Sigma Ft Paloma Faith - Changing [Osu|Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
201
show more
Mint
Hello Hula!

WARNING: Will contain nazi stuff and also modded a bit before you updated it, so you might see things you already fixed, sorry!

:idea: General


* Ask someone to cut your mp3.
* Sorry, I don't mod Taiko ;_;

Normal


* Check DS in AIMod.
* Uhmm... nothing I guess?

Ayu's Hard


* 00:27:804 (3) - Very nazi, but try making the curve a bit more loose so the flow is smoother with (1).

* 00:47:277 (3) - It would sound better if you moved this a 1/2 tick earlier imo, so you can follow the vocals. You could fill the empty space you've left with a 1/2 note.
* 01:12:716 (5) - Is it on purpose that you didn't stack it on (2)?
* 01:29:909 - I don't think you need this green line here. There are no notes and you alreadu have a green line adfter this one that does the job.
* 01:52:365 (1) - Just a very minor thing I noticed, but you have 'slider art here' and the slider after this one is just a simple plain slider, however at an identical part of the song (00:33:769 (1,2,3) - ), it's the other way around. You could make the rhythm of these two parts and the usage of slider art consistent if you want, but that's up to you, since it's not a big problem or anything o/
* 02:00:786 (1) - I'd reverse the curve of the slider here. The flow would be consistent with something you had at 00:42:190 (1,2) - and it just flows much better imo.

* 02:11:663 (4) - Move it upwards until it's above (3) for a smoother flow? You already have a flowbreaking-jump after this slider, so it would be nice if you kept the flow for now.

* 02:22:892 (4) - Something similar to what I said above.

Tesla's Insane


Hula

* 00:35:523 (2,4) - Try adding some curves to these sliders so you can have a much smoother flow with (3,5)
* 00:47:628 - I don't really think it's necessary for you to have a reverse slider here, since you are now ignoring the strong beat that's on the repeat. You aren't following the vocals anyway the slider after this, so I recommend you to follow the instruments here instead. This way the rhythm here is more smoothly done and you won't ignore the strong bass sound.

* 01:15:874 (7) - Add either a NC here, or delete Tess' one at the end of the map for consistent NCs (you might want to apply this to all the other diffs as well)

Tess

* 01:45:172 - If you are following the piano as well, you should consider adding a note here, if you're not feel free to ignore o/
* 01:57:628 (6) - Move this note (together with the stream and slider) a bit to the right so you have a perfect diamond shape?
* 02:06:927 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2) - Nazi. But make this symmetrical? You are mostly using geometric shapes in this part, so would be nice if you used symmetry.

* 02:15:523 (4) - I'd move this more to the right for a better flow with (2), because that slider has a big curve.
* 02:24:646 (1) - Woah, this slowdown is really unexpected and hard to read, because you used the same slider shape ( 02:23:593 (2) - )as you had before, which can make it hard to read for some players. I recommend you to tweak this slider a bit so there's a slight curve in it. You many need to rework this pattern a bit to have it work out well.

Pinky


* 00:25:699 (4,1) - Is this intentional? If not, could you please stack them perfectly?
* 00:30:611 (7,1) - Watch out with this sudden spacing change. I recommend you to keep the DS from 1/4 rhythms in your map somewhat the same. Try to have a similar spacing as 00:25:348 (3,4) -
* 00:38:330 (2) - Move this a little bit to the right, so it's in the middle of (1,3) - the pattern would look neater imo.
* 00:59:383 (2,3) - (optional) Mirror the first slider? Looks nice this way, and it wont be too repetitive like you have now.

* 01:15:874 (1) - Put this in the centre (around 224/292) of (5,6) since you now have a nice symmetry pattern, so why not put this in the centre of those two?

It's even more awesome now. So have another star.

Every diff is really well done in this mapset, good job (pls map more ;_;)!

Good luck getting this mapset ranked :3
-GN
"GN" tag is redundant.

:^):):)::))^:^)^):)):^^):)^)):^9
9¨9.)):^99.
9¨9)^:9.)^).
99
Makoa
Your best person ever hula. im big fan.
Topic Starter
Hula
Some mod responses below.

Sorry for the super late replies guys

Rtyzen wrote:

Hey there! Here from the SG Modding Team with Standard mods! Sorry it took a while orz
[Kiai] - About the kiai, I think I might do something like that, gotta work out if it will be feasible on the other diffs.


  1. [notice][Tesla's Insane]
    1. 00:25:699 (4) - I think replacing this with just a circle would be better since there's no sound on 00:25:874 Keeping as a 1/2 slider for now since I'm attempting to kinda map the vocals here
    2. 00:40:523 and 00:40:699 - Add circles? to be consistent with 00:34:821 (6,7,8,9,1) Did it, I decided to spice it up a bit and stuck made it a slightly spaced quintuple!
    3. 00:46:137 and 00:46:313 - ^ (can make a 5-note stream) Nope, there i'm trying to map the AH-AH!
    4. 00:47:453 (6,1) - Probably should change this to be consistent with the previous parts as well Consistent with what? Cos that's the first time the those lyrics appear in the song.
    5. 00:55:962 (6,7,8) - Should delete IMO Same reason as Pinky
    6. 00:59:383 (3) - Move to x:260 y:292 looks better Moved it down a bit more than that since the spacing was too close otherwise.
    7. 01:05:348 (4) - Ctrl-G? Same reason as Pinky
    8. 01:09:558 (4,5) - Flow here is kinda bad cuz the slider is pointing upwards :/ I'l work something out for this, trying to make the slider unique to the violin sound.
    9. The first kiai uses significantly less 1/4 than the second kiai, should do something about that :PThe idea I'm getting with this collab insane is that the map gets harder throughout, I kinda like this approach since I will usually make a map of very linear difficulty which can get boring on a song like this. Maybe I could spice up my section, who knows!
[Pinky]
  1. 00:26:225 (6,1) - Flow here is quite bad especially since they are so close together in timing :/ What I suggest is you Ctrl-H Ctrl-J 00:26:225 (6) (or just Ctrl-> twice) Yeah, idk what i was thinking there. I did a Ctrlh/j thing with is and now the middle point is on the y-x crossover thing
  2. 00:31:663 (5,6,7) - A proper triangle would look better This is an isoceles triangle and the idea is that then 6,7,1 are all on the same y axis. And an equilateral triangle wouldn't allow me to increase the spacing like I wanted to here.
  3. 00:55:962 (2,3,4) - Should delete IMO It feels empty without it there and i've tried to map it so the decrease in spacing and HS volume match that the 1/4 drums are also reduced at that point. Also i think it kinda adds a bit more OOMF to that first slider.
  4. 02:14:558 (2,3,4) - ^ ^
  5. 01:04:997 (4) - Ctrl-G? Possible, but here I'm trying to reduce the SV and calm it down a bit briefly.
  6. 02:23:944 (4) - ^ ^
  7. 01:15:874 (7) - Stack on the head on 2 to center it pls. And adjust 01:15:172 (3,4,5,6) - to be parallel again that jump sequence there is all one pattern, I've moved it onto the Y-axis so that it is symmetrical to that
  8. 02:37:277 (5) - NC
No need, it's the end of the map!

That's all from me, good luck with your map! :D
Thankyou very much for the mod




appleeaterx wrote:

Hello Hula! hi

WARNING: Will contain nazi stuff and also modded a bit before you updated it, so you might see things you already fixed, sorry!

:idea: General


* Ask someone to cut your mp3. For now i'm keeping the whole mp3 in, it's timed perfectly and it doesn't hurt being able to hear the whole shabang. Plus aimod doesn't care about it
* Sorry, I don't mod Taiko ;_; that's okay

Tesla's Insane


Hula
thanks for noticing whose part's whose 8'|
* 00:35:523 (2,4) - Try adding some curves to these sliders so you can have a much smoother flow with (3,5) I curved them a bit but i'm keeping the basic pattern/flow there since i'm going for that jumpy feel, yet not jumpy. you know?
* 00:47:628 - I don't really think it's necessary for you to have a reverse slider here, since you are now ignoring the strong beat that's on the repeat. You aren't following the vocals anyway the slider after this, so I recommend you to faollow the instruments here instead. This way the rhythm here is more smoothly done and you won't ignore the strong bass sound.
Here I'm trying to maybe map a few too many things at once. But i'm mapping the strings and the vocals start on the red tick. I currently think that the repeat slider on the downbeat actually works, but only in this instance because the song goes a bit funky. So I try to represent that with something non-standard. Since what your image shows is a standard way of mapping it, i think many of the nuances would be ignored here. If I get further displease about it i'll change it. So it's duly noted.
* 01:15:874 (7) - Add either a NC here, or delete Tess' one at the end of the map for consistent NCs (you might want to apply this to all the other diffs as well) Hm, I'll ask tess about dis. Also this circle is much different to Tess' bit cos Tess' one comes at the end of a streamy bit

Tess

* 01:45:172 - If you are following the piano as well, you should consider adding a note here, if you're not feel free to ignore o/
* 01:57:628 (6) - Move this note (together with the stream and slider) a bit to the right so you have a perfect diamond shape?
* 02:06:927 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2) - Nazi. But make this symmetrical? You are mostly using geometric shapes in this part, so would be nice if you used symmetry.

* 02:15:523 (4) - I'd move this more to the right for a better flow with (2), because that slider has a big curve.
* 02:24:646 (1) - Woah, this slowdown is really unexpected and hard to read, because you used the same slider shape ( 02:23:593 (2) - )as you had before, which can make it hard to read for some players. I recommend you to tweak this slider a bit so there's a slight curve in it. You many need to rework this pattern a bit to have it work out well.

Pinky


* 00:25:699 (4,1) - Is this intentional? If not, could you please stack them perfectly? intentional, i know it's not the prettiest thing in the world. But it's just gonna have to be that way cos im' not increasing spacing and i'm not stacking, it ruins the flow
* 00:30:611 (7,1) - Watch out with this sudden spacing change. I recommend you to keep the DS from 1/4 rhythms in your map somewhat the same. Try to have a similar spacing as 00:25:348 (3,4) - I don't see the problem here, it looks much neater it being a bit further away and slider end stacked on (3) than a partial overlap, and it retains its readability. Plus the spacing would be higher cos now the song's getting all roiled up and ready to go XZXZXZXZXZXZXZXXZ
* 00:38:330 (2) - Move this a little bit to the right, so it's in the middle of (1,3) - the pattern would look neater imo. Tidied up that whole combo ;)
* 00:59:383 (2,3) - (optional) Mirror the first slider? Looks nice this way, and it wont be too repetitive like you have now.
rotated them 14 degree clockwise and mirrored them.
* 01:15:874 (1) - Put this in the centre (around 224/292) of (5,6) since you now have a nice symmetry pattern, so why not put this in the centre of those two?
fixed this pattern previous mod to be on the almighty y-axis

It's even more awesome now. So have another star.

Every diff is really well done in this mapset, good job (pls map more ;_;)!

Good luck getting this mapset ranked :3thankyou very much and thankyou for the mod!
Topic Starter
Hula

Makoa wrote:

Your best person ever hula. im big fan.
cheers dude?
Avena

Hula wrote:

Makoa wrote:

Your best person ever hula. im big fan.
cheers dude?
hula u have a fan appreciate it.
Topic Starter
Hula

Priti wrote:

hula u have a fan appreciate it.
:D
Makoa
:( where'd hula go?


I will aspire to fill your role one day.
Nyxa
I'll apply mods when Hula gets unbanned I guess.
Topic Starter
Hula

Makoa wrote:

:( where'd hula go?


I will aspire to fill your role one day.

Tess wrote:

I'll apply mods when Hula gets unbanned I guess.
do it!
Kurosanyan
Is this happening?
Aiceo
he's aliveeee
Topic Starter
Hula

Kurosanyan wrote:

Is this happening?
YOU BET IT IS BRUTHAH
Nwolf
EVERYTHING IS CHANGING



(why is it "kurosayan" instead of "kurosanyan" looooooool :°) )
Topic Starter
Hula

Nwolf wrote:

EVERYTHING IS CHANGING



(why is it "kurosayan" instead of "kurosanyan" looooooool :°) )
UWAT
Aiceo
get a clean mp3 what is this shit quality lol
Topic Starter
Hula

Aiceo wrote:

get a clean mp3 what is this shit quality lol
get one for me and kds
Aiceo
http://puu.sh/kAlDh/3dcad1b913.mp3

i cut the super long end since it doesn't fit the ranking criteria, and the quality should be better
Sieg
wb
RVMathew
Hi there. This is a short mod. Note that whatever I say is my own opinion so you do not have to follow it if you want to.

Metadata
Source Info:
Song Name: This is the correct Title: Changing (feat. Paloma Faith)
Source/Tags: Add 'Life' since this song is actually part of the album 'Life' which will be released soon.

General
1) Background: Ranking criteria recommends that you need a 1366*768 image (16:9) or a 1024*768 (4:3). Here is the same background at 1366*768 resolution
2) Disable widescreen support because that is used only when a storyboard is present.
3) Unless you are going to map 3:22 of the song, I would recommend cutting it since at present, the last 40 seconds of the mp3 is unused.

Tesla's Insane
1) For naming you can remove the 'Collab' part because the difficulty name says 'Tesla's Insane' (Tess and Hula); it is already implied that it is a collaboration between you two so having the word 'Collab' is redundant. Tesla's Insane sounds cool.
2) 00:48:506 (3,4,5,6) - I like the pattern but it feels cramped with the way it is positioned right now. When playing the map though I did not have problems playing it.
3) 00:49:734 (2,3,4,5,6) - I was thinking that you can use a star pattern.

4) 02:24:646 (1,2,3,4,5) - This area looks cramped considering the previous patterns which were spaced out. This may have been done intentionally.

Pinky
1) 01:59:032 (3,4,1) - Note 4 seems to be 4 pixels higher than notes 3 and 1. Shift it down to: 68,356
2) Just a small thing 02:14:383 (4,1,2,3,4) - The change in distance snap looks weird but when playing it was fine. I do not think you have to change it because this is a personal issue and does not affect the beatmap that much.
I do like the various patterns and stuff.

Final Thoughts: I know that this was a very short mod but the map looks cool.

Good luck :) and welcome back Hula (I wish you were not banned from Disqus).
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply