Sorry it took me a while to get to you. Modding queue was a bit cancerous as well as other requests
All that matters is I'm here now
[
Collab]
00:02:677 (2) - Slider tail missing same hitwhistle as the previous slider? Not as consistent
00:04:095 (4) - Whistle in the beginning doesn't need to be there. It boshes with the sound a bit rather than just having it at the end which makes it sound better
00:05:984 (2) - Same ^
00:09:292 (1) - End of the slider sounds better if there was a whistle to follow off with this note 00:11:181 (1) keep it consistent
00:16:851 (3) - Slider tail doesn't need to have a whistle like the other 1/2 sliders
00:20:630 - There are some notes in there that have claps but the clap really brings out this part of the song the most and I believe should be required and implemented by a pattern. What I did to exhence the sound quality of hitsounds is to do something like this.
Hitsound CheckYou can implement this if you want to or not. It's just my way of sound preference and how I map and it really emphasizes sounds in here a lot and that is value my friend
00:20:630 (1) - Clap at the end of slider
00:22:047 (5) - Clap at start of slider
00:22:520 (1) - Finish at start of slider
00:22:992 (2) - Clap at start of slider
00:23:937 (5) - Clap at start of slider
00:24:410 (1) - Finish at start of slider and clap at the end of slider
00:25:827 (5) - Clap
00:26:299 (1) - Finish at start and clap at end
00:29:607 (6) - Clap
00:30:079 (1) - Finish at start
00:30:551 (2) - Clap at start
00:31:496 (4) - Clap at start
00:31:969 (1) - Finish at start
00:32:441 (3) - Clap at start
00:32:914 (5) - Finish at start
00:33:386 (7) - Clap at start
00:33:858 (9) - Finish at start
00:20:276 - Add another note? Triple sounds exquisite if you put on there, without one it skips a part of the rhythm flow and screws with me sound wise
00:27:244 (3) - Sounds better if you extend the slider to end here 00:27:599 or just add a note for more emphasis
00:37:638 (1) - Finish hitsound?
00:52:402 (8) - Possibly extend slider to 00:52:638? You were possibly going for that sound that is there but either way it's fine
00:59:370 (6,7,1,2,3,4) - The pause and spacing in this part might throw people off. I suggest moving it here a bit to match with the next slider?
http://puu.sh/edAIP/6001d00fbf.jpg01:05:748 (2) - Blanket by moving more a little to the left
01:09:764 - Hitsound was example as above but only if you wanted to follow it either than that it's fine in kiai mode as the way it is
01:19:213 (1) - To me seems out of place being in the corner of the previous note. Not really any changes needed but just a suggestion to be here?
http://puu.sh/edBe7/9dee38b928.jpg my reasoning is to follow same pattern you had in the 2 las previous sliders moving from up and down but this one moves from left to right on cursor movement and that would be pretty fun
01:25:827 (3,4) - I feel it should be the other way around. Starting with slider and then a note. Tell me how you feel about it so I can check it out
02:31:733 (3,1) - Make these 2 symmetrical?
02:36:103 (4,1,2,3,4) - I think this is pretty sweet but not sure what others would think
I like it though because it's unique
02:40:000 (7,8) - The way you placed that small slider seems a bit awkward to me, how about placing it here to keep it simple,
http://puu.sh/edC55/5560c8c28f.jpg03:23:110 (2,1) - My thing but keep these 2 equally spaced out from the triples so move x432 y128 gives it perfect spacing
04:16:378 (1,2,3) - Same as ^ I believe it's quite a stop and then next note is quite difficult to play out but it's alright if you insist to keep it that way to bring in more challenges
04:16:851 (1,2,3) - Spaced equally to follow that stability in the vocals?
Overall Overview: I thought it was quite enjoyable with the different patterns it has. I believed if you had more hitsounds in the right area it would stand out superbly. The strong notes in kiai need a finish to really emphasize that it's a strong beat or vocal and that the claps is what makes the rhythm you had in the notes stand out more, plus it makes it easier for people to follow a certain rhythm so they don't mess up while transitioning with single tap or alternating on the song. Other than that I hope I helped out with this mod and that I look forward to seeing this marathon ranked in the near future