensity at 02:24:350 (5,6) so it seems confusing / unnatural imo, and it's inconsistent with 04:36:759 (5,6) too.
- 03:20:208 (1,1,1) - There are no beats at the end of these spinners so seperating them feels weird to me, escpecially since 03:28:483 is left out, so I'd rather put the into one long spiner, it's one continuous sound after all. Also, I'd let it end one white tick later at 03:29:518 -, the big gap feels weird to imo and in an Extra everyone can handle just one beat of recovery time ^^ You did both of this in the Insane so it would also be for consistency's sake I guess
- 03:38:139 (1,2) - All other main-downbeats are sliders, these is the only time it's mapped as circles and it feels rather empty too
- 02:12:621 (1) and 04:25:035 (1,2,3,4) are rather inconsistent too, choose one
- Not that much of an issue but after having very big jumps at 02:16:759 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) I kinda missed them at 04:29:173 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) where only (6,7,8) are that big
- 04:52:621 (1,2) - Is not mapped 100% to the vocals but it omits the upbeat on the slidertail - I'd either keep 1/2-slider but map the next two 1/4s clickable (circlecircle oder circleslider) or replace the 1/2-slider with a circle and a 1/4-slider to 100% fit the vocals, then it's more understandable why the upbeat is omitted
- 05:05:035 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) is unusually many closely-spaced notes, I'd at least space 05:05:380 (3,4,5,6) more as that's how it is in the rest of the map
[Another]
- 03:35:384 (2) I'd let this end one 1/6 to be more accurate to the vocals
- Generally the way you space 1/4-gaps between two sliders is very inconsistent: Until the break 02:08:488 (1,2,3,4) is the only time where slidertail and -head are not touching, only there you spaced it the same as many other 1/2-gaps, so that's a bit confusing and I think it would help a lot if those were spaced so no default-followpoint is visible. After the break 02:08:488 (1,2,3,4) and 04:22:970 (5,6) are the same ecxeptions again, they suddenly become more and more afterwards and it's incredibly confusing - How is someone supposed to differentiate between 04:34:005 (3,4) and 05:00:039 (3,4) for example? I'd generally recommend to keep a certain DS between these 1/4s as those barely touching like 04:20:901 (1,2) look rather messy, and the blankets you create with the higher spaced ones aren't that beautiful either most of the time, especially 04:21:591 (3,4) lol. But then again that's rather subjective so dunno, I'd just like it to bee consistent
Good luck!