Oh gosh it's him, watched him 3 times already and met him twice this year already. Aaaaaaaa
(maybe I should have asked him to sign on his personal album instead of the group ones)Ok idolising aside.
GeneralThere is another romanization of his name, I don't know which one is more commonly used, because they used this when he came over this year:
I'll ask a BATNormal00:00:387 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - can't really tell the pattern of whistles here sadly, each combo seems to be using a different pattern of hitsounding, it just doesn't seem consistent because sometimes I expect a whistle at one point but in actual fact it will be somewhere else
Hmm, I see it's complicated. But there's is no real pattern I'm sticking to, because if I do keep a consistent pattern it wouldn't match the song at all. I checked everything, but in the end only removed 1 whistle 00:32:516 (2) - add clap
I'm stupid >_<"00:36:774 (5) - add finish at the end of slider, no harm complementing the cymbal sounds here in the music
^
00:57:483 (4) - idk about you, but placing this slider around x: 380 y: 152 would be better for the movement from 00:57:290 (3) - if you think it wouldn't look as good being near 00:55:935 (1) then you can rotate 00:57:483 (4) slightly to make it look better, though I don't see much relation to them right now, because the ring from the previous slider is quite far away, something like this:
Hmm.. not really sure what you mean, since I ended up wioth almost the same pattern, but I tweaked the curve a little.01:10:451 (4) - I suggest you remove the whistle at the end of the slider, the sound in the music is actually earlier than where this slider ends, it's just that the vocals end where this slider does, but it ends with quietness in the music (the music starts around 01:10:645 and then stays for awhile before you hear nothing) Hence with the whistle, it sounds odd because it becomes like an add-on to the sounds in the song, like something loud when it should be quiet.
I'll consider this later, since I wanted to emphasize the change of the mood - but I guess you're right.
01:20:903 (1) - remove the whistle, no hitsound here would sound nicer, just like how 01:17:806 (1) has no whistle, but finish. It is also identical to 01:21:677 (2,3,4) which all fit with the clap at the end only
There are quite a few instruments that land here, such as the bass and the 'beep'-sound also starts here, so I'll keep it. Next time if someone mentions this, I'll consider removing it.01:21:677 (2) - remove the whistle
fixed everything below this!01:35:612 (5) - finish at end of slider
01:52:645 (2) - whistle to be similar to 01:49:548 (2)
01:56:128 (3) - cymbals start here too, why not finish
02:05:032 (2) - whistle like 02:01:935 (2)
02:52:064 (3) - add clap to the end of the slider
03:01:548 (3) - finish at start of slider
03:10:645 (4) - whistle at start of slider? All similar tunes in the other chorus have it
03:14:322 (4) - finish at start of slider to go with cymbals
03:27:483 (5) - add clap
Patterns are pretty clean
Hard00:08:128 (1,2,3,4) - why you suddenly started placing the whistles on the off-beat of the music here I am not really sure why, just sticks out from the patterning
Same as Normal00:12:386 (3) - really unsure about this circle here. Sure, you would like to leave a gap, but 00:12:580 sounds really involved in the music and this gap makes 00:12:386 (3) sound like it ended so abruptly
It's also more a consistent-rhythm thing, since I did this earlier - but I do know what you mean. I have no intention to shorten the slider before and make a 3/4 rhythm here, because that ruins it, but I can't really think of something else ;_; I'll leave it for now and see what other modders say/suggest.00:17:806 (5) - whistle on end of slider to be the same as 00:15:096 (7)
00:21:290 (7) - ^ unless you didn't intentionally place that whistle there, then remove whistle from 00:15:096 (7)
These mistakes are probably all
because I'm a lazy freak that uses HS Copier. I had a whistle in the Insane diff, so the triplet wouldn't be so monotonous... but I guess I need to add on all the others as well
Fixed
00:24:387 (7) - ^
so on so forth if the whistle was intentional (really, one whistle in the whole things is so odd)
00:27:483 (7) - ^
00:29:806 (5) - suddenly you have the same whistle here lol, now I'm confused so yeah, basically this hitsounding pattern just isn't consistent
00:36:774 (3) - finish on the end of slider
01:04:257 (6) - add clap on end of slider too, it's the same as 01:02:709 (2)
01:10:838 (8) - remove the whistle at the start of the slider, place the whistle on 01:10:645 (7) as that is where the sound you are trying to follow really is (really, it's there :<)
Removed the whistle, but I did a double-clap on (6,7) instead.01:55:354 (2) - finish on end of slider
01:56:903 (4,1) - blanket could be improved
02:09:483 (8) - can add whistle here like, what I mentioned for the previous kiai, it's similar to 01:10:645 (7)
Double-clap rhythm instead.
02:37:548 (5) - clap at the start of the slider too
02:52:064 (4) - clap at the end of the slider
03:01:548 (1) - add finish to go with cymbals
03:07:354 (5,6) - blanket could improve slightly, the head of 03:07:741 (6) just seems closer than the other end, looking at it with the ring from the previous slider
03:23:032 (5,6) - make them blanket each other better? In regards to the curve of 03:23:032 (5)
03:27:096 (8) - claps on the start and middle of slider? would fit the drums
Good idea!Don't worry about spacing,it's the way you want to interpret it! Even I feel it's still find being calm and less jumpy, that's how I see the song, smooth
Yeah, that's exactly how I interpreted the song! Usage of 1/4 and jumps shouldn't be in a Hard diff with a calm song like this imo (
mostly because i'm terrible at using 1/4 and making pretty and fun jumps ;_;)
Insane00:12:774 (1,3) - are they supposed to blanket each other? There is some imperfection if they are supposed to
Blanket looks fine to me o_o00:17:999 (4) - whistle at the end of the slider? It's the same thing as mentioned in Hard really, so I won't repeat further if there are any more
00:24:774 (6,1) - the positioning here caught me out, unlike other parts, the directional movement here is cut, and it doesn't feel like it fits the music, because the start of 00:25:161 (1) is below the end of the previous slider, and the slight curve actually goes against the direction they are all moving towards to (furthermore, 90 degrees change is always harder to adjust than a 180 one, hence such changes could be weird)
I think the Laurier pattern fits well here, and the flow shouldn't be that awkward. Added a little curve, but might even remove it later. Nice catch though!01:10:838 (4) - remove the whistle at the start of the slider, like 01:10:838 (8) in Hard and place it on 01:10:645 (3) - same reasoning
01:23:225 (5,7) - whistles here like 01:20:128 (5,6) - ? I don't see much difference from their tunes
Only added a whistle on (5), but not on (7) because I think the clap is sufficient.01:35:612 (3) - finish at the end of the slider to go with the cymbals
01:54:774 (1,3,4,5,1,3,4,5) and all other similar patterns in the other kiai times - are you sure you want the slider shape like that? lol because I shifted one of the circles to check and the curve around the circle would be like this:
too much work to change it all owo, imperfect blankets are fine if you can't notice them in-game02:09:483 (3) - whistle, just like in Hard
02:34:451 (3,1) - blanket?
i'm a terrible person02:41:225 (1,2) - guessing you don't want to blanket this, but still looks weird lel
tried to make it better 02:44:903 (2,4,5) - make this one similarly spaced pattern, and then space 02:45:096 (3,6,7) similarly with each other for more uniformity or something? Right now 02:45:096 (3,5,6,7) spaces all randomly, so trying to figure out any sort of pattern in any part of this section right now isn't possible
but that shape is so nice ;_; - i get what you mean tho. i'll rework this pattern if it's a real problem since it plays fine to me02:52:064 (1) - clap on the end of the slider
03:02:999 (7) - should add the drum clap here as well
yup03:09:096 (1,3,4,5) - the blanketing here like 01:54:774 (1,3,4,5,1,3,4,5) lol
i'll prob have to rework a chunk of the kiai to fix this, so i'll leave it for now03:14:322 (2) - finish on start of slider
03:27:096 (4) - same as 03:27:096 (8) in Hard
Kayyyyyy
Good Luck :>
thank you so much for pointing the dumb mistakes i made c:
TAKE ME TO A NICO EVENT PLS