Hi, i posted on your queue for M4M since there still was slots.
So first, the whole set needs a lot of changes imo (easpecialy the Oni, i am too exhausted to check all the pattern sorry ;_;).
I tried to point all the important issues, i really suggest you to apply most of my suggestions, the notes structure still needs more changes.
Also if you keep that much patterns in your Oni, the gap between Muzu and Oni is pretty big, that Oni almost is an Inner (some patterns are hard enough, you still need to place them better tho). In this case you may have to map an Oni lol x_x (so if you decide to change that Oni to Inner Oni and don't want to make another Oni by yourself, then i would be glad to do one btw).
(just in case: k are blue notes, d are red notes)
[Kantan]
A lot of off-beat notes :c
- 00:04:126 (3) - remove this finisher, this spot doesn't really sound higher than the previous ones.
- 00:06:667 (5) - this is not really needed once again.
- 00:07:706 (6,7,8) - are wrongly placed, move them to 1/4 later (on the white lines).
- 00:16:590 - add d here ? more consistency with the pattern i just pointed.
- 00:18:439 (19) - remove ? more consistency again and because this rhythm is kinda hard to play for beginners.
- 00:20:283 (2) - ^.
- 00:20:744 - 00:31:821 - many notes off-beat on this part, i suggest you to remove almost all of them and keep a simple rhythm just like - 00:20:283 (1,2,3) -. I mean keep notes like :
x_ _ _ x_ _ _x or x_ _ _ _x_ _x, these style are both alright for a Kantan imo ("_" are whites and red lines without notes).
- 00:31:821 - add something here ?
- 00:37:359 - 00:49:590 - do similar changes than the ones i suggested for the - 00:20:744 - 00:31:821 - part.
- 00:55:831 (41,42,43,44) - this pattern sounds pretty good, why not using it at - 00:52:129 - too ?
- 01:01:359 - This slider is not at the right bpm, remove it and make it from - 01:01:359 - to - 01:02:283 -.
- 01:09:667 (56) - move this to - 01:09:436 - ? to follow the vocal like you do on the whole kiai.
- 01:19:821 - sliders issue again, remove them and replace the first from - 01:19:821 - to - 01:21:206 - and the second from - 01:21:667 - to - 01:23:052 - to entirely follow the vocal.
[Futsuu]
This diff looks better but you have to make it easier (make smaller patterns).
- 00:00:206 (10,11) - remove them and add k at - 00:06:667 - , just like you did at - 00:13:359 -.
- 00:09:667 (1,2,3,4) - try to not get more than 3 1/2 notes patterns in a Futsuu! i suggest you to remove something here, like - 00:09:898 (2) - or - 00:09:898 (2,3) -.
- Ok then you used a loooot of pattern that are too long. so as i just suggested you, you should remove some notes to make it a bit easier, real beginners can't handle these sudden long patterns.
- 00:46:590 - end this slider at - 00:47:283 -!
- 00:58:590 - add something here, else the previous d sounds pretty weird.
- 01:12:898 (2,4) - remove one (or both) of these 2 notes to emphasize more the vocal, they are not really needed anyways.
- 01:19:821 - end this sinner at - 01:21:206 -!
[Muzukashii]
What happened to the SV lol ? keep everything at x1, only the kiai x1n20 MAX! the song is pretty calm and these SV ups are way too much.
- 00:07:590 (18) - remove ? that part is pretty calm so it sounds a bit better with more break imo.
- 00:15:206 (42) - remove that finisher ? not needed.
- 00:19:129 (53) - maybe change this to d ? personnal pref, i like it more as ddkd dk, sounds better in this case imo.
- 00:22:244 (62) - ballzy use of blue line man x_x it works tho, the only issue is the lack of consistency : why have you not done something similar at - 00:24:090 - and - 00:25:936 - and - 00:27:783 - ?
If you change this, then yeah add something at - 00:24:090 -, move your triplet to - 00:24:436 - and then remove - 00:24:898 (71,72) - ? then do something similar at - 00:25:936 - and - 00:27:783 -. else i suggest you to remove that - 00:22:244 (62) - and do something different, that ryhthm is pretty dangerous to follow.
- 00:29:744 (90,91,92) - complexe patterns are not recommended for muzukashii (by complexe i mean anything that is not ddd or kkk). so maybe use kkk or idk ? safer for rank.
- 00:31:590 (96,97,98) - same here, i suggest you to not use a triplet tho, maybe only k d or juste that last d are enough.
- 00:35:052 - this pattern is totaly nope x_x can be hard to hit even in Onis é_è, maybe just remove - 00:35:398 (108) - and add a finisherfor the next k.
- 00:36:783 - and - 00:38:629 - are also similar to - 00:22:244 (62) - lol ;_; so yeah you should avoid these blue lines i guess.
- 00:40:129 (124,125,126) - swap colors ? for the cool effect k d k ddd with the following d k d kkk (+it sounds a bit better as k d k imo).
- 00:46:359 - a bit dangerous again, maybe remove - 00:46:475 (147) -.
- 00:49:821 - too big again x_x, i believe so you can do something better here anyways, - 00:50:283 - seems to be a good spot for a finisher. No suggestion as i have not found something that sounded incredibly good there yet :c (but you have to change it!).
- 01:08:513 - these 2 kkk would sound better at 1/2 later maybe ? just like what you did at - 01:10:590 (63,64,65) - which fits better the vocal.
- 01:12:436 - wrong bpm here again x_x i wonder what happened to these silders lol. the lenght is good but remake it in the right bpm please.
- 01:15:206 (72) - move this to - 01:14:975 -, fits better the vocal/melody.
- 01:21:206 - too long, maybe use a slider here ?
- 01:23:052 - kkkkK is unrable, whatever the difficulty is (thanks to rules x_x), remove - 01:23:398 (98) - or do something else.
[Lino1000's Oni]
Same comment about the SV.
A bit overmapped é_è... There are way too mcuh patterns in the beginning which is a calm part, it plays a bit weird for this reason.
- 00:08:398 (29,28,30)- doesn't follow anything and is wrongly placed imo, remove this and maybe add something at - 00:08:744 -.
- 00:15:667 (61,62,63) - this part sounds better with nothing imo, to imphasize the following d.
- 00:22:129 (91,92,93,94) - sounds weird, - 00:22:590 - needs a note, so maybe do something like k ddk here.
- 00:27:552 (117,118) - sounds weird even tho it might be in rythm, but i have no idea what to do else... it isn't that easy to map i must admit ,_,.
- 00:28:706 (123,124,125) - sounds weird too, try to avoid using patterns that are not at all on white lines (i mean triplet+ patterns).
- move - 00:36:898 (6) - to - 00:36:789 - i guess since that is the rythm you are following after.
- 00:45:321 - these two pattern really sounds weird as both start on blue lines... try something like dkkd kdk d instead of dkd dkdkk ?
- 00:48:436 - better start the pattern here and remove the previous k. this spot surrounded by 2 patterns sounds weird as the melody is hight.
- 00:59:052 - again this spot needs a note.
- mm for the rest of that kiai, the main problem is that you start and end patterns on blue lines... some kd dk etc on blue lines will work in a high drum and bass song but not for this one ;_;. You must do a lot of changes there imo.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Good luck'