Alarido wrote:

RESSURRECTED.

LET IT GO, LET IT GO! LET IT GET QUALIFIED!

Alarido wrote:

Alarido wrote:

RESSURRECTED.

LET IT GO, LET IT GO! LET IT GET QUALIFIED!

yes!!!!!

Project Railgun wrote:

02:52:424 (7) - missing NC ► Fixed.

02:43:852 (1) - remove NC? ► Fixed, although being Kazuya's. @Kazuya feel free to revert or tell me to revert if a NC here was intentional.

Depends on if you want to use the NC from 00:50:519 - or 01:51:471 -

1. Some of your settings are kinda random in all difficulties and makes no sense at all, I mean why not just go and use simple settings? like this for example:
   -Easy: HP: 2 CS: 3 AR: 3 OD: 2
   -Normal: HP:4 CS: 3.5 AR: 5 OD: 4
   -Hard: HP: 6 CS: 4 AR: 7 OD: 6
   -Insane: HP: 7 CS: 4 AR: 8 OD: 7
2. Consider to add "Collaboration" in your tags, because is the complete word of "Collab" a part of that everything's else seems alright.

1. 00:00:043 (1) - How about to use Sampleset Soft in this spinner? just as the other difficulties.
2. 00:28:376 (1,2) - I think these sliders are not follow the vocal singer in a properly way, I mean as previously it does dude that it was a sustained note which fits with this kind of rhythms, but this isn't the case, so I'd like you to change this by something more accurate. (How about this.)
3. 01:29:328 (1,2) - Same as above.
4. 02:20:043 (2) - This is good actually, but the rhythm that you've used is bothering me a bit, I think that this should be ended at 02:20:995 - because it makes more sense than the red tick, since this is where the vocal ends and for obvious reasons is really important to make it clear for newbies players to avoid any kind of confusions, don't forget to use the correct distance snap after fixing this.

1. 00:18:138 (1,1) - Seems like the beats between spinners and objects are correct, but still is alittle bit complicated for newbies to get it and click on an object that is so far from the center grind and I bet that the most of them will miss this note, so could you move it a couple of grids?
2. 01:19:090 (1,1) - Same as above.
3. 00:32:424 (3,4) - Looks like this is the only part where you decided to use this kind of rhythm which could be really confusing and not consistent with the other parts that are exactly the same as this, I highly recomend you to do what you've did it here 01:33:138 (2,3) - it's in a fact better than the current one.
4. 01:37:900 (4,1,2,3) - How about to follow the vocals at this part? I think you could change thse objects by something like this, you should try it.
5. 00:50:519 (1) - Probably you missed the fact that you've used an Normal Finish at the start of all kiai times, so would be great if you consider to do the same thing here.

1. 00:32:424 (3) - Is not wrong or something like that, but how about to use the same rhythm as Alexa or even in the Insane difficulty? it's quite better than the current one.
2. 01:33:376 (3) - Same as above.
3. 01:25:519 (1) - Hey buddy, seems like that you've forgot to add a whistle thingy at the head of this slider.
4. 02:18:971 (3) - Since the previous patterns were just exactly like this one, I mean rhythm and spacing, would be great to keep it consistent the whole section, so consider to move this slider to X:356 Y:56 to improve the readability and aesthetics.
5. 03:00:043 (1,1,1) - This particular part causes that the spike difficulty drops a lot. because the fact that you simply added three spinners which instead in the lowest difficulties it was mapped entirely, so this could make an conflict in the spread due that this is a Hard difficulty, the only solution I could find is considering to map the whole section to avoid it.

1. 00:18:197 (1) - I don't get the fact about started the spinners in 1/8, I mean this could be perfectly placed in an normal snap (1/4),move it til the blue tick otherwise it doesn't has an enough time after the previous objects which is an several issues for me. (The same goes for these two 01:19:150 (1) - and 03:05:816 (1) - fix them please.)
2. 01:18:138 - This manual break is not necessary and doesn't affect the gameplay or helps in anything, do the same thing just as the other difficulties,because this is the only one that seems to be used.
3. 00:40:995 (6) - Consider to add a NC due the change of stanza in the background sound.
4. 00:48:614 (7) - Same as above.
5. 00:47:662 (4) - Short it to 1/2 due that this isn't following anything in the music the same happens with the vocal, which could be confusing while playing this specific part.
6. 01:29:924 - How about to add one circle here? it fits very well.(The same goes for this 01:33:733 - one too.)
   02:00:281 (4,5,6) - This is overmapped, delete the circle that is placed in the blue tick.
   
   Could you rework in the NCs patterns? they're really inconsistent in the whole difficulty, and honestly them all could be improved, so a double check at this wouldn't hurt at all.

Gero wrote:

Hello Alarido. ( (Don't kudosu this because you've gave me one already in my previous post.)

◄ Working on my diff (Hard), on (Szeretet) (mods on my parts) and (BM's Normal) as allowed to do by the mapper (since no longer active on the game). Later Railgun will apply them. ►

General

1. Some of your settings are kinda random in all difficulties and makes no sense at all, I mean why not just go and use simple settings? like this for example:
   -Easy: HP: 2 CS: 3 AR: 3 OD: 2 ► Kept this one under the discretion of Railgun, changed all other diffs.
   -Normal: HP:4 CS: 3.5 AR: 5 OD: 4
   -Hard: HP: 6 CS: 4 AR: 7 OD: 6
   -Insane: HP: 7 CS: 4 AR: 8 OD: 7
2. Consider to add "Collaboration" in your tags, because is the complete word of "Collab" a part of that everything's else seems alright.

BM's Normal

1. 00:18:138 (1,1) - Seems like the beats between spinners and objects are correct, but still is alittle bit complicated for newbies to get it and click on an object that is so far from the center grind and I bet that the most of them will miss this note, so could you move it a couple of grids?
2. 01:19:090 (1,1) - Same as above.
3. 00:32:424 (3,4) - Looks like this is the only part where you decided to use this kind of rhythm which could be really confusing and not consistent with the other parts that are exactly the same as this, I highly recomend you to do what you've did it here 01:33:138 (2,3) - it's in a fact better than the current one.
4. 01:37:900 (4,1,2,3) - How about to follow the vocals at this part? I think you could change thse objects by something like this, you should try it.
5. 00:50:519 (1) - Probably you missed the fact that you've used an Normal Finish at the start of all kiai times, so would be great if you consider to do the same thing here.

Hard

1. 00:32:424 (3) - Is not wrong or something like that, but how about to use the same rhythm as Alexa or even in the Insane difficulty? it's quite better than the current one.
2. 01:33:376 (3) - Same as above.
3. 01:25:519 (1) - Hey buddy, seems like that you've forgot to add a whistle thingy at the head of this slider.
4. 02:18:971 (3) - Since the previous patterns were just exactly like this one, I mean rhythm and spacing, would be great to keep it consistent the whole section, so consider to move this slider to X:356 Y:56 to improve the readability and aesthetics.
5. 03:00:043 (1,1,1) - This particular part causes that the spike difficulty drops a lot. because the fact that you simply added three spinners which instead in the lowest difficulties it was mapped entirely, so this could make an conflict in the spread due that this is a Hard difficulty, the only solution I could find is considering to map the whole section to avoid it.

Szeretet

1. 00:18:197 (1) - I don't get the fact about started the spinners in 1/8, I mean this could be perfectly placed in an normal snap (1/4),move it til the blue tick otherwise it doesn't has an enough time after the previous objects which is an several issues for me. (The same goes for these two 01:19:150 (1) - and 03:05:816 (1) - fix them please.)
2. 01:18:138 - This manual break is not necessary and doesn't affect the gameplay or helps in anything, do the same thing just as the other difficulties,because this is the only one that seems to be used.
3. 00:40:995 (6) - Consider to add a NC due the change of stanza in the background sound.
4. 00:48:614 (7) - Same as above.
5. 00:47:662 (4) - Short it to 1/2 due that this isn't following anything in the music the same happens with the vocal, which could be confusing while playing this specific part.
6. 01:29:924 - How about to add one circle here? it fits very well.(The same goes for this 01:33:733 - one too.)
   02:00:281 (4,5,6) - This is overmapped, delete the circle that is placed in the blue tick.
   
   Could you rework in the NCs patterns? they're really inconsistent in the whole difficulty, and honestly them all could be improved, so a double check at this wouldn't hurt at all.

Call me back when you've finished to apply the necessary changes.

Gero wrote:

General

• Easy: HP: 2 CS: 3 AR: 3 OD: 2 Changed HP and OD, but I want to keep CS and AR

Railgun's Easy

1. 00:00:043 (1) - How about to use Sampleset Soft in this spinner? just as the other difficulties. Fixed, thanks for catching this
2. 00:28:376 (1,2) - I think these sliders are not follow the vocal singer in a properly way, I mean as previously it does dude that it was a sustained note which fits with this kind of rhythms, but this isn't the case, so I'd like you to change this by something more accurate. (How about this.) Fixed here and in all similar places!
3. 01:29:328 (1,2) - Same as above. Fixed
4. 02:20:043 (2) - This is good actually, but the rhythm that you've used is bothering me a bit, I think that this should be ended at 02:20:995 - because it makes more sense than the red tick, since this is where the vocal ends and for obvious reasons is really important to make it clear for newbies players to avoid any kind of confusions, don't forget to use the correct distance snap after fixing this. Not sure how I'd change this. I like how the slightly long slider emphasizes this part. I think the wait is ok since it's similar to 00:20:043 -, 00:23:852 -, etc.. I also feel like the wait would be too long for the sound at 02:21:471 -

Call me back when you've finished to apply the necessary changes.