Thank you all, you did awesome work as I can see!
Kenterz wrote:
[notice]Normal
00:46:207 (1,2) - These 2 objects aren't perfectly stacked I can't stack them better because it is snapped automatically, I can't do anything with this.
Good luck for rank :3
Sieg wrote:
[General]Good Luck!
- Your mp3 128kpbs, you can try to find better version. Difference between 128 and 192 is quite noticeable. I can't, because this song is cutted by me, idk how to cut songs without changing bitrate :<
- anime girl in tags is not related to the song, huh, well… whatever lololol WHY I added it to tags IT WASN'T ME I PROMISE ;W;
Thank you very much!!CloudSplash16 wrote:
From my queue.
[Easy]
- 00:33:793 - The slowdown feels really unnecessary, as the song does not get heavier in this part, and it feels excessively slow. I'd recommend keeping consistent SV throughout the map for Easy. I prefer to keep this as in other diffs
Dzięki Krfawy! <3Krfawy wrote:
Laaaast Krysmes! <3 Bezwartościowy mod od Krfawego aktiwejtyd! >83
OgółemEasy
- Coś się dzieje z tłem niedobrego, bo powinno być, ale go nie ma. Magia?
Normal
- 01:23:448 (1,2) - Tak jak wyżej. I jeżeli tak pomodzisz, to może być chyba problem z DSem następnych notek: 01:26:552 (3,4) - Ale zawsze można symetrią poratować w razie czego. XD Nie widzę tego. ;_;
- 01:35:862 (1) - Jeżeli można, to proszę o ustawienie tego na końcu 01:32:758 (2) - tego slidera. Chodzi mi o to że tera takie ustawienie na bok wygląda dla mnie dosyć randomowo po prostu. To nie jest randomowe, tylko pyknąłem trójkąt z końcówką 01:32:758 (2) - i początkiem 01:33:793 (3) - XD
Hard
- Nowe combo co czwartą notkę wydaje mi się być spamem combami. Zastanów się nad używaniem bo co czwarty wers w piosence, a nie co drugi. Myślę, że jest okej, ale jeżeli jeszcze ktoś tak powie to oczywiście że zmienię. ;w;
- 01:08:965 (1,2) - Zastanawiam się czy taka ilość kółek nie jest trochę przegięta. Gęstość notek jest cool, ale wiesz, kółka są cięższe do klikania, slidery mniej, a to jest tylko Normal. Ogólnie normal jest trochę bardziej wymagający od innych normalów ~120 BPM, głównie dlatego że hard jest trochę przytrudny. Więc bez zmian, trzeba zachować poziom trudności. ;_;
Desko, wierzę w Ciebie! =3=
- 01:06:896 (1) - Popraw blanket, plis. ;_; Ten slider blanketuje do 01:07:672 (2) a nie do 01:06:638 (6) więc blanket jest okej. ;_;
-Bakari- wrote:
Yo, as promised.
[Easy]
- 00:10:517 (2) - the slider ends on the downbeat and it makes the rhythm here sorta broken, if you ask me. Try to replace the pattern with two circles, that'd fit way better. I think it sounds good however and I don't want to change pattern, this is one of my favs in this diff. :< XD
Ayu wrote:
Christmas modding.Easy
- From 00:00:690 - to 00:08:448 - you used a clap on the end of the sliders to emphasize the drums, but the end of a slider has zero impact from the player, making it miss out on a lot of emphasis that it could have. Instead of the player actually getting a feel of hitting the drum, they hit a softer sound and slider over it instead. I don't understand your point at all. So i must delete all clap hitsounds? It seems okay for me, beats when the sliders start are stronger than drums. Especially for easy, when playing is mostly not feeling the rhytm - it is clicking circles when approach circle is closed. No changes here. :<
- 00:10:517 (2) - Here on the other hand, you used the slider start to emphasize the drum, creating inconsistency with the part before. ^ I don't think it makes any difference, sorry. :<
Gift
- 01:16:724 (3) - You should reverse this slider, so the flow will improve greatly. 01:17:241 - Offbeat here, I don't want to break rhytm in this moment.
imoutosan wrote:
Hi hi from wcx's queue 0w0
[Gift]
00:07:414 (3,4) - I suggest ctrl+g and move them upward Ctrl+G breaks flow a bit, but moved up a bit. xD
This song reminds me of one Christmas that I went window shopping with my mom.just for a joke
star
Thank you very much for mod!!Lapis Aoki wrote:
Hi hi <3 mod via irc
[Easy][Normal]
- 00:25:517 (1,2) - Hmm, blanket them for a good flow ? and also, please try to avoid the overlap with (3), will look better imo Added blanket between both but not moved (3) cuz it is the same slider as (1) but Ctrled+Shifted+Ded, I like this. xD
- I wonder why in this diff you used 3 spinners and in the other diff's you didnt, i would highly recommend to remove the other 2 spinners (any 2 spinner) and map it to keep consistency between all diff's
- 00:17:241 (1,2) - imo the tail and the head touching isnt a nice flow, would recommend rotating (2) 90 clockwise and there you'll have a nice flow Meh I like as it is, sorry.
- 00:32:500 (3) - kinda the same as above, but here, (3)'s tail touching (1)'s middle isnt also a nice flow, i would suggest doing something like this to (3) It makes me rearranging many notes after this.
- 00:33:793 (1) - move this to x:104 y:96 to improve blanket with (4) and (2)
- 01:06:896 (1,2) - same like the first suggestion, but do something like this ^
[Gift]
- 01:23:448 (1,2) - ^ ^
- 01:31:724 (1,2) - ^ ^
- 01:33:793 (1,2) - ^ ^
Very nice map! good luck for rank ~ :3
- 01:21:121 (4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - this jump looks too big for a part like this, suggesting to reduce it I very like putting the hardest part in a section before last kiai.
Thank you for all suggestions! Everything that's not copied - changed.blissfulyoshi wrote:
Christmas mod (As a warning, these are technically quick mods from me, so I will be skipping offset checks and not be checking as thoroughly as I might do at times)
Warning: I am blunt about certain points, so please don't take offense.
Hard:
The DS multiplier increase for the slow section, makes the sliders feel very slow and jerky to play
00:41:810 (5,1) - Is this jump intentional? The flow here is very strange.
00:53:448 (5,6,7,8) - what is this jump following? It is not hard, but it is incredibly random to me (looking at previous mods and more at your map, there are a bunch of jumps I don't understand, so not going to say more) I don't know what I was doing but I saw this is good pattern and not very high jump. Plays ok so I don't want to change it.
Gift:
00:06:379 (4,1,2) - you really seem to hate stacking back and forth , if you don't want stacking, at least don't have overlap, please (not going to comment any more about this, fix them if you want) What's wrong with overlapping here? It is practically the same moment as in patterns like this and people don't complain.
01:14:138 (1) - why did you add a new combo here?
01:21:379 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - I don't think anything in the song suggests something this big As in previous mod.
=====================
Not that bad overall, but I feel Hard and Gift both need work.
Hard has a problem of inconsistent jumps. If you want to add jumps to a location, consistently add it with the music. Not a difficult problem to address.
Gift has a bunch of jumps where I question what you are following in the song. Moderate jumps during the slow section, extreme jumps for a slight upbeat section. Pairing this with some ugly overlaps and a few weird antijumps, and you got a lackluster map imo. Maybe someone likes this map more than I did, but just stating how I felt.
Thank you Sakura!!Sakura wrote:
[Hard]
00:50:862 - Spacing starts to increase here despite the song still being kinda having that slow feeling, just continue using the same spacing you were using in this section. I don't get it, all slowed part have the same spacing (except jumps) or I wrong understood you?
256,172,45431,1,0,0:0:0:0:
304,232,45690,1,2,0:0:0:0:
256,296,45948,1,0,0:0:0:0:
256,296,46077,1,0,0:0:0:0:
256,296,46207,6,0,B|292:324|340:304|340:304|376:320,1,120.000004577637
rEdo wrote:
[Gift]
Niestandardowe nazwy diffów znowu są dozwolone? Fajnie. Chyba, że nie są, to zmień nazwę na Insane. Są dozwolone na najtruniejszy diff w mapsecie.
00:54:095 (4,5,6,1) - A ten stream to skąd? Samo 1/2 zdecydowanie wystarczy. Moim zdaniem słychać tam gitarę czy coś takiego, ale jeżeli jeszcze ktoś to powie to zmienię.
Jak na moje to to jest gotowe do ranknięcia. Powodzenia!
All fixed~Sakura wrote:
Recheck~ No kds
[Gift]
00:07:673 (4,5) - Uhhh... i think you forgot to readjust the spacing here.
01:14:656 (5,6) - Dunno why 6 is like over there...
[Hard]
00:48:276 (1,2,3,4,5) - Why no star pattern :<
Call me back.
All fixed!Melophobia wrote:
I started modding this yesterday. I'm sorry if my suggestion is duplicate.
[Gift]
00:00:559 - I don't recommend using 5% volume here, since it's not really safe now.. And I think you shouldn't use a slider in the first place if there's nothing in the song
00:00:690 - Maybe default soft-finish here? I can hear the cymbal sound here and I want you to follow it. Please apply this to other difficulties too if you agree with me.
00:00:690 - How about adding an extra anchor like this to match the slider shape with the next notes? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2361873
00:16:983 - Use the default sampleset here. Sounds much better that way I think.
00:24:483 (5) - This stacking flows really bad imo because of the previous jump. I recommend something like this. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2361882
00:33:535 (8) - Kinda dislike these 3 claps in a row, the last one isn't supported by the song too. Consider removing it and adding a whistle instead.
00:46:207 - Add a whistle here?
00:49:310 (3,4) - This jump is really excessive considering how calm this part is. Please reduce the spacing a little. Maybe you'd better use 3.10x or so
00:55:258 (2) - Feels empty here because there's no constant whistle due to the long slider, how about adding a whistle to the head of this slider?
00:59:396 (2) - ^
00:58:362 - If I were you I would add a note here following the bass guitar in the background music. This is just my preference so it's totally up to you.
01:15:172 - Consider using the default soft-finish here, the current one is unfitting to me and I can clearly hear the cymbal sound.
[Hard]
00:16:983 (7) - Use the default samplset here.
00:37:931 (1) - Add a whistle here?
00:46:077 - This section is much more streamy although this part i's much calmer than the rest. I would remove this note to balance the difficulty throughout this map.
00:46:207 (1) - Add a whistle here.
00:55:000 - ^
00:55:517 - ^
01:15:172 - Same as gift diff, default soft-finish sounds much better imo.
[Normal]
00:40:776 - Add a whistle here?
00:49:052 - ^
00:50:345 (1,2,3,1,2) - Maybe you can use more whistles in this section.
00:59:396 (2) - Whistle.
[Easy]
00:15:172 (3) - Add a clap or something to the end of this slider? Feels empty here due to this long slider.
00:47:758 (2) - Blanket/spacing issue.
00:55:258 - Add a whistle here?
00:59:396 - ^
01:18:017 - ^
01:15:172 - Default soft finish please.
Ok poke me back for recheck.
What is that supposed to mean D:TicClick wrote:
please
it's not even full
after 3 yearsAcularis wrote:
aw hell yeah