thx for Asph sama's suggestion, i changed all stuffs except this one 00:53:155 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - ;D
forum
Tomatsu Haruka - courage
posted
Total Posts
105
Topic Starter
Recheck
[xxdeath's Normal]
- 01:18:333 (3) - Now the slider here doesn't fit the music at all. Its repeat lands on nothing musically.
- 01:01:496 (3,4) - The overlap here may be confusing for newer players. They will be tempted to press early due to the slider technically being close to the previous note.
[OniJAM's Hard]
- 00:54:150 (1,2,3) - Inconsistent spacing here. is this intentional?
[xxdeath's Normal]
- 01:18:333 (3) - Now the slider here doesn't fit the music at all. Its repeat lands on nothing musically.
- 01:01:496 (3,4) - The overlap here may be confusing for newer players. They will be tempted to press early due to the slider technically being close to the previous note.
[OniJAM's Hard]
- 00:54:150 (1,2,3) - Inconsistent spacing here. is this intentional?
ts8zs
ts8zs wrote:
[12345]
00:35:803 (1) - 1/2 longgerwhat? it's not slider, how to make it longer lol
aLEXEFER
Alexefer wrote:
[Yuko's Extra]
01:09:303 (2) - it's really easy to missclick that slider
01:10:068 (1,2) - I'd drop hitcircles on 1/1 here and on first 1/2 after stream
01:25:833 (7,1) - that slider and jump are IMO unnecessary, just make one long stream
01:29:201 (5) - slider 2x longer
Owntrolf
Owntrolf wrote:
Yuko's extrA!!
00:12:364 (1,2,3) - Could probably use more circles with
00:13:741 (1,2) - Should follow vocals here instead of the piano
00:17:415 (1) - ^
00:40:680 (1,2,3) - there could be some mapping here because it doesnt feel right since it had so many notes in 1/4 and then it suddenly changes to 1/1
00:46:190 (2) - Is a little bit hard to reach
01:25:221 (5) - I dont think there should be a stream
01:29:507 - Should probably have last beat here
appleeaterx
appleeaterx wrote:
Yuko's extrA!!
* Disable 'Widescreen Support', no SB
* 00:06:394 (1) - (Kibbleru/iN/EX) Consider making the spinner volume a little higher after the pitch changes.
* 00:14:813 (1) - I'd put the slider 1/2 beat later. The sound is much stronger there, and now you're basically ignoring the sound at 00:14:966 - which I don't recommend. If you want to have a sound on the red tick just put a normal circle there.
* 00:19:711 (3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2) - This part is bearly hearable (or I'm deaf), I'd raise the volume a bit. You could also put some whistles here like you did at 00:22:466 (2,3,4) -
* 00:38:843 (5) - No red slider points here? It would fit your style to add some red points here, especially since you're following the guitar here o_o"
* 00:48:639 (2) - I'd make the slider straight, or make the curve very small. I don't really hear a change in the song like the previous and next combo.
* 01:14:966 (1,1,1) -hentai sliders<3
* 01:29:507 - Consider adding a note here?
moextrA.
Woah, good mapset! A lot of good mappers here, have a star and good luck on
speed-one-week-rank! [/color]
DarkVortex
DarkVortex wrote:
[Yuko's extrA!!]
00:19:787 (4) - Remove, I can't hear any 1/4 here. Next stream is fine though.
00:19:864 - How about increasing the volume here already? It feels awkward that the drums don't have a real feedback.
00:23:384 (7,1) - Swap these two (slider first then circle) it matches the vocal and the beat after better.
00:25:833 (7,1) - ^
00:28:894 (2) - Move to (126,192) for a slightly better blanket
00:31:496 (2) - Feels delayed after the vocal on 00:31:343 - . I suggest a pattern like this starting at 00:30:884 -
00:35:782 - ^
00:37:619 (5) - 1/4 here instead?
00:40:680 - See box
01:08:384 (5,6,7,8,9,10,1) - The stream doesn't fit imo. How about this instead?
01:29:201 (5) - Make repeat slider if you want to get the final vocal too.
Good map in general, it's just those two streams which were unfitting imo.
RzHr
RzHr wrote:
Yuko's extrA
01:29:201 (5) - move it forward, and add something on it
IMO, iNsAnE more difficult than extrA ._.
NoHitter
Response for the mods, in case of possibly coming stupid situation. :pNoHitter wrote:
[Yuko's extrA!!]
- Map from the start like the other diffs? Considering the map is short already and TV Size, you could increase playtime.
- 00:12:364 (1) - Was expecting a note at 00:12:517 or a slider repeat.
- 00:13:741 (1,2) - The emphasis here is wrong. Maybe map the vocals here? Remap this by adding a notes/sliderstarts/sliderrepeats at 00:14:048, 00:14:201, and 00:14:354.
- 00:14:966 (1) - Same comment here. Remap to add a note/repeat here to emphasize vocals.
- 01:01:803 (3,4) - The jump here is too much IMO. At least match it with (2,3).
- 01:29:201 (5) - Add a repeat here, so it will match the vocals trailing off?
Everything without comment is fixed, as usual.
NoHitter wrote:
Recheck
[OniJAM's Hard]
- 00:54:150 (1,2,3) - Inconsistent spacing here. is this intentional? //Yes on purpose, I think here can have some little jump so i did that
Topic Starter
NoHitter wrote:
Recheck
[xxdeath's Normal]
- 01:18:333 (3) - Now the slider here doesn't fit the music at all. Its repeat lands on nothing musically.
- 01:01:496 (3,4) - The overlap here may be confusing for newer players. They will be tempted to press early due to the slider technically being close to the previous note.
fixed all
Hoping for Project Alicization already ;_;
有戏看吗
good luck
good luck
it's happening...
talked with those and he seems didn't intend to mod it
then, ranked
@chole：记得改改creator，现在要求把guest全写进creator words里
then, ranked
@chole：记得改改creator，现在要求把guest全写进creator words里
gz chole!wcx19911123 wrote:
@chole
Topic Starter
草
3 days
i suppose we could have the ranking process way faster now according to this?
gratz
i suppose we could have the ranking process way faster now according to this?
gratz
GJ, Congratulations!
屌
?
...
...
Grats!
w
Chloe - courage
This was ranked faster than the time it takes for me to get a mod for a map of mine, oh well.
Wow
damn fast
Shouldn't the title be courage (TV-Size)?
YO^^
Gratz^^
Gratz^^
剁吧
those wrote:
subscribing
those wrote:
subscribing
这就rank了 chloe你做点LL的图好不
What 3 days? @@ GOD!
Congratz anyways!
Congratz anyways!
没看出有什么好操心的
坐等被
坐等被
..
Unqualified. Please consider the following issues:
[General]
Please re-read the ranking criteria, which states:
Even more saddening is that someone like wcx tries to rank this. This is a speedrank that is beyond unneeded, especially because the mapset is beyond undone and unfinished. Mods were ignored or brushed off (p/3449344), even tho that this really needs heavy fixing before this can even go for ranked. This is blatant abuse. The mapper clearly was asking every random person for a mod (I got around 15 complaints about this), which is also noticeable when you see the people who actually modded it. No offense to the modders, but this kind of difficulties need also a very advanced opinion, but basically no one who modded this, including the bubbler and ranker, can provide such an opinion. The mods weren't gathered for the good intention to get the map polished but just to farm them off in the meaning of "Let's ask people who will not suggest too much, so I can keep my crappy mapped mapset as it is and get it ranked quickly". This is similiar to a different case and I am not going to tolerate this at all.
Consider this as unqualified for a while. Contact me again in around 6 weeks. Then we can talk about a requalification.
[General]
- Why are soft-hitclap.wav, soft-hitclap2.wav and soft-hitclap3.wav the exact same sound?
- Concerns arose that this needs a (TV-size) label. Someone please provide the evidence for this. We were not able to fully confirm this, yet we find it with (TV-size) on various sources.
- The timing is doubtful. The offset is heavily shifting and got this confirmed by several timers. We will figure out a proper timing when we head for opening this case again.
- 00:50:170 (1,2) - I don't think, this extension is anywhere needed.
- Why is the diff-name so crappy capitalized? There is no need for you to be the special snowflake among all your guest differs. Name it Insane.
- The hitsounds are inconsistently placed and unpolished. For example is this finisher spam here not really needed: 00:25:833 (4) . Moreover 00:26:599 (1,2,3,4) - reaches out of the common hitsounding of this map. 00:29:048 (4,5) - This is also inconsistent from previous steady hitsounding. etc.etc.etc.
- 00:23:002 (2,3) - overmapped
- 00:24:685 (5,6) - ^
- 00:25:451 (2) - ^
- 00:27:976 (4,5) - ^
- 00:28:129 (6) - unneccessary extended slider
- 00:31:343 (1,2) - this follows nothing
- 00:31:803 (1) - why is this extended?
- 00:32:109 (1,1,1,1) - unneccessary NC spam
- 00:33:257 (2,1) - overmapped
- 00:33:869 (4,1) - ^
- 00:34:481 (4,1) - ^
- 00:36:701 (1,1) - this is confusing and doesnt even play well
- 00:36:241 (1,2) - this follows nothing
- 00:37:007 (1,1,1,1) - unncessary NC spam
- 00:38:155 (2,1) - overmapped
- 00:38:767 (4,1) - ^
- 00:39:379 (4,1) - ^
- 00:40:374 (2,3,4,5) - ^ (I stop here, it's getting stupid)
- 00:41:139 (2,1) - what
- 00:41:599 (3) - unncessary slider extension
- 00:41:599 (3,1) - how does that play good? it totally a contradicting movement
- 00:47:109 (2,3,4) - you can't be serious. A 1/4 jump that is mapped like they are 1/2?
- 00:51:701 (2) - same weird slider extension
- 01:00:731 (4,5,6,1,2,3) - this is the definition of overmapping
- 01:08:078 (4,5) - are these jumpy things really needed?
- 00:42:823 (6) - You know, you silenced slidersides and sliderends. This is one of the examples where it doesn't work as you wish it to work. The vocals are fading off WAAAY earlier, yet you extend this and even silence the end to cover up that the object is actually not fitting to anything you mapped, not even to a fade-off of vocals.
- 00:43:588 (3) - this counts even more here.
- why are there two !!?
- 00:22:160 (5,6,1) - overmapped
- 00:22:772 (3) - overmapped
- 00:24:303 (5,6,7) - overmapped. Okay I start again. This song does not contain the triplets you put here. Maybe you want to look into this again. I am sure, you can generate a similiar transistion without overmapping that much.
Please re-read the ranking criteria, which states:
Even tho this is a guideline, you have no apparent reason to overmap it in this way, since it does not even enhance the gameplay experience in any kind. Maybe take a look on Kibbleru's Insane again, since THIS plays really good and is not overmapped and yet an Insane. It's disappointing that the worst difficulty is the one of the mapset creator.Ranking Criteria wrote:
All hitcircles and the starting point of any sliders should be snapped to be a beat in the music. Slider end points should be snapped to a beat in the music, or the end of a prolonged note where appropriate. Adding hitobjects where there is no musical cue to justify them can result in confusing patterns which are difficult to follow and incongruent with the backing track.
Even more saddening is that someone like wcx tries to rank this. This is a speedrank that is beyond unneeded, especially because the mapset is beyond undone and unfinished. Mods were ignored or brushed off (p/3449344), even tho that this really needs heavy fixing before this can even go for ranked. This is blatant abuse. The mapper clearly was asking every random person for a mod (I got around 15 complaints about this), which is also noticeable when you see the people who actually modded it. No offense to the modders, but this kind of difficulties need also a very advanced opinion, but basically no one who modded this, including the bubbler and ranker, can provide such an opinion. The mods weren't gathered for the good intention to get the map polished but just to farm them off in the meaning of "Let's ask people who will not suggest too much, so I can keep my crappy mapped mapset as it is and get it ranked quickly". This is similiar to a different case and I am not going to tolerate this at all.
Consider this as unqualified for a while. Contact me again in around 6 weeks. Then we can talk about a requalification.
my inner thoughts were like YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO but oh well good luck in reranking
poop out a superficially mapped Insane with tons of GDs in order to be the first one with a ranked songYOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
hehe inverness everywhere